Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.
You may have found your curiosity piqued by a mattress-in-a-box unboxing video, watching a seemingly too-small carton produce a king-size mattress in just a matter of seconds. Yes, you really can get an amazing night's sleep from one of these mattresses that gets shipped to your doorstep - no need to drive around town and strap your new bed to the roof of your car after all!
In fact, many customers have a strong preference for foam mattresses over the traditional spring or coil versions paired with a box spring. Technology has come a long way over the last decade or so, and if you're tired of waking up with an aching back, sore shoulder, or irritable partner (because your tossing-and-turning shook the bed all night), you'll definitely want to consider what a foam mattress can do for you.
Sunday, December 10th
Leesa is the foam mattress brand you'll feel great about supporting. Their beds are assembled in the US, letting you help the economy with your purchase, and the company goes out of its way to benefit others in lots of ways. More on that later, but you'll also love the way these mattresses help you sleep.
5 all-foam and hybrid mattresses to choose from
When choosing a foam mattress from Leesa, you'll have five styles and sizes to consider:
Big discounts - and free pillows
There was a big sale going on during our most recent visit to the Leesa online store. Mattresses were discounted up to $400, and every purchase came with two free pillows. That brought the price on an Original Twin down to just $749 ($100 off) and the Legend King down to $2,299 ($400 off). We also spotted a pop-up with a 15% discount when signing up for the Leesa mailing list.
Attention residents of Alaska and Hawaii
If you live in Alaska or Hawaii, you'll definitely want to look at Leesa mattresses. Why? We didn't spot any other brand that includes your state in the "free delivery" range. You'll have $100 deducted from your refund if you decide to return your mattress after the 100-night sleep trial, but that's it.
Made in the USA - mostly
One change we've noticed with Leesa since our last review is that their mattresses are no longer 100% USA-sourced-and-made. While they're still designed and manufactured in the US, the components are both domestic and imported. That's not a reason to avoid buying your foam mattress here, but it's worth pointing out if the "made in the USA" label was a driving factor for your purchase.
Doing great things in the community
Leesa donates a mattress to a child in need for every ten that they sell - more than 37,000 so far. And these are no cast-off returns either: they're made to order for each child, with the same high-quality foam Leesa is known for and designed to be the perfect height for bunk beds. Beneficiaries have included the Los Angeles LGBT Center, Thrive Arizona, and Covenant House, among others. But yes, returned mattresses are donated too; sometimes Leesa will schedule the pickup, and in others they'll let you make the arrangements. That's a big part of the reason why Leesa is a certified B corporation: they're committed to being a force for good and keeping mattresses out of landfills.
And yes, these mattresses also do just fine reputation-wise. Leesa still has an "A+" and accreditation from the Better Business Bureau, and there were only 10 complaints filed there over the course of three years. The only complaints people seem to have about buying a Leesa mattress relate to the delivery end of the process - which is often out of Leesa's hands, though they make every effort to get issues taken care of. You can read reviews both on and off the Leesa site and you'll find lots of loyal repeat customers who won't sleep on anything but a Leesa mattress, ranking them higher than even the most premium, well-known brands.
#1 for foam mattresses
Leesa lets you sleep well at night - not only because their mattresses are fantastic, but also because your purchase supports a company doing good in the world. Win-win! There's no reason you shouldn't make Leesa the brand you choose when shopping for a great foam mattress. This is our first-place winner in the industry.
Nectar specializes strictly in memory foam mattresses: you won't find any springs, coils, or hybrid styles here. More than two million people have gotten their best night's sleep with a Nectar mattress, and this is the only company in our review to offer a full year sleep trial and a "forever" warranty. You can't beat that. Nectar mattresses have also received quite a few accolades, like Women's Health's "Healthy Sleep" and Forbes' Best Back Pain Mattress in 2021, and Health Magazine's Best Memory Foam Mattress in a Box in 2022.
3 mattresses to consider here
You'll only have three mattress styles to choose from at Nectar, and they all ship for free:
Get free accessories with your purchase
How about some extras? At the time of this review (and maybe always?) Nectar was including a nice bundle of accessories with every mattress purchase. Depending on the mattress size, each order came with 1-2 cooling pillows, a sheet set, and a mattress protector, valued at $375+.
