Who's better?

Party Expert vs Costumes

We've analyzed the best Halloween Costume Stores to help you find the right solution for your needs.

2025 Halloween Costume Store Reviews

Here you can see how Party Expert and Costumes match up head-to-head in a battle for the Best Halloween Costume Stores in 2025.

Winner

Party Expert

  • Woman-owned family business
  • Costumes for adults, kids, and pets
  • Free standard shipping on orders over $70

Party Expert is a top destination for on-trend Halloween costumes that ship quickly throughout the United States and Canada. There are hundreds of Halloween costumes for adults, kids, and pets here, plus all the party supplies you might want to get as well. You'll have 10 days to make a return or exchange, but since most people say that costumes come exactly as pictured online, hopefully you won't need to. We like the shopping experience here and the extra low prices on products, so Party Expert is a great choice for Halloween costumes.

Costumes

  • Adult, kid, and pet costumes
  • Halloween decor, toys, and other celebratory costumes
  • 10% off first order with email signup

If you are looking for a costume to go along with the latest major movie to come out of Hollywood or to dress up like a social icon that's been in the media a lot, Costumes will likely have options for you. There are tons of costumes and accessories here (as well as home decor, toys, and other celebratory clothing) and we're happy with the selection. Pricing is reasonable and the website is easy to browse. We don't love that returns incur restocking fees of 12% and that recent customer reviews have been really poor. The company seems to be switching over to a new software system and having tons of issues relating to shipping. If you're shopping close to Halloween, you may want to try a different retailer to ensure that your costume comes in time. Otherwise, give Costumes a chance and maybe plan well in advance to make sure you don't run into problems.

For lots of people, Halloween ranks among the favorite holidays, a built-in excuse to binge scary movies, set skeletons in the yard, hang bats around the house, brave haunted attractions, and devour pumpkin-flavored everything - plus way too much candy. Whether you're all-in or just along for the ride, you'll probably end up tracking down a costume for yourself or your kids. Costumes and decorations tend to sell out fast as October rolls on, so planning ahead can save you stress.

Picking a Halloween costume takes a little imagination. Whether it's for you or your kid, you're probably aiming for something that channels a movie you loved this year, a favorite celebrity or cultural icon, or a look that feels true to your personality. The trick is landing on an idea that doesn't feel like the same thing you saw all over social media last year, so give yourself time to brainstorm and let a few quirky ideas surface. Start browsing early - thrift stores, costume swaps, and quick DIY tweaks can turn a simple concept into something memorable. With a bit of thought, you can land on a costume that feels fresh and genuinely iconic.

Whether you DIY every detail or grab a couple of capes from the clearance rack, the point is to show up and have a blast. Snap the group shot on the front steps, let the kids smudge their face paint, and chase that golden-hour glow before the porch lights flip on. Pile into the neighborhood parade, trade candy on the curb, and laugh when someone's inflatable tail knocks over a pumpkin. By the time you scroll through the camera roll, you'll have proof of the chaos - and the charm - that makes the night unforgettable.

Whichever route you take, shop online with a retailer that offers plenty of choices and all the accessories and pieces you need to make your costume look realistic and memorable. Start your hunt well before Halloween - the earlier you begin, the better. Give yourself time to brainstorm a fun idea and track down every last item before the big holiday rush hits. And don't forget to check shipping timelines and sizing charts so nothing derails your plans at the last minute.

There are many companies that sell Halloween costumes online, and many of them can be taken advantage of all year long for things like cosplay, themed parties, and other dress-up occasions. So how do you select the best retailer? We've done plenty of research to help you find the ones that will provide memorable costumes at reasonable prices for you this season. Here are some major things to consider when weighing your options:

The experts at Top Consumer Reviews have researched the most reputable and exciting Halloween stores online. We hope this information helps you find everything you need to make the season spooktacular!

