Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

The Best Hot Sauce Clubs

Which Hot Sauce Club is the Best?

Thinking that a hot sauce is the perfect gift for a friend or the ultimate way to treat yourself? You're right. Most hot sauce clubs come with easy-breezy gift-giving features, from fun newsletters to jazz up the overall experience with serving suggestions and background info on the hot sauce makers, to hassle-free scheduling of a gift notification and the first delivery.

Hot sauce, a condiment with ancient roots, has evolved from being a simple addition to meals to becoming a beloved flavor enhancer that boasts a wide range of tastes and heat levels. Its history dates back to ancient civilizations like the Mayans and Aztecs, who used spicy concoctions to enhance their dishes and believed in the medicinal properties of chili peppers.

Sunday, April 21st

2024 Hot Sauce Club Reviews

Top Consumer Reviews Best-In-Class Blue Ribbon Award HEAT Hot Sauce Shop Review 5 Star Rating

HEAT Hot Sauce Shop

5 Star Rating
  • From $14.99 to $29.99 per month
  • Selection: Choose from Mild & Medium, Classic, or Extra Hot
  • Amount: 1 or 3 bottles
  • Duration: Month-to-month or prepay for a 3, 6, or 12-month plan
  • Frequency: Monthly or quarterly
  • Shipping: Free
  • Pay in full or pay as you go
  • Subscriber-only perks
Top Consumer Reviews Best-In-Class Blue Ribbon Award

At HEAT's Hot Sauce Shop, you get the whole package: top-notch hot sauce, options tailored to your preferences, competitive prices, and, above all, a strong dedication to the love of spice. The shop's journey started over 10 years ago with a young California couple's passion for flavorful and spicy foods, which quickly transformed into a successful business with a solid reputation. HEAT takes pride in connecting small-batch artisanal sauces with consumers who might not have easy access otherwise.

3 heat levels to choose from

This hot sauce club gets lots of kudos from us for providing options for every aficionado of the heat. Maybe you're all about the taste and not so much about the burn? The Mild & Medium Club is for you, with mellow sauces focused on flavor. Prefer a range from mild to wild? HEAT Hot Sauce's Classic subscription will be just the thing. And, if you're among what they call "diehard chileheads" , don't miss the Extra Hot membership. Across all heat levels, this company goes the extra mile to let you taste exciting new hot sauces before they're available to the general public.

Broad range of brands

What are some of the flavors you might see with your membership here? Past boxes have included tasty hot sauces like Bobby T's Original Bonita Sauce, Newks, The Subtle Tease, Black Bison, Volcanic Peppers Spicy Ponzu, Torchedstone Thai XXX Hot, and Karma Sauce's Cherry Bomb, to name a few. You might even see particular brands from other hot sauce clubs on our list, like Mikey V's.

Best Hot Sauce Clubs

1 or 3 bottles, plus shipping is always free

All clubs let you choose between one bottle ($14.99 for Mild/Medium and Classic, $16.99 for Extra Hot) and three bottles ($29.99 and $35.99, respectively) per delivery. You can also opt to have your deliveries come quarterly if you'd rather spread out your incoming hot sauces a little more. You'll pay the same whether you go month-to-month or you prepay for a term of 3, 6, or 12 months, and shipping is always included in the price.

Great to give as a gift

If you're giving HEAT's hot sauce subscription as a gift, make sure to check the little box during the ordering process. You'll be able to enter their name and email address along with your personalized gift message; just be aware that the FAQ says that your message won't be sent automatically unless you tell them to (so as to not spoil the surprise).

Member perks

Your subscription to HEAT Hot Sauce Shop's monthly box comes with other perks too. Every box comes with pairing tips and tasting notes, and if you find something you really like and want to buy more a la carte, you'll get free shipping.