2 financing options
Excited about a Nectar mattress but not about shelling out the money all at once? No worries. Look right above the "Add to Cart" button and you'll see Nectar's financing options. These include 0% APR financing through Affirm or Afterpay's four interest-free installments, your choice.
BBB listing is inconclusive
Nectar had a "Not Rated" listing with the Better Business Bureau at the time of this review - hard to say if that's an improvement or a decline compared with the "B-" grade the company had in our last evaluation. The BBB also pointed out a 2021 settlement that required Nectar Sleep's parent company (Resident Home LLC) to pay $753,000 for misleading advertising regarding "made in the USA" mattresses. Oops.
Tens of thousands of 5-star reviews
On the other hand, we were blown away by the tens of thousands of five-star reviews on the Nectar site. That's a gigantic leap from the 5,000 reviews they had when we last evaluated them. Nectar doesn't filter out the low ratings, but they're so infrequent that you have to look really hard to see them. Reading through them, it's easy to see the profile of the customers leaving the reviews and find ones that match your situation: if you sleep hot or cool, alone or with a partner/pets, on your back/stomach/side, and so on.
Longest sleep trial in the industry
Nectar's got a lot to offer, not the least of which is its legendary year-long sleep trial. We highly recommend you take a serious look at their foam mattresses, especially if you're not interested in a hybrid style with coils or springs. Will you be Nectar's next loyal customer?
Purple is one of the biggest names in the mattress-in-a-box industry, with over 30 years in business. Choose between all-foam or foam-hybrid configurations and give it a try for 100 nights: see for yourself if Purple lives up to its reputation as one of the "OGs" on the market.
Are you on the Grid?
What makes Purple mattresses different from others in the industry is the GelFlex Grid: a hyper-elastic material that both supports and offers localized pressure relief at the same time. Unlike traditional foam that experiences some lag time when you change positions, the Grid reconfigures itself to you whenever you roll or shift in bed. Another benefit of the Grid's 1400 individual air channels is that they don't trap body heat, helping you maintain a comfy temperature the whole time you're in bed.
5 mattress styles here
You'll see five different mattress options in Purple's online store:
Discounts are available
Visiting the Purple site for the first time, you may get a pop-up offer: enter your email address and you'll get $50 off your first mattress purchase. Or, click the box to sign up for SMS updates and that discount goes up to $75. We also noticed discount links at the bottom of the site for healthcare professionals, military, first responders, educators, and even truckers.
Consider buying additional accident protection
You've got 10 years of warranty coverage on any Purple mattress, which is fairly standard within the industry. This is also the only foam mattress brand we saw that lets you purchase accident protection, starting at $49.99 for a three-year plan and going up to a super-reasonable $89.99 on a ten-year plan. If your mattress gets stained when you're having that bedtime glass of wine (or from bodily fluids, ew), cut or punctured, you'll get professional in-home service and no deductible.
Reputation is excellent
From what we can see, Purple absolutely lives up to its history. Whether you look at their mattress reviews on the site or elsewhere, it's almost always a 5-star rating. Even for customers who don't get their best sleep on a Purple foam mattress, they usually have a hassle-free experience taking advantage of the 100-night trial and getting a refund (with no processing or return fees). The Better Business Bureau agrees, giving Purple their highest "A+" rating plus accreditation.
In the top five for foam mattresses
You don't have to spend a ton of money to get a comfortable mattress with advanced cooling features, because even Purple's most basic model delivers that. Purple comes in near the top of our list among foam mattress brands, and we encourage you to see if one of their models is a good fit for you.
Arizona-based Tuft & Needle hopes that you can reconnect with the power of rest - by sleeping on one of their innovative, responsibly-crafted foam mattresses. Since 2012, this company has helped over 500,000 people get an incredible night's sleep. Are you next?
