Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

American Greetings Review

Wednesday, February 12th

2025 Gift Box Reviews

American Greetings Review 3 Star Rating

American Greetings

3 Star Rating
  • Most boxes are under $5
  • Bundles available that include tissue paper and/or bows
  • Boxes come in different sizes and colors
  • Holiday boxes are available
  • There are plain boxes available for personal customization

American Greetings is truly a story of the American Dream. The story started in 1906, when Polish immigrant Jacob Sapirstein, with a vision and a $50 loan, began importing beautiful postcards from Germany and selling them to local shop owners from his family's horse-drawn cart. He lived to see his company become worth $1 billion. The company boasts a rich history and has garnered recognition for its cultural contributions. In a digital age, it's a special thing to receive gifts and cards with real paper, and American Greetings continues to supply gift-givers with tangible cards and gift boxes that add a feeling of special care to a gift.

High-quality boxes

Thousands of reviews from satisfied customers indicate that American Greetings' gift boxes, especially the clothing gift boxes, are high-quality and sturdy enough to make a wonderful presentation.

Push-down boxes include matching ribbons.

Each push-down box is about 5x5x7 and is large enough to hold a small plushie. The push-down boxes come in a pack of 4 with different designs - some with glitter - and all the boxes in the multipack come with a beautiful matching ribbon to give that finishing touch for your gift. In addition to plushies, push-down boxes can hold clothing, perfume, books, and more. American Greetings also sells tissue paper to add an even nicer finish to your gift.

Best Gift Boxes

Pillow boxes

American Greetings' pillow boxes come in a four-pack and are perfect for hard-to-wrap items. Regrettably, customers often return these pillow boxes, citing difficulties in assembling them without tearing.

Rich history, but not a lot of options for gift boxes

American Greetings has over a hundred years of history in the gifting industry, and yet the choices for gift boxes are extremely limited. We appreciate the quality of the clothing boxes and the included matching ribbons with the push-up boxes. We wish the push-up and pillow boxes came in more sizes, though. We'd also love to see more boxes with patterns. We feel like American Greetings is a worthy option for purchasing gift boxes if you are gifting clothing, neckties, or scarves. However, compared with its higher-ranking rivals on our list, it's easy to see that the inventory here is degrees of magnitude smaller. Since most people looking for gift boxes need more than just two styles to choose from, we only give American Greetings a "just average” rating.

Where Can You Find the Best Gift Boxes?

Do you love the holiday season and celebrations but dread wrapping all the gifts? Do you routinely host big parties or family get-togethers but don't want to overspend on packaging? Or have you just started your own baking business and need some packaging ideas for your cookies and baked goods?

Whether you are packaging things for your Etsy store, booth at the farmer's market, or your daughter's wedding, you want to be able to present something that looks beautiful and reflects the care and thought you put into all that you do. Sure, you can visit brick-and-mortar stores, but they are often poorly stocked and messy, or overstocked in one thing but missing the rest of what you need to create the perfect gift package.

The Best Gift Boxes Compare Gift Boxes Compare Gift Box Reviews What are the best Gift Boxes Best Gift Box Reviews

Gift Box FAQ

The answer to that question really depends on whether you're buying a lot of them or just a few. Some retailers focus on business customers who need hundreds (or thousands) of gift boxes at once, while others are definitely more for the everyday consumer who wants something special for their holiday and special occasion gift-giving. Either way, you've got several fantastic options to choose from.
Yes! Some retailers of gift boxes specialize in bulk orders, especially for businesses. This is a much better alternative than trying to find them at a local brick-and-mortar store and hoping they'll have enough in stock.
Yes! There's no need to buy 100 gift boxes if you only need 10. You might pay a little more for a smaller order, but you can definitely get just what you want. And, if you want a more decorative gift box, you've got that option as well (because they usually aren't offered in bulk like the plain white variety).
Sometimes. But if you know you need more than one or two for all of your holiday gift-giving, or you prefer gift boxes in non-standard sizes, do you want to risk not being able to get them for free? It's probably smarter to pay for what you want instead of hoping that your local retailer will give them to you for free.
Definitely. Some retailers go all out to provide beautiful, unique gift boxes that you'll be proud to present to the choosiest of recipients.
That varies. Small, plain white boxes purchased in bulk can be just a couple of cents each, while decorative gift boxes with lots of flourishes can be $5 each or more.
That depends. How many gift boxes are you buying? Do you need expedited delivery? You may get your shipping included at no extra cost, or you could wind up paying $10 or more. Most retailers will tell you exactly how much you'll pay for delivery well before you click "buy now”.
Check the retailer's return policy. Some stores give you 30 days or more to return your gift boxes for a full refund.
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

