Foam Mattresses Reviews

Who's better?

Puffy vs Live and Sleep

We've analyzed the best Foam Mattresses to help you find the right solution for your needs.

2025 Foam Mattress Reviews

Here you can see how Puffy and Live and Sleep match up head-to-head in a battle for the Best Foam Mattresses in 2025.

Winner

Puffy

  • Pricing from $599 to $3,998
  • 4 mattress types in stock
  • Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, Cali King, and Split King

Puffy offers a range of foam mattresses with a luxury feel and added perks like free gifts with your purchase. The mattresses are designed with cooling layers, and the brand claims to provide pressure relief, though some customers felt their pain got worse with use. While Puffy has competitive prices and quick shipping, there are also concerns about the durability of their foam mattresses. Basically, if you're not a back sleeper, Puffy may not give you the sleep you're looking for.

Live and Sleep

  • Pricing from $439 to $3,419
  • 3 mattress types in stock
  • Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, and King

Live and Sleep is a newer mattress company, but it has a lot of red flags. They offer three mattress styles, but there are fewer details about the mattresses and their composition than we've seen from other brands. Plus, Live and Sleep's return window changes depending on what mattress you buy. With almost no feedback and no rating on the BBB, Live and Sleep ends up being a question mark in terms of quality.

Solid sleep underpins your health and overall well-being, and the right mattress can make all the difference in how easily you drift off and stay asleep. For many people, a quality foam mattress - with its body-hugging support and pressure relief - is the most reliable route to deep, restorative rest. If you tend to overheat, consider a breathable or gel-infused foam option to stay comfortable through the night.

If you're wondering what a foam mattress is, it usually means a bed made with one of two main foams: polyurethane or memory foam. They're built from similar ingredients, but polyfoam feels springier and is typically cheaper, while memory foam - created by NASA in the 1960s - didn't catch on for bedding until the 1990s. Many newer mattresses blend the two to balance contouring and bounce, so the best pick often comes down to the feel you like and what you want to spend.

Choosing a foam mattress comes with plenty of perks compared to the old-school spring style. It contours to your shape, easing pressure on joints while distributing support more evenly from head to toe. If you're into that sink-in, soft-cocoon feel that helps you drift off, memory foam is absolutely worth a look. It also excels at isolating motion - a major plus if you share your bed with a partner or a pet.

Foam mattresses are often praised for easing pressure points, but how does that translate to your overall health? Some research suggests memory foam can reduce back and joint pain while helping you sleep more deeply. They're also great at motion isolation - less bounce and wiggle when a partner shifts beside you. Beyond that, you may see benefits like improved temperature regulation and even a bit of relief for people with sleep apnea. The specific feel and density you choose can make a big difference in how well these perks show up, so it's worth paying attention to materials and construction.

Not long ago, buying a mattress meant a full-blown outing: drive to a local store, bounce from model to model, and choose from whatever was on the floor. Now you can do the whole thing online, browsing hundreds of options across sizes, shapes, materials, thicknesses, and firmness levels. Most brands ship straight to your door, and foam models arrive vacuum-sealed, unfurling over a few hours until they reach full shape - the bed-in-a-box era feels a little sci-fi. On top of that, detailed reviews and generous trial periods make it easier to choose with confidence.

If you're ready to stop counting sheep and get the best sleep of your life, we're right there with you, and we've put together a list of factors to help you narrow your options. Here are some things to keep in mind:

To help you stop having nightmares about your bed, Top Consumer Reviews has researched and ranked the top foam mattress brands out there today. This way, you can sink into your new mattress at the end of a long day and enjoy the support and relaxation of memory foam. Just imagine: you'll be looking forward to naps more than ever with your comfortable new foam mattress. Sweet dreams!