3 mattress styles in the lineup
The Tuft & Needle website makes it really easy to compare their three mattresses and choose the one that's a good fit for you, but here's the short version:
6 sizes, 100-night sleep trial
All T&N mattresses come in six sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, and Cal King. You'll have a 100-night sleep trial and a 10 year warranty no matter which one you ultimately select, as well as free shipping and financing options through Affirm or Afterpay.
Savings tucked away at the bottom of the site
We noticed that this was the only online store in our review that didn't jump right at us with a pop-up offering a discount for signing up as an email newsletter recipient or with some big seasonal sale at the top of the page. That's okay: as you can see above, pricing here is reasonable even without a coupon. But, if you're a healthcare professional, first responder or member of the military, be sure to scroll all the way down to the bottom of the T&N site because there's some savings available for you. You might also find some reduced-priced options through the Sale link down there; at the time of this review, there was a closeout sale on the Mint mattress from two years prior, bringing the price down by more than $100 compared with the current model year's cost. Why not?
Numerous 5-star ratings from thrilled customers
It always makes us happy when companies let us see unfiltered reviews, and you'll see over 76,000 of them on the Tuft & Needle website (yes, you read that number correctly). Read customer comments on- or off-site and you'll see thousands and thousands (and thousands) of five-star ratings. Shoppers sing Tuft & Needle's praises for having extremely responsive customer support, heavenly mattresses, and fast delivery. Let's go! The BBB won't argue with that reputation either: they've given this brand an "A+" and accreditation too.
Gives back to people in need
And, like most of the companies in the top ranks here, Tuft & Needle does their part to make the world a better place. Through a combination of direct donations, donations of returned mattresses, and school fundraising, the company has given over $13 million in mattresses - plus 2500+ volunteer hours in setting up beds, cleaning bedding, providing meals, building housing, and beyond. Fantastic mattresses and a feel-good brand? Absolutely.
One of our favorite foam mattress brands
The next time you're shopping for a foam mattress and you want to increase your chances of not needing to make a return, start your shopping at Tuft & Needle. You'll still have 100 nights to decide, and 10 years of warranty in case something goes awry, but tens of thousands of five-star reviews aren't going to steer you wrong. This is a fabulous company we're excited to recommend.
Live and Sleep is the memory foam mattress company created with the customer in mind from the very beginning. Each product is designed to leave you feeling refreshed and rested - and also feeling good about your purchase. All Live and Sleep mattresses are CertiPUR-US certified, and a portion of every order is donated to charity.
3 mattresses to look at
Live and Sleep has three mattresses to choose from:
Trial period may be shorter than you expect
The length of time you'll have to try out your new mattress depends on which one you choose. For example, you'll only get 30 nights on Live and Sleep's entry-level Classic mattress, while the Luxury style gives you a 100-night trial. All mattresses have a 20-year limited warranty and come with free shipping within 4-7 business days.
Discounts make these mattresses even more affordable
At the time of our review, there was a seasonal sale offering discounts of $50 on Classic, $100 off on Elite, and $150 off Luxury mattresses. We also got a pop-up offer of a "special discount code" if we entered our email address.
Recommended by customers
We were surprised not to find a Better Business Bureau listing for Live and Sleep, given that they've been around for several years. Not to worry, though: there's plenty of shopper feedback elsewhere, and it's overwhelmingly positive. Even on the Live and Sleep site itself, there are hundreds of five-star reviews (though the company doesn't filter out the lower ones either). We thought it was funny to see how many people bought these mattresses for a child's bed and then thought it was so comfy, they had to have one for their own bedroom. Looking outside of the Live and Sleep site, we still found lots of satisfied shoppers who recommend these mattresses.
Good-quality mattresses for less money
There's a lot to like about Live and Sleep. These foam mattresses are really affordable without losing anything in terms of quality and durability, and their 20-year warranty is double that of many rival brands. We wish that they would offer a longer sleep trial on all mattresses; 30 nights on the Classic and 75 nights on the Elite is much shorter than most competitors' 100+ night trial period. Still, we've not no qualms about recommending Live and Sleep as one of the brands to consider when shopping for a good-quality foam mattress that won't empty your wallet.
