Graduation Invitation Stores Reviews

Best Graduation Invitation Stores in New York

We've analyzed the best Graduation Invitation Stores to help you find the right solution for your needs.

The Best Graduation Invitation Stores in New York

Where can I find the best Graduation Invitation Stores in New York? New York makes you think the local stationery shop has everything, but once you start browsing online, your options explode. You can filter styles in seconds, see proofs instantly, and get specialty touches like letterpress or foil without hunting all over the boroughs. With sample kits shipped to your door, you'll feel paper weights and finishes before committing. That convenience matters when graduation week is barreling toward you.

The Best Graduation Invitation Stores in New York

5.0

EXCELLENT

1

Best Option

  • Pricing starts at $64.50 per 50 invites
  • Almost 90 themes available
  • Print is completed in 1-2 days

Read Full Review

EXCELLENT

5.0

On the Mixbook website

4.5

GREAT

2

Great

  • Prices from $0.83 per card
  • Free shipping on $100+
  • Tons of customizations

Read Full Review

GREAT

4.5

On the Vistaprint website

4.4

GREAT

3

Great

  • Prices start at $1.44 per card
  • 40,000+ themes available
  • Partnerships with pop culture brands for designs

Read Full Review

GREAT

4.4

On the Zazzle website

4.0

VERY GOOD

4

Very Good

  • Pricing starts at $27.99 for 25 cards
  • Ships in 5-7 days
  • 200+ unique designs

Read Full Review

VERY GOOD

4.0

On the Staples website

3.5

GOOD

5

Good

  • Prices start at $115 for 85 invites
  • 1-5 day shipping
  • 360+ designs

Read Full Review

GOOD

3.5

On the Minted website

3.4

GOOD

6

Good

  • Prices from $29.90 for 10 cards
  • Pre-made designs
  • Environmentally-friendly

Read Full Review

GOOD

3.4

On the Paper Culture website

2.5

FAIR

7

Fair

  • Prices start at $44 for 20 invites
  • Shipping in as little as 1 business day
  • 115 themes available

Read Full Review

FAIR

2.5

On the Paper Source website

2.0

SUBPAR

8

Subpar

  • Pricing from $0.60 per card
  • 1,238 different designs available
  • 2-5 days shipping

Read Full Review

SUBPAR

2.0

On the Simply to Impress website

1.5

WEAK

9

Weak

  • Prices start at $1.99 per card
  • Ships in 1-10 days
  • 183 different themes available

Read Full Review

WEAK

1.5

On the Shutterfly website

1.0

POOR

10

Poor

  • Prices from $2 per card
  • 264 designs
  • 4-8 day turnaround

Read Full Review

POOR

1.0

On the Snapfish website

Continued from above...

Where Can I Find the Best Graduation Invitation Stores in New York?

New York makes you think the local stationery shop has everything, but once you start browsing online, your options explode. You can filter styles in seconds, see proofs instantly, and get specialty touches like letterpress or foil without hunting all over the boroughs. With sample kits shipped to your door, you'll feel paper weights and finishes before committing. That convenience matters when graduation week is barreling toward you.

From a tiny table in Buffalo, you might be tweaking colors at midnight while the radiator knocks. You'll see production timelines clearly on most sites - many quote 2-5 business days to print plus shipping - so you can back into your mail‑out date. For New York addresses, ground shipping from the Northeast often lands fast, while West Coast packages can take a few extra days. Standard 5x7 invitations go out at the regular letter rate, but square envelopes bring a non‑machinable surcharge you'll want to budget.

Funny thing about graduation season - everything in New York seems to hit at once. Ceremonies across public schools and universities cluster from late May into mid‑June, and with tens of thousands of grads celebrating, you could run into sold‑out paper stocks and designs. You can lock in a spot by ordering 4-6 weeks ahead and requesting digital proofs within 24-48 hours. If you're leaning photo‑heavy, a lab in Rochester has that deep print DNA and might offer press‑printed or photo‑paper cards that match your style.

Meanwhile, pricing shakes out differently once you add finishes and shipping, so you'll want to run the full cart before you decide. At checkout, you should see New York sales tax added on most large platforms, and some include free addressing or envelope liners that save time. You can request sample packs, test ink colors, and even order a small batch first - handy if your ceremony date in Albany isn't finalized. When speed matters, you'll do best choosing printers with East Coast fulfillment or rush options and tracking that updates in real time.