Slide Down Image Left Slide Image FAQ Image Slide Image Twirl Image

Foam Mattress FAQ

What is a foam mattress?
When you hear "foam mattress", you might immediately think of egg carton-like pads used for sleepovers or campouts. Those are nothing like the foam mattresses that have taken the bedding industry by storm: well-constructed, delivered right to your home, and possibly giving you the best night's sleep you've ever had.
Why wouldn't I want a traditional coil/spring mattress?
Traditional mattresses often create pressure points, leaving you sore and restless. Foam mattresses are designed to contour to your body, offering support and comfort all night long.
I need a firm/medium/soft mattress. Do they make foam mattresses with that level of firmness?
Yes - and sometimes you can even find options with different levels of firmness on each side! Not every manufacturer offers you a choice, but you can read through customer reviews to see how each brand "sleeps". The experience varies based on the sleeper's weight, sleeping position, and other factors, so finding comments from people similar to you can be a good guide for your purchase.
How much do they cost?
You'll spend anywhere from $390 to $6100 for a foam mattress. As you'd expect, twin sizes are less expensive than king-size mattresses, and many manufacturers have designs ranging from basic to luxury.
Is shipping included?
Yes. Most of the time, your foam mattress will be delivered at no extra charge. Considering how much effort it would take to go to a local mattress store and drive it home yourself (or worse, pay for delivery), this is a huge perk when buying a foam mattress online. There might be a learning curve to get your mattress set up initially - you may have even seen a few humorous unboxing videos, showing how these mattresses expand when you take them out of the box - but most customers say it's pretty straightforward.
How fast can I get my new mattress delivered?
Usually within 1-2 weeks. You might have to wait a little longer during popular buying times (with June through September being the busiest times, since the mattress industry usually debuts new products then).
What if I try the mattress and I don't like it? Can I return it?
This is probably one of the biggest perks to buying a foam mattress: most manufacturers give you a lengthy trial period ranging from several weeks to a year, so that you can put it to use and see how well you sleep. That's important because foam mattresses can take some getting used to (and you might actually feel a little sore for the first few days to a week!). Better yet, some of the best foam mattress companies will let you return your mattress (or donate it locally) absolutely free of charge if you decide during the trial period that you don't like it.
Is it really safe to order foam mattresses online?
Absolutely! It's easy to find thousands of reviews from customers and a Better Business Bureau listing for most foam mattress companies today, so you can feel perfectly confident ordering your new bed from any one of them. Sweet dreams!

Compare Any 2 Products

Nectar
Leesa
Tuft & Needle
Casper
Keetsa
Purple
Layla
Essentia
Puffy
Live and Sleep
Tempurpedic
Sweet Night
vs
Nectar vs LeesaNectar vs Tuft & NeedleNectar vs CasperNectar vs KeetsaNectar vs PurpleNectar vs LaylaNectar vs EssentiaNectar vs PuffyNectar vs Live and SleepNectar vs TempurpedicNectar vs Sweet NightLeesa vs Tuft & NeedleLeesa vs CasperLeesa vs KeetsaLeesa vs PurpleLeesa vs LaylaLeesa vs EssentiaLeesa vs PuffyLeesa vs Live and SleepLeesa vs TempurpedicLeesa vs Sweet NightTuft & Needle vs CasperTuft & Needle vs KeetsaTuft & Needle vs PurpleTuft & Needle vs LaylaTuft & Needle vs EssentiaTuft & Needle vs PuffyTuft & Needle vs Live and SleepTuft & Needle vs TempurpedicTuft & Needle vs Sweet NightCasper vs KeetsaCasper vs PurpleCasper vs LaylaCasper vs EssentiaCasper vs PuffyCasper vs Live and SleepCasper vs TempurpedicCasper vs Sweet NightKeetsa vs PurpleKeetsa vs LaylaKeetsa vs EssentiaKeetsa vs PuffyKeetsa vs Live and SleepKeetsa vs TempurpedicKeetsa vs Sweet NightPurple vs LaylaPurple vs EssentiaPurple vs PuffyPurple vs Live and SleepPurple vs TempurpedicPurple vs Sweet NightLayla vs EssentiaLayla vs PuffyLayla vs Live and SleepLayla vs TempurpedicLayla vs Sweet NightEssentia vs PuffyEssentia vs Live and SleepEssentia vs TempurpedicEssentia vs Sweet NightPuffy vs Live and SleepPuffy vs TempurpedicPuffy vs Sweet NightLive and Sleep vs TempurpedicLive and Sleep vs Sweet NightTempurpedic vs Sweet Night Sweet Night vs TempurpedicSweet Night vs Live and SleepSweet Night vs PuffySweet Night vs EssentiaSweet Night vs LaylaSweet Night vs PurpleSweet Night vs KeetsaSweet Night vs CasperSweet Night vs Tuft & NeedleSweet Night vs LeesaSweet Night vs NectarTempurpedic vs Live and SleepTempurpedic vs PuffyTempurpedic vs EssentiaTempurpedic vs LaylaTempurpedic vs PurpleTempurpedic vs KeetsaTempurpedic vs CasperTempurpedic vs Tuft & NeedleTempurpedic vs LeesaTempurpedic vs NectarLive and Sleep vs PuffyLive and Sleep vs EssentiaLive and Sleep vs LaylaLive and Sleep vs PurpleLive and Sleep vs KeetsaLive and Sleep vs CasperLive and Sleep vs Tuft & NeedleLive and Sleep vs LeesaLive and Sleep vs NectarPuffy vs EssentiaPuffy vs LaylaPuffy vs PurplePuffy vs KeetsaPuffy vs CasperPuffy vs Tuft & NeedlePuffy vs LeesaPuffy vs NectarEssentia vs LaylaEssentia vs PurpleEssentia vs KeetsaEssentia vs CasperEssentia vs Tuft & NeedleEssentia vs LeesaEssentia vs NectarLayla vs PurpleLayla vs KeetsaLayla vs CasperLayla vs Tuft & NeedleLayla vs LeesaLayla vs NectarPurple vs KeetsaPurple vs CasperPurple vs Tuft & NeedlePurple vs LeesaPurple vs NectarKeetsa vs CasperKeetsa vs Tuft & NeedleKeetsa vs LeesaKeetsa vs NectarCasper vs Tuft & NeedleCasper vs LeesaCasper vs NectarTuft & Needle vs LeesaTuft & Needle vs NectarLeesa vs Nectar
See the Best Foam Mattresses in Your State
Only the Best Reviews