Layla thinks you'll "flip" for their reversible mattresses: firm feel on one side, soft feel on the other, essentially giving you two beds in one. All of their mattresses use a copper gel infusion to keep you cooler and your bed cleaner - for longer. This is one of the newer entries in the foam mattress industry, but Layla has already earned an "A+" and accreditation from the Better Business Bureau.
All foam or hybrid?
Shopping for a Layla mattress is nice and straightforward: you only need to choose between the all-foam construction and the foam/coil hybrid. The all-foam style is your best bet if you want to sink into your mattress and you're not overly concerned about edge support. On the other hand, if the intended sleeper has a larger frame, needs good edge support when getting out of bed, or would benefit from the additional cooling factor from a layer of pocketed coils, the hybrid is the better choice. Sizes range from Twin to Cal King and include some harder-to-find sizes like Twin XL and Full, but there's no split King/Cal King here if you're looking for that.
Bundle up and save
You won't break the bank buying a Layla mattress. Regular pricing on the all-foam models ranges from $749 to $1,249, and from $1,299 to $1,899 on the hybrid. During this review, there was a sitewide sale in progress. It brought the starting price of Layla's basic foam mattress down from $749 to $599 for the Twin size, and the hybrid down to $1,099 from $1,299. Also, if you're outfitting your bedroom from scratch, be sure to shop Layla's bundles: you'll pay less if you buy your mattress, foundation, and bedding in one fell swoop. You can also see those add-ons at the bottom of the mattress page. Your shipping is free in the continental United States.
Try it for 120 nights
What about returns and warranties? Layla is more generous than most with a 120-night sleep trial, while its rivals tend to max out at 90 nights or less. On the other hand, you'll only have a 10-year warranty on any mattress you buy here, which doesn't quite compete with some competitors' coverage of 20 years - or even lifetime.
How does Layla's reputation stack up against the competition? Pretty well, mostly. Despite being so new, the company has that fantastic rating from the BBB we mentioned. And, over more than a thousand ratings on Layla's site, these mattresses average close to a perfect five stars. Going outside of the reviews on Layla, sentiment became a little more mixed, but the biggest complaints seemed to surround the pillows sold here (and their difficult donation/" return" policy). A few people had problems with Layla's customer service team, but others had nothing but good things to say about the experience.
Good choice if you'd like firm and soft in one mattress
Layla strikes a great balance between features and price. We love the idea of having a two-sided mattress: experiment with firm vs. soft without having to send it back and get a whole different product. We also appreciate the streamlined simplicity of choosing between just two different mattress models, not having to sort out and compare multiple options just to get some Zzzs. Though we'd like to see Layla boost its warranty period, that's still nothing that gets in the way of the company earning a solid recommendation from us.
More than a million people have entrusted Casper mattresses to give them "award-winning sleep" , which according to the company is "the superpower that charges everything that people do" . We agree that a good night's sleep does make people friendlier, faster and smarter.
5 mattresses in 6 different sizes
At the time of this review, there were five Casper mattresses to choose from, all available in six sizes ranging from Twin to Cal King:
100-night sleep trial, standard 10-year warranty
Nothing about Casper's customer policies should catch you off-guard, because they're pretty standard. You've got 100 nights to try your foam mattress and decide if it works well for you, and you won't have any fees deducted from your refund if you choose to return it. Mattresses ship for free in the continental United States, and they're covered by a 10-year warranty.
Generous donations to people (and pets) in need
We really like how Casper gives back to the community - or, as they put it, "at the end of the day [they] give a sheet" . They've made donations of sleep products to people and animals through the International Rescue Committee, Sense of Home, and other nonprofits. This includes mattresses that get returned within the 100-night trial period: their couriers will come and pack up your mattress at a time that's convenient to you and either donate or recycle it. And, in select brick-and-mortar locations, Casper accepts drop-offs of old pillows, sheets and bedding to be recycled. We can get behind that.
Besides their do-gooder reputation, Casper is a brand you can trust. They've earned an "A+" and accreditation from the BBB, and you've already seen that there are tens of thousands of reviews on the mattresses sold through their site. We always like to double-check customer feedback beyond what the store posts, and that's pretty solid for Casper too. 85% of shoppers give Casper a 4- or 5-star rating; any complaints we found were related to shipping issues or expressed a dislike of foam mattresses as a whole, while few had anything bad to say about the brand or its support reps in particular.