Best Hot Sauce Clubs

Devoted customer following

And, there's no shortage of love for the 600+ hot sauces in HEAT's inventory or their direct-to-you subscriptions, either. The company has gained lots of loyal followers over the last decade, with people saying that they've never gotten a sauce they didn't like. Pro tip: if you're getting the Extra Hot subscription, customers recommend trying one bottle at a time or getting three bottles quarterly - because they're not messing around with just how hot these sauces are, and you might not go through it as quickly as you're thinking.

Best all-around hot sauce club

With HEAT, you're in for an unbeatable hot sauce subscription. The prices are fantastic, you get the most choices of any club we've found, and you're sure to love each hot sauce they carefully curate in each box. We're so happy to see how this company has continued to thrive and amaze as they've evolved into the #1 hot sauce club on the market.

Amazing Clubs Review 4.5 Star Rating

Amazing Clubs

4.5 Star Rating
  • From $25.95 to $27.95 per month, depending on club length
  • Selection: Sauces chosen for you each month
  • Amount: 2 bottles
  • Duration: 3, 4, 6, or 12 months
  • Frequency: Monthly or every other month
  • Shipping: Free
  • Pay in full or pay as you go
  • "A+" rated by the BBB
  • Millions of happy customers
  • Fantastic satisfaction guarantee

If you're on the lookout for a trustworthy hot sauce subscription that caters to both newcomers and enthusiasts, you've hit the jackpot with Amazing Clubs. With a track record dating back to 2003, this company offers a reliable and well-regarded experience that you can count on. In fact, the Wall Street Journal recognized them as a top hot sauce subscription provider for seven consecutive years. When you opt for Amazing Clubs, you're guaranteed access to gourmet products sourced from small-batch, specialty boutiques - a testament to their commitment to quality.

Sneak preview before each delivery

Every month, you'll receive a delightful package from Amazing Clubs containing two distinct and new hot sauce bottles. You'll always know what you're getting in advance - they'll send you an email a couple of weeks before each delivery, and you can always skip a month if there's a combo you'd rather not get (or if you're going to be out of town). Curious about what Amazing Clubs has offered before? Take a peek at the Previous Selections tab on the Hot Sauce Club page; some examples are Cherry Bomb Hot Sauce by Bushel & Peck, Reaper of Sorrow Hot Sauce by Born to Hula, and Chesapeake Ghost Pepper Sauce by Eagle Wings.

Best choice for gift-giving

As a fun bonus, each shipment includes the Hot Sauce Lover's Newsletter, which offers an array of entertaining facts, handy tips, and valuable tricks to elevate your hot sauce experience. That's just part of what makes Amazing Clubs genuinely, well, amazing, for gift-giving: not only will your lucky person get a fun club, but it's really easy for you to surprise them. You can choose to send an email notification on the date of your choice, print out or email an announcement yourself, or even have something sent via USPS - all included in your subscription. And it's no problem to schedule your club way in advance, if you know you're the forgetful type and want to make sure you don't miss that special occasion.

Best Hot Sauce Clubs

Unbeatable satisfaction guarantee

The icing on the cake is their "They'll Love It!" guarantee. Across all of the clubs we've given and received via Amazing Clubs, there have only been a handful of times something has gone wrong - melted chocolates, wilted flowers, and so on - and each time the company has bent over backwards to make it right. You'll always get a no-questions-asked offer of a refund or replacement. And, since this company has so many different kinds of clubs, you can even ask for a substitute club shipment instead.

Prices have gone up but it's still affordable

So, what will your hot sauce club cost here? Prices have gone up since our last review (but what hasn't?!), but they're still a decently-affordable $25.95 to $27.95, depending on how you set up your subscription. Options include clubs that last 3, 4 (seasonal), 6, or 12 months, and you can even opt to space those deliveries out to every other month. Good news: shipping is included with your price, as long as the hot sauce is being sent within the continental US.

Everyone loves this hot sauce club

And, customers have nothing but good things to say about the hot sauce club at Amazing Clubs. Across more than 600 reviews, this subscription has an impressive average of 4.6 out of 5 stars. People describe it as "their favorite gift, ever" , "best hot sauces I've ever had" , and "great variety" . You won't be disappointed.

