Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

Paper Source Review

Tuesday, February 7th

2023 Gift Box Reviews

Paper Source Review 4 Star Rating

Paper Source

4 Star Rating
  • Single-purchase options
  • Boxes for gifting and shipping
  • Focused on individuals
  • All gifting materials in one place
  • In-store pick-up can save you on shipping costs

First opened in 1983 in Chicago, IL, Paper Source is a store for all things paper: wrapping paper, bags, and, of course, gift boxes. Their products offer a unique presentation, with decorative gift boxes that are available in a variety of sizes and patterns. You can wrap them or add a bow and leave them as is.

Six gift box styles

Paper Source specializes in creating fun and beautiful patterns on well-loved standard box shapes. They offer six styles of gift boxes for a variety of purposes:

  • Boxes with lids: your traditional hard-sided gift box
  • Clothing boxes: white flat boxes with a lid and base
  • Treat tins: tins for food with colorful flat covers
  • Gift card boxes: small boxes that open for gift cards
  • Mailer boxes: a box that meets postal requirements
  • Treat boxes: open, basket-style boxes for snacks and treats
  • Novelty boxes: boxes with fun shapes, like a French bulldog

Styling and design

While at first glance some of their offerings might feel basic, the fan-favorite box with a lid design is Paper Source's showstopper. Instead of plain white or even simple colors, Paper Source offers designs for specific holidays, and patterns that elevate the simple gift box into something exciting all on its own. While Paper Source does sell wrapping paper, the goal with their box designs is to keep you from needing wrapping paper at all - like tartan designs, pine trees, and watercolor-style artwork already printed onto the boxes.

Sometimes simple is better

If you want something simple, they offer gold and white options as well. Their standard boxes with lids are hard-sided and stand up on their own. A basic white box with a lid is $7.50 per box, but as a reusable, sturdy item, the quality makes up for the higher price.

Best Gift Boxes

No wholesale or bulk pricing

If you're looking to buy a lot of boxes in one go, however, Paper Source doesn't offer package deals, so you will have to pay for as many individual units as you'd like. With their cheapest gift box running $3.50 per unit and their most expensive size running $17.50 per unit, it's important to consider how many boxes you'll need for your gift giving.

Getting the gift boxes to you

While shipping for single items starts at $7 per order, which isn't too bad, Paper Source is a large enough company to have in-person stores across the US. If you happen to live close to a Paper Source location, you can pick up your wares in person and skip the shipping fees altogether. The company is based in Chicago, IL, so there's several locations in that area, but there are also 150+ locations across the US including in Florida, California, Georgia, Utah, and New York. So, before you pay for shipping, double check to see if you can pick up your boxes in person.


The prices are a little higher per unit with Paper Source, but they have everything you might need in one place. On top of offering tags, bows, ribbons, bags, and wrapping paper so that everything you gift can be color or thematically coordinated, they also offer stationery gift items and other items to put inside your boxes. So, on top of gift wrapping materials, Paper Source can help you select the perfect item to go inside it.

Great individual options, but not ideal for large purchases

If you're looking to give a few beautifully presented gifts for a holiday, birthday, or wedding shower, Paper Source is an amazing place to stop. Their box patterns are unique and artistic and allow you to really get into decorating your gifts for that special someone. However, if you're looking for a large quantity of gift boxes for a business or to hand out packaged party favors, Paper Source isn't the best place to shop. Their per-unit pricing doesn't change if you buy multiple boxes, so it can get expensive quickly if you need more than a few boxes at a time.

Where Can You Find the Best Gift Boxes?

Do you love gift giving seasons but find getting all the presents ready for a big celebration is super stressful? Do you wish you had a way to take the hard work out of gift boxing and give the picture-perfect present every time? Whether you're packaging for Christmas, Birthdays, Weddings, or Anniversaries, or if you're a professional looking to spice up your delivery packaging, you want to be able to make it just right.