Slide Down Image Left Slide Image FAQ Image Slide Image Twirl Image

Halloween Costume Store FAQ

When did Halloween costumes first become popular?
Although Halloween originated hundreds of years ago, the way we know it today started in the early 1900s. People wore dark, scary costumes intended to ward off evil spirits, but those outfits gave way to more pop culture styles in the 1920s and 1930s.
Do people celebrate Halloween around the world?
While the modern-day celebrations of Halloween are definitely more prevalent in the United States, people in many other countries have picked up the tradition as well. Who doesn't love the idea of getting dressed up in fun costumes and eating candy?
Aren't Halloween costumes just for kids?
Some aspects of Halloween still tend to be more for the younger set, like trick-or-treating. But grown-ups don't want to miss the fun: you'll often find costume contests in the workplace, or teenagers on your doorstep asking for candy right next to their younger siblings. Halloween costumes are for everyone!
I'm going to a theme party - in July! Where can I find something to wear?
Lucky for you, there are a number of online Halloween costume retailers who have you covered any time of year. You might not find the biggest selection, and some of the "hottest trends" may be last year's top picks, but you'll still have plenty to choose from.
Why should I shop online for my Halloween costume?
That's easy: selection, price, and availability. You may have noticed that the pickings in retail stores are pretty slim by the second week of October, so you could be out of luck if you procrastinated getting your child's favorite character costume - unless you shop online. Many online Halloween costume shops offer low-price guarantees and carry thousands of options in a huge range of sizes.
Does anyone sell Halloween costumes for big-and-tall people?
Yes! While you might often come away from retail stores disappointed that there's nothing you like that fits, you won't have that experience when you shop online for a Halloween costume. Some of the best retailers make sure to carry costumes in lots of sizes: tall, short, petite, plus size, and so on. Halloween should be enjoyed by every body (pun intended).
Can I return my Halloween costume?
That depends on the retailer. Most stores give you at least 30 days to return your costume, as long as it's in the original packaging with all tags attached. (In other words, no wearing it to trick-or-treat and then sending it back!) If you're not sure the costume you're buying is going to be a good fit, make sure to check the return policy before you place your order.
Are Halloween costumes expensive?
They can be - but they don't have to be. You can find plenty of fun options for under $20 - or go crazy and buy a Halloween costume that costs $200 or more! (You can even get cute stuff for your dog. ) Don't forget to factor in the accessories, too: will you need makeup, a wig, shoes or props to complete your look? Most Halloween costume stores have all of that as well.

Compare Any 2 Products

Halloween Costumes
Spirit Halloween
Halloween Express
Party Expert
Party City
Costumes
Costume Kingdom
Costume Supercenter
Miccostumes
Find Costume
vs
Halloween Costumes vs Spirit HalloweenHalloween Costumes vs Halloween ExpressHalloween Costumes vs Party ExpertHalloween Costumes vs Party CityHalloween Costumes vs CostumesHalloween Costumes vs Costume KingdomHalloween Costumes vs Costume SupercenterHalloween Costumes vs MiccostumesHalloween Costumes vs Find CostumeSpirit Halloween vs Halloween ExpressSpirit Halloween vs Party ExpertSpirit Halloween vs Party CitySpirit Halloween vs CostumesSpirit Halloween vs Costume KingdomSpirit Halloween vs Costume SupercenterSpirit Halloween vs MiccostumesSpirit Halloween vs Find CostumeHalloween Express vs Party ExpertHalloween Express vs Party CityHalloween Express vs CostumesHalloween Express vs Costume KingdomHalloween Express vs Costume SupercenterHalloween Express vs MiccostumesHalloween Express vs Find CostumeParty Expert vs Party CityParty Expert vs CostumesParty Expert vs Costume KingdomParty Expert vs Costume SupercenterParty Expert vs MiccostumesParty Expert vs Find CostumeParty City vs CostumesParty City vs Costume KingdomParty City vs Costume SupercenterParty City vs MiccostumesParty City vs Find CostumeCostumes vs Costume KingdomCostumes vs Costume SupercenterCostumes vs MiccostumesCostumes vs Find CostumeCostume Kingdom vs Costume SupercenterCostume Kingdom vs MiccostumesCostume Kingdom vs Find CostumeCostume Supercenter vs MiccostumesCostume Supercenter vs Find CostumeMiccostumes vs Find Costume Find Costume vs MiccostumesFind Costume vs Costume SupercenterFind Costume vs Costume KingdomFind Costume vs CostumesFind Costume vs Party CityFind Costume vs Party ExpertFind Costume vs Halloween ExpressFind Costume vs Spirit HalloweenFind Costume vs Halloween CostumesMiccostumes vs Costume SupercenterMiccostumes vs Costume KingdomMiccostumes vs CostumesMiccostumes vs Party CityMiccostumes vs Party ExpertMiccostumes vs Halloween ExpressMiccostumes vs Spirit HalloweenMiccostumes vs Halloween CostumesCostume Supercenter vs Costume KingdomCostume Supercenter vs CostumesCostume Supercenter vs Party CityCostume Supercenter vs Party ExpertCostume Supercenter vs Halloween ExpressCostume Supercenter vs Spirit HalloweenCostume Supercenter vs Halloween CostumesCostume Kingdom vs CostumesCostume Kingdom vs Party CityCostume Kingdom vs Party ExpertCostume Kingdom vs Halloween ExpressCostume Kingdom vs Spirit HalloweenCostume Kingdom vs Halloween CostumesCostumes vs Party CityCostumes vs Party ExpertCostumes vs Halloween ExpressCostumes vs Spirit HalloweenCostumes vs Halloween CostumesParty City vs Party ExpertParty City vs Halloween ExpressParty City vs Spirit HalloweenParty City vs Halloween CostumesParty Expert vs Halloween ExpressParty Expert vs Spirit HalloweenParty Expert vs Halloween CostumesHalloween Express vs Spirit HalloweenHalloween Express vs Halloween CostumesSpirit Halloween vs Halloween Costumes
See the Best Halloween Costume Stores in Your State
Only the Best Reviews