Best Hot Sauce Clubs

Lack of customization is the only downside

But, we can't quite put Amazing Clubs at the very top of our list. Why? Simply put, there are competitors who give their customers just a little bit more say-so: maybe you only want one bottle per month, or you want to be able to specify just how fiery you want your sauces to be. The fact is, you just can't do that here. It's not a huge downside when you consider all the benefits, but it's still a valid point.

Excellent option among hot sauce clubs

Across the board, we love Amazing Clubs, and we have no problem recommending this hot sauce club. It's perfect to give as a gift (or to keep for yourself) and we've never seen a company more on point with customer service. However, if you want a subscription with more (or less) hot sauce each month, or you know you only want the truly spicy stuff (or you'd rather walk on the "mild side" ), check out some of the other clubs on our list too.

Fuego Box Review 4 Star Rating

Fuego Box

4 Star Rating
  • From $12.95 to $29.95 per month, depending on number of bottles
  • Selection: Choose between mild-to-hot or extra hot plans
  • Amount: 1-3 bottles
  • Duration: Month-to-month, or prepay for 6 or 12 months
  • Frequency: Monthly or every 90 days
  • Shipping: $5 per box
  • Pay in full (and get a discount) or pay as you go

The story behind Fuego Box is pretty relatable: the creator says he "went down the hot sauce rabbit hole" , starting with lightweights like Cholula and Sriracha and then disappearing into a world of bhut jolokia and African fatalii peppers. This hot sauce club prioritizes discovering emerging flavors and bringing them right to your doorstep.

Choose among 3 subscriptions

Fuego Box offers you three hot sauce clubs to pick from. The entry-level plan is called "Dip Your Toe In" : you'll get one bottle each month, with heat levels ranging from mild to hot. But, if you know you and yours go through a ton of hot sauce, consider the Sauce Lover subscription - because you'll get three bottles instead of just one. And, for anyone who says, "bring it on" , the Pain Seeker hot sauce club comes with two bottles of extra-hot flavors.

Several price points and delivery frequencies

What will it cost? You'll pay $12.95 + $5 shipping for the one-bottle plan, $28.95 + $5 shipping for two, and $29.95 + $5 shipping for three. The one-bottle plan can only be set up to come every 30 days, while the other two also give you the option for delivery every 90 days.

Best Hot Sauce Clubs

Prepaid plans also available

You can set your hot sauce club up in several additional ways with Fuego Box. Maybe you'd rather just have a simple monthly delivery that keeps the heat coming until you say "no mas" . Or, you can get a discount by prepaying for a 6- or 12-month plan, bringing your cost per month down by $1 or $2 (respectively). Those prepaid hot sauce club options also come with a free hot sauce tasting booklet.

Look for pop-up savings

When you visit the Fuego Box site, keep an eye for a pop-up discount. At the time of our review, we got $10 off our first subscription box by entering our email. Later as we browsed, we got another offer of 10% off our subscription: either way, it's nice to save some money.

Gift-giving features are on point

Giving a Fuego Box subscription as a gift is absolutely hassle-free. It's easiest if you go to the Hot Sauce Gifts section of the website, and choose "subscriptions" from there, rather than going through the main club page. Once you've selected the gift club you want to send, you can opt to ship it as soon as possible with a personalized gift note, or you can have an email sent on the date you prefer: they'll get your message and a link to claim their hot sauce gift whenever they're ready.

Best Hot Sauce Clubs

Check out the shop for a flavor preview

While you won't know what you're getting in advance, you can browse the Fuego Box Hot Sauce Shop to get an idea of what's typically on offer here. Many of the sauces have reviews, and a few even come with a video describing the overall experience.

Service might be slow during peak periods

The only downside is that the customer service with Fuego Box can be a little iffy, especially around the holidays. There's a pretty small team behind the fulfillment of orders here, and sometimes customers say that translates to slow responses and delayed deliveries. It's not a reason to avoid this hot sauce club, but it does keep it from earning our highest score.

