Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

Frog Hollow Farm Review

Friday, March 31st

2023 Fruit Club Reviews

Top Consumer Reviews Best-In-Class Blue Ribbon Award Frog Hollow Farm Review 5 Star Rating

Frog Hollow Farm

5 Star Rating
  • Cost: From $110 to $2,065 (club lengths range from weekly to yearly)
Top Consumer Reviews Best-In-Class Blue Ribbon Award

Frog Hollow Farm is our new favorite option among fruit clubs. In operation since 1989, the farm is located in Brentwood, California and maintains growing practices that are based on regenerative agriculture.

All organic fruit

All of their produce is organic and includes peaches, nectarines, blood oranges, pluots, cherries, and several other types of fruit. Completely committed to being good stewards of the environment, Frog Hollow Farm even offsets 100% of their carbon emissions from shipping, uses eco-friendly packaging, and the ice packs (as needed) that keep your fruit deliveries fresh are non-toxic and biodegradable. This is an eco-friendly business model we can get behind!

Great variety of fruit

All of these important details aside, one of our biggest reasons for giving this fruit club our highest ranking is because of the variety of options you can choose from. Most fruit subscriptions give you one or two fruits each month, and you don't get much say-so in what you're receiving. Or, maybe you have to commit to deliveries that are all apples, completely citrus, or plain pears. That's great if it's what you want, but many customers prefer a little more flexibility in their selection - and this farm definitely provides it.

Best Fruit Clubs

12 fruit clubs to choose from

Take a look at the fruit clubs offered by Frog Hollow and you'll see what we mean:

  • Cal Red Cravings: two shipments of the Cal Red variety of peaches. Available in 3, 5, and 10 lb. quantities, you'll pay anywhere from $110 to $260 depending on the size you select. These peaches have an August harvest window that can be as short as two weeks!
  • Monthly Cornucopia of California: available in delivery schedules of 3, 6, or 12 months, this club delivers the seasonal best of fruit grown in California. You might get apricots, cherries, plums and peaches from May through September; Frog Hollow Farm apples, pomegranates and pears in the fall and winter; and other seasonal produce from FHF and other local organic farms. You'll pay anywhere from $165 to $1,550, depending on the subscription length and fruit quantity you choose.
  • Battle of the Peaches: if you're a true peach lover, you'll enjoy deciding which is better - O'Henry or Cal Red? Your first shipment will be just O'Henry, the second will be a mixed "battle box" of O'Henry and Cal Red, and your final box will have only Cal Reds. Also available in 3, 5, and 10-lb. sizes, you'll pay $165 to $385. All deliveries will be in August (the harvest season of these two fruit varieties).
  • Flavor King Fiesta: this fruit club consists solely of Flavor King-variety pluots. Take note that this fruit club ships weekly and not monthly, usually in July. You'll pay anywhere from $165 to $390, based on which quantity you choose (3, 5, or 10 lbs.).
  • Weekly Farm Box: if you're up for some weekly surprises of mixed organic fruit from Frog Hollow Farm and their local small-farm partners, this is the club for you. Your produce may include citrus, avocados, apricots, peaches and more, depending on the season of your subscription. You can choose quantities of 3, 5, and 10 lbs., and delivery schedules of 4, 8 or 16 weeks. Prices range from $220 to $2,065.
  • Pear Parade: consisting of four shipments of pears - several European varieties plus Asian pears - delivered biweekly. These were sold out at the time of our review, so pricing wasn't available. But, if you know you want this for the pear lover in your life, you can opt in to Frog Hollow Farm's availability notifications on this fruit club's product page.
  • Gotta Have My Plums and Pluots: this fruit club ships weekly and includes several varieties of plums and pluots, like Dapple Dandy, Santa Rosa, Emerald Beaut and more. You'll pay anywhere from $220 to $515, for shipments of 3, 5, and 10 lbs.
  • Need My Nectarines: typically shipping in June, this weekly fruit club lets you sample some of the most succulent varieties of nectarines - like Summerflare and Fantasia. As with most of Frog Hollow Farm's clubs, this one comes in weights ranging from 3-10 lbs. and is priced between $220 and $515.
  • Peachy Picks (Petite): this is a four-shipment fruit club with, of course, just peaches. Similar to the previous two clubs, the quantities and pricing are the same and still depend on which combination you select. Deliveries happen weekly.
  • Peachy Picks: if you love peaches so much that the Petite, four-shipment fruit club just isn't enough, this eight-delivery plan is the upgrade. Ever tried a Gold Dust, Suncrest, O'Henry or Cal Red? Here's your chance. Choose quantities of 3, 5, or 10 lbs. and pay from $440 to $1,035.
  • Gotta Have My Pluots: you guessed it, this fruit club is just pluots (a cross between apricots and plums). Varieties may include the Flavor King, Crimson Royale and Honey Punch. Delivered weekly, you'll get four shipments and the prices are also between $220 and $515 in quantities from 3-10 lbs.
  • Pick of the Crop: want to try what Frog Hollow Farm's own Farmer Al says is the best pick of the day? This is the perfect fruit club for variety-lovers. It consists of 10 shipments of mixed fruit: whatever is the absolute best fruit at the time of shipment. That could include peaches, plums, cherries, pears and more. The quantity range is the same (3-10 lbs.), and the club is priced from $545 to $1,290.