A brand we can recommend
Casper is a solid win among foam mattress brands. You've got several options here, depending on how much support and/or cooling you need and on your budget, there should be no problems with getting a refund during your 100-night trial if you need it, and you get the added bonus of helping Casper help others. Sounds good to us. Long story short, we like Casper and we think you will too.
If money is no object and you want an amazing night's sleep, Tempur-Pedic mattresses are the way to go. They've earned multiple customer satisfaction awards from J.D. Power over the last few years, and despite having a much higher than average price point, Tempur-Pedic mattresses still earn thousands of five-star ratings from sleepers everywhere.
3 main mattress designs
You'll see three foam and foam-hybrid mattress models at Tempur-Pedic, all with a 90-night trial and 10-year warranty:
Sales and closeout deals
You'll want to keep an eye out for sales at Tempur-Pedic. The last time we shopped for mattresses, there was a 30% off sale in progress. That brought the most affordable mattress here down to just $1,329.30 from its original price of $1,899. There was also a closeout category of mattresses, the Breeze 2.0 Collection; all sales were final for those particular models, and since it was "while supplies last" , they may not be available during your shopping visit to the Tempur-Pedic site.
Reputation is flawless
We've got zero concerns about the reputation of this brand or its mattresses. The Better Business Bureau continues to give Tempur-Pedic its highest accolades, an "A+" rating and accreditation. You can also see from the unfiltered reviews on the site that people love the way they sleep on a Tempur-Pedic mattress.
You get what you pay for
They say you get what you pay for, and that's the truth here: this brand delivers on its promises of superior support and cooling, depending on which mattress style you buy. Even on the highest-end models (the LUXEbreeze), you'll see lots of customers who say it's absolutely worth every penny because they're sleeping better than they ever dreamed possible (pun intended). We never thought we'd see shoppers who were excited about a $9,000+ mattress, but here we are.
Excellent foam mattresses if you can afford them
The only reason Tempur-Pedic isn't our #1 brand is the obvious one: many customers aren't looking to spend thousands of dollars on a foam mattress, even if it offers amazing benefits. There's nothing budget-friendly here, which will leave some shoppers looking to other retailers for a more affordable option. Other than that, however, Tempur-Pedic is an excellent choice if you've got the resources and you'll do anything it takes to finally sleep soundly.
Essentia has worked hard to perfect "the world's only natural memory foam" . If you want a mattress that's organic and non-toxic, this is the brand for you. They even offer this fun fact: if you were to leave your Essentia mattress completely exposed to the elements of sun, wind, and rain, it would fully biodegrade within three years.
100% organic mattresses are a thing
You might be wondering how, exactly, a foam mattress can be "organic" . They're made from hevea milk (the sap of the rubber tree), organic latex, Dunlop latex (also made from rubber tree sap), plant extracts like hydrolyzed corn, organic cotton, and even essential oils like grapefruit seed and jasmine essence.
Premium materials = premium price
It should be no surprise that you'll pay a lot more for an organic foam mattress, compared with pricing from Essentia's non-organic rivals. The lowest-priced mattress here is $2,448, and the most expensive is a jaw-dropping $14,500. At least the shipping is free, right?
Choose your category, then your desired firmness
Once you've gotten past the sticker shock, how do you go about choosing the right Essentia mattress for you? Start by deciding which category you prefer, and then choose the feel you like best:
Longer sleep trial and warranty period
With the exception of the custom-made beds, all Essentia foam mattresses come with a 120-night sleep trial and a 20-year warranty. Their testing indicates that your mattress should experience a height decrease of less than a half-inch within 10 years, and your warranty goes well beyond that for extra peace of mind about your investment. But, unlike many foam mattress brands, Essentia charges a return fee of around 9% of the retail price. We're a little disappointed that trying a mattress here isn't exactly risk-free.
