Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

The Best Hockey Equipment Stores

Where Can You Find the Best Hockey Equipment Online?

Whether you're a dedicated hockey player, or a fan looking for the right gear, finding a reliable online hockey store can be a challenge. It's no secret that playing any sport, especially hockey, requires a whole bunch of gear. If you're gearing up to hit the ice and play some hockey, you're gonna need the works: a solid helmet, skates that glide like a dream, a trusty stick, a mouthguard to protect those pearly whites, shoulder pads, elbow pads, shin guards, comfy pants, and more.

With various brands, models, and specifications available, choosing the right gear can greatly impact performance and enjoyment on the ice. Many people may be hesitant to buy hockey equipment online, but with efficient shipping practices, you can now receive your gear quickly and safely.

Friday, July 19th

2024 Hockey Equipment Store Reviews

Top Consumer Reviews Best-In-Class Blue Ribbon Award Scheels Review 5 Star Rating


5 Star Rating
  • Prices range from $25.99 to $1,079.99
  • Great website
  • 100% satisfaction guarantee
  • Returns at any time
  • Price match guarantee
  • Rebates available
  • "A-" rating from the BBB
Top Consumer Reviews Best-In-Class Blue Ribbon Award

You may not know this, but Scheels started with potatoes. You read that right. Friedrich A. Scheele, a German immigrant, settled in Sabin, Minnesota with his family and planted potatoes on their small plot of land. With the earnings from their first harvest, he made a down payment on a small hardware and general merchandise store, which started the Scheels legacy.

Extensive retail presence

Today, Scheels has grown into a prominent retailer with 30 locations across 13 states, offering an extensive range of sporting goods, apparel, footwear, and more from renowned brands. What sets Scheels apart is its commitment to people, exemplified by giving back to local communities. In line with this dedication, Scheels donates a significant portion of its profits, between 8-10% annually, to organizations in the communities it serves.

Great experience and wide variety

If you're looking for a site that is easy to use with a modern design and a visually striking user interface, Scheels is it. The main hockey equipment items are all listed across the top bar with photos to make it easy to see what you're searching for. Further, you can easily select items from the side list to narrow down your search along with a wide variety of useful filters to make sure that you can search as broadly or as narrowly as you need. While the site doesn't tell you how many items are available at a glance, there are well over 8 individual pages of hockey sticks, skates, and other hockey equipment must-haves.

Best Hockey Equipment Stores

Competitive range and pricing

With so many items available, we were excited to get into the pricing at Scheels. In this review, we checked out the pricing at Scheels for three key products: hockey sticks, hockey skates, and hockey helmets/masks. Scheels offers a range of prices for hockey sticks from an affordable $25.99 to $359.99. When it comes to skates, Scheels provides a selection that caters to youth sizing as well as adults, with brands that are well known for pro hockey players such as Bauer, and reasonable prices. You can find skates at Scheels from $49.99 to $1,079.99. As for hockey masks, Scheels offers options for casual players, kids, and even more expensive masks for pros with prices ranging from $39.99 to $429.99.

100% satisfaction doesn't include return shipping

The Scheels return policy ensures customer satisfaction by providing a 100% Satisfaction Guarantee. This sounds perfect at first glance. If a customer is not completely satisfied with their purchase, Scheels offers the option to exchange or refund the item. There is no specific time limit for returns or exchanges, as the focus is on meeting the customer's needs and expectations. However, it is important to note that shipping costs will not be refunded, and items must be returned in their original condition. So if you've opened an item and can't return it at one of their brick-and-mortar locations, you're stuck paying the shipping costs.

Price match process is super easy

Scheels is committed to price matching if customers come across a better price elsewhere, while there are the same requirements here as with other places: customers need to ensure that the item being matched is the exact same brand, model/style, size, and color. For other requirements, like ensuring the retailer is authorized to sell hockey equipment, the Scheels Customer Service team will verify it for you, which can make the process easier for the customer.

Best Hockey Equipment Stores

Rebates available for select items

Scheels offers rebates for select items to help offset the costs of shopping for sports equipment, which can get pretty pricey. These rebate items are listed on the Scheels rebate page and change out from time to time, so it may be helpful to check back regularly and see if there's a rebate for something you're looking for. At the time of this review, Scheels was offering up to $100 back on specific types of crossbows, as well as rebates for GPSs and even clothing items - so not necessarily hockey equipment in there, but you might spot some in the future.

Great reputation for customer service

In terms of reputation, Scheels is doing fantastic with both the Better Business Bureau and third-party review sites. The BBB has awarded Scheels a competitive "A-" rating which is higher than many competitors in our review. Further, the company has an average star rating of 4.3 out of 5 from verified shoppers. Customers love the prices at Scheels and they say that working with their customer service is a breeze. Even with orders that had problems or concerns, Scheels was able to easily resolve the situation to the customer's satisfaction.

Top option for customer satisfaction

Scheels is hands down our favorite hockey equipment store. With top tier ratings and reviews, customers love shopping at Scheels. Their listings are competitive with other retailers and their pricing ranges from affordable for casual players to more expensive for the pro-level gear. With a customer-focused price match guarantee and rebates available to make items more affordable, this one-stop shop for sports gear is a great place to look for your next purchase of hockey equipment. For this reason, it ranks as the #1 hockey retailer in our review.

