Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

The Best Fruit Clubs

Which Fruit Clubs Are the Best?

Why settle for past-their-prime apples and overripe oranges from your local grocery store when you can savor a delightful array of fruits, hand-picked at the peak of perfection? Fruit clubs offer you the opportunity to relish juicy, sweet fruits conveniently delivered right to your doorstep. Plus, they make for impressive gift subscriptions that can arrive weekly, monthly, or quarterly. Your holiday gift-giving list? Done and dusted - and healthy too!

Surprise and variety and two reasons why fruit clubs have become so popular. Subscribers receive a curated selection of fruits each month, sometimes introducing them to new and exotic varieties they might not find easily at their local grocery stores. This element of discovery adds an exciting dimension to the subscription, turning it into a monthly culinary adventure. It appeals to people who enjoy trying different flavors and textures, fostering a sense of exploration, and expanding their fruit loving palate.

Sunday, May 19th

2024 Fruit Club Reviews

The Fruit Company Review Top Consumer Reviews Best-In-Class Blue Ribbon Award 5 Star Rating

The Fruit Company

5 Star Rating Top Consumer Reviews Best-In-Class Blue Ribbon Award

The Fruit Company, established in 1942 by the Webster family, offers a variety of fruit club subscriptions. They have a rich history of providing mail-order apples, pears, cherries, and other fruits. Much of their fruit is handpicked from their orchards in Hood River, Oregon, and they offer four subscription plans: Americana, Medley, Exotica, and Organic, with options for 3, 6, or 12 months. Prices start at $139 for a 3-month subscription, and shipping is included. Although their satisfaction guarantee isn't explicitly stated on their website, they have numerous positive reviews and an "A" rating from the BBB. The Fruit Company is a fantastic choice among fruit clubs.

Frog Hollow Farm Review 4.5 Star Rating

Frog Hollow Farm

4.5 Star Rating

Frog Hollow Farm, established in 1989, is a pioneer in regenerative agriculture and organic fruit production. They offer two main fruit club options: the Monthly Cornucopia of California, providing a mix of seasonal organic fruits in 3, 5, or 10-pound quantities, starting at $185.99 for three months, and the Weekly Farm Box, offering similar options with weekly deliveries for 4, 8, or 16 weeks, starting at $247.99 for 4 weeks. Frog Hollow Farm is environmentally conscious, offsetting shipping emissions, using sustainable packaging, and employing biodegradable ice packs. And, with nearly 11,000 reviews averaging 4.8 out of 5 stars, they excel in product quality and responsive customer service. While their fruit club selection may vary seasonally, Frog Hollow Farm remains a top choice for high-quality organic fruit deliveries nationwide.

A Gift Inside Review 4.5 Star Rating

A Gift Inside

4.5 Star Rating

A Gift Inside, a seasoned player in the fruit industry, originally focused on pears and cherries in the Sacramento Valley. Over the years, they've expanded to include Golden State Fruit, Farmstead Gourmet, and CY Chocolates in their offerings. With a range of fruit clubs lasting from 2 to 12 months and free shipping, they offer tons of flexibility in all of their subscription options, which include DeLite, Premium, Light Fruit/Cheese, Premium Fruit/Cheese, and Organic fruit clubs. There's something for everyone at A Gift Inside, and customers love them too.

Amazing Clubs Review 4 Star Rating

Amazing Clubs

4 Star Rating

Amazing Clubs partners with top growers for express-shipped, high-quality fruit like Chinese Gooseberries, Black Splendor Plums, and Tarocco Blood Oranges for their fruit club deliveries. In every box, you receive two fruit types totaling about five pounds, but you don't get to choose the type (citrus, mixed fruit). Still, their flexibility shines with options spanning 3 to 12 months, monthly or bi-monthly deliveries, and hassle-free skips. This club is competitively priced and has no shipping fees, and there are plenty of perks when you give this subscription as a gift. At the end of the day, Amazing Clubs' "They'll Love It!" Guarantee and reputation with over two million happy customers make this fruit club an excellent choice.

Fruit Gift of the Month Review 4 Star Rating

Fruit Gift of the Month

4 Star Rating

Clubs of America, a trusted provider of monthly membership clubs for over two decades, offers the Fruit Gift of the Month Club, known for its affordability and quality. Each shipment includes five pounds of assorted fruit, such as Comice Pears, Honey Tangerines, Bing Cherries, and Royal Pineapple, along with the Fruit Expeditions Newsletter. The club provides extensive customization options, and prices range from $89.90 to $503.40 with the convenience of both monthly and upfront payment options. While specific reviews for this club are scarce, Clubs of America enjoys a solid reputation, including an "A+" rating from the BBB and a 4.5-star average overall. The company's satisfaction guarantee further reflects their commitment to offering reliable and customer-focused service, making the Fruit Gift of the Month Club a dependable choice for your regular fruit deliveries.