Save with a sale or discount for certain professions
When we visited the Essentia online store most recently, there was a mattress sale in progress. Shoppers could save 20% on the Lifestyle category, 22% on Performance, and 25% on Wholebody. When we clicked on the link at the top of the page to get more info on the sale, we also found that Essentia offers an everyday discount of $100 to teachers, military, first responders and medical professionals who verify their status. Just note that this discount can't be stacked with any other promo code, and a sitewide sale might offer you more savings.
No BBB complaints
Essentia was listed as "Not Rated" by the Better Business Bureau. That's a bit of a surprise, given that the company has been around for over a decade - but that also reflects the fact that there have been no complaints filed against Essentia with the BBB. And that's always a good thing.
Customer feedback varies
Customer comments elsewhere are a mixed lot. Some people have nothing but praise for Essentia, from the mattresses themselves to their experience with customer support. The opposite is also true, with complaints about the comfort of the mattress (and the cost of the return fees) and with the way Essentia reps handled issues that were raised.
Great option for some, too expensive for most
If you or someone in your household struggles with allergies and sensitivities, Essentia's organic, non-toxic products might be your only option in the foam mattress marketplace. We can appreciate the care and research that have gone into making these mattresses, and it's impressive that there's an option for fully-customized mattresses geared towards world-class athletes (or even just those of us who aspire to be). But, Essentia's price point combined with a return fee of nearly 10% keep the brand from reaching greater heights in our rankings.
Keetsa got its start in 2007 after its founders noticed how stressful most people found mattress shopping to be. Why not make it easy to get the right one, with no sales pressure or dozens of models to choose from? You can test out Keetsa mattresses in a tranquil, customer-centric setting if you visit one of their stores in CA or NY, or simply use their website's Match Wizard to determine your perfect fit online.
4 foam and hybrid mattresses
Keetsa offers just four foam and hybrid mattresses to choose from (plus two iCoil varieties you'll also see on their website):
Watch out for the return fee
You get a 12-year warranty and a 90-night sleep trial with any Keetsa foam mattress. However, don't overlook the detail of the return fee: you'll have 10% deducted from your refund as a processing fee. That's not as generous as most of Keetsa's rivals in the industry, who make it risk-free to try their mattresses by not charging any kind of restocking or return fee.
Free shipping in lower 48 states
When we browsed the Keetsa site recently, there was a pop-up discount code (STAYCOMFY) that earned us a 15% discount on all mattresses: a savings of up to $463. You'll get free shipping as long as you live within the continental United States, though we noticed that the Tea Leaf Dream's product info said that the King and Cal King sizes would be delivered at no charge via freight service and not FedEx Ground (and take 10-15 business days to arrive instead of the usual 5-10).
Mostly positive feedback from customers
The Better Business Bureau gives Keetsa a disappointing "D-" rating, but that stems from the company's failure to respond to two complaints filed more than a year ago: hardly a pattern of poor customer service. Looking beyond the BBB's listing, customer comments on Keetsa mattresses are usually very positive. We like that the company displays unfiltered reviews on their site: you can trust that the five-star ratings are legitimate because they also let you see the handful of one-star reviews they've received. There are plenty of people who have bought Keetsa mattresses on more than one occasion, loving the sleep they got so much that they've outfitted their guest bedroom or kids' rooms with them too.
Just average as a foam mattress brand
Still, there's nothing so "wow" about Keetsa to earn this retailer a top rating from us. We're not big fans of their 10% return fee, and we didn't see anything particularly novel or noteworthy in the construction of their foam mattresses. Keetsa is good, but it would take some changes to make them stand out in our rankings.
Sweet Night is a new entry in the foam mattress marketplace, getting its start around 2019. All of their mattresses come with a 100-day return policy and a 10-year warranty, with free shipping in the lower 48 states.
7 foam mattress options here
There are three memory foam mattress styles (Dreamy S1, Sunkiss, Breeze) and four foam-hybrid styles (Twilight, Dreamland, Ocean Blue, Island) offered by Sweet Night. Short of scrolling through all of the options, customers aren't given an easy way to compare and contrast the mattress choices. But at least one feature caught our eye as we browsed Sweet Night's inventory: the two-sidedness of the Dreamy S1. The bottom of the mattress is firm, while the reverse side has a softer feel at the head and medium-firm towards the "tail" of the mattress.
