Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.
For many, Halloween is a favorite holiday. It's an excuse to watch all the scary movies, display skeletons in your yard, hang bats throughout your house, visit haunted attractions, eat and drink pumpkin-flavored everything, and - of course - eat way too much candy. Whether you're all in on Halloween or not, you'll probably find yourself on the hunt for a Halloween costume for you or your children.
Picking out the right Halloween costume requires some creativity. You or your child will want to be something that represents a favorite movie you saw during the year, a celebrity or icon you've come to love, or something reflecting your personality. Usually you'll try to choose something unique that you didn't already see a million people dress as last year on social media, so you've got to get the gears turning in your head to come up with something iconic.
Saturday, November 2nd
Halloween Costumes has everything we are looking for in a Halloween retailer. They've got costumes for the whole family in nearly every theme and character you can dream of. Their website is fun to look at, since they use real customer photos to display their products rather than just models (in some categories). They have upfront shipping costs, a 30-day return policy, and extremely high ratings from customers. This is a reliable place to shop for a Halloween costume, so they've earned our top rating.
Spirit Halloween is one of the most widely recognized stores that sells Halloween costumes both in-person and online. They offer free shipping on orders over $35 and 20% off of any item with email signup. Spirit Halloween has an incredible selection of on-trend costumes and accessories for the whole family, whether you're looking for something innocent and cute or completely horrifying. This company knows their stuff and offers a positive online shopping experience, so they've earned one of our top spots.
Halloween Express is a fantastic choice for Halloween costumes since their inventory is so extensive. You'll find the trendiest themes and character costumes here that change year over year. Halloween Express has a user-friendly website that makes it as simple as it can be to find what you're looking for - or get ideas if you don't know where to start. They offer free shipping on orders over $35, and you have 30 days to make a return if needed. They have an "A+” rating from the Better Business Bureau, and besides a few glitches with packaging and order mix-ups, they have really high customer reviews. This is a great place to turn for Halloween costumes, so Halloween Express has earned one of our top scores.
Party Expert is a top destination for on-trend Halloween costumes that ship quickly throughout the United States and Canada. There are hundreds of Halloween costumes for adults, kids, and pets here, plus all the party supplies you might want to get as well. You'll have 10 days to make a return or exchange, but since most people say that costumes come exactly as pictured online, hopefully you won't need to. We like the shopping experience here and the extra low prices on products, so Party Expert is a great choice for Halloween costumes.
Party City is prepared to supply customers with all their decor and party supplies for any event they want to celebrate. All year round you'll find great seasonal products, and Halloween is no exception. They have tons of decorations for your home, supplies to throw a scary Halloween party, or costumes for the whole family to dress up. Their selection of Halloween costumes doesn't rival our highest-rated retailers', but it includes relevant, popular accessories and costumes that people will likely be looking for. Party City's pricing is competitive and they have a 30-day return policy with no restocking fees. Despite some mixed reviews from people who have either shopped online or in-store for one thing or another, Party City is still a good place to shop for Halloween costumes.
If you are looking for a costume to go along with the latest major movie to come out of Hollywood or to dress up like a social icon that's been in the media a lot, Costumes will likely have options for you. There are tons of costumes and accessories here (as well as home decor, toys, and other celebratory clothing) and we're happy with the selection. Pricing is reasonable and the website is easy to browse. We don't love that returns incur restocking fees of 12% and that recent customer reviews have been really poor. The company seems to be switching over to a new software system and having tons of issues relating to shipping. If you're shopping close to Halloween, you may want to try a different retailer to ensure that your costume comes in time. Otherwise, give Costumes a chance and maybe plan well in advance to make sure you don't run into problems.
Costume Kingdom has been around for nearly 25 years and they haven't made a lot of efforts to keep their site up-to-date and appealing. It's easy enough to find the category of costumes you're looking for, but many items are out-of-stock or only come in a couple of sizes. Their pricing is what is so appealing about Costume Kingdom since you can get great deals here and their shipping is fast (and free over $50). Unfortunately, they get low scores on their customer service and their return policy is pretty strict, but overall they do have a decent selection that won't cost a fortune. Costume Kingdom isn't one of our favorite choices, but we wouldn't steer clear of them altogether.
Costume Super Center has great potential, with hundreds and even thousands of products for any given gender and age group. Their selection is great, pricing is as expected, and the website is easy to browse. Their 15-day return policy comes with a 12% restocking fee and unfortunately, a lot of recent reviews have reported major problems with shipping and quality control issues. We were happy to find a company that offers such a good selection, but we aren't confident that Costume Super Center will deliver good results, so we suggest looking elsewhere for a Halloween costume.
Miccostumes has a unique inventory of Halloween costumes, cosplay costumes, swimsuits, wigs, accessories, shoes, and more. You'll get a wide variety of items you won't easily find in other places here. The problem is that their website doesn't have filter features, so you'll spend quite a bit of time scrolling pages and pages of inventory to (hopefully) find what you are looking for. You only have 5 days to make a return, but the main issue with Miccostumes is that most customers say their orders take weeks to arrive or they never show up at all. We don't trust Miccostumes as a reliable retailer of Halloween costumes.
Find Costume initially appears just like every other Halloween costume site, but we quickly found out they have way more issues. Trying to browse products through their listed categories takes you down a rabbit hole that often leads you to nothing. Tons of their costumes are listed as out-of-stock. Pricing is fair, but you'll need to pay for shipping. Many customers report that they never received the items they purchased and if they did, they were poor quality and looked nothing like the photos online. To try and return a costume will cost you 20% in restocking fees, plus whatever shipping charges are. We are not confident in Find Costume's processes or background whatsoever, so we don't recommend shopping here.
Halloween is kind of a big deal and that's what makes it so much fun. All for the photos, right? Some people choose to do a theme with their family, like dressing as characters from Toy Story, Ghostbusters, zoo animals, or fast food items. The sky's the limit! Others will want to pick their own unique, standalone costume.
Either way, you'll want to shop online from a store that gives you more than enough options for both and provides all the accessories and pieces to make your getup realistic and memorable. The sooner you get shopping during Halloween, the better. Make sure you give yourself time to come up with a fun idea and get everything you need before the big Halloween rush hits.
There are many companies that sell Halloween costumes online, and many of them can be taken advantage of all year long for things like cosplay, themed parties, and other dress-up occasions. So how do you select the best retailer? We've done plenty of research to help you find the ones that will provide memorable costumes at reasonable prices for you this season. Here are some major things to consider when weighing your options:
The experts at Top Consumer Reviews have researched the most reputable and exciting Halloween stores online. We hope this information helps you find everything you need to make the season spooktacular!
Select any 2 Halloween Costume Stores to compare them head to head