YouTube on MSN

Halloween costumes if you are with a friend group of 3 people

which ONE are you gonna be?? I love all these Halloween costumes so much. Halloween is going to be brilliant. The costumes Alvin and the chipmunks, minions, 3 little pigs, powderpuff girls and ...

Mon, 08 Dec 2025

Only the Best Reviews

The Cincinnati ...

Bengals Halloween costumes include Logan Wilson as a lion, 'High ...

And, finally, Bengals Tight End Tanner Hudson also brought childhood nostalgia to the Halloween party. He and his wife, Karley Weatherly-Hudson, dressed up as Cosmo and Wanda from Nickelodeon's " The ...

Wed, 05 Nov 2025

Only the Best Reviews

WCVB Channel 5 ...

The most popular Halloween costumes of the ‘70s, ‘80s and ‘90s

To the spirit of Halloween this year with *** mask or costume and you haven't bought yours yet, it might be too late to become one of the most popular characters. Super villain Darth Vader of Star ...

Fri, 17 Oct 2025

Only the Best Reviews

AOL

50 Creative Halloween Costume Ideas That Aren’t Just The Hot Nurse ...

Usually, the most popular Halloween costumes every year are inspired by the biggest moments and movies that happened just prior to it. With Wicked and K-pop Demon Hunters blowing up in 2025, it’s ...

Mon, 20 Oct 2025

Only the Best Reviews

The Grio

13 Halloween costumes we do and do not want to see this year

Before the season’s first pumpkins were plucked from patches, an offensive Halloween costume targeting Drake was pulled from Fashion Nova’s website. Meanwhile, a crewneck sweatshirt emblazoned with ...

Fri, 11 Oct 2024

Only the Best Reviews

People

The Best Halloween Costume for You to Wear, Based on Your Zodiac Sign

From Heidi Klum to Katy Perry, these Halloween costumes are inspired by the stars Getty Every year, when Halloween rolls around, it’s more than just tricks and treats — it’s a full-blown costume ...

Mon, 28 Oct 2024

Top Products.  

Top Reviews.  

Top Consumer Reviews.

Reviews 

Browse through thousands of reviews.

Social Media 

Like us?  Follow us!  We'd love to have you join our community.

Newsletter 

Stay up to date with the latest reviews. We'll keep you informed, and we'll never sell your information to anyone.