Gutter Guards Reviews

Who's better?

Leaf Filter vs GutterFoam

We've analyzed the best Gutter Guards to help you find the right solution for your needs.

2025 Gutter Guard Reviews

Here you can see how Leaf Filter and GutterFoam match up head-to-head in a battle for the Best Gutter Guards in 2025.

Winner

Leaf Filter

  • Prices available after estimate
  • Made in the USA
  • uPVC

LeafFilter is a company that specializes in providing high-quality gutter guards designed to keep your gutters free from debris, making it easy to maintain your home's exterior. With a free, no-obligation estimate process and professional installation, LeafFilter takes the hassle out of gutter cleaning, allowing you to enjoy a worry-free experience. Backed by a transferable lifetime warranty and an excellent reputation, LeafFilter is the top-rated solution for homeowners, earning the top spot on our list.

GutterFoam

  • Priced around $200 for a complete house
  • Made in the USA
  • Woman-owned business

GutterFoam, established in 2003, offers a durable and eco-friendly solution for keeping gutters clear. Their foam inserts, shipped compressed to reduce environmental impact, expand to fit gutters within 24 hours. With an intuitive e-guide and various models to choose from, GutterFoam provides a cost-effective and beginner-friendly option for gutter protection, earning it a very high rating for its ease of use and effectiveness.

Gutter guards, also known as gutter screens or covers, are essential for preventing debris from entering rain gutters. If you're considering buying gutter guards, you likely understand the problems clogged gutters can cause. Debris can lead to water spilling over the sides and pooling at your home's base, causing costly foundation issues, encouraging mold and mildew growth, and creating a breeding ground for insects.

These problems can result in expensive repairs and significant inconvenience. Installing gutter guards is an obvious solution because they reduce the frequency of cleaning while still allowing rainwater to flow freely through the gutters. Many homeowners are pleasantly surprised by how affordable gutter guards can be.

Some models even come with warranties that last up to 20 years. Most of these guards can be easily installed by snapping them onto the lip of your gutter, making the process quick and simple.

When choosing gutter guards, you have a variety of materials to consider, each offering different colors, durability levels, and sizes to meet your specific needs. Once installed, gutter guards require minimal maintenance, letting you set them and forget them. This one-time purchase significantly simplifies the upkeep of your home, saving you time and effort in the long run.

For the best shopping experience, consider purchasing gutter guards online. Numerous retailers offer a wide range of options, allowing you to compare prices and features from the comfort of your home. Online shopping enables you to quickly find the best deals and read customer reviews, ensuring that you choose high-quality, durable gutter guards based on the experiences of others.

Given the variety of companies selling gutter guards, we have put together an essential checklist to help you decide which brand to purchase:

To help you keep your roof and home safe from damage, Top Consumer Reviews has reviewed and ranked the best places to purchase gutter guards. We hope this information helps you find the right products to keep your home's gutters clear and ensure water flows smoothly away from your property!

Slide Down Image Left Slide Image FAQ Image Slide Image Twirl Image

Gutter Guard FAQ

What are gutter guards?
Gutter guards are a system used to prevent leaves and other debris from clogging your gutters. Water is still allowed through and funneled away from your home as usual, while the solid materials remain on top (and are often carried away by the wind during and after the storm).
Do gutter guards work in heavy rain?
If by "work" you mean keeping the leaves and branches out, the answer is yes! Even in a heavy downpour, your system should have no problem keeping everything flowing smoothly. Of course, if it's raining hard enough to flood your gutters, you may still see an overflow of water.
Are gutter guards expensive?
The cost for your gutter guards will depend on several factors: the size of your home, the type of system, and the materials used. Expect pricing that ranges from $0.50 to $10 per foot, with a total system cost anywhere between $100 and $2,000.
Are gutter guards maintenance-free?
Not exactly. While gutter guards can eliminate a lot of the dirty work, like cleaning muck out of the gutters and clearing clogs, you might still need to brush debris off the surface from time to time. The wind will probably take care of most of it, though.
What happens to gutter guards when there's snow and ice?
The best gutter guards are designed to support the weight of snow and ice. Some customers worry that gutter guards can cause ice damming, but a properly-installed system can actually alleviate it: snow and ice are able to melt off the front of the gutter, instead of filling it up and growing larger on the roof line.
Do gutter guards void my roofing warranty?
That's a smart question to ask. If you choose a system that installs under your shingles, your roofing warranty could be voided. Many systems attach to the fascia board instead, keeping your shingles intact and not interfering with the roof's warranty. You'll also want to look for gutter guards that come with a protective baffle, which makes it impossible for debris to enter the gutter from behind.
Can I install gutter guards on my own?
Yes. You can find many options for gutter guards at home improvement stores online and near you. However, unless you're somewhat experienced with DIY home repairs, it might be worth it to pay a professional to install them. You don't want to experience issues with leaking or damage your roof and gutters, and it's important that your gutter guards are pitched correctly too.
What kind of guarantee/warranty can I expect with my gutter guards?
That depends on which manufacturer you choose and may also be affected by whether you installed the gutter guards or had them put in place by a professional. You could get a transferable warranty that lasts 20 years, a lifetime warranty, or no warranty at all. Be sure to read the details before making your purchase.