Consumer Reports on ...

9 best mattresses of 2025, lab-tested and reviewed

Our rigorous tests of innerspring, foam, and adjustable air beds reveal top models from brands including Casper, Essentia, and Sleep NumberCR mattress ratings include beds from Earthfoam (top ...

Mon, 08 Dec 2025

Only the Best Reviews

Insider on MSN

The best mattresses for heavy people, tested and reviewed by a ...

I spent months finding the best mattresses for heavy people. My top picks include options for every sleeping position, plus people with back pain.

Mon, 08 Dec 2025

Only the Best Reviews

Apartment Therapy ...

We Tested 3 of the Most Popular Bear Mattresses — Here Are Our ...

Further insights on the Bear Original Mattress were provided by SEO director Adriana Velez, who oversees strategy for search-focused content on Apartment Therapy. She has had her Bear mattress for ...

Sat, 29 Nov 2025

Only the Best Reviews

Forbes

The 8 Best Memory Foam Mattress Toppers To Make Your Bed Cozier

A topper can work wonders when you’re looking to cozy-up your mattress without spending money on a whole new bed. Memory foam mattress toppers instantly add contouring, firmness or plushness to your ...

Tue, 20 Aug 2024

Only the Best Reviews

Consumer Reports

Should You Flip a Foam Mattress?

When you shop through retailer links on our site, we may earn affiliate commissions. 100% of the fees we collect are used to support our nonprofit mission. Learn more. Most foam mattresses are made up ...

Sat, 06 Oct 2018

Only the Best Reviews

The Virginian-Pilot

How to choose a twin memory foam mattress

Buying a mattress is an important decision as a quality mattress should last 7-10 years and a mattress’s level of support and comfort can make a huge difference in how you sleep. If you’re in the ...

Thu, 29 Jul 2021

Top Products.  

Top Reviews.  

Top Consumer Reviews.

Reviews 

Browse through thousands of reviews.

Social Media 

Like us?  Follow us!  We'd love to have you join our community.

Newsletter 

Stay up to date with the latest reviews. We'll keep you informed, and we'll never sell your information to anyone.