Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.
Tuesday, May 13th
When you hear "Rosetta Stone," it might conjure images of dusty Egyptian artifacts, but in the world of language learning, it's synonymous with immersive teaching methods. Famous for software that plunges you directly into a new language without any translation "crutch”, Rosetta Stone has built its reputation on the idea that immersion is the key to fluency. It uses images, text, sound, and video to mimic the natural language acquisition process. However, Rosetta Stone's idea of "immersion" might not be the best way for adults to learn a new language. Keep reading to find out why.
Rosetta Stone isn't really immersive
Rosetta Stone calls its language learning approach "immersion," but what you get isn't quite the full immersion experience. True immersion means being part of a community where everyone speaks the language naturally, pushing you to constantly use and adapt to the language in real situations. Instead, Rosetta Stone has you working with a computer program that uses pictures, audio clips, and text in the target language, trying to mimic real-life use. For example, you might be asked to match words to pictures or respond to simple prompts, but you won't actually talk with native speakers in real-time, which is crucial for authentic immersion.
Translations help adults learn faster, not slower
Moreover, as an adult who already speaks one language fluently, you might find that learning without translations makes things harder. Adults usually pick up new languages better when they can link new words and grammar to what they already know. Translations help make new language concepts clearer and easier to remember, especially when dealing with complex ideas or technical topics that pictures alone can't explain. Rosetta Stone does their best to give you the context clues you need to decipher a sentence - for example, the phrase, "Der Supermarkt ist in der Nähe der Brücke” is accompanied by images of a supermarket produce section and a bridge superimposed over a map - but you'll still need to do some deciphering, which is time-consuming.
20 German units
When you check out "Explore All Content," you'll find 20 different sections of German lessons, from basic language to community and family topics. There are also a few short On-Demand videos, along with some stories.
Stories leave you in the dark
In the story "Der neue Schüler," you read about Mateo joining a soccer team at his new school. Your options are to read the story, listen to it, or read it out loud. However, there's no option for translation. Occasionally, certain words are highlighted in blue. If you hover over these words, an image appears to help explain the word's meaning. For example, when you hover over Gymnasium, an image of a high school appears (not a gym!). But what if you need help with some of the verbs, like beitreten, or you're not sure what belegtes Brot is? You're left with two options: look it up independently or remain confused.
Not equipped to teach complicated German grammar
Learning complex German grammar can be tough with Rosetta Stone's teaching style. German grammar includes intricate rules that change words based on gender and the case (nominative, accusative, dative, or genitive) being used. For instance, "Ich gebe der Frau das Buch" means "I give the woman the book." If you know some basics, you might wonder why a feminine noun (die Frau) suddenly has a masculine article here (der Frau) - and Rosetta Stone wouldn't explain that "der Frau" is the dative form for "the woman” based on the German rule that nouns change their articles according to their grammatical role, a concept foreign to English speakers who don't use article changes to indicate cases. Adults learning a new language need clear grammar explanations. While kids can learn a new language by immersion and repetition, adults often struggle because they try to apply their native language's grammar rules. This can lead to confusion and slow down learning, especially when the new language's structure is very different from their first language, like English and German.
A pricey set of flashcards
So how much would it cost to supposedly learn like a kid?
We don't think this is a good deal. When you look at the monthly subscription rate, there are other programs out there that provide more interactive features for about half the price. Some past users said Rosetta Stone was like a $250 set of flashcards and was too boring to continue using.
Choose a different service
If you're thinking about learning German, Rosetta Stone isn't the best way to do it. It tries to teach you ”the natural way” (by making you guess meanings), but it's really just a gimmicky waste of time. Adults can (and should) use their first language as a springboard to gain fluency in foreign languages. Rosetta Stone is pretty expensive, too. We'd recommend you try one of our higher ranked options, which tend to be more engaging, effective, and affordable.
Learning a language opens doors to new possibilities, and German is no exception. The trend of learning German online has gained traction globally due to the convenience, adaptability, and diversity of available resources. Want to learn German online? There's a plethora of options to suit your learning preferences.
Whether you're fascinated by Germany's picturesque architecture, interested in its robust engineering and philosophical legacy, a fan of its classical music and literature, seeking to reconnect with your family roots, or interested in job opportunities in the country with the largest economy in Europe, studying German can enhance your life.
When comparing German to English, there are several unique challenges you might face. German is notorious for its long compound words, but it also has a high degree of phonetic consistency, which can simplify pronunciation for beginners. However, German grammar won't be so easy to conquer, thanks to three genders for nouns, four cases, and seemingly endless verb conjugations. But, the precision of German, with its structured syntax and the rhythm of its sentences, offers a distinctive learning curve that can be immensely rewarding to master.
If you're an auditory learner and thrive on hearing how German sounds, there are specialized programs designed for that. These help you familiarize yourself with the language's intonation and pronunciation. And if you enjoy interactive learning, there are engaging platforms where you can acquire new vocabulary and grammar through games, competing against other learners and earning rewards as you progress.
If you prefer a structured learning approach, there are courses that integrate video lessons, quizzes, and even writing exercises. This helps you improve your reading, writing, speaking, and listening skills in German, all of which are required to reach fluency.
Prefer real-time interaction? You can connect with native German speakers via tutoring services. This is an excellent way to learn the practical usage of the language and gain deeper insights into German culture.
Not sure where to begin? Consider these factors as you explore your options:
To guide you to the best German lessons that match your goals and preferred learning style, our team at Top Consumer Reviews has reviewed today's top offerings and provided candid feedback on what each provides. So, why wait? Begin learning German today!
Select any 2 German Lessons to compare them head to head