Compare Any 2 Products

Leaf Filter
A-M Gutter Guard
GutterFoam
Raptor Gutter Guard
Gutterglove
Spectra Gutter Systems
Raindrop Gutter Guard
LeafGuard
Amerimax
eGutter
vs
Leaf Filter vs A-M Gutter GuardLeaf Filter vs GutterFoamLeaf Filter vs Raptor Gutter GuardLeaf Filter vs GuttergloveLeaf Filter vs Spectra Gutter SystemsLeaf Filter vs Raindrop Gutter GuardLeaf Filter vs LeafGuardLeaf Filter vs AmerimaxLeaf Filter vs eGutterA-M Gutter Guard vs GutterFoamA-M Gutter Guard vs Raptor Gutter GuardA-M Gutter Guard vs GuttergloveA-M Gutter Guard vs Spectra Gutter SystemsA-M Gutter Guard vs Raindrop Gutter GuardA-M Gutter Guard vs LeafGuardA-M Gutter Guard vs AmerimaxA-M Gutter Guard vs eGutterGutterFoam vs Raptor Gutter GuardGutterFoam vs GuttergloveGutterFoam vs Spectra Gutter SystemsGutterFoam vs Raindrop Gutter GuardGutterFoam vs LeafGuardGutterFoam vs AmerimaxGutterFoam vs eGutterRaptor Gutter Guard vs GuttergloveRaptor Gutter Guard vs Spectra Gutter SystemsRaptor Gutter Guard vs Raindrop Gutter GuardRaptor Gutter Guard vs LeafGuardRaptor Gutter Guard vs AmerimaxRaptor Gutter Guard vs eGutterGutterglove vs Spectra Gutter SystemsGutterglove vs Raindrop Gutter GuardGutterglove vs LeafGuardGutterglove vs AmerimaxGutterglove vs eGutterSpectra Gutter Systems vs Raindrop Gutter GuardSpectra Gutter Systems vs LeafGuardSpectra Gutter Systems vs AmerimaxSpectra Gutter Systems vs eGutterRaindrop Gutter Guard vs LeafGuardRaindrop Gutter Guard vs AmerimaxRaindrop Gutter Guard vs eGutterLeafGuard vs AmerimaxLeafGuard vs eGutterAmerimax vs eGutter eGutter vs AmerimaxeGutter vs LeafGuardeGutter vs Raindrop Gutter GuardeGutter vs Spectra Gutter SystemseGutter vs GuttergloveeGutter vs Raptor Gutter GuardeGutter vs GutterFoameGutter vs A-M Gutter GuardeGutter vs Leaf FilterAmerimax vs LeafGuardAmerimax vs Raindrop Gutter GuardAmerimax vs Spectra Gutter SystemsAmerimax vs GuttergloveAmerimax vs Raptor Gutter GuardAmerimax vs GutterFoamAmerimax vs A-M Gutter GuardAmerimax vs Leaf FilterLeafGuard vs Raindrop Gutter GuardLeafGuard vs Spectra Gutter SystemsLeafGuard vs GuttergloveLeafGuard vs Raptor Gutter GuardLeafGuard vs GutterFoamLeafGuard vs A-M Gutter GuardLeafGuard vs Leaf FilterRaindrop Gutter Guard vs Spectra Gutter SystemsRaindrop Gutter Guard vs GuttergloveRaindrop Gutter Guard vs Raptor Gutter GuardRaindrop Gutter Guard vs GutterFoamRaindrop Gutter Guard vs A-M Gutter GuardRaindrop Gutter Guard vs Leaf FilterSpectra Gutter Systems vs GuttergloveSpectra Gutter Systems vs Raptor Gutter GuardSpectra Gutter Systems vs GutterFoamSpectra Gutter Systems vs A-M Gutter GuardSpectra Gutter Systems vs Leaf FilterGutterglove vs Raptor Gutter GuardGutterglove vs GutterFoamGutterglove vs A-M Gutter GuardGutterglove vs Leaf FilterRaptor Gutter Guard vs GutterFoamRaptor Gutter Guard vs A-M Gutter GuardRaptor Gutter Guard vs Leaf FilterGutterFoam vs A-M Gutter GuardGutterFoam vs Leaf FilterA-M Gutter Guard vs Leaf Filter
Only the Best Reviews

Homes and Gardens ...

What are gutter guards, and do they really work? Roofing experts ...

Since gutter guards prevent clogs from leaves and other debris, they reduce the need for frequent gutter cleaning while extending the lifespan of gutter systems. There’s less to worry about as mold ...

Sat, 26 Apr 2025

Only the Best Reviews

The Baltimore Sun

Are gutter guards worth it? - Baltimore Sun

Gutter guards are potent tools to keep your gutters clean. You can choose from several different options, but all gutter guards fulfill the same basic purpose: blocking debris from entering your ...

Tue, 09 Mar 2021

Only the Best Reviews

Daily Press

Are gutter guards worth it? - Daily Press

Gutter guards are potent tools to keep your gutters clean. You can choose from several different options, but all gutter guards fulfill the same basic purpose: blocking debris from entering your ...

Tue, 09 Mar 2021

Only the Best Reviews

Chicago Tribune

Are gutter guards worth it? - Chicago Tribune

Gutter guards by type —Metal mesh screens: $1.20 to $4 per foot. These are sheets of metal with holes punched through. They block most debris, but anything smaller than the holes, ...

Tue, 09 Mar 2021

Only the Best Reviews

Orlando Sentinel

Are gutter guards worth it? - Orlando Sentinel

Gutter guards are potent tools to keep your gutters clean. You can choose from several different options, but all gutter guards fulfill the same basic purpose: blocking debris from entering your ...

Tue, 09 Mar 2021

Only the Best Reviews

The Gazette

Should I get gutter guards? - The Gazette

Gutter guards can be purchased in a variety of categories, including screens, inserts and reserve curves. The type you need will depend on your home's location, ...

Sat, 27 Jul 2019

Top Products.  

Top Reviews.  

Top Consumer Reviews.

Reviews 

Browse through thousands of reviews.

Social Media 

Like us?  Follow us!  We'd love to have you join our community.

Newsletter 

Stay up to date with the latest reviews. We'll keep you informed, and we'll never sell your information to anyone.