When it comes to choosing graduation invitations, there are a few factors to consider helping you find the perfect option for your celebration:

Gathering your friends and family to celebrate your graduation is a wonderful way to create lasting memories and share in the joy of your accomplishment. To help you make your day extra special, Top Consumer Reviews has reviewed and ranked the top graduation invitation services out there today. Whether you're planning a small gathering with close friends or a larger party with extended family, we hope this info (and inspo!) helps you pick out the perfect place to design the invites. So, whether you're planning a graduation party, ceremony, or other special event, don't forget to send out invitations and let your loved ones share in the excitement of your big day!

Slide Down Image Left Slide Image FAQ Image Slide Image Twirl Image

Graduation Invitation Store FAQ

What is a graduation invitation?
A graduation invitation is a formal announcement sent to friends and family to invite them to your school's graduation ceremony. They are sent to a smaller, closer-knit group of friends and family that would be able to watch you receive your diploma in-person. Graduation invitations are used by high school, college, and university graduates.
Why should I make a graduation invitation?
Graduation invitations let friends and family know that you've completed your degree. It allows your loved ones to come celebrate with you and witness a memorable day. Even if they aren't able to come to the graduation ceremony, oftentimes friends and family will send graduation money and/or gifts when they find out you're receiving a degree. That alone is a good enough reason to send them out.
How do you make a graduation invitation?
Sleek online tools allow people to create graduation invitations with a click of a few buttons. You'll choose from a variety of templates that have different designs and color schemes that fit your style. Next, you'll input the details of your graduation ceremony in the text boxes, upload any pictures you want, and submit the invitations for printing. The whole process can be completed in just a few minutes.
What should you include on a graduation invitation?
Graduation invitations usually just include your name, the name of your high school/college/university, your degree and honors, graduation year, time, date, and location of your ceremony, and RSVP instructions. If you choose, you could also make graduation announcements that have information about your graduation party that additional people could be invited to.
How long will it take to receive my graduation invitations?
It's always a good idea to get a head start on graduation invitations, just in case there is a shipping delay or the company is slammed with orders. On average, you should expect it to take between 1-2 weeks for your graduation invitations to be printed and shipped to you. That doesn't account for the time it takes for you to compile your invitations and mail them to guests, so giving yourself about a month of leeway will ensure your invitations arrive in a timely manner.
Are graduation invitations expensive?
Most graduation invitations cost between $1.75 and $3 per card. On top of this, you might have to pay for shipping if the company doesn't offer it for free. The end cost will depend on how many people you plan to send invitations to, if you want any add-ons, and what type of paper you select. The cost of your graduation invitations will also include envelopes, which is a perk.
What if my graduation invitations arrive with an error printed on them?
If your graduation invitations arrive and have a misprint, it will likely be because you didn't do a thorough check before submitting your order. However, there are many generous online graduation invitation companies that offer a satisfaction guarantee and will give you a refund or exchange, regardless of why you need it. This will add weeks onto your timeline of sending out invitations though, so double and triple check all the details on your graduation invitations before submitting them for printing.
What do I need in order to send my graduation invitations out?
Once you receive your graduation invitations and envelopes in the mail, all that's left to do is send them out. You'll need to collect the addresses of the friends and family you want to invite, so you could do this by text, email, or a phone call. If you have a running Christmas card address list, refer to that. The only other thing you'll need is stamps. Once the invitations are compiled and ready to go, you can send them out and get excited about your big day!