Hale Groves Review 3.5 Star Rating

Hale Groves

3.5 Star Rating

Hale Groves, a Florida-based fruit company in operation since 1947, offers a variety of fruit clubs, mainly focusing on citrus but with some mixed fruit options. Prices start at $72.99 for a 3-month sampler, with the option to receive up to 29 lbs of fruit per delivery. While free shipping is available for some clubs, additional shipping fees apply to others, and their gift-giving options are relatively basic. But, with an "A+" rating from the BBB and lots of five-star reviews from customers, you can be assured that Hale Groves delivers fresh and delightful produce. If you're seeking citrus-centric subscriptions, Hale Groves' fruit clubs are a dependable choice, though they lean toward the pricier side when factoring in shipping and handling costs.

Harry and David Review 3.5 Star Rating

Harry and David

3.5 Star Rating

Harry & David recently moved up in our fruit club rankings, thanks to overwhelmingly positive feedback from happy customers. Among the options here, you'll find organic, medley boxes that include other non-fruit treats, strictly citrus, and more, with prices starting at $94.99 for three months. Keep in mind that shipping fees vary, but an annual Passport Celebrations plan can get you free delivery. Rest assured, if you or your fruit club recipient ever get a less-than-perfect fruit delivery, Harry & David has a strong commitment to customer satisfaction as demonstrated by favorable reviews from customers. However, Harry & David still lacks a distinctive edge compared to top competitors, so we'd suggest looking at its higher-rated rivals first.

Pittman & Davis Review 3 Star Rating

Pittman & Davis

3 Star Rating

Pittman & Davis has expanded its offerings since our last review, providing a more diverse selection of fruit club subscriptions to choose from. These options include the Harvest-A-Month, Harvest-A-Month Lite, Simply Citrus, Citrus Supply-All Grapefruit, Citrus Supply-All Oranges, and Citrus Supply-Navels and Grapefruit. Prices start at $22.99 per delivery, and all plans come with free shipping. While Pittman & Davis maintains an "A+" rating and accreditation from the BBB, recent complaints regarding fruit quality have emerged -all of which keeps this fruit club from moving up (or down) in our rankings.

Dragonberry Review 3 Star Rating

Dragonberry

3 Star Rating

The Dragonberry Fruit Club, operating since 2004, specializes in unique fruit varieties and offers monthly deliveries of around 4-5 pounds of a single exotic fruit, such as Chocolate Persimmons or Rambutan. Prices range from $297 for 3 months to $990 for 12 months (with free shipping). While it caters to those seeking unique fruit experiences, the club's higher prices and limited customer feedback make it a slightly risky choice.

Melissa's Review 2 Star Rating

Melissa's

2 Star Rating

Melissa's has been a significant player in the global produce market since 1984 and currently holds the title of the largest distributor of specialty produce in the United States. Their food service division even collaborates with esteemed chefs to bring culinary offerings to sports venues across the country. However, Melissa's fruit club may disappoint you, as it focuses exclusively on exotic fruits with limited variety, and their pricing, when factoring in shipping fees, definitely isn't the best value in comparison to competitors. And, because customer feedback has raised concerns about the produce quality and customer service, Melissa's fruit club isn't one we can recommend with confidence.

Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

Of course, convenience is another reason why people love fruit clubs. n a world where time is a precious commodity, people appreciate services that simplify their lives. Monthly fruit subscriptions eliminate the need for regular trips to the grocery store, saving both time and effort. This convenience is particularly appealing to busy professionals, families, and individuals with hectic schedules who want a hassle-free approach to maintaining a healthy lifestyle.

It's important to remember that different fruits have varying shipping abilities. That's why in fruit club shipments, you'll commonly find fruits with more hardy skins or peels, like pears, oranges, grapefruits, and apples. They tend to withstand shipping better than softer alternatives like strawberries and grapes.

However, some fruit clubs may pleasantly surprise you with those fruits - as well as delicious cherries, peaches, and nectarines. A few subscriptions even allow you to opt for organic fruits, complement your order with gourmet cheese and nuts, or indulge in sweet treats like candy.

Yet, not all fruit clubs are cut from the same cloth. Some operate their own orchards and farms, delivering the freshest produce directly to you, while others serve as intermediaries, sourcing produce from various suppliers. So, how do you determine the ideal fruit club for you?

Here are some key factors to consider as you explore the diverse world of fruit memberships:

  • Fruit variety. Does the fruit club provide a wide selection of fruits to satisfy your taste buds? Can you mix and match different types of fruits to create your perfect selection, either in one box or from one month to the next?
  • Value. What quantity of fruit is included in each delivery, and does it match your expectations? Is shipping included in the subscription fee? Are there options to include additional items beyond fruits, such as gourmet treats?
  • Subscription options. Does the fruit club offer subscription plans that align with your budget and preferred duration? While most memberships span from three to twelve months, are there options for alternative frequencies, such as weekly or quarterly? Can you pay for each delivery as it ships, or do you have to pay upfront?
  • Customer service. Fruit can be a little delicate. Does the company promise to make it right if your apples arrive bruised or the grapefruit are already moldy? Check out what other customers have experienced when subscribing to the fruit club that interests you: is it hassle-free or a headache when you need help?