Most mattresses are under $1,000
Other than that, you're left to look through the brief descriptions of each Sweet Night mattress and see which ones match with what you need as a sleeper. Is that the cooling, breathable slumber of the Dreamland Hybrid? Or the body contouring, back/stomach sleeper support of the Ocean Hybrid? Or something else? That's up to you. Whichever mattress you select, you will usually pay less than $1,000; most twin mattresses start in the $300 range.
You might be out of luck for your mattress size
Mattress sizes here are more limited than we expected. For example, the Dreamland Hybrid, Twilight Hybrid, Island Hybrid, and Ocean Blue Hybrid were only offered in three sizes: sometimes that was Twin/Full/Queen, and for others it was Twin/Queen/King. It seemed that shoppers might be able to find the missing sizes eventually, but at the time of our shopping trip they were listed as out of stock. That's a downside compared with rival foam mattress stores who have everything ranging from extra-long Twin to Split California King sizes and that make them easy to find. We had to go into Sweet Night's Buying Guides to shop by size; even then, it only listed Twin-Full-Queen-King, but we spotted frames-only for Twin XL and Split Cal King sizes.
Don't miss the buying guides
Those Buying Guides could be useful if you're shopping for a particular mattress height, sleeping position, health condition (like sciatica, shoulder pain or hip pain), or even by people. Want recommendations for kids, heavy people, seniors, and so on? Then be sure to find this section of the Sweet Night site. We got a particular chuckle out of the "Mattress for Sex" section, which said the ideal fit would have "great responsiveness, bouncy support and minimal noise." Yes sir!
Not the most polished foam mattress company
At the time of this evaluation, Sweet Night had a "B-" grade from the Better Business Bureau, but their reasons weren't worrisome: 13 complaints filed against Sweet Night over the course of three years and the overall time the company has been in business. Not a big deal! And yet, there were aspects of Sweet Night that left us scratching our heads a little. Some of the text throughout the site felt amateurish: typos, an "About Us" that read like something hastily thrown together as an afterthought, and so on.
Good initial feedback from shoppers
Still, we were somewhat reassured by the customer reviews on the mattresses themselves. The Twilight alone had over 1,000 unfiltered ratings the last time we checked, and the vast majority were a perfect five stars. We found similar feedback outside of the Sweet Night store, including quite a few people who said that this brand's customer service team is helpful and takes care of issues quickly.
Room for improvement
For now, we give Sweet Night a "just average" rating. We like the affordability of their foam and hybrid mattresses and the 100-night sleep trial, but the online store isn't easy to navigate and comes across as unpolished compared with the company's more established competitors. We hope to see Sweet Night continue to build its reputation and earn a stronger ranking in the future.
Puffy is one of the only companies in our review that offers foam and hybrid mattresses made in the USA. They use only foams that are Certi-PUR-US certified, which means you won't have to worry about your mattress being made with phthalates, ozone depleters, or other harmful chemical compounds. You've got a 101-night sleep trial here, and Puffy also offers a lifetime warranty on all of their mattresses.
3 mattress types suitable for any base you like
There are three types of mattresses available here, all of which are designed to rest on any surface you choose, from box springs to frames to Puffy's own adjustable base:
Big discounts and free stuff
Keep an eye out for discounts. The last time we shopped the Puffy website, there was a coupon code that, as you'd imagine, saved us money on any mattress. A weekend sale sweetened the deal with a free sheet set, mattress protector, and pillows too (though that part may be included all the time, lucky for you).
Not compressed for long
What else sets Puffy apart from its rivals? We like the fact that their mattresses are made, compressed, and packaged in small batches: they're only compressed for a week or so before you have it delivered, so there's no quality degradation from being squished for a long period of time.
Mattresses that sag after a year or two
How about reputation? In our previous review of Puffy, the company had an "A+" from the Better Business Bureau - but more recently, the listing was changed to "under review" . That's not usually a good sign. We got an idea of why when we looked at customer feedback beyond the 10,000+ filtered five-star reviews on the Puffy website: complaint after complaint described mattresses that sagged noticeably after a few years, difficulties getting a response from Puffy reps to fix problems covered by the "lifetime" warranty.