Finding the right Gift Boxes can be challenging when shopping the limited selection in your local brick-and-mortar stores. As you start shopping for gift boxes online, you'll see that some retailers specialize in large orders, for those people buying in bulk. Other stores focus on more creative boxes, for those people looking for something unique.

The Best Gift Boxes Compare Gift Boxes Compare Gift Box Reviews What are the best Gift Boxes Best Gift Box Reviews

Gift Box FAQ

The answer to that question really depends on whether you're buying a lot of them or just a few. Some retailers focus on business customers who need hundreds (or thousands) of gift boxes at once, while others are definitely more for the everyday consumer who wants something special for their holiday and special occasion gift-giving. Either way, you've got several fantastic options to choose from.
Yes! Some retailers of gift boxes specialize in bulk orders, especially for businesses. This is a much better alternative than trying to find them at a local brick-and-mortar store and hoping they'll have enough in stock.
Yes! There's no need to buy 100 gift boxes if you only need 10. You might pay a little more for a smaller order, but you can definitely get just what you want. And, if you want a more decorative gift box, you've got that option as well (because they usually aren't offered in bulk like the plain white variety).
Sometimes. But if you know you need more than one or two for all of your holiday gift-giving, or you prefer gift boxes in non-standard sizes, do you want to risk not being able to get them for free? It's probably smarter to pay for what you want instead of hoping that your local retailer will give them to you for free.
Definitely. Some retailers go all out to provide beautiful, unique gift boxes that you'll be proud to present to the choosiest of recipients.
That varies. Small, plain white boxes purchased in bulk can be just a couple of cents each, while decorative gift boxes with lots of flourishes can be $5 each or more.
That depends. How many gift boxes are you buying? Do you need expedited delivery? You may get your shipping included at no extra cost, or you could wind up paying $10 or more. Most retailers will tell you exactly how much you'll pay for delivery well before you click "buy now" .
Check the retailer's return policy. Some stores give you 30 days or more to return your gift boxes for a full refund.
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

Gift wrapping is a tradition that goes back thousands of years. The first gifts were decorated in fabric before greeting cards, tissue paper, and printed gift paper became popular. Now, it's an industry all its own. Today, Americans spend more than $3 billion on gift wrap each year. But wrapping paper is unwieldy, hard to use, and hard to recycle. Many gifters are switching over to gift boxes, which you can use again and again.

With so many different gifts, gifters, and recipients, it can be hard to know how to pick out gift wrapping or boxes. Fortunately, online gift box services will put it all together for you wholesale. However, it can be hard to choose which service to go with. The boxes all look so nice, and everyone has a different style. Whether you're looking for something for your loved ones or a business-focused packaging option, we've got all the best gift box services here for you to consider.

So, how do you choose the best gift boxes for your needs? If you're not sure where to start, here are some factors that can help you pick the best boxes for you:

  • Business or Personal: Do you want to buy in bulk for your business? Or do you just want a few choice gift boxes for that special someone? Do you need 50 units for your order, or just one or two?
  • Price per Unit: How much are you looking to pay per box? Does having single-purchase options matter more than cost per unit? How do similar boxes compare?
  • Design: Do you need a specific box shape for a particular gift, or is a basic square box good for your needs? Do you need boxes that display their contents or have luxurious materials?
  • Creativity: Do you want boxes that reflect your personality, or do you want to be able to add something yourself? Do you want a box that can be gifted without wrapping paper or are you happy with something basic as long as it does the job? Do you need to be able to add custom designs for your business?
  • Add-ons: Are you looking for a one-stop shop, where you can buy all your gifting supplies in one place, or do you just need a few boxes and that's all?

To help you take the stress out of beautiful gift-giving, Top Consumer Reviews has evaluated and ranked today's most popular online gift box services. We hope these will make it easy to choose the best gift boxes for your needs, so you can feel confident you've got the perfect present every time.

Compare Gift Boxes

Select any 2 Gift Boxes to compare them head to head

Compare the Best Gift Boxes
- VS -
Review the Best Gift Boxes
The Best Reviews of Gift Boxes