Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

Guardian vs Control 4

Monday, April 15th

2024 Home Automation Company Reviews

Guardian Review 2.5 Star Rating


2.5 Star Rating
  • Pricing estimated around $129 to $1,249+
  • Monthly membership costs
  • Automation for lights, security, sound, TV, and cameras
  • App access to your entire home
  • Tailored to your home
  • Call for a quote
  • "A+" rating from the BBB

Guardian Security emphasizes comprehensive home security with automation features. Unfortunately, getting a quote requires a call, and customer reviews highlight issues like malfunctioning systems and poor customer service. With an "A+" BBB rating but widespread customer dissatisfaction, Guardian earns a lackluster rating in our review.

Control 4 Review 4 Star Rating

Control 4

4 Star Rating
  • Pricing from $3,000 to $20,000+
  • Automation for lights, security, sound, TV, and more
  • App access to your entire home
  • Tailored to your home
  • Call for a quote
  • Integrates with most technology
  • "A-" rating from the BBB

Control4 is a versatile home automation system offering flexibility in choosing smart home devices. You'll need to contact them for a personalized estimate, with costs ranging from $1,500 to over $10,000. While the system integrates well with existing technology, customer feedback is mixed. Altogether Control4 earns a solid rating in our review.

What's the Best Home Automation System?

Just a few years ago, the idea of home automation was a futuristic dream, a vision of Jetsons-style technology that promised to simplify every aspect of home life. Fast forward to today, and we're living in a future that even George Jetson would marvel at, thanks to the advancements in home automation technologies.

With smartphones, smart appliances, and smart lights, you can basically automate your entire living space. Whether you're looking for a small efficiency upgrade or to restructure your whole home into an automated utopia, there's an option out there for you. Modern home automation systems go beyond merely securing your home; they now encompass a wide array of functions, from ensuring your home's safety to providing entertainment - and much more in between.

The Best Home Automation Companies Compare Home Automation Companies Compare Home Automation Company Reviews What are the best Home Automation Companies Best Home Automation Company Reviews

Home Automation Company FAQ

Sometimes referred to as a "smart home" , home automation lets you operate your lighting, appliances, security equipment and more - usually through an app on your mobile phone or through an online dashboard. Want your home to be playing your favorite relaxation music and have the thermostat set to "just right" every day after work? Home automation can do that - and much, much more.
It's true that most systems start with security as the foundation. From security cameras to smoke detectors, "smart homes" can give you peace of mind knowing that it's all under control and professionally monitored, if you choose a company that offers that. But, as technology advances, more features are being added "for fun" , like controlling all of your audio and video or letting your kids turn off lights at bedtime with a simple verbal command.
You could pay as little as $20/month or as much as $10,000+ to set up a smart home with all of the bells and whistles. Obviously the more features you want, the more you'll have to pay for the equipment. Monthly monitoring fees (for systems that include security features) are rarely more than $60/month.
Yes. Check with the provider of your homeowner's insurance policy to see if you can get a discount for the home automation system you're installing. A "smart home" can also save you money in the cost of utilities through managing your use of electricity and water.
Most of the time, yes. That's the appeal of "smart home" equipment: being able to monitor and control it from your phone, tablet or computer.
Sometimes. This is more common if you have security features that are professionally monitored. Read the terms and conditions carefully to determine if you're obligated to keep the service for a set period of time, and what the penalties are for early cancellation.
Possibly. If you've got features that are hard-wired into your home, maybe not. However, most of today's home automation systems use equipment that is easy to install and take down on your own, letting you use it wherever you live. Just be sure to change your home address in your provider's system, to allow emergency services to be dispatched to the correct location (if you're using a service that includes security monitoring).
It might! Home automation is in high demand, so having a system already set up may make your property more appealing to prospective buyers. Consult your real estate agent, though: they may not recommend that you install a home automation system solely for the purpose of increasing your home's value.
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

A basic home automation setup typically includes features like a doorbell intercom and camera, smart lights, smart thermostats, motion detectors, sensors for doors and windows, as well as monitoring for smoke and carbon monoxide. For those with a more flexible budget, seeking a provider that integrates entertainment and environmental controls for television, music, lighting, and temperature is a wise move.

While a handful of providers offer do-it-yourself options, (and some of them even require coding knowledge for the very industrious DIYers) most home automation services are delivered through professional dealers. These experts conduct thorough assessments of your home's requirements, then proceed to design, build, and install a customized system.

A reputable professional home automation vendor usually responds within a week of your inquiry, providing a comprehensive price estimate. Many providers go the extra mile by visiting your home for a visual inspection and measurements for precision system installation.

The time required for installation and configuration can vary significantly. For straightforward systems, installation might take just a few days. On the other hand, more complex setups could extend to a month or more. It's essential to be aware that advanced systems might necessitate modifications to walls, floors, and ceilings to accommodate the mounting of equipment and wiring.

If you're feeling overwhelmed trying to figure out where to start, don't worry. When looking for home automation solutions, here are some factors to consider:

  • Features. Does the provider offer the features you're looking for to upgrade your home? Does it offer security or automated energy saving? Make sure that the parts of your life that matter the most are addressed by the home automation you choose.
  • Reputation. When you need help, will the company you choose have your back? What kind of reviews are out there for the home automation service you choose? See how other customers felt about their completed home project before you dive in.
  • Value. Pricing on home automation systems varies and can depend on factors like the size of your home or the cost of installation. But make sure that the features you get and the quotes you see match up. Don't overpay for a "luxury" upgrade until you see what they're offering for your personalized home automation.

To help you make your house your dream home, Top Consumer Reviews has reviewed and ranked the best Home Automation solutions available today. We hope to help you find the right home automation system so you can start enjoying your new futuristic home life that's even better than a sci-fi dream!

The Best Reviews of Home Automation Companies