A hot sauce wonderland

All in all, Fuego Box offers everything you could want in a hot sauce club: multiple ways to set up a subscription, different quantities and heat levels on offer, and ample gift-giving options. Give it a look if you're ready to take your own trip down the "hot sauce rabbit hole" - without all the work.

Heatonist Review 4 Star Rating

Heatonist

4 Star Rating
  • Priced at $30 per month + shipping
  • Selection: Sauces chosen for you each month
  • Amount: 3 bottles
  • Duration: Month-to-month, or prepay for 3, 6, or 12 months
  • Frequency: Monthly
  • Shipping: $6 per delivery
  • Pay as you go or pay in full
  • Skip a month or cancel anytime

Heatonist's Hot Ones hot sauce club is based on the YouTube talk show hosted by Sean Evans. All of the flavors in these monthly boxes have either been featured on the show or they're favorites of the people at Hot Ones - so you're surprised every month. Time your subscription just right, and you may even have your box on hand when those specific flavors are featured on the show's lineup.

3 bottles + fun extras

Every delivery in the Hot Ones subscription comes with three full-sized bottles of hot sauce, typically in a range of heat levels. You'll get the first taste of any new Hot Ones sauces, rewards points that can be used towards a la carte purchases, and even some limited Hot Ones stickers you can use to give your water bottle or laptop a visual upgrade.

Easy to set up your subscription

You don't have to put a lot of thought into setting up the Hot Ones hot sauce club at Heatonist. You've got options to set it up as a month-to-month plan or pay for a 3, 6, or 12 month subscription - but it's the same $30 per month price no matter how you slice it. Shipping costs $6 per shipment, so don't forget to factor that into what you're budgeting.

Skip or cancel anytime

Need to skip a month? Or cancel? No problem. This hot sauce club lets you do that anytime; just sign into your customer dashboard and make any changes you need.

Best Hot Sauce Clubs

Giftable but not many bells and whistles

You can definitely send this hot sauce club as a gift. Just don't expect to see any gift-giving features as you go through the checkout process. There isn't even a spot to enter a personalized message. No matter when you place your order, it'll ship out around the middle of the month, so plan on letting your recipient know when to expect their first delivery.

Hot sauce club with lots of fans

Where Heatonist's hot sauce club really shines is its reputation. There are nearly 300 customer reviews averaging an impressive 4.7 out of 5 stars. Happy subscribers love being able to try out hot sauces right along with their favorite YouTube show, and even the ones who have no idea that there even IS a show think that the flavors in this subscription are perfectly varied and consistently delicious. We encourage you to scroll through the reviews yourself, to see customer photos and get a sneak peek at what the boxes look like.

Great club if you want a pantry full of hot sauces

We're happy to add Hot Ones by Heatonist to our list of recommended hot sauce clubs. You'd better be a true aficionado, since you're going to be getting three bottles each month, but you can always pause your deliveries if your collection gets bigger than you'd like. But can you ever really have too much hot sauce? Heatonist would say no. This is a great choice as a hot sauce club for the most devoted fans of all things spicy.

Gindo's Review 3.5 Star Rating

Gindo's

3.5 Star Rating
  • Priced at $15.95 or $39.95/month
  • Selection: Sauces chosen for you each month
  • Amount: 1 or 2 bottles
  • Duration: 3, 6, or 12 months, or month-to-month
  • Frequency: Monthly, every other month, or every third month
  • Shipping: Free
  • Pay in full (comes with a discount) or pay as-you-go

Based in the Chicagoland area, Gindo's is a family-owned business that has crafted over 500 hot sauce flavors since 2011. Their hot sauces are used a little differently from the norm: these are meant to be "poured over, under, and in food to make any ordinary dish extraordinary" , and the company is proud of the fact that many foodies and top chefs have used their sauces to make award-winning dishes.

