Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

Shutterfly Review

Friday, December 9th

2022 Graduation Invitation Store Reviews

Shutterfly Review 2.5 Star Rating


2.5 Star Rating
  • 100% happiness guarantee
  • Save 20% when you sign up for texts
  • Free shipping on orders over $89
  • Afterpay options

Shutterfly has been around since 1999, originally as a source to print "4x6" photographs from your digital camera. They now provide a range of custom photo services for those looking to make cards and stationery, prints, gifts, calendars, wall art, decor, and wedding products. All of their inventory can be personalized using photos uploaded from your phone or computer and designed to your liking. Their sister companies include Tinyprints, Lifetouch, Groovebook, and Spoonflower.

Narrow down your options

You can narrow down the graduation invitation options by foil color, trim options, the number of photos you want to use, design color, theme, style (classic, modern, contemporary, whimsy, rustic), price, card size, designer, and format. In addition to flat cards, they also have multi-fold options for a more unique look. The designs would cater to a range of tastes and are similar to what you might find from another card retailer.

Minimal customization

Shutterfly has four different paper options that you can have your graduation invitations printed on and offers pre-printed addressing on most envelopes. Their customization tools are easy to use, but you aren't able to make too many changes to the card you select. Besides adding your personal details and the photos you choose, most of the time you can't rearrange the placement of the photos, headings, or other predetermined style images.

Score major sitewide sales

The more graduation invitations you purchase from Shutterfly, the cheaper each card is. Graduation invitations start out at $1.38 each and at the time of this review, a sale for 50% off cards plus free shipping was happening, so some invitations were as inexpensive as $0.69 per card. Normally shipping is free if you spend $89 or more. If you are willing to provide your mobile number to Shutterfly, you'll also get a code for 20% off your order.

Best Graduation Invitation Stores


If you need to make a big order from Shutterfly and don't want to pay in full at checkout, you have the option of using Afterpay. This is a service that breaks up your total into four interest-free payments that you can pay off every 2 weeks.

The Shutterfly guarantee

Shutterfly has a 100% happiness guarantee that says if you aren't satisfied with your order, contact their customer service and they'll make it right. Nowhere does it say you'll get a refund, so you can't necessarily depend on that, but maybe you'll get reprints or some type of store credit if needed. Shutterfly also promises to never delete the photos you upload to their site and give you free, unlimited storage of your images and products.

Gone downhill

Shutterfly has a "D-" rating from the Better Business Bureau, which is a significant drop from over the last couple of years. This was as disappointing as the thousands of poor reviews they receive directly from customers. Over the last year, people have been very frustrated by how long it takes to receive their orders. Some people wait months and have a hard time communicating with customer service about it. Others said their cards arrived with big Shutterfly watermarks on them and had other quality control issues that they were furious about. Most people would not recommend this company, which is unfortunate. Shutterfly has mostly had positive reviews over the years, so it seems their company has taken a dip recently and has a lot of work to do to get back on track and keep their customers happy. In the meantime, we recommend ordering graduation invitations from a higher-rated company.

Where Can You Create the Best Graduation Invitations Online?

After spending so much of your life in school, it's a feeling of great relief and accomplishment to finally put on your cap and gown. The person you've become, the things you've learned, and the people you've met along the way all are celebrated in one big, momentous occasion. Whether you're the one receiving the diploma or honoring someone else who is, the graduate deserves to be recognized and applauded for making it to graduation day.

Your loved ones will want to be there for graduation or at least get an invitation so they know about your big milestone. If you're lucky, they might even send you gifts or money! Making and sending custom graduation invitations are an important to-do list item when preparing for your graduation ceremonies. It only takes a few minutes to create them online and order them straight to your house.

The Best Graduation Invitation Stores Compare Graduation Invitation Stores Compare Graduation Invitation Store Reviews What are the best Graduation Invitation Stores Best Graduation Invitation Store Reviews

Graduation Invitation Store FAQ

A graduation invitation is a formal announcement sent to friends and family to invite them to your school's graduation ceremony. They are sent to a smaller, closer-knit group of friends and family that would be able to watch you receive your diploma in-person. Graduation invitations are used by high school, college, and university graduates.
Graduation invitations let friends and family know that you've completed your degree. It allows your loved ones to come celebrate with you and witness a memorable day. Even if they aren't able to come to the graduation ceremony, oftentimes friends and family will send graduation money and/or gifts when they find out you're receiving a degree. That alone is a good enough reason to send them out.
Sleek online tools allow people to create graduation invitations with a click of a few buttons. You'll choose from a variety of templates that have different designs and color schemes that fit your style. Next, you'll input the details of your graduation ceremony in the text boxes, upload any pictures you want, and submit the invitations for printing. The whole process can be completed in just a few minutes.
Graduation invitations usually just include your name, the name of your high school/college/university, your degree and honors, graduation year, time, date, and location of your ceremony, and RSVP instructions. If you choose, you could also make graduation announcements that have information about your graduation party that additional people could be invited to.
It's always a good idea to get a head start on graduation invitations, just in case there is a shipping delay or the company is slammed with orders. On average, you should expect it to take between 1-2 weeks for your graduation invitations to be printed and shipped to you. That doesn't account for the time it takes for you to compile your invitations and mail them to guests, so giving yourself about a month of leeway will ensure your invitations arrive in a timely manner.
Most graduation invitations cost between $1.75 and $3 per card. On top of this, you might have to pay for shipping if the company doesn't offer it for free. The end cost will depend on how many people you plan to send invitations to, if you want any add-ons, and what type of paper you select. The cost of your graduation invitations will also include envelopes, which is a perk.
If your graduation invitations arrive and have a misprint, it will likely be because you didn't do a thorough check before submitting your order. However, there are many generous online graduation invitation companies that offer a satisfaction guarantee and will give you a refund or exchange, regardless of why you need it. This will add weeks onto your timeline of sending out invitations though, so double and triple check all the details on your graduation invitations before submitting them for printing.
Once you receive your graduation invitations and envelopes in the mail, all that's left to do is send them out. You'll need to collect the addresses of the friends and family you want to invite, so you could do this by text, email, or a phone call. If you have a running Christmas card address list, refer to that. The only other thing you'll need is stamps. Once the invitations are compiled and ready to go, you can send them out and get excited about your big day!
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

Graduation announcements can be formal and professional or whimsical and fun, reflecting the graduate's personality. You can include relevant educational information about the degree being received, photos, details about the graduation ceremony date, location, and time, and even information about an after-party if you're planning one. Whatever your style is, you can easily find a graduation announcement you like among the hundreds of options available online.

There are quite a few companies that offer graduation invitations, so we have provided important information for you to consider when deciding who to buy from:

  • Selection: Are there plenty of options to choose from to reflect your style and be able to include all the information you need? You'll want something unique, so be sure to find a company that offers lots of design choices.
  • Cost: How does the cost of graduation announcements from one company compare to another? Do you get a bigger discount if you buy more announcements? Do they charge a reasonable price for shipping?
  • Production time: Once you've designed your graduation announcements online, how long does it take for them to be printed and shipped to your house? Make sure you have plenty of time to mail your invitations before graduation.

TopConsumerReviews.com has reviewed and ranked the best graduation invitation companies available today. We hope this information helps you find the right graduation announcements to celebrate the big accomplishment of finishing school!

The Best Reviews of Graduation Invitation Stores