Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

Costume Supercenter Review

Monday, December 2nd

2024 Halloween Costume Store Reviews

Costume Supercenter Review 2.5 Star Rating

Costume Supercenter

2.5 Star Rating
  • Costumes and home decor
  • For adults, kids, and pets
  • Free shipping on orders over $75
  • Unfiltered customer reviews on some products
  • 15-day return policy

Costume Super Center doesn't have an "About Us” section or provide background about how long they've been in business, so all we can say upfront is that they provide the shopping experience you'd expect when you set out looking for a Halloween costume. For pets, kids, and adults, you can find a variety of costume themes and sizes at pretty good deals. They also sell a good range of accessories to perfect the details of your costume from head to toe.

Costumes and decor

The categories you can choose from at Costume Super Center include new arrivals, featured costumes/trending ideas, kids, adults, sexy, accessories, pets, and even decor. On top of getting you and your family's Halloween costumes here, you could get everything to deck out your yard and home interior for the spooky holiday. This includes yard props, banners, candy bowls, inflatable figures, signs, and so much more.

Impressive selection

If you'd rather just search for the costume you're looking for, that's an option at Costume Super Center too. You'll want to use additional filter features to narrow down your choices since we found 1,079 in-stock women's costumes (1,274 if you include what was out-of-stock), 999 men's costumes (1,253 with out-of-stock), 863 girls costumes (977 with out-of-stock), and 738 boys costumes (864 with out-of-stock). This doesn't even include teen costumes, costumes for pets, and infant/toddler costumes. Needless to say, the selection here is pretty good so it helps that you can specify if you want sale products, the collection you're interested in, character, and size.

Best Halloween Costumes

Little to no product reviews

When you select a costume, you'll see what sizes it comes in. Not all costumes have the full range of sizes for the category available, so searching by size is a good idea. Each costume has a few photos included, a description of the costume, a size chart for reference, what material it is made of, and care instructions. There is a place for customers to come back and leave reviews on the products, but we found that most costumes had no reviews at all.

Free shipping over $75

You should expect to pay between $25 and $60 for a costume from Costume Super Center. We found quite a few "super saver” deals, which meant that the costume was on sale, but otherwise you'll pay full price. Costs depend on how detailed the costume is and the materials used. If you spend at least $75, you'll get free shipping on your order; otherwise rates start at $8.99 and depend on the size and weight of the products. Costume Super Center says their standard shipping averages 5 days, but could be anywhere from 2-10.

15-day returns

You'll have 15 days from your order date to return your costume or Halloween decor to Costume Super Center. Keep in mind you'll still need to pay for return shipping and the company charges a 12% restocking fee as well. Returns are typically processed in 2 weeks, but could take as long as 3 weeks during the Halloween season (September - November).

Best Halloween Costumes

Some major issues

Costume Super Center does not have a rating from the Better Business Bureau. They have thousands of third-party reviews, but they're very average. Some people had no issues with their order at all and are totally pleased with the company. However, the majority of what we read from recent reviews reported issues like costumes arriving late, poor shipment packaging, costumes that appear used and stained, and other issues. These can be major problems, so we are disappointed that so many people have bad reports. If you happen to find a costume in your size that has reviews from the website, then that's a score. Pay attention to how others said the costume fit and what the material/quality is like and that could be a reliable way to decide whether or not to buy anything here.

Hesitant due to ratings

We wish we had a little more background on this company like how long they've been in business and where they operate out of for starters. We like the selection here and pricing seems similar to what we've seen through competitors. However, the poor customer reviews are what have really given us pause about deciding to shop at Costume Super Center, and we recommend that you look elsewhere too.

Where is the Best Place to Buy Halloween Costumes?

For many, Halloween is a favorite holiday. It's an excuse to watch all the scary movies, display skeletons in your yard, hang bats throughout your house, visit haunted attractions, eat and drink pumpkin-flavored everything, and - of course - eat way too much candy. Whether you're all in on Halloween or not, you'll probably find yourself on the hunt for a Halloween costume for you or your children.

Picking out the right Halloween costume requires some creativity. You or your child will want to be something that represents a favorite movie you saw during the year, a celebrity or icon you've come to love, or something reflecting your personality. Usually you'll try to choose something unique that you didn't already see a million people dress as last year on social media, so you've got to get the gears turning in your head to come up with something iconic.

The Best Halloween Costume Stores Compare Halloween Costume Stores Compare Halloween Costume Store Reviews What are the best Halloween Costume Stores Best Halloween Costume Store Reviews