Compare Any 2 Products

Mixbook
Vistaprint
Zazzle
Staples
Minted
Paper Culture
Paper Source
Simply to Impress
Shutterfly
Snapfish
vs
Mixbook vs VistaprintMixbook vs ZazzleMixbook vs StaplesMixbook vs MintedMixbook vs Paper CultureMixbook vs Paper SourceMixbook vs Simply to ImpressMixbook vs ShutterflyMixbook vs SnapfishVistaprint vs ZazzleVistaprint vs StaplesVistaprint vs MintedVistaprint vs Paper CultureVistaprint vs Paper SourceVistaprint vs Simply to ImpressVistaprint vs ShutterflyVistaprint vs SnapfishZazzle vs StaplesZazzle vs MintedZazzle vs Paper CultureZazzle vs Paper SourceZazzle vs Simply to ImpressZazzle vs ShutterflyZazzle vs SnapfishStaples vs MintedStaples vs Paper CultureStaples vs Paper SourceStaples vs Simply to ImpressStaples vs ShutterflyStaples vs SnapfishMinted vs Paper CultureMinted vs Paper SourceMinted vs Simply to ImpressMinted vs ShutterflyMinted vs SnapfishPaper Culture vs Paper SourcePaper Culture vs Simply to ImpressPaper Culture vs ShutterflyPaper Culture vs SnapfishPaper Source vs Simply to ImpressPaper Source vs ShutterflyPaper Source vs SnapfishSimply to Impress vs ShutterflySimply to Impress vs SnapfishShutterfly vs Snapfish Snapfish vs ShutterflySnapfish vs Simply to ImpressSnapfish vs Paper SourceSnapfish vs Paper CultureSnapfish vs MintedSnapfish vs StaplesSnapfish vs ZazzleSnapfish vs VistaprintSnapfish vs MixbookShutterfly vs Simply to ImpressShutterfly vs Paper SourceShutterfly vs Paper CultureShutterfly vs MintedShutterfly vs StaplesShutterfly vs ZazzleShutterfly vs VistaprintShutterfly vs MixbookSimply to Impress vs Paper SourceSimply to Impress vs Paper CultureSimply to Impress vs MintedSimply to Impress vs StaplesSimply to Impress vs ZazzleSimply to Impress vs VistaprintSimply to Impress vs MixbookPaper Source vs Paper CulturePaper Source vs MintedPaper Source vs StaplesPaper Source vs ZazzlePaper Source vs VistaprintPaper Source vs MixbookPaper Culture vs MintedPaper Culture vs StaplesPaper Culture vs ZazzlePaper Culture vs VistaprintPaper Culture vs MixbookMinted vs StaplesMinted vs ZazzleMinted vs VistaprintMinted vs MixbookStaples vs ZazzleStaples vs VistaprintStaples vs MixbookZazzle vs VistaprintZazzle vs MixbookVistaprint vs Mixbook
See the Best Graduation Invitation Stores in Your State
Only the Best Reviews

Columbia News

Columbia Graduation 2026

Aziza Shuler (JRN’26) may be an Emmy Award-winning journalist who co-anchors Weekend Mornings on CBS News New York, but she is also a student at Columbia, about to graduate with her master’s degree ...

Fri, 10 Apr 2026

Only the Best Reviews

Coeur d'Alene Press

Celebrate your graduation with exciting ideas and tips

Discover amazing ideas to make your graduation unforgettable. Plan the perfect celebration and make every moment count. Start your graduation journey here!

Fri, 10 Apr 2026

Only the Best Reviews

The New York Times

What Should I Wear to a College Graduation?

It can be tricky to look nice without stealing the spotlight. Our critic has some tips on dressing as smart as the graduate.

Mon, 06 Apr 2026

Only the Best Reviews

Columbia News

15 Great Places to Take Graduation Photos on Columbia's Campuses

Construction for graduation ceremonies on Morningside's Low Plaza near Alma Mater starts on April 13. Here are some great alternative spots for your graduation photos in the run-up to Commencement.

Tue, 07 Apr 2026

Only the Best Reviews

Marshall Independent

Graduation rates rise in state, SW Minn.

The Minnesota Department of Education (MDE) recently released the graduation data for last year’s class of 2025, revealing a state record-high graduation rate. Local area schools of southwest ...

Wed, 08 Apr 2026

Only the Best Reviews

Saint Louis ...

Graduation Information

The 2026 Saint Louis University School of Science and Engineering precommencement ceremony will take place on May 15, 2026, at Chaifetz Arena. This ceremony introduces and recognizes all SLU School of ...

Wed, 11 Mar 2026

Top Products.  

Top Reviews.  

Top Consumer Reviews.

Reviews 

Browse through thousands of reviews.

Social Media 

Like us?  Follow us!  We'd love to have you join our community.

Newsletter 

Stay up to date with the latest reviews. We'll keep you informed, and we'll never sell your information to anyone.