Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

Manhattan Fruitier Review

Wednesday, March 22nd

2023 Fruit Basket Company Reviews

Top Consumer Reviews Best-In-Class Blue Ribbon Award Manhattan Fruitier Review 5 Star Rating

Manhattan Fruitier

5 Star Rating
  • 40+ different fruit baskets available for shipment nationwide or for hand delivery in NYC
  • Emphasis placed on gourmet-quality items and overall sustainability
  • Prices range from $40 to $375
  • Beautiful packaging
  • In operation since 1987
  • Donates blemished-but-edible fruit to NYC's City Harvest
Top Consumer Reviews Best-In-Class Blue Ribbon Award

Manhattan Fruitier has been "inspiring delight" for over 35 years. When it comes to fruit baskets, they taste-test every case of produce and visually inspect each piece before it gets included in an all-natural basket. Everything here is top-quality, focused on sustainability, and bespoke. In fact, Manhattan Fruitier's fruit baskets are so sought after, you'll even spot them offered by several of the other vendors we evaluated (like A Gift Inside and Harry & David).

Stellar array of fruits and treats

You'll find an aesthetically-appealing selection of over 40 fruit baskets here, ranging in price from $40 for the diminutive Pippin All-Fruit basket to the grandiose New Amsterdam ($375, NYC only) and Imperial ($335) arrangements. Each fruit basket description lets you know what to expect, but because the included produce will always depend on what's fresh and in season, you won't usually know exactly which varieties to expect - just a blend of exotic and traditional fruits. Also, some arrangements include a specified treat, while others will give you the ability to choose: the New Amsterdam lets you select three from a list that (at the time of our most recent visit) included caramels, biscotti, rugelach, cheese crisps, and Harbor Sweets chocolates.

Most popular basket is under $100

Manhattan Fruitier's most popular fruit basket is the Cortland Hamper for $95 (or $127 if you prefer all-organic). Over 90 reviews, this gift averaged a perfect five-star rating. Depending on the time of year that you place your order, the basket's ~14 pieces of fruit may include mangoes, avocados, persimmons, pears, apples, citrus and more. There's an extra treat in every Cortland too, which also depends on the season. At the time of our review, it was seven goat milk caramels, but your basket could have chocolates or other gourmet sweets.

Get discounts and gift suggestions

Need some recommendations for your special occasion gifting? We saw a pop-up during our last visit to the Manhattan Fruitier store that let us choose a holiday or event (Sympathy, Graduation, Corporate Gift) and enter our email address; in return, we got an email with suggested gifts for that occasion plus a 10% discount code.

Gorgeous presentation

How your fruit basket will be packaged depends on where it's going. If you're sending an arrangement to someone in NYC, it'll probably be an open, handled basket covered with an Abaca net bag and hand-delivered. Otherwise, your gift will be "nestled in paper excelsior" , closed with a lid, and shipped in a cardboard box with ice packs if needed. Either way, customers rave about the beautiful presentation, saying it's so pretty it looks like a painting.

Best Fruit Basket Companies

Shipping fees from $15 to $61

Shipping fees vary, based on the product and delivery date you select. For example, on that Cortland fruit basket we described earlier, Saturday deliveries came with a $61 shipping cost, while Tuesday through Thursday arrivals would only incur a $15 fee. At least in the zip codes we used, there were no available deliveries on Sundays or Mondays.

Committed to your satisfaction

Despite being in business since 1987, Manhattan Fruitier has a "Not Rated" listing with the Better Business Bureau, who say they don't have enough information to issue a rating. That's actually not a bad thing: no complaints filed there, ever, is terrific. And, for the most part, customer feedback found elsewhere is very positive too. Clients say these fruit baskets are elegant, sometimes exotic, and always make an impression on the recipients. We spotted a few reports of poor quality (dates with mold, rotten fruit) but they were followed almost immediately by an apologetic response from Manhattan Fruitier's team - sometimes from the owner himself. The company guarantees that your gift will be in pristine condition upon arrival and they'll replace anything that's damaged or spoiled.