Halloween Costume Store FAQ

Although Halloween originated hundreds of years ago, the way we know it today started in the early 1900s. People wore dark, scary costumes intended to ward off evil spirits, but those outfits gave way to more pop culture styles in the 1920s and 1930s.
While the modern-day celebrations of Halloween are definitely more prevalent in the United States, people in many other countries have picked up the tradition as well. Who doesn't love the idea of getting dressed up in fun costumes and eating candy?
Some aspects of Halloween still tend to be more for the younger set, like trick-or-treating. But grown-ups don't want to miss the fun: you'll often find costume contests in the workplace, or teenagers on your doorstep asking for candy right next to their younger siblings. Halloween costumes are for everyone!
Lucky for you, there are a number of online Halloween costume retailers who have you covered any time of year. You might not find the biggest selection, and some of the "hottest trends” may be last year's top picks, but you'll still have plenty to choose from.
That's easy: selection, price, and availability. You may have noticed that the pickings in retail stores are pretty slim by the second week of October, so you could be out of luck if you procrastinated getting your child's favorite character costume - unless you shop online. Many online Halloween costume shops offer low-price guarantees and carry thousands of options in a huge range of sizes.
Yes! While you might often come away from retail stores disappointed that there's nothing you like that fits, you won't have that experience when you shop online for a Halloween costume. Some of the best retailers make sure to carry costumes in lots of sizes: tall, short, petite, plus size, and so on. Halloween should be enjoyed by every body (pun intended).
That depends on the retailer. Most stores give you at least 30 days to return your costume, as long as it's in the original packaging with all tags attached. (In other words, no wearing it to trick-or-treat and then sending it back!) If you're not sure the costume you're buying is going to be a good fit, make sure to check the return policy before you place your order.
They can be - but they don't have to be. You can find plenty of fun options for under $20 - or go crazy and buy a Halloween costume that costs $200 or more! (You can even get cute stuff for your dog. ) Don't forget to factor in the accessories, too: will you need makeup, a wig, shoes or props to complete your look? Most Halloween costume stores have all of that as well.
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

Halloween is kind of a big deal and that's what makes it so much fun. All for the photos, right? Some people choose to do a theme with their family, like dressing as characters from Toy Story, Ghostbusters, zoo animals, or fast food items. The sky's the limit! Others will want to pick their own unique, standalone costume.

Either way, you'll want to shop online from a store that gives you more than enough options for both and provides all the accessories and pieces to make your getup realistic and memorable. The sooner you get shopping during Halloween, the better. Make sure you give yourself time to come up with a fun idea and get everything you need before the big Halloween rush hits.

There are many companies that sell Halloween costumes online, and many of them can be taken advantage of all year long for things like cosplay, themed parties, and other dress-up occasions. So how do you select the best retailer? We've done plenty of research to help you find the ones that will provide memorable costumes at reasonable prices for you this season. Here are some major things to consider when weighing your options:

  • Selection. Does the company have kid and adult costumes? Do they stock a wide variety of sizes? Do they have classically-themed costumes like princesses and witches as well as new, trendy costumes from the latest movies and world events?
  • Price. Even though you might want to make a splash with your Halloween costume, you probably aren't going to be excited about spending a fortune on it. Find a retailer with competitive pricing on clothing and accessories so that you can put together your whole look at a reasonable, comfortable cost.
  • Return policy. If the costume you order doesn't fit quite right or you change your mind about what to wear , are you able to send back your costume for a full refund? Be sure to read the fine print on how long you have to return your costume and how it needs to be packaged when it's returned.
  • Reputation. What do other customers have to say about the Halloween costume store? Do they ship products on time and provide high quality options? What rating does the store get from the Better Business Bureau? Paying attention to these things will help ensure that your online shopping experience goes smoothly and you get what you hoped for.

The experts at Top Consumer Reviews have researched the most reputable and exciting Halloween stores online. We hope this information helps you find everything you need to make the season spooktacular!

Compare Halloween Costume Stores

Select any 2 Halloween Costume Stores to compare them head to head

best-halloween-costumes
  • Halloween Costumes
  • Spirit Halloween
  • Halloween Express
  • Party Expert
  • Party City
  • Costumes
  • Costume Kingdom
  • Costume Supercenter
  • Miccostumes
  • Find Costume
Halloween Costumes vs Spirit Halloween Halloween Costumes vs Halloween Express Halloween Costumes vs Party Expert Halloween Costumes vs Party City Halloween Costumes vs Costumes Halloween Costumes vs Costume Kingdom Halloween Costumes vs Costume Supercenter Halloween Costumes vs Miccostumes Halloween Costumes vs Find Costume Spirit Halloween vs Halloween Express Spirit Halloween vs Party Expert Spirit Halloween vs Party City Spirit Halloween vs Costumes Spirit Halloween vs Costume Kingdom Spirit Halloween vs Costume Supercenter Spirit Halloween vs Miccostumes Spirit Halloween vs Find Costume Halloween Express vs Party Expert Halloween Express vs Party City Halloween Express vs Costumes Halloween Express vs Costume Kingdom Halloween Express vs Costume Supercenter Halloween Express vs Miccostumes Halloween Express vs Find Costume Party Expert vs Party City Party Expert vs Costumes Party Expert vs Costume Kingdom Party Expert vs Costume Supercenter Party Expert vs Miccostumes Party Expert vs Find Costume Party City vs Costumes Party City vs Costume Kingdom Party City vs Costume Supercenter Party City vs Miccostumes Party City vs Find Costume Costumes vs Costume Kingdom Costumes vs Costume Supercenter Costumes vs Miccostumes Costumes vs Find Costume Costume Kingdom vs Costume Supercenter Costume Kingdom vs Miccostumes Costume Kingdom vs Find Costume Costume Supercenter vs Miccostumes Costume Supercenter vs Find Costume Miccostumes vs Find Costume
Compare the Best Halloween Costume Stores
- VS -
Review the Best Halloween Costume Stores
See the Best Halloween Costume Store
The Best Reviews of Halloween Costume Stores