Hockey Monkey Review 4.5 Star Rating

Hockey Monkey

4.5 Star Rating
  • Prices range from $12.99 to $1,149.99
  • 1-year return policy
  • Price matching with US retailers
  • Frequent sales
  • "A+" rating from the BBB

Hockey Monkey operates as a division of MonkeySports Inc., a company that specializes in selling a wide range of sports equipment, including hockey, baseball, softball, and lacrosse gear. With a history dating back to 1999, Hockey Monkey has established itself as a trusted source for sports enthusiasts.

Comprehensive hockey info

Beyond offering a vast selection of products, the website also features an informative blog that keeps hockey fans up-to-date with the latest news and developments in the sports world. Whether you're in search of equipment or seeking insightful information, Hockey Monkey serves as a comprehensive destination for all your hockey needs.

See items in action before you buy

When it comes to stocking its inventory, Hockey Monkey leaves no stone unturned. Rest assured, they have a wide variety of products to cater to every requirement. For those new to the game, the website provides detailed gear guides that assist customers in finding the perfect equipment. The site itself is modern and sporty. You can easily find different equipment types on the top navigation bar and customers are shown a variety of photographs to help them find what they need and preview some of the hockey equipment in action.

Good cost and great sales

In order to get a clear cost comparison at Hockey Monkey, it's important to look at their prices for a few different hockey items. We checked out Hockey Monkey's listings for hockey sticks, hockey skates, and hockey helmets/masks. At Hockey Monkey, the prices for hockey sticks range from $12.99 to $369.99 regularly priced. These include items for kids, street hockey, and pro hockey players. In terms of skates, the products at Hockey Monkey range from skates for children up to senior-level skates for competitors, with prices from $49.99 to $1,149.99. Finally, for hockey masks, the prices at Hockey Monkey range from $13.98 to $429.99, including options for casual players, pros, and even kids. Notably, many of their hockey products are often on sale, making them a competitive retailer for budget-conscious players. With prices that are already competitive within the industry, this may be a great place to find items on sale.

Best Hockey Equipment Stores

1-year returns

One aspect that sets Hockey Monkey apart is their generous return policy. Customers have the luxury of a whole year to return new and unused purchases. Within the first 90 days, products are eligible for refunds or exchanges, demonstrating the company's commitment to customer satisfaction. Even after this initial period, exchanges for alternative products can be facilitated within the one-year return window. Notably, restocking fees of 10% are only applicable if customers opt to return multiple sizes of the same product, making this a fair and reasonable policy overall.

Price guarantee for US retailers

At Hockey Monkey, they are dedicated to offering affordable prices for customers' favorite hockey equipment. If shoppers come across a lower price on an identical, in-stock product from a US-based authorized online retailer, Hockey Monkey is ready to match it. To qualify for the price match, certain guidelines must be met. The competitor's website should have the item currently in stock, and the price and availability should remain unchanged during the price match verification process.

BBB loves them

The Better Business Bureau has given MonkeySports Inc, the company that owns Hockey Monkey, an impressive "A+" rating, showing that Hockey Monkey has raised its reputation in recent years. However, on the flip side, customers who have reviewed this retailer at verified third-party review sites aren't as happy with the service they received. Although there aren't more than 100 reviews on any one site, the average star rating for Hockey Monkey is just over 1.2 stars out of 5. While this might be a red flag for this company, the low number of reviews may not reflect the experience of all shoppers at Hockey Monkey, which is important to keep in mind.

Top option for sales and deals

Hockey Monkey has an extensive product range, which caters to both novices and experienced players across a range of price points. And, with a 1-year return policy, this service stands out from other hockey retailers. However, it's worth noting that while they do have an "A+" rating from the BBB, customers are saying that the experience of shopping with Hockey Monkey isn't their favorite. Since customer feedback only is lower than our top option, we had to knock their rating down a little. But still, Hockey Monkey is a great retailer to check out for sales and deals on hockey equipment.

Hockey Supremacy Review 4 Star Rating

Hockey Supremacy

4 Star Rating
  • Prices range from $19.99 to $1,299.99
  • Easy shopping experience
  • Filters for pro-level details
  • 365-day returns for unopened items
  • Lacrosse gear for off-season shopping

Hockey Supremacy is a Canada-based hockey retailer that offers a full range of items for both amateur hockey enthusiasts and pros. With pricing that ranges from under $40 for gear up to options in the thousands, there is something at Hockey Supremacy for everyone.

Products from kids to adults

The site feels like a sports website and provides products for kids and adults to enjoy this exciting winter sport. You can tell they love their work at Hockey Supremacy, which makes it stand out a bit from the pack. But with no reviews or BBB presence, it's hard to say how much customers really enjoy shopping here, so you may need to browse and make that decision yourself.

Clean and sporty website

Browsing at Hockey Supremacy is a great experience. The key products are easily visible along the top menu and customers are met with a clean and modern webpage. And, while you're browsing it's easy to find what you need with a variety of useful filters. On top of having items split out by level, including "youth" or "senior" level gear, there are filters for brand, price, and sales as well as some unique filters for each item type. For example, hockey sticks can be filtered by "flex" or "curve" in addition to the other standard filters.

