Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

Party City vs Costume Supercenter

Thursday, December 8th

2022 Halloween Costume Store Reviews

Party City Review 4 Star Rating

Party City

4 Star Rating
  • Thousands of costumes and accessories for all ages
  • Can buy online and pick up in store
  • 30-day return policy

Any time of year, you can find a great selection of Halloween costumes at Party City's online store. They make it easy and fun to find the right outfit online and have it delivered to your home or pick it up in person at a brick-and-mortar location near you. The store offers a 30-day return policy as long as your costume is new and unworn, though returns made in the week leading up to Halloween will get you a store credit instead of a refund. Party City is a retailer you can rely on to provide thousands of fun and trendy costumes to choose from.

Costume Supercenter Review 2.5 Star Rating

Costume Supercenter

2.5 Star Rating
  • 15-day return policy (12% restocking fee)
  • "A+" rated by the BBB
  • Free shipping on orders $75+

Costume Supercenter used to own a high ranking among Halloween costume shops online. Unfortunately, looking at recent customer feedback detailing hassles with returns, missing deliveries, and a worse-than-average return policy (just 15 days and a 12% restocking fee), we've had to drop this store significantly in our rankings. You could find a good costume here, but more than 25% of Costume Supercenter's customers would advise against clicking the "buy now" button.

Where Can You Find the Best Selection of Halloween Costumes?

There's something in Halloween for everyone, from the kids who can't wait to get their hands on piles of free candy, to grown-ups who get to feel like a kid again by dressing up like their favorite superhero or celebrity. Of course, at the heart of any Halloween celebration is the perfect costume. If you're tired of dragging out the same tired clown, witch, or devil attire every year and you're ready for something new, it's time to get shopping!

But wait - what if it's not even fall yet? Or what if you're trying to dress up your kids for their end-of-the-year theme days at school? No need to panic: even though they're called "Halloween" costumes, you can shop for almost any imaginable attire with any number of online retailers who keep the proverbial doors open year-round. That's especially true now that conventions, cosplay, and other dress-up occasions have become so popular - why should that kind of fun be limited to the month of October, right?

The Best Halloween Costume Stores Compare Halloween Costume Stores Compare Halloween Costume Store Reviews What are the best Halloween Costume Stores Best Halloween Costume Store Reviews

Halloween Costume Store FAQ

Although Halloween originated hundreds of years ago, the way we know it today started in the early 1900s. People wore dark, scary costumes intended to ward off evil spirits, but those outfits gave way to more pop culture styles in the 1920s and 1930s.
While the modern-day celebrations of Halloween are definitely more prevalent in the United States, people in many other countries have picked up the tradition as well. Who doesn't love the idea of getting dressed up in fun costumes and eating candy?
Some aspects of Halloween still tend to be more for the younger set, like trick-or-treating. But grown-ups don't want to miss the fun: you'll often find costume contests in the workplace, or teenagers on your doorstep asking for candy right next to their younger siblings. Halloween costumes are for everyone!
Lucky for you, there are a number of online Halloween costume retailers who have you covered any time of year. You might not find the biggest selection, and some of the "hottest trends" may be last year's top picks, but you'll still have plenty to choose from.
That's easy: selection, price, and availability. You may have noticed that the pickings in retail stores are pretty slim by the second week of October, so you could be out of luck if you procrastinated getting your child's favorite character costume - unless you shop online. Many online Halloween costume shops offer low-price guarantees and carry thousands of options in a huge range of sizes.
Yes! While you might often come away from retail stores disappointed that there's nothing you like that fits, you won't have that experience when you shop online for a Halloween costume. Some of the best retailers make sure to carry costumes in lots of sizes: tall, short, petite, plus size, and so on. Halloween should be enjoyed by every body (pun intended).
That depends on the retailer. Most stores give you at least 30 days to return your costume, as long as it's in the original packaging with all tags attached. (In other words, no wearing it to trick-or-treat and then sending it back!) If you're not sure the costume you're buying is going to be a good fit, make sure to check the return policy before you place your order.
They can be - but they don't have to be. You can find plenty of fun options for under $20 - or go crazy and buy a Halloween costume that costs $200 or more! (You can even get cute stuff for your dog. ) Don't forget to factor in the accessories, too: will you need makeup, a wig, shoes or props to complete your look? Most Halloween costume stores have all of that as well.
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

One of the best things about shopping for your Halloween costume online is the selection. Have you been to a retail store a few weeks before the holiday and seen how picked-over it gets? Good luck finding anything that fits or matches, let alone a costume that everyone will be talking about.