Gives edible-but-ugly fruit to charity

We love the fact that no fruit goes to waste here. Anything that's edible but not quite up to Manhattan Fruitier's aesthetic standard of excellence gets donated to City Harvest of New York City, where it gets distributed to various soup kitchens and other non-profit organizations. Another really great reason to patronize this business.

Best fruit baskets in the industry

We're pleased to give Manhattan Fruitier our first-place ranking. It's a competitive industry with many worthy candidates, but this company's commitment to sustainability without sacrificing quality or presentation is remarkable. Your gift recipients will be delighted, maybe even speechless, when they receive a fruit basket from Manhattan Fruitier.

Where Can You Buy the Best Fruit Baskets?

With so many people trying to "eat clean" these days, fruit baskets are a fantastic option when you're struggling to decide what to give someone as a gift. Chocolate? They might be allergic. Nuts? Even more so. Gift cards? Boring. But fresh fruit? Everyone loves a juicy peach, ripe pear, tangy orange or crunchy-crispy apple!

What can you expect when shopping for the right fruit basket for your lucky recipient? Some retailers focus just on fresh produce, and you'll see boxes laden with the winter's best grapefruit from Texas and Florida, carefully-wrapped apples from the Northeast, or a variety mix of several different kinds of fruit. Yummy! Other fruit baskets offer an assortment of pieces of fruit and treats like cheese and crackers, chocolate-dipped pretzels, and much more. The sky's the limit when it comes to the options you'll see when you start browsing fruit baskets.

The Best Fruit Basket Companies Compare Fruit Basket Companies Compare Fruit Basket Company Reviews What are the best Fruit Basket Companies Best Fruit Basket Company Reviews

Fruit Basket Company FAQ

Fruit, of course! (Just kidding.) A fruit basket usually consists of a reusable container, sometimes a basket but possibly a wicker bowl or a hamper. The type of fruit included depends on the provider you select and maybe the current growing season - for example, fresh citrus in the winter months, uncommon varieties of apples in the fall, and so on.
Absolutely. The sky's the limit! Chocolate, nuts, baked goods, jams and jellies, and cheese are just a few of the most popular add-ons to a fruit basket.
Yes, but you may have to look a little harder to find a company that offers it. Only a small handful of fruit basket retailers go the extra length to source their fruit specifically from organic growers. And, as you'd expect, you will probably pay a little more compared with non-organic fruit baskets.
They can be as budget-friendly or luxury-priced as you choose to make them. You'll find prices generally range from $22 to $375.
Yes, most of the time your delivery fees aren't included in the price of the fruit basket. It takes a little extra TLC to make sure your fruit and any additional items arrive in fresh, flavorful condition. But, some fruit basket retailers have promotions that might get you free or discounted shipping on your order, so keep your eyes "peeled" (pun intended).
That depends on which fruit basket company you use. If you select one that has a network with local florists and gift shops, it's possible to get your basket delivered same- or next-day. Otherwise, expect it to take at least a few days, up to a week, for most fruit baskets to arrive.
The retailer of your fruit basket wants you to be delighted, so it shouldn't be difficult to get a replacement or a refund if the fruit doesn't arrive in good condition or there's another issue with the delivery. If you're sending the fruit basket to someone else, they may need to take a photo of the problem and submit it to the customer service department.
Especially during the holidays, we tend to get overloaded on cookies and other decadent desserts, alcoholic beverages and high-calorie savory foods. Sending a fruit basket gives your lucky recipient a healthy alternative - or maybe some fruits they can pair with their wine or cheese!
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

Fruit baskets are also a great way to show you care. Not only are they healthy, they're tasty and can be a special way to charm anyone on your gift giving list. However, when you're trying to decide which fruit basket to give, the choices can seem a little daunting.

Feeling overwhelmed? Don't worry. Here are some criteria you can use to choose the right supplier for your order, whether you're buying it as a treat for yourself or giving it as a gift:

  • Number of Fruit Baskets. How many choices are there? Some stores have dozens of arrangements to choose from, making it more likely that you'll spot the perfect one for your occasion. Others may offer just a handful of fruit baskets to consider.
  • Variety of Items. What can you get with your fruit basket? Is it just fruit, or are there arrangements that have sweet or savory items to complement the produce? Can you customize the basket with add-ons of your choice, like a stuffed animal or even a floral bouquet?
  • Price. Does the retailer have fruit baskets within your desired budget? Will you get a good value for what you spend? Is shipping included?
  • Reputation. What do previous customers say about the fruit baskets and the company's customer service? It's not uncommon for fruit to occasionally spoil en route or for pieces to arrive damaged, so how does the retailer handle it when there's a problem? The best ones will make it right with a refund or a reshipment - and without any hassle about it.