Competitive costs across levels

In order to get a clear cost comparison at Hockey Supremacy, it's important to look at their prices for a few different hockey items. For this review, we checked out Hockey Supremacy's offerings for three essential products: hockey sticks, hockey skates, and hockey helmets/masks. At Hockey Supremacy the prices for hockey sticks range from $59.99 to $439.99 regularly priced. Some hockey sticks were on sale for as low as $39.99 at the time of this review. In terms of skates, the products at Hockey Supremacy range from skates for children up to senior-level skates for competitors. The prices range from $54.99 to $1,299.99. Finally, for hockey masks, the prices range from $19.99 to $529.99 and include options for every age and hockey level.

Best Hockey Equipment Stores

Only a few items available for returns

At Hockey Supremacy, you can request a return for eligible items that meet specific criteria within 365 days. These criteria include ensuring the items are in their original condition, unused, and in the original packaging. This return policy covers items that may have been damaged during shipping or are defective, as well as items that are protected by the manufacturer's warranty. However, there are many items that are not eligible for return. For instance, sharpened or baked skates cannot be returned. Similarly, taped sticks, jocks, undergarments, mouthguards, special orders, pro stock items, team orders, and customized products, such as jerseys with personalization, fall under the category of items that cannot be returned. Further, if you do decide to return, you'll be responsible for return shipping, which could be pricey.

Lacrosse for the off-season

One benefit of shopping with Hockey Supremacy is that for the off-season, they have a sister site that provides pro and casual-quality lacrosse equipment. The lacrosse site is easily accessible from Hockey Supremacy's front page and offers the same online experience and quality for fans of lacrosse - including hockey fans who want a summer sport to keep them in shape.

Reviews aren't available

On the other hand, there is one big negative for Hockey Supremacy: there isn't much of a review presence out there. Including a full search of the BBB, we checked out Hockey Supremacy, and other than some reviews on the website itself, there isn't much buzz about this online retailer. With no reputation with the Better Business Bureau and almost no presence from verified third-party review sites, we can't really say how customers feel about shopping with this Canadian-based site.

Great option for variety

Overall, Hockey Supremacy is a good retailer, but not quite "supreme" enough to beat out our top two hockey equipment stores. With a limited return policy and no reviews or presence with the Better Business Bureau, it couldn't take a top spot in our rankings. However, the prices here provide high and low-cost options for every level of hockey player, so you can find some great deals on this site no matter how long you've been playing the sport. And, with 365 days to return your purchases, this site has one of the longest return windows out there. With these things considered, this one-stop shop earns a high rating among retailers of hockey gear.

Perani's Hockey World Review 3.5 Star Rating

Perani's Hockey World

3.5 Star Rating
  • Prices range from $29.99 to $1,199.99
  • 30-day limited returns
  • Team discounts available
  • 4.6-star ratings from reviewers

Perani's Hockey World, founded by former pro hockey player Bob Perani in 1976, has established itself as a go-to retail store for hockey players looking to find all their essentials under one roof. From hockey jerseys and helmets to pants, protective gear, skates, sticks, bags, gloves, performance wear, and socks, they have you covered.

Competitive pricing but concerns

With their main operations and customer service center based in Flint, Michigan, they offer competitive pricing for a wide variety of items. However, with no rating from the BBB and a very outdated website, this doesn't rank as one of the top competitors in our review.

Older site is a little clunky

When comparing Perani's to other hockey retail sites, this one falls a little flat in the design department. The site comes across as being a little older than some of the alternatives in our review. Even some of the features like the filters on the sidebar are hard to read with an oversized font that doesn't fit the webpage. Additionally, details about the listings are hard to read as many jumble information together or mix fonts. The site does offer a wide range of name-brand products from renowned manufacturers like Nike, Easton, Reebok, Warrior, Mission, Infiniti, Bauer, and more, which helps it remain competitive despite the poor user experience.

Mid-range for pricing

To check out how these prices stacked up against other companies in this review, we examined Perani's Hockey World's hockey sticks, hockey skates, and hockey helmets/masks. Perani's Hockey World offers a wide range of prices for hockey sticks, with regular prices ranging from $49.99 to $359.99 for composite material hockey sticks. For hockey skates, Perani's Hockey World provides options for skaters of all ages and skill levels, with prices ranging from $29.99 to $1,199.99. Additionally, their selection of hockey masks includes listings for casual players, professionals, and children, with prices ranging from $39.99 to $429.99. It's important to note that these prices are competitive, but not any lower than some of the other stores in this review.

Best Hockey Equipment Stores

Returns aren't customer-focused

Perani's Hockey World offers a passable exchange policy. The company allows customers to easily exchange new products for different sizes, colors, or items without any restocking fees. However, customers are responsible for the shipping costs of the replacement product. For returns, items must be received within 30 days of the invoice date, as Perani's Hockey World does not accept returns after this period. Used items are not eligible for refunds or exchanges. Customers are responsible for the freight costs associated with returns, and shipping and handling charges are non-refundable. This is one of the worst return policies in this review as it puts the burden of shipping entirely on the customer and is one of the shorter return windows overall.