Not a favorite anymore
We really like the idea of buying a mattress that's made in the USA, and we don't want to completely overlook the thousands of people who love their Puffy mattresses - at least, they do at first. Puffy falls down when it comes to offering a good night's sleep night after night and year after year, and they make you jump through a lot of hoops to try and prove that there's a warranty-covered problem. You have so many options for buying a new foam mattress, so why not get yours from a company with a stronger reputation for customer service?
Nature's Sleep was founded by Marc Werner in 2001, stemming from his personal desire to create the perfect mattress. This store has three main mattress lines: Nature's Sleep, GhostBed, and the Venus Williams Collection (also by GhostBed).
Website isn't easy to navigate
This retailer doesn't make it easy to see the differences among those three lines at a glance. In fact, even their FAQ invites you to "carefully read all of [their] product descriptions and choose the mattress that fits your unique needs" . Not very helpful, but okay.
3 mattress collections
Here's an idea of what you can expect:
Too many disappointed customers
Customer feedback on Nature's Sleep mattresses is pretty mixed. About a third of shoppers say it's the best sleep they've gotten in their lives, but another third give the product the lowest possible rating of one star. And, for the customers who decide to return their Nature's Sleep purchases, it can be really hard to get their money back. Several customers said that it took months to get a refund: they sent the mattresses back, only to be told much later that they'd have to return the pillows Nature's Sleep had given them for free with their order too. Finally, we noticed that all of the reviews on the site were not only a year old or more, but also almost all of them were related to GhostBed Canada. What's up, Nature's Sleep?
Last choice for foam mattresses
The word we'd use to describe buying a Nature's Sleep mattress is "frustrating" . How hard is it to make a comparison chart so that customers can see the differences between two different mattresses? Or to include a checkbox that lets you select the ones that interest you and see them side-by-side? It's no problem for Nature's Sleep rivals, apparently. Between an aggravating shopping experience and more than a few unhappy customer reviews, Nature's Sleep winds up dropping from an impressive 4.5-star rating in our last review to the bottom of the pile in this one.
What do you need to know about this type of mattress? First, there's a distinction between all-foam and hybrid construction. All-foam is just like it sounds: every layer consists of some kind of foam that either contours to your body or supports the mattress as a whole. These layers can vary quite widely from one brand to another, and even within the same manufacturer - offering different mattress heights, levels of support, and firmness at the edge of the bed itself. Hybrid mattresses are a combination of foam and coils or springs. These are usually designed to give you more support and cooling, and give you a sleep experience that more closely approximates what you're used to while offering the softer, more supportive feel of foam.
One innovation we've seen recently is flippable foam mattresses. If you're not sure whether you prefer yours to be on the firm or soft side, no worries: several brands give you a two-in-one experience. But, even if you don't purchase a two-sided foam mattress, you're not stuck with whatever you buy.
Why? Every brand in our review gives you at least 30 nights to try it out and see how it feels - because it can take at least that long for your body to adjust to a new mattress. Most foam mattresses give you even longer than that, from 100 days to a full year, and you can return it if you wind up thinking something else would be a better fit. Just watch for the details on that trial period: some companies charge a return fee, while others give you a full refund.
It's incredible how many foam mattress companies have hit the market over the last few years. Which one should you pick? You might feel overwhelmed even trying to start shopping around. We've evaluated some of today's most popular brands, and while you browse, here are some factors to keep in mind:
TopConsumerReviews.com has evaluated and ranked today's most popular retailers of foam mattresses. We're sure this information will help you pick the right mattress to get your best night's sleep ever!
Select any 2 Foam Mattresses to compare them head to head
Best Mattress of 2023: Top 5 Mattresses for Back Pain, Edge Support, ...
Us Weekly is not endorsing the products showcased below. If you’re searching for the best mattresses of 2023, you’re not alone. The wrong mattress can leave you tossing and turning or even make you ...
Sun, 03 Dec 2023