To help you find the best fruit baskets for your next gift-giving occasion, TopConsumerReviews.com has evaluated and ranked today's most popular online providers. We're sure this information will make it easy to buy a sweet-and-healthy treat that will delight your lucky recipient!

Compare Fruit Basket Companies

Select any 2 Fruit Basket Companies to compare them head to head

  • Manhattan Fruitier
  • A Gift Inside
  • Gift Tree
  • Gourmet Gift Baskets
  • Harry & David
  • Wine Country Gift Baskets
  • The Fruit Company
  • FTD
  • Edible Arrangements
  • Pittman & Davis
  • Fruit Bouquets
  • Shari's Berries
Manhattan Fruitier vs A Gift Inside Manhattan Fruitier vs Gift Tree Manhattan Fruitier vs Gourmet Gift Baskets Manhattan Fruitier vs Harry & David Manhattan Fruitier vs Wine Country Gift Baskets Manhattan Fruitier vs The Fruit Company Manhattan Fruitier vs FTD Manhattan Fruitier vs Edible Arrangements Manhattan Fruitier vs Pittman & Davis Manhattan Fruitier vs Fruit Bouquets Manhattan Fruitier vs Shari's Berries A Gift Inside vs Gift Tree A Gift Inside vs Gourmet Gift Baskets A Gift Inside vs Harry & David A Gift Inside vs Wine Country Gift Baskets A Gift Inside vs The Fruit Company A Gift Inside vs FTD A Gift Inside vs Edible Arrangements A Gift Inside vs Pittman & Davis A Gift Inside vs Fruit Bouquets A Gift Inside vs Shari's Berries Gift Tree vs Gourmet Gift Baskets Gift Tree vs Harry & David Gift Tree vs Wine Country Gift Baskets Gift Tree vs The Fruit Company Gift Tree vs FTD Gift Tree vs Edible Arrangements Gift Tree vs Pittman & Davis Gift Tree vs Fruit Bouquets Gift Tree vs Shari's Berries Gourmet Gift Baskets vs Harry & David Gourmet Gift Baskets vs Wine Country Gift Baskets Gourmet Gift Baskets vs The Fruit Company Gourmet Gift Baskets vs FTD Gourmet Gift Baskets vs Edible Arrangements Gourmet Gift Baskets vs Pittman & Davis Gourmet Gift Baskets vs Fruit Bouquets Gourmet Gift Baskets vs Shari's Berries Harry & David vs Wine Country Gift Baskets Harry & David vs The Fruit Company Harry & David vs FTD Harry & David vs Edible Arrangements Harry & David vs Pittman & Davis Harry & David vs Fruit Bouquets Harry & David vs Shari's Berries Wine Country Gift Baskets vs The Fruit Company Wine Country Gift Baskets vs FTD Wine Country Gift Baskets vs Edible Arrangements Wine Country Gift Baskets vs Pittman & Davis Wine Country Gift Baskets vs Fruit Bouquets Wine Country Gift Baskets vs Shari's Berries The Fruit Company vs FTD The Fruit Company vs Edible Arrangements The Fruit Company vs Pittman & Davis The Fruit Company vs Fruit Bouquets The Fruit Company vs Shari's Berries FTD vs Edible Arrangements FTD vs Pittman & Davis FTD vs Fruit Bouquets FTD vs Shari's Berries Edible Arrangements vs Pittman & Davis Edible Arrangements vs Fruit Bouquets Edible Arrangements vs Shari's Berries Pittman & Davis vs Fruit Bouquets Pittman & Davis vs Shari's Berries Fruit Bouquets vs Shari's Berries
Compare the Best Fruit Basket Companies
- VS -
Review the Best Fruit Basket Companies
See the Best Fruit Basket Company
The Best Reviews of Fruit Basket Companies