Most hot sauces made in-house

What flavors can you expect with this hot sauce club? Gindo's tells you exactly what to expect; for example, during the month of our evaluation, in the 1-bottle box customers received Wild Berry Chipotle, and the 3-bottle box came with that flavor along with Artichoke Pesto and Sauteed Wild Mushroom. Most of the hot sauces you'll get in this club have been made specifically at Gindo's, but they occasionally supplement with bottles from other local partners.

Several different ways to structure your subscription

You've got several options for setting up your membership here. The easiest plan is just to set it and forget it with a recurring monthly delivery. You'll pay $15.95/month for one bottle and $39.95/month for three bottles. Or, if you'd like to save a little cash, prepaying for a 3-month subscription comes with a 5% discount, a 6-month plan saves you 10%, and subscribing for a full year is discounted by 15%. And, you can decide if you'd like your sauces to come every month, every other month, or quarterly. No matter which way you go, shipping is always included in the price of your Gindo's hot sauce club.

Best Hot Sauce Clubs

Not a lot of gifting features

Giving a subscription as a gift? You can enter a gift note when you add the hot sauce club to your cart. That's about the extent of the bells-and-whistles here, though. You don't have an option to have a gift message sent via email or to print one out through the website, and it doesn't seem like there's any kind of fun newsletter or anything else to make this club sparkle a little bit as a gift-giving option.

People rave about the sauces and the club

But, you could just take it as the hot sauces speak for themselves - or, at least, the people who have tried them do. Check out some of the flavors in the a la carte store - like Vampire Slayer, Honey Habanero, or Truffle Parmesan - and you'll see nothing but love. And, pretty much every subscriber who took the time to leave a review for Gindo's hot sauce clubs offered a five-star rating: excellent customer service, fantastic experience trying new flavors, you get the idea.

Above average among hot sauce subscriptions

Gindo's hot sauce club is better than average. There are some novel flavors coming from their kitchen, and we love that. We also appreciate the various ways the subscriptions can be set up, and that the club is priced competitively with others on our list. While it doesn't have the same kind of variety as we find in rival clubs that source their hot sauces from around the nation (or even the world), Gindo's could be a worthy addition to your collection.

Hot Sauce Lover Review 3 Star Rating

Hot Sauce Lover

3 Star Rating
  • Priced at $7.95 per month
  • Selection: Choose between mild/medium or hot/extremely hot sauces
  • Amount: 1 bottle per month
  • Duration: Month-to-month
  • Frequency: Monthly, every other month, or quarterly
  • Shipping: $8 per delivery
  • Satisfaction guaranteed

Hot Sauce Lover, formerly known as Doc Hotties, takes great pride in sourcing hot sauces from around the world. The owners travel the globe to bring great flavors to you, from food trucks in California to family restaurants in Jamaica and Antigua.

Hot or not?

Hot Sauce Lover has two clubs to choose from: mild and medium or hot and extremely hot. Either way, you'll get one bottle per month, though you can also set up your subscription to be delivered every other month or quarterly. You won't know what you're getting in advance, but all it takes is a look through the store's a la carte shop to get an idea of what hot sauces might be in your box: Dave's Gourmet Scorpion Pepper, Karma Sauce Burn After Eating, and Lottie's Original Barbados are just a few of the ones we spotted.

Cheap subscription but spendy shipping

You'll pay $7.95 for either hot sauce club from Hot Sauce Lover - but that doesn't include the shipping fees. That actually costs more than the sauce itself. In total, your monthly cost for this hot sauce club comes in at just under $16: not terrible, but not quite competitive with some clubs that give you two bottles for just a little more. And, FYI, there are no long-term commitments here either, so you'll just pay month to month.

Best Hot Sauce Clubs

Gift-giving features are lacking

Hot Sauce Lover doesn't come with any features for giving the club as a gift, either. Aside from entering one address for billing and another for shipping, we couldn't find anything specific to gifting: no option to designate it as a gift, no spot to enter a personalized message, nada.

Solid feedback from customers

On the other hand, we were pleased to spot some really recent feedback specific to the hot sauce clubs here. Almost everyone gives the subscription a perfect five-star score, saying that the sauces are flavorful and deliver the perfect level of heat (corresponding to what they selected when setting up their membership). One person wasn't thrilled with getting two "dessert" hot sauces back to back, but other than that this club seems to be a winner.