At Top Consumer Reviews, we've meticulously reviewed and ranked the finest fruit clubs currently available, to help you select the freshest and most delectable fruit subscription box for your upcoming gift-giving occasion or to treat yourself. Indulge in the delight of premium, hand-picked fruits, and elevate your culinary experience with the convenience of a fruit club.

The Best Fruit Clubs Compare Fruit Clubs Compare Fruit Club Reviews What are the best Fruit Clubs Best Fruit Club Reviews

Fruit Club FAQ

Some companies are fully organic, meaning they only offer organic products. Whereas others have different types of memberships that offer a pricier organic and an affordable non-organic fruit package. Its hard to tell 100% if it is organic - we recommend relying on company reputation.
Many fruit club companies have growers all over the US and even some international. Some of the fruit is handpicked from the local fruit orchards whereas other exotic fruits may be imported directly to the company and then to your table.
Club memberships have a variety of lengths. Some memberships range from weekly to every 2, 3, 4, 6, or 12 months (depending on the company). Many fruit club companies provide flexibility to select when the deliveries begin, allowing a customer to preorder a subscription to start delivering several days or even months from the day the order was originally placed.
You will see the gamut. Many of the companies allow the customer to give their preference on the type of fruit they enjoy. Other fruit club companies do not offer customization but do have a customer satisfaction guarantee.
Each company has various methods of packaging, but all guarantee fresh fruit right to the doorstep.
Most companies offer a customer satisfaction guarantee that includes either replacement or a refund. Some of the companies offer cancelation of the subscription at any time and include a refund (if it was a prepaid plan).
The type of fruit and amount can vary on the type of subscription chosen. Some subscriptions offer just the basic pears, peaches, oranges, and apples. More premium subscriptions can offer exotic fruits such as Grapefruit, dragon fruit, papayas, and more. For the most part, the amount of fruit shipped, varies by company, but averages to be around 2-4 different fruits.
The wide variety of fruit offered, means a wide variety of prices. A typical membership can cost anywhere from $64.99 to $2,065. Prices differ per company, size, type, and length of subscription.

Compare Fruit Clubs

Select any 2 Fruit Clubs to compare them head to head

best-fruit-clubs
  • The Fruit Company
  • Frog Hollow Farm
  • A Gift Inside
  • Amazing Clubs
  • Fruit Gift of the Month
  • Hale Groves
  • Harry and David
  • Pittman & Davis
  • Dragonberry
  • Melissa's
The Fruit Company vs Frog Hollow Farm The Fruit Company vs A Gift Inside The Fruit Company vs Amazing Clubs The Fruit Company vs Fruit Gift of the Month The Fruit Company vs Hale Groves The Fruit Company vs Harry and David The Fruit Company vs Pittman & Davis The Fruit Company vs Dragonberry The Fruit Company vs Melissa's Frog Hollow Farm vs A Gift Inside Frog Hollow Farm vs Amazing Clubs Frog Hollow Farm vs Fruit Gift of the Month Frog Hollow Farm vs Hale Groves Frog Hollow Farm vs Harry and David Frog Hollow Farm vs Pittman & Davis Frog Hollow Farm vs Dragonberry Frog Hollow Farm vs Melissa's A Gift Inside vs Amazing Clubs A Gift Inside vs Fruit Gift of the Month A Gift Inside vs Hale Groves A Gift Inside vs Harry and David A Gift Inside vs Pittman & Davis A Gift Inside vs Dragonberry A Gift Inside vs Melissa's Amazing Clubs vs Fruit Gift of the Month Amazing Clubs vs Hale Groves Amazing Clubs vs Harry and David Amazing Clubs vs Pittman & Davis Amazing Clubs vs Dragonberry Amazing Clubs vs Melissa's Fruit Gift of the Month vs Hale Groves Fruit Gift of the Month vs Harry and David Fruit Gift of the Month vs Pittman & Davis Fruit Gift of the Month vs Dragonberry Fruit Gift of the Month vs Melissa's Hale Groves vs Harry and David Hale Groves vs Pittman & Davis Hale Groves vs Dragonberry Hale Groves vs Melissa's Harry and David vs Pittman & Davis Harry and David vs Dragonberry Harry and David vs Melissa's Pittman & Davis vs Dragonberry Pittman & Davis vs Melissa's Dragonberry vs Melissa's
Compare the Best Fruit Clubs
- VS -
Review the Best Fruit Clubs
See the Best Fruit Club
The Best Reviews of Fruit Clubs