Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.
Sunday, March 3rd
Puffy is one of the only companies in our review that offers foam and hybrid mattresses made in the USA. They use only foams that are Certi-PUR-US certified, which means you won't have to worry about your mattress being made with phthalates, ozone depleters, or other harmful chemical compounds. You've got a 101-night sleep trial here, and Puffy also offers a lifetime warranty on all of their mattresses.
3 mattress types suitable for any base you like
There are three types of mattresses available here, all of which are designed to rest on any surface you choose, from box springs to frames to Puffy's own adjustable base:
Big discounts and free stuff
Keep an eye out for discounts. The last time we shopped the Puffy website, there was a coupon code that, as you'd imagine, saved us money on any mattress. A weekend sale sweetened the deal with a free sheet set, mattress protector, and pillows too (though that part may be included all the time, lucky for you).
Not compressed for long
What else sets Puffy apart from its rivals? We like the fact that their mattresses are made, compressed, and packaged in small batches: they're only compressed for a week or so before you have it delivered, so there's no quality degradation from being squished for a long period of time.
Mattresses that sag after a year or two
How about reputation? In our previous review of Puffy, the company had an "A+" from the Better Business Bureau - but more recently, the listing was changed to "under review" . That's not usually a good sign. We got an idea of why when we looked at customer feedback beyond the 10,000+ filtered five-star reviews on the Puffy website: complaint after complaint described mattresses that sagged noticeably after a few years, difficulties getting a response from Puffy reps to fix problems covered by the "lifetime" warranty.
Not a favorite anymore
We really like the idea of buying a mattress that's made in the USA, and we don't want to completely overlook the thousands of people who love their Puffy mattresses - at least, they do at first. Puffy falls down when it comes to offering a good night's sleep night after night and year after year, and they make you jump through a lot of hoops to try and prove that there's a warranty-covered problem. You have so many options for buying a new foam mattress, so why not get yours from a company with a stronger reputation for customer service?
You may have found your curiosity piqued by a mattress-in-a-box unboxing video, watching a seemingly too-small carton produce a king-size mattress in just a matter of seconds. Yes, you really can get an amazing night's sleep from one of these mattresses that gets shipped to your doorstep - no need to drive around town and strap your new bed to the roof of your car after all!
In fact, many customers have a strong preference for foam mattresses over the traditional spring or coil versions paired with a box spring. Technology has come a long way over the last decade or so, and if you're tired of waking up with an aching back, sore shoulder, or irritable partner (because your tossing-and-turning shook the bed all night), you'll definitely want to consider what a foam mattress can do for you.
What do you need to know about this type of mattress? First, there's a distinction between all-foam and hybrid construction. All-foam is just like it sounds: every layer consists of some kind of foam that either contours to your body or supports the mattress as a whole. These layers can vary quite widely from one brand to another, and even within the same manufacturer - offering different mattress heights, levels of support, and firmness at the edge of the bed itself. Hybrid mattresses are a combination of foam and coils or springs. These are usually designed to give you more support and cooling, and give you a sleep experience that more closely approximates what you're used to while offering the softer, more supportive feel of foam.
One innovation we've seen recently is flippable foam mattresses. If you're not sure whether you prefer yours to be on the firm or soft side, no worries: several brands give you a two-in-one experience. But, even if you don't purchase a two-sided foam mattress, you're not stuck with whatever you buy.
Why? Every brand in our review gives you at least 30 nights to try it out and see how it feels - because it can take at least that long for your body to adjust to a new mattress. Most foam mattresses give you even longer than that, from 100 days to a full year, and you can return it if you wind up thinking something else would be a better fit. Just watch for the details on that trial period: some companies charge a return fee, while others give you a full refund.
It's incredible how many foam mattress companies have hit the market over the last few years. Which one should you pick? You might feel overwhelmed even trying to start shopping around. We've evaluated some of today's most popular brands, and while you browse, here are some factors to keep in mind:
TopConsumerReviews.com has evaluated and ranked today's most popular retailers of foam mattresses. We're sure this information will help you pick the right mattress to get your best night's sleep ever!
Select any 2 Foam Mattresses to compare them head to head
The best pillow-top mattresses 2024: Hotel quality beds tested by ...
Our expert testers have reviewed a wide range of pillow-top mattresses and, based on our extensive in-house testing and analysis of customer reviews, we recommend the Saatva Classic as the best pillow ...
Sat, 02 Mar 2024