Good but not yet great

Looking at all of the hot sauce clubs available today, Hot Sauce Lover's are decidedly average. It's nice to have the ability to choose a heat level, but the company is missing a lot of features commonly found among its rivals (like being able to set a specific subscription length instead of just month-to-month, or easy options to give it as a gift). There's nothing bad about this hot sauce club, but we'd suggest browsing its higher-ranking competitors first.

Month Club Store Review 2.5 Star Rating

Month Club Store

2.5 Star Rating
  • Starting at $42.99 for a 3-month plan with one bottle
  • Selection: Sauces chosen for you each month
  • Amount: 1 or 2 bottles
  • Duration: 3, 6, 9, or 12 months
  • Frequency: Monthly, every other month, every third month, or every fourth month
  • Shipping: Free
  • Pay in full
  • "A+" rated by the BBB
  • Satisfaction guaranteed

Month Club Store has been in business for over a decade, as a part of the Food E (get it? Foodie?) Concepts brand family. The company has an "A+" rating from the Better Business Bureau, and there's only been one complaint registered there in the last three years.

Seriously lacking in details

That's a good sign, but it's not enough to move the needle for this company's hot sauce club. It's one of the most nondescript options we've found: instead of telling you what you can expect, where they source their sauces, or any of the other kinds of details that would make a customer say, "sign me up!" , Month Club Store relies on a grainy image of sauces that went out in boxes at some unspecified time in the past. Not just that, but this company doesn't give you any idea what people have thought about those hot sauces. Huge hit or big bummer? It's anyone's guess.

Ho-hum for gift-giving

Even the gift-giving features are boring at Month Club Store. You can enter an email greeting to be sent for free, or you can pay $0.49 for a greeting card to be sent directly to you or to your recipient. That's about it.

Best Hot Sauce Clubs

Multiple ways to set up your membership

About the only thing we can find to get excited about is the numerous configuration options when setting up a hot sauce membership here. You can choose between one or two bottles in every delivery, set a start month anytime between now and almost a year out, and even separate your shipments by up to four months. The hot sauce club requires you to choose an initial subscription duration - 3, 6, 9, or 12 months - so your cost will range from $42.99 (one bottle a month for three months) to $199.99 (two bottles a month for a year).

Not enough information to earn a recommendation

While we appreciate that this hot sauce club comes with a 100% guarantee, and because of the grade with the BBB we're pretty sure that Month Club Store has no problem honoring that, we're not actually sure that people are rushing to hit the "order now" button here. If they want customers to be convinced that this is the "perfect gift for the hot sauce lover" , they're going to have to put some effort into revealing the details. Until then, Month Club Store's hot sauce club will continue to earn a below-average rating from us.

Puckerbutt Pepper Company Review 2.5 Star Rating

Puckerbutt Pepper Company

2.5 Star Rating
  • Priced at $10 + shipping for month-to-month or $109.99 + shipping for 1-year subscription
  • Selection: Sauces chosen for you each month
  • Amount: 1 bottle
  • Duration: Ongoing or 12 months
  • Frequency: Monthly
  • Shipping: Not included
  • Pay in full or month-to-month
  • Satisfaction guaranteed

Puckerbutt Pepper Company is the creation of "Smokin'" Ed Currie, a breeder of chili peppers who holds the Guinness World Record for growing the hottest chili pepper in the world - not once but twice. Have some fun going through the videos and links on the company website: see Rhett and Link or Chili Klaus eat one of Smokin' Ed's Carolina Reapers, or read what The New Yorker had to say about the record-holding heat of the peppers used to make the hot sauces here.

One bottle each month

The hot sauce club offered by Puckerbutt Pepper Company is a little light on details. You'll get one bottle every month - not necessarily just from Smokin' Ed's own kitchen, but maybe one that he's found and is excited about - along with a note describing the hot sauce and why he finds it interesting. And, if you're a big fan of what this company makes on its own, subscribers to the hot sauce club here will get early access to anything new coming from the kitchen.