What you planned on being an hour-long shopping trip turns into an all-day hunt as you go from store to store looking for all the things you need. And after all that, you have to battle traffic on the way home. When you shop online for gift boxes and accessories, the first thing you will realize is that if you stick with the brick-and-mortar retailers' online storefronts your selection is still limited and often a little overpriced.

Dig a little deeper, and you will hit the jackpot: the internet has so many gift box options that it can be almost overwhelming. From wholesalers who require a 100-piece minimum to specialty shops found in online marketplaces, you are sure to find everything you were looking for, and maybe even things you didn't know you loved, but that now inspire you to gift-giving excellence.

Gift wrapping is a millenia old tradition, and it first began with gifts wrapped in pretty fabrics. With the continuing evolution of gift wrapping using digital printing methods and new technologies, we now have everything from handmade tags made out of specialty papers, to spectacularly-printed wrapping paper, to neatly and elegantly-presented gifts in gift boxes of all shapes, sizes and materials. Gift wrapping and boxing is now an industry all its own. Today, Americans spend more than $3 billion on gift wrap and packaging each year. But wrapping paper is unwieldy, hard to use, and hard to recycle. Many gifters are switching over to gift boxes, which can be used again and again.

With so many different gifts, gifters, and recipients, it can be hard to know how to pick out gift wrapping or boxes. Fortunately, online gift box services will put it all together for you wholesale. However, it can be hard to choose which service to go with. The boxes all look so nice, and everyone has a different style and reason for needing gift packaging options. Whether you're looking for something for a special friend or planning a family reunion, a church party or a business event, we've got all the best gift box services here for you to consider.

So, how do you choose the best gift boxes for your needs? If you're not sure where to start, here are some factors that can help you pick the best boxes for you:

  • Business or personal. Do you want to buy in bulk for your business? Or do you just want a few choice gift boxes for that special someone? Do you need 50 units for your order, or just one or two?
  • Price per unit. How much are you looking to pay per box? Does having single-purchase options matter more than cost per unit? How do similar boxes compare? Are you prepared to spend extra on special fees or shipping costs?
  • Design. Do you need a specific box shape for a particular gift, or is a basic square box good for your needs? Do you need boxes that display their contents or have luxurious materials? Do you want to give a gift to a child or are you planning a formal event? Do you need something that looks luxurious or do you want it to be playful?
  • Creativity. Do you want boxes that reflect your personality, or do you want to be able to add something yourself? Do you want a box that can be gifted without wrapping paper or are you happy with something basic as long as it does the job? Do you need to be able to add custom designs or brand logos for your business or organization?
  • Add-ons. Are you looking for a one-stop shop, where you can buy all your gifting supplies in one place, or do you just need a few boxes and that's all?
  • Time constraints. Do you have the time to wait on custom impressions and specialty items or are you in a time crunch? Do you need 50 cute cupcake boxes…tomorrow… or do you have time to get a sample of the gift box before making a decision?

To help you have a stress-free gift wrapping experience and to help you show your friends, family, colleagues or clients how much you care about them, Top Consumer Reviews has evaluated and ranked today's most popular online gift box retailers. We hope these will make it easy to choose the best gift boxes for your needs, so you can feel confident you've got the perfect presentation every time.

The Best Reviews of Gift Boxes