Yes, you're always going to find the most options in stock if you shop sooner rather than later, but some online stores can hook you up with a killer costume - literally, if you're into dressing up like a slasher movie - and get it delivered even just a few days before Halloween.

With so many Halloween costume stores out there, and so many themes to choose from, it's normal to feel a little overwhelmed when deciding where to shop. Want to make it a little easier? Keep these factors in mind:

  • Ease of navigating the site. Some stores make it quick and fun to find exactly what you're looking for, or to get ideas if you're feeling uninspired. Others make you click and click and click just to see what they have. Look for filters that let you sort by your budget, size, or desired theme.
  • Selection. Even the most user-friendly online store isn't much good if it only carries a handful of Halloween costumes. How many will you have to choose from? More importantly, are they actually in stock?
  • Return policy. Yeah, so maybe you thought you'd fit perfectly into that Elvis costume, but it's a little tight in some places and loose in others. Will the store let you return it? Be sure to read the details about how long you have to send it back and if the package has to be unopened or just in new, resalable condition.
  • Customer satisfaction. Has the store been rated by the Better Business Bureau? Have shoppers had a good experience getting their Halloween costumes delivered on time? Was the return process hassle-free or hard to deal with? Are the costumes well-made or flimsy?

To help you get your spooky on, TopConsumerReviews.com has evaluated and ranked today's most popular online retailers of Halloween costumes. We're sure this information will make it fun and fast to get the perfect outfit before the big party or trick-or-treat!

Compare Halloween Costume Stores

Select any 2 Halloween Costume Stores to compare them head to head

best-halloween-costumes
  • Halloween Costumes
  • Party City
  • Halloween Express
  • Costumes
  • Costume Kingdom
  • Spirit Halloween
  • Buy Costumes
  • The Halloween Spot
  • Costume Supercenter
  • Find Costume
  • Trendy Halloween
  • Frank Bee Costume Center
Halloween Costumes vs Party City Halloween Costumes vs Halloween Express Halloween Costumes vs Costumes Halloween Costumes vs Costume Kingdom Halloween Costumes vs Spirit Halloween Halloween Costumes vs Buy Costumes Halloween Costumes vs The Halloween Spot Halloween Costumes vs Costume Supercenter Halloween Costumes vs Find Costume Halloween Costumes vs Trendy Halloween Halloween Costumes vs Frank Bee Costume Center Party City vs Halloween Express Party City vs Costumes Party City vs Costume Kingdom Party City vs Spirit Halloween Party City vs Buy Costumes Party City vs The Halloween Spot Party City vs Costume Supercenter Party City vs Find Costume Party City vs Trendy Halloween Party City vs Frank Bee Costume Center Halloween Express vs Costumes Halloween Express vs Costume Kingdom Halloween Express vs Spirit Halloween Halloween Express vs Buy Costumes Halloween Express vs The Halloween Spot Halloween Express vs Costume Supercenter Halloween Express vs Find Costume Halloween Express vs Trendy Halloween Halloween Express vs Frank Bee Costume Center Costumes vs Costume Kingdom Costumes vs Spirit Halloween Costumes vs Buy Costumes Costumes vs The Halloween Spot Costumes vs Costume Supercenter Costumes vs Find Costume Costumes vs Trendy Halloween Costumes vs Frank Bee Costume Center Costume Kingdom vs Spirit Halloween Costume Kingdom vs Buy Costumes Costume Kingdom vs The Halloween Spot Costume Kingdom vs Costume Supercenter Costume Kingdom vs Find Costume Costume Kingdom vs Trendy Halloween Costume Kingdom vs Frank Bee Costume Center Spirit Halloween vs Buy Costumes Spirit Halloween vs The Halloween Spot Spirit Halloween vs Costume Supercenter Spirit Halloween vs Find Costume Spirit Halloween vs Trendy Halloween Spirit Halloween vs Frank Bee Costume Center Buy Costumes vs The Halloween Spot Buy Costumes vs Costume Supercenter Buy Costumes vs Find Costume Buy Costumes vs Trendy Halloween Buy Costumes vs Frank Bee Costume Center The Halloween Spot vs Costume Supercenter The Halloween Spot vs Find Costume The Halloween Spot vs Trendy Halloween The Halloween Spot vs Frank Bee Costume Center Costume Supercenter vs Find Costume Costume Supercenter vs Trendy Halloween Costume Supercenter vs Frank Bee Costume Center Find Costume vs Trendy Halloween Find Costume vs Frank Bee Costume Center Trendy Halloween vs Frank Bee Costume Center
Compare the Best Halloween Costume Stores
- VS -
Review the Best Halloween Costume Stores
See the Best Halloween Costume Store
The Best Reviews of Halloween Costume Stores