Month-to-month or year-long subscription

You've got two options for setting up your hot sauce subscription at Puckerbutt Pepper Company: either pay $10 for a month-to-month recurring plan, or pay $109.99 for a year-long membership. Shipping isn't included in the cost of the hot sauce club, but it's not that expensive either: when we added the 12-month subscription to our cart, we were only charged $6.07 for the entire plan, not per month. On the other hand, the month-to-month plan came with a fee of $4.81 per month for shipping, bringing the total price to $14.81 for one bottle of hot sauce. That's not too far off from most rival hot sauce clubs on our list.

Best Hot Sauce Clubs

Zero gift-giving tools

While you can definitely give the Puckerbutt Pepper Company's hot sauce clubs as a gift, there's nothing that makes it stand out. Other than entering a different address for shipping and billing, the store doesn't offer the ability to designate the subscription as something being gifted: no note, no scheduling in advance for a special occasion, and so on.

Club would benefit from customer reviews

This company has a solid reputation overall, with an "A+" from the Better Business Bureau, positive feedback for its in-person locations, and a decent number of reviews on individual hot sauces in the online store. But, there's no place for hot sauce club subscribers to leave any feedback, making it a challenge to determine if this club is a winner or yet another wannabe.

Room to improve

If you like supporting small businesses and you don't mind taking a chance on a lesser-known hot sauce club, Puckerbutt Pepper Company might be worth a look. But, for us, it just doesn't come with anything that catches our attention. We'd be happy to bump up this store's rating in the future once more details about the included hot sauces are provided (or even some ratings for the club itself), but for now it ranks low on our list.

Mikey V's Review 2 Star Rating

Mikey V's

2 Star Rating
  • From $16.99 to $34.99 per month
  • Selection: Choose between mixed heat and extra-hot sauces
  • Amount: 1, 2, or 3 bottles
  • Duration: Month-to-month or one year
  • Frequency: Monthly
  • Shipping: Free
  • Pay in full or month-to-month
  • 1-year subscription comes with a free t-shirt

"Veteran-owned and Texas proud" describes the team behind Mikey V's, one of the newest hot sauce clubs on our list. In business since 2015, Mikey V's is the passion project of Michael Valencia, a self-taught chef who's enthusiastic about creating hot sauces, salsas, and other food. His hot sauces have won over 100 recognitions, including the top 3 of the Scoville Award for 7 consecutive years.

3 clubs on offer

Mikey V's has a nice variety of hot sauce clubs to choose from. You could start with a basic one-bottle-per-month plan, priced at $16.99 (and shipping is included). Your deliveries will feature a range of flavors and heat levels, either from the Mikey V's brand or another craft-made hot sauce. If you know you want every delivery to pack maximum heat, go for the Extra Hot Box: it comes with two bottles per month, extra hot only, priced at $33.99. And, for those who go through hot sauce like it's water, the 3-bottle plan is affordably-priced at $34.99 per month.

Reach out for a year-long plan with free t-shirt

Mikey V's website also mentions that you can get a free t-shirt with a one-year subscription. You'll have to send them a message to initiate that hot sauce club, because it's not listed among the clubs you can sign up for directly.

You'll have to make an account

One aspect of this club that we found, well, annoying? You have to create an account and confirm your email before you can get more details about the hot sauce club: you'll see that once you click on "get started" . Wondering what subscription terms are available? Want to know if you can set it up as a gift? You guessed it: it requires a confirmed account first. That feels like a sneaky way to get people's email addresses even if they don't go through with their purchase.

Best Hot Sauce Clubs

Payments limited to PayPal

It doesn't get better from there: when you go ahead and create that account, it'll ask you to pay via PayPal"and it still doesn't tell you what you're getting, where you're sending the hot sauce club, and so on. And if you don't want to pay with PayPal? Looks like you're