Positive customer reviews

There are plenty of customer reviews at the very bottom of each fruit club's main page. We encourage you to read through them for yourself and see what's been said about the flavor and variety you'll get with Frog Hollow Farm.

Shipping is included

If you need to set a particular delivery date, enter that in the "Order Notes" section of your shopping cart before you check out. Shipping is included in the price of each of these fruit clubs. That's pretty amazing, considering that your fruit goes from tree to table in 48 hours! You can also sign up for Frog Hollow Farm Rewards, earning you one point for every dollar you spend. Points are redeemable on future purchases, and you'll even get a surprise reward on your birthday. This rewards program is complimentary.

Fresh, quality fruit

We found more than 5,000 unfiltered customer reviews and comments on the FHF site itself and you'll soon see that this business is doing a stellar job of delivering extremely fresh, superior-quality fruit - and has been for quite a while. Even with the tricky nature of delivering fruit, Frog Hollow Farm typically gets everything to your doorstep in unblemished condition - and their 100% commitment to your satisfaction ensures that you'll get a replacement or a credit towards future deliveries if anything gets damaged in transit.

Highest rating

For fruit clubs in a staggering number of mouthwatering varieties, make Frog Hollow Farm your first stop. While their prices are on the higher side compared with other fruit subscription plans, it's true that you get what you pay for - and, in this case, you get organic fruit at the peak of ripeness, a terrific satisfaction guarantee, and the knowledge that you're supporting sustainable agriculture. Frog Hollow Farm is the clear winner among fruit clubs.

Where Can You Find the Best Fruit Clubs?

It's easy to see why these membership plans have become so popular. Why settle for anemic apples and moldy mangoes from the grocery store when you can have the most delicious selection of fruits picked at the height of freshness?

With fruit clubs, you can get juicy, sweet fruit delivered right to your doorstep. Or, you can impress someone with a gift subscription delivered weekly, monthly or quarterly!

The Best Fruit Clubs Compare Fruit Clubs Compare Fruit Club Reviews What are the best Fruit Clubs Best Fruit Club Reviews

Fruit Club FAQ

Some companies are fully organic, meaning they only offer organic products. Whereas others have different types of memberships that offer a pricier organic and an affordable non-organic fruit package. Its hard to tell 100% if it is organic - we recommend relying on company reputation.
Many fruit club companies have growers all over the US and even some international. Some of the fruit is handpicked from the local fruit orchards whereas other exotic fruits may be imported directly to the company and then to your table.
The type of fruit and amount can vary on the type of subscription chosen. Some subscriptions offer just the basic pears, peaches, oranges, and apples. More premium subscriptions can offer exotic fruits such as Grapefruit, dragon fruit, papayas, and more. For the most part, the amount of fruit shipped, varies by company, but averages to be around 2-4 different fruits.
Club memberships have a variety of lengths. Some memberships range from weekly to every 2, 3, 4, 6, or 12 months (depending on the company). Many fruit club companies provide flexibility to select when the deliveries begin, allowing a customer to preorder a subscription to start delivering several days or even months from the day the order was originally placed.
You will see the gamut. Many of the companies allow the customer to give their preference on the type of fruit they enjoy. Other fruit club companies do not offer customization but do have a customer satisfaction guarantee.
Each company has various methods of packaging, but all guarantee fresh fruit right to the doorstep.
Most companies offer a customer satisfaction guarantee that includes either replacement or a refund. Some of the companies offer cancelation of the subscription at any time and include a refund (if it was a prepaid plan).
The wide variety of fruit offered, means a wide variety of prices. A typical membership can cost anywhere from $64.99 to $2,065. Prices differ per company, size, type, and length of subscription.
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

Naturally, some fruits ship better than others - so you're more likely to see pears, oranges, grapefruit, apples and other varieties with a thick skin or peel, rather than softer choices that may spoil quickly (like strawberries and grapes). But, you might be surprised to find fruit clubs that feature flavorful peaches and nectarines too. Some of these subscription plans let you choose organic fruits, add on gourmet cheese and nuts, or even throw in some candy or other treats as well.

Not all fruit clubs are created equal, however. Some offer produce that comes directly from their own orchards and farms, while others merely act as a middleman to deliver fruit from a variety of sources. How can you tell which fruit club is the right choice?

Here are several criteria to keep in mind as you browse the many fruit memberships on the market:

  • Variety. Does the fruit club offer you a range of choices? Can you get several types of fruit? Are there options that include extras that go beyond fruit, if desired?
  • Plans. Is there a plan that meets your budget and your desired length? Most clubs range from three to twelve months, but what if you want something weekly or quarterly?
  • Value. How much fruit is in each delivery? Is shipping included or will you pay extra? Are you getting your money's worth with the fruit club?
  • Reputation. What do other customers say about their experience with the fruit club? Does fruit consistently arrive in good condition - and, if not, is there a solid satisfaction guarantee in place? Is it easy to get help from customer service if there's a problem?

TopConsumerReviews.com has reviewed and ranked the best fruit clubs available today. We hope this information helps you choose the freshest, most delicious fruit subscription box for your next gift-giving occasion - or for yourself!

See the Best Fruit Club
The Best Reviews of Fruit Clubs