Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.
Tuesday, March 19th
The Best Gift Baskets sounds pretty confident that they'll deliver a top-notch experience when sending their arrangements. After all, they call themselves "the best" . But, across multiple evaluations of this retailer over the years, we're still not convinced that this is much more than a one-man-show run by a guy named Bill (he even provides his personal email in the About Us Section).
Not too much on either extreme of the price spectrum
You won't find much here that's bargain priced, although The Best Gift Baskets has a few items under $40. These include the Ghirardelli Chocolate Squares in a Gift Tin for $29.95 and the California Classic White Wine and Cheese Gift Box for $39.95. On the other end of the price spectrum, this retailer's most expensive option - Only For The Best Dom Perignon Champagne Gift Basket, $399.99 - was out of stock at the time of this review.
About 50 affordable gift baskets to choose from
Most of the options at The Best Gift Baskets fall in the $75-$150 range. We were happy to see that there are non-food arrangements on offer, like the Fields of Lavender Spa Gift Basket and the Welcome Home Baby Gift Basket. Of course, if you're looking for a traditional selection of treats like fruit, chocolates, or cheese, you'll find those too. Overall, this retailer sells just over 50 different gift baskets, though at least a quarter of them were marked as "unavailable" during our most recent visit to their online store.
Shipping is spendy and delivery may take a while
Shipping is expensive here. You'll pay $19.95 for ground shipping on gifts under $150 and 16% of your total for orders over that amount. West Coast deliveries will take around two business days, five business days for East Coast addresses, and three to five business days for anywhere in between - but The Best Gift Baskets says you should assume five business days no matter where your recipient lives "to be safe" .
Almost no customer feedback - still
At the time of this review, the Better Business Bureau didn't have enough information to issue a rating for The Best Gift Baskets. That tracks with our own experience trying to find any customer testimonials beyond the handful featured on the store's website. Even jumping to the social media links provided by The Best Gift Baskets, those accounts seem to have gone radio silent after 2021 - despite having more up-to-date blog posts on the website itself.
Satisfaction guaranteed... theoretically
While we appreciate this retailer's 100% satisfaction guarantee that gives customers 30 days from delivery to reach out if there's a problem, that's not enough to convince us that Bill and his supposed team (with "a combined experience of over 10 years in the gift space" ) are on the ball enough to handle any issues that may arise. And, despite offering to customize gifts for corporate giving, The Best Gift Baskets doesn't have the kind of presence that we'd want to see for any kind of bulk ordering that a large business might need at the holidays or for a big event.
Go with a more popular gift basket retailer
With so many well-established gift basket stores out there, The Best Gift Baskets just can't compete. We were hoping that, in the years since our previous evaluation, this retailer would have more evidence of doing a robust business within the industry - but that just hasn't happened. Until The Best Gift Baskets has more to show for itself, particularly with customer reviews and feedback, it will remain at the bottom of our list. Try one of the more popular gift basket stores in our evaluation instead.
Gift-giving can be a daunting task. It can be challenging to find the right gift that is both thoughtful and appropriate for the recipient. Gift cards may be an easy option, but they can come across as impersonal and boring.
This is where gift baskets come in. They are beautifully arranged and full of a variety of items that are tailored to the occasion. Whether it's a child's birthday or a colleague's promotion, there's a gift basket for every occasion. Fine wine and cheese? Absolutely! Teethers and burp cloths for your friend's first baby? You got it! There's a gift basket to suit just about any budget, from popcorn tins under $25 to jaw-dropping arrangements priced at $400 and up.
Gift baskets hit all the right notes no matter the occasion: expertly packaged, beautifully arranged, and full of an assortment of the perfect snacks, toys, or other items designed to match the moment. The sky is truly the limit, with budget-friendly gift baskets that might have a small toy and a candy bar for a child's birthday, all the way up to the most decadent, luxurious array of fine wine and gourmet cheese to commemorate a long-anticipated promotion.
However, not all gift basket companies are created equal. Some offer a wide variety of options, including customization down to the color of the ribbon, while others may provide only a few overused basket designs.
Consider these criteria to help you narrow down the possibilities and find the perfect gift basket for your recipient:
To help you find the best baskets for your gift-giving occasion, Top Consumer Reviews has reviewed and ranked the most popular companies on the market. So, the next time you're struggling to find the right gift, consider a gift basket. It's sure to impress and delight the recipient!
Select any 2 Gift Basket Companies to compare them head to head