Customers loved the staff

We checked out Perani's Hockey Word on the BBB and were a little disappointed to find that the company held an "NR'' ranking at that moment, and there were no customer reviews on the BBB at the time of this review. On the bright side, customers have been reviewing the service on Google Reviews where Perani's Hockey World holds an average rating of 4.6 stars out of 5. Customers praised the service team at Perani's Hockey World. They loved the shopping experience and felt like the customer service reps were knowledgeable and particularly helpful.

Team discounts bonus

One benefit of shopping with Perani's Hockey World is that they offer special deals if you're ordering for the whole team. Perani's Hockey World's team discounts are offered if you're part of a group placing an order for 12 or more items. They even provide contact information for a representative who can assist with customizations on apparel or gear, catering to the unique needs of your team.

Good for keeping prices down

Overall, Perani's Hockey World impresses us with its comprehensive inventory and fun extras like a team discount bonus. However, with no rating at the BBB and a very poor return policy, Perani's Hockey World isn't one of our top two. The difficulty navigating the site also knocked Perani's down a few notches. But with competitive pricing, it may be worth a shot for many customers seeking a full cart of hockey equipment.

Pure Hockey Review 3.5 Star Rating

Pure Hockey

3.5 Star Rating
  • Prices range from $49.99 to $1,149.99
  • 90-day returns
  • Low-price guarantee
  • Flat rate shipping
  • Custom items

Pure Hockey proudly claims the title of being the largest online hockey retailer in the United States. What sets them apart is that all of their store managers are former hockey players and enthusiasts, bringing a deep understanding and passion for the sport.

In-store locations

This is another retailer that offers both online shopping experiences and options for in-person shopping if you live near one of their brick-and-mortar locations. However, customers voiced concerns with paying for returns and a high flat-rate fee for shipping, As such, Pure Hockey doesn't stand out as a top competitor in this review, but their competitive rates for hockey gear did earn them a middle-of-the-pack review.

Easy to browse and wide selection

Navigating Pure Hockey's website is a breeze, thanks to its well-organized product categories. Whether you're in the market for sticks, skates, protective gear, accessories, bags, jerseys and apparel, goalie equipment, NHL merchandise, or items on sale, you can easily find what you're looking for. Furthermore, if you have a specific brand preference, Pure Hockey allows you to shop by brand, featuring popular names like Bauer, TRUE, Warrior, CCM, Shock Doctor, and more. You can refine your search by price, size, product line, color, division, and other criteria. With an extensive array of options within each category, Pure Hockey ensures that its customers have a wide selection to choose from.

Best Hockey Equipment Stores

Huge variety and custom items

To check out how the pricing at Pure Hockey stacks up against competitors, we explored Pure Hockey's hockey sticks, hockey skates, and hockey helmets/masks. Pure Hockey provides a range of prices for composite hockey sticks, with prices ranging from $49.99 to $719.99. With over 170 different composite hockey sticks there are tons of listings to choose from, even custom items at Pure Hockey. When it comes to skates, Pure Hockey offers a variety of products, from children's skates to senior-level skates for competitive players. There are 100 different options to choose from with prices from $49.99 to $1,149.99. As for hockey masks, Pure Hockey offers a selection of designs and sizes for casual players, professionals, and kids, with prices ranging from $34.99 to $429.99 with customizable masks available. Pure Hockey does offer one of the greatest varieties of hockey equipment with pricing that works for low-cost and pro budgets.

90-day returns available

One aspect of Pure Hockey that stands out is its 90-day return policy. Customers have the option to return online purchases for a refund, store credit, or exchange at any of Pure Hockey's retail store locations. If a customer is unable to visit a store, they can log in to their account to generate a return shipping label. However, while the review window is quite large, Pure Hockey does charge a return shipping fee of $8.99 which sticks the customer with the cost of shipping.

30-day Low Price Guarantee

One of the most competitive features at Pure Hockey is their Low Price Guarantee. If within 30 days of the purchase, customers find the same item is found for a lower price at one of the listed qualifying retailers, Pure Hockey will match that price. Customers can request a price match at any Pure Hockey location or by contacting customer service. It is important to provide proof of the current lower price and have the receipt on hand when making the price match request. Like most price match policies, the item being matched must be identical in terms of brand, size, weight, color, quantity, and model number.

Best Hockey Equipment Stores

High shipping cost

One place Pure Hockey didn't stand out for us was that they charge flat-rate shipping on all purchases. For customers within the contiguous US, there is a fee of $13.99, while orders en route to Alaska and Hawaii are subject to a charge of $39.99. This is much higher than flat-rate shipping at other retailers and could be frustrating for customers who are used to free shipping options at other online hockey stores.

Reputation has taken a hit

While Pure Hockey used to have a great reputation, recently that reputation has fallen. The Better Business Bureau previously gave Pure Hockey an "A+" rating. However, when we checked their rating, the BBB lowered the company's score to "D-" which is a significant change. The store's reputation has been tarnished as customers complain about certain Pure Hockey stores "concealing damage" to items before selling them or not honoring their return policy. On the other hand, Google reviews show that customers have rated Pure Hockey an impressive 4.9 out of 5 stars. Most of these positive reviews are related to particular locations and customers rave about the staff at these brick-and-mortar stores. However, there are no reviews for Pure Hockey on other verified third-party sites like Trustpilot.

Best for custom items

Pure Hockey's extensive range of products meets the needs of diverse budgets, making it an inclusive online store for all hockey enthusiasts. We especially love that they offer customizable items. On the other hand, with their recently fallen reputation, high shipping costs, and the fact that they charge customers to ship items back for returns, this can't be one of our top competitors. However, it earns a 3.5 instead of a lower score because of the truly impressive variety of hockey products and the custom items. So, if you need something that is exactly to spec, you should check out Pure Hockey.

Ice Warehouse Review 3 Star Rating

Ice Warehouse

3 Star Rating
  • Prices range from $49.99 to $1,119.99
  • Free shipping on returns
  • 90-day return policy
  • Free shipping on orders over $99

Based in Obispo, CA, Ice Warehouse is a popular online retailer of hockey equipment. In addition to hockey, Ice Warehouse is partnered with two other companies - Derby Warehouse and Inline Warehouse - to similarly help customers interested in derby skating, outdoor skating, and skating for fitness.

Employees know their gear

Ice Warehouse promises to stand out due to their training system: employees at Ice Warehouse work closely with gear experts, brand representatives, and customers to ensure that they have a deep understanding of the products they offer and how they are being utilized. This collaborative approach allows them to provide the best possible knowledge and insights to meet your needs.

Shopping is unnecessarily complex

Shopping at Ice Warehouse seems super easy at first, but gets more complicated the further you go. All of the categories you might need for hockey equipment are listed along the left-hand side of the site. Each selection has a list of filters to choose from, and you can even limit your search to only items on clearance. One thing we would like is a place to see all the hockey sticks at once. When you get into the search, you have to keep limiting to particular types of hockey sticks. First, choose the type, then the flexibility, and when you finally get to the listed hockey sticks, they have no prices on them and are arranged in a hard-to-see side-scrolling style. Customers looking to quickly and easily browse through hockey equipment may get frustrated while shopping at Ice Warehouse.

Higher costs focus on pro players

To get a clear idea of the pricing at Ice Warehouse, we examined Ice Warehouse's offerings for hockey sticks, hockey skates, and hockey helmets/masks. For hockey sticks, we specifically checked out "composite" sticks as customers can only choose one type of hockey stick to look through at a time. The prices for composite hockey sticks at Ice Warehouse range from $49.99 to $349.99. When it comes to skates, Ice Warehouse offers a range of listings for different foot types (labeled as "profiles" ), with prices spanning from $89.99 to $1,119.99. Finally, hockey masks at Ice Warehouse that are "adjustable fit" are priced between $139.99 and $429.99. Overall, this site feels more geared toward professionals, though they offer small sizes as well. The site asks questions about mask type or stick flexibility that assumes customers know exactly what they're looking for when shopping for hockey equipment. On top of that, the prices are higher overall.

Best Hockey Equipment Stores

Top-notch return policy

Ice Warehouse has one of our favorite return policies. The company offers a hassle-free return policy with free return shipping. Every package includes a prepaid shipping label, making it easy to send items back if they don't meet your expectations. You have 90 days from the original invoice date to return items for a full refund or exchange, as long as they are in new, store-bought condition. Used or worn items can also be returned within this period but will receive a store credit minus a 10% restocking fee.

Free shipping and competitive flat-rates

A nice benefit of Ice Warehouse is its free shipping policy. To qualify for free shipping at Ice Warehouse is a straightforward process. Customers simply need to choose the free shipping option at checkout for orders exceeding $99. For orders under $99, a flat rate of $7.99 is applicable for shipping. Delivery services will be provided by either UPS or GLS, depending on the customer's location. It's important to note that certain large or heavy items may incur an additional $7.99 charge, as indicated on the respective product pages.

Not enough reviews to get a read

While we'd love to give you the deets on Ice Warehouse's reputation, there just aren't enough details out there. Ice Warehouse doesn't have any presence on the BBB website, unfortunately. There are a handful of third-party reviews for Ice Warehouse on Trustpilot, but there weren't enough of them (only 11 at the time of this review) to get a solid read on the company. For the available reviews, customers seem polarized. Some love Ice Warehouse, noting that the prices are fair and the products are high quality. On the other hand, unhappy customers had problems with payment processing and getting their orders properly fulfilled.

Designed and priced for pros

While there are some fantastic things going on at Ice Warehouse, like their free shipping policy and their returns (at no cost to the customer), we're a little worried that there isn't more buzz online about this service. However, if you're a hockey pro and you know exactly what you want when you're shopping, this could be a great option for you. So, don't knock it till you've had a look. But if you're just getting started, this site might be a little confusing and overpriced.

DICK'S Sporting Goods Review 2.5 Star Rating

DICK'S Sporting Goods

2.5 Star Rating
  • Prices range from $14.99 to $629.99
  • 90-day return policy
  • Price matching available
  • Brick-and-mortar locations

For nearly four decades, DICK'S Sporting Goods has occupied a prominent place in households, serving as a go-to destination for sporting gear. Today, the company aims to inspire and equip athletes of all levels through its extensive network of stores, online platform, and mobile app, offering a wide range of sporting goods and outdoor gear.

Both online and traditional store locations

DICK'S Sporting Goods traces its roots back to 1948 when Dick Stack, an ambitious 18-year-old, left his job at an Army surplus store in Binghamton, New York. With relentless dedication, Dick expanded his business over the years, ultimately evolving into the prominent omnichannel retailer known as DICK'S Sporting Goods. As a bonus, this store also offers a number of brick-and-mortar locations. So, if you want to bypass shipping or try something on, there are some options for in-person shoppers too.

No hockey on the front page

As one might expect from a well-known retailer like DICK'S, the website is extremely clean and easy to navigate. Additionally, features like sales are highlighted on their landing page, offering customers easy access to reduced-price options. The best thing about DICK'S is that it's a one-stop shop. So if you have a hockey enthusiast in the family and a swimmer as well, you can get gear for everyone in the same place. One thing we would love, however, is a button for hockey clearly visible on the landing page. While it's super easy to search for hockey in the search bar, we miss having a clear button like some other sites do. Instead, the hockey button is hidden under the sports tab, which may not be immediately clear to some shoppers.

Best Hockey Equipment Stores

Competitive rates across the board

In order to accurately compare prices at DICK'S Sporting Goods, we examined DICK'S offerings for three essential products: hockey sticks, hockey skates, and hockey helmets/masks. DICK'S prices for hockey sticks range from $14.99 to $349.99. There were a total of 160 different hockey sticks available ranging from beginner to pro styles. As for skates, their range spans from $49.99 to $629.99, accommodating both children and senior-level skaters. Finally, their hockey mask prices range from $49.99 to $309.99, also in child and adult sizing. It is worth noting that DICK'S has competitive rates compared to some of the options in our review, and may be worth checking into for savings, especially with their regular sales and coupons.

90-day returns for most items

DICK'S Sporting Goods offers an impressive 90-day return policy for most products. It's important to note that some items like those sold at DICK'S Sporting Goods Warehouse locations follow a 45-day return policy for most items. Customers who provide valid proof of purchase, such as the order number, order confirmation email, original sales receipt, packing slip, or return barcode, will receive a refund based on their initial form of payment. However, returns without valid proof of purchase require a valid ID and will only receive a store credit for the lowest selling price. This store credit can be used exclusively for in-store merchandise purchases.

Reviews on the site are honest

One commendable aspect of DICK'S is its policy of allowing customers to leave unfiltered reviews on their purchases. This transparency enables shoppers to gain valuable insights into the quality and performance of specific items before making an online purchase, particularly given the inability to examine products in person. Despite DICK'S unfavorable reputation among many customers, if you do choose to proceed with a purchase, the product reviews may assist you in making an informed decision about whether a particular hockey product meets your requirements.

Best Hockey Equipment Stores

Low price guarantee

To provide customers with added peace of mind regarding pricing, DICK'S offers a price-matching service. Should a customer find an identical product being sold at a lower price by another hockey retailer, either in-store or online, they can contact customer service to request a price match. To qualify for the Best Price Guarantee, the product must be an exact match, including the same brand, model number, color, and size. It should be readily available at a qualifying store or website, However, there are certain exclusions, such as markdowns during special daily and hourly sales, which are not eligible for the Best Price Guarantee.

Poor reputation with customers

While the extensive inventory and user-friendly online browsing experience at DICK'S would typically lead us to recommend them as a reliable source for hockey equipment, it is disheartening to note the substantial number of customer complaints found online, as well as the company's "F" rating from the Better Business Bureau. Naturally, these alarming indicators give rise to significant concerns, prompting us to caution potential customers against engaging with DICK'S to avoid any potential issues. Many customers who reviewed DICK'S gave the company only 1 star: they felt "ripped off" by the shipping rates at this superstore and were also frustrated by their return process.

Better for in-person shopping

While DICK'S has some great options in terms of pricing and a large number of items for hockey specifically, this one-stop shop doesn't stand out as much as we expected. Unfortunately, customer service-related issues appear to be a recurring theme among individuals who have shopped at DICK'S. It is disappointing to see with a company that enjoys widespread recognition, maintains an extensive network of physical stores, and boasts an extensive selection of hockey equipment. In light of these concerns, we strongly recommend seeking out higher-rated online retailers for your hockey gear needs, to get a better overall shopping experience. However, if having an in-person store is a must-have for you, it may still be worth checking out DICK'S Sporting Goods.

HockeyShot Review 2 Star Rating


2 Star Rating
  • Prices range from $69.99 to $1,959.99
  • Offers products for coaches and home rinks
  • 30-day returns
  • Free shipping in US and Canada
  • "A+" rating form the BBB

Established in 2007, HockeyShot emerged as an online retailer dedicated to providing hockey enthusiasts with the essential tools for training. Their extensive product range includes flooring tiles, passing kits, synthetic ice, goals, slide boards, and much more. However, this site might not be ideal for folks looking to buy the basics. If you're not a coach, this may not be the ideal shopping experience for you.

Retailer meant for teachers

Navigating the shopping experience at HockeyShot may prove slightly perplexing, particularly for those new to the sport. Unlike other online retailers, their products are designed to help buyers who either coach hockey or want to set up a practice space. To this end, the categories primarily revolve around shooting, pass/stickhandling, skating, and training. As a result, essential items like skates and apparel are noticeably absent. However, if your intention is to get accessories that enhance your game environment or facilitate personalized training sessions, HockeyShot is an ideal destination.

Doesn't have common hockey equipment

To make a fair price comparison at HockeyShot, it's important to consider the prices of various hockey items they offer. But, this was harder at HockeyShot than at some of the other retailers in our review as the products focus on teaching tools and not on normal hockey gear. To give you an idea of what items cost at HockeyShot, we checked out their training kits. But it's important to note that HockeyShot doesn't sell individual sticks, skates, or masks like other retailers we compared. The kits start at $69.99 for something called "Skills in a Box" . The prices go up to $1,959.99 for the "Home Ice Skating Zone" . While the price points are similar to other retailers, the items aren't. So, if you're not looking for teaching tools, you might want to shop somewhere else.

Limited 30-day return policy

HockeyShot promises a hassle-free return experience for its customers. If a customer is dissatisfied with their HockeyShot purchase, they can request a return within 30 days of purchase to receive a full refund of the item's purchase price. However, the return excludes original shipping and handling fees. To qualify, returned items must be unused and in their original packaging. Also, unfortunately, if there's any damage to the items, they are also not eligible for returns, making this policy a little limited compared to others in our review.

Best Hockey Equipment Stores

Free shipping for US and Canada

One aspect that might give prospective customers pause is the free shipping policy. The Free Shipping promotion offered by HockeyShot applies to orders shipped to destinations within the 48 contiguous United States and the 10 provinces of Canada. According to the policy page, there is no cost minimum you have to hit before earning free shipping, so this means shipping has no cost for most orders from HockeyShot as long as you live in the specified areas.

Customers are concerned about delays

Unfortunately, concerns have been raised regarding the ordering process and customer experience at HockeyShot. Many customers have reported extended shipping delays, with orders taking an unusually long time to reach their destination. At third-party review sites, HockeyShot only has a 2.5-star average score. However, it is worth noting that HockeyShot has a better reputation with the Better Business Bureau. Their BBB profile features a high "A+" rating.

Only good for coaches

Considering the limitations in their inventory, it is likely that HockeyShot will find greater appeal among teams, coaches, and facility managers rather than individual players. The site's focus on providing training equipment and accessories aligns well with the needs of such entities. So, while HockeyShot offers a diverse range of training tools, its inventory may not adequately cater to individual hockey players seeking a comprehensive shopping experience. Considering some of their lower ratings with his drawback, HockeyShot isn't a top competitor for hockey equipment among those we evaluated. HockeyShot remains a viable option for those looking to acquire specialized training equipment or at-home skating rinks, but if you need the hockey basics, you'll have to shop somewhere else.

Academy Sports Review 1 Star Rating

Academy Sports

1 Star Rating
  • Prices range from $15.99 to $59.99
  • Offers a price match guarantee to reduce prices by 5%
  • Offers 60-day return policy

Established in 1938 in San Antonio, Texas, Academy Sports initially focused solely on tire sales. However, over the years, they diversified their offerings and ventured into the sporting goods and outdoor gear market. With a presence of over 250 brick-and-mortar stores scattered across the United States, Academy Sports enables customers to conveniently shop online and choose in-store pickup if they reside near one of their locations.

Limited stock for hockey

While Academy Sports' website is user-friendly and offers a decent navigation experience, the limited selection of hockey equipment poses a challenge. There were only 48 total hockey-related items at Academy Sports that were in stock at the time of this review. Further, the only filters for types of gear are hockey pucks, hockey sticks, hockey goals, and "accessories" , which can make it hard to find what you want if you're looking for skates or masks. Regrettably, this retailer falls short when it comes to catering to the needs of hockey players, as their inventory for the sport is quite sparse. Although Academy Sports excels in other sports categories, hockey enthusiasts may find it more beneficial to explore alternative options that provide a wider range of products.

Not enough items

In order to get a clear cost comparison at Academy Sports, it's important to look at their prices for a few different hockey items. While their stock is limited, we were able to find some of the items for comparison. At Academy Sports, we checked out hockey sticks, as there were no listings at all for hockey skates or hockey helmets/masks. At Academy Sports, the prices for hockey sticks range from $15.99 to $59.99 which is much more limited than other retailers. If you're looking for pro gear, you're not going to find it here. On top of that, you can't even get a full set of hockey items at Academy Sports, so you'll end up shopping at multiple places. The low prices don't seem worth it in our opinion.

Price match guarantee

A feature that stands out at Academy Sports is its price match guarantee. To qualify, the items must be in stock at the time of purchase, and products should be identical to the ones on the competitor's website. Lastly, the advertised price must be current and valid, not promoted by a third party, at the time of purchase. Academy Sports strives to provide unbeatable value by offering a 5% price reduction when customers meet these criteria.

Best Hockey Equipment Stores

60-day returns available

Another benefit is that Academy Sports does allow for exchanges and returns. Academy Sports provides refunds within a 60-day timeframe. Customers will receive cash refunds for purchases made with cash or check, credit back to their debit or credit card for card transactions, credit to their account for purchases made through Apple Pay, PayPal, or other authorized payment systems, and merchandise credit for gift card or merchandise credit card purchases, as well as for returns made without a receipt or packing slip. It is important to note that original purchase receipts are required for cash refunds.

Poor reputation and high concerns

A cause for concern is the warning provided on Academy Sports' Better Business Bureau (BBB) listing. Numerous disputes have prompted the BBB to issue a cautionary statement regarding their practices. According to the BBB post, consumers have alleged misleading and deceptive sales practices, including incidents where customers received used items instead of new ones. Additionally, the BBB has only awarded Academy Sports a rating of "C+" due to the complaints. Concerns have also been raised about negative customer service experiences and interactions with employees.

The cons outweigh the pros here

While perks like 60-day returns and a price match guarantee may seem great, the other factors involved with Academy Sports force us to strongly advise against investing time and effort into this retailer when you want to purchase hockey equipment. The combination of their limited product offerings in the hockey category and the concerning warnings from the BBB raises significant red flags. It may be better to explore other reputable stores that prioritize customer satisfaction and offer a wider range of hockey gear to start your online shopping off on the right foot.

Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

Hockey equipment holds a special place in the hearts of players and enthusiasts alike. If you're a newbie looking to dive into the game, finding an online store that's got everything you need in one spot can be a game-changer.

Online stores ensure that the equipment is well-packaged and delivered in a timely manner, allowing you to gear up for your next game without any worries. Furthermore, these stores often provide gift options, allowing you to surprise fellow hockey enthusiasts with top-quality equipment.

Hockey has gained immense popularity worldwide, captivating fans with its fast-paced action, physicality, and skillful play. It is a beloved sport that has a significant following, particularly in countries like Canada, the United States, Russia, and several European nations.

From professional leagues like the NHL to grassroots community teams, hockey has become deeply ingrained in the culture of many nations, bringing people together and creating unforgettable moments on the ice. The sport's popularity can be attributed to its rich history, thrilling rivalries, and the passion it evokes in both players and spectators.

With an abundance of online retailers for hockey equipment to choose from, it can feel like there are just too many good options out there to decide. If you're unsure where to begin, keep your cool. Here are some factors to consider to help you decide which online hockey equipment store is best for your needs:

  • Price. Cost is a crucial factor for many people when they are shopping for hockey equipment. Since hockey gear is generally considered high-end, its affordability plays a vital role in determining the quantity and frequency of enjoying the sport. It is important to consider your budget and additional expenses such as shipping or customization fees in order to identify the retailers that offer the most favorable prices for hockey equipment within your price range.
  • Variety. Are you looking for just some new hockey sticks? Or are you looking to gear up with all new equipment for the hockey season? Either way, you'll need to make sure that the retailer you go with offers the items you need.
  • Returns. Buying online can be uncertain, especially with gear that you need to fit you properly like hockey skates or helmets. Making sure that an online hockey equipment retailer has a friendly return policy can help make the process a little easier.
  • Customer satisfaction. Most of us aren't hockey pros or equipment experts, but regular customers have great insights into how a company operates. Checking out real customer reviews can help you figure out which companies actually deliver on their promises and put customer satisfaction first when it comes to hockey equipment.

To make your next skating sesh a breeze, Top Consumer Reviews has evaluated and rated the best options for buying hockey equipment on the market today. We hope this helps you take the stress out of shopping online and get back to doing what you really love: getting out on the rink with your friends!

The Best Hockey Equipment Stores Compare Hockey Equipment Stores Compare Hockey Equipment Store Reviews What are the best Hockey Equipment Stores Best Hockey Equipment Store Reviews

Hockey Equipment Store FAQ

While you can probably get away with just having skates and a stick when playing for fun at the neighborhood pond, you (or your child) will need a lot more than that if you're joining a hockey league. In addition to the skates and stick, you'll likely need to get a helmet, mouth guard, practice jersey and pants, shoulder-elbow-shin pads, gloves and socks, a jock (or "jill" for girls), and a bag to carry all of your gear.
You'll definitely want a water bottle and maybe some extra pucks to have on hand. Some additional accessories worth considering are skate guards, shin pad tape, stick tape and a stickhandling ball.
That depends on whether you're buying for an adult or a child, used or new, and so on. But, as a ballpark figure, expect to spend anywhere from $300 to $700 for a full set - though you could spend considerably more if you purchase higher-end gear.
That's easy: selection and price. Even if you live in an area where hockey is popular, there's no local store that can match the inventory you'll find online. Shopping online also lets you easily compare prices and get the best deals on your hockey equipment, without having to drive all over town to save a few dollars.
Most hockey equipment websites have helpful buying guides that explain how to take measurements and choose properly-sized skates and other gear. You can also reach out to the retailer's customer service team; they're usually happy to answer any questions you have and recommend equipment that's right for your player's needs.
Believe it or not, you can almost always get your hockey equipment delivered at no extra cost! Retailers frequently have free shipping if your order meets a minimum spend amount (like $75 or $100).
Yes, though return policies vary by retailer. You may only be able to get a refund if your hockey equipment is in unused condition, but a few stores will let you exchange used items within 30 days of purchase.
There are lots of good stores out there. Obviously, your first choice should be the site that has the gear you need! Starting your shopping at an internet retailer with a large inventory is always a good bet. From there, look for customer-friendly policies like price matching or a lengthy return period. Finally, see what other shoppers have said about their experience with the retailer, including the store's reputation with the Better Business Bureau.
The Best Reviews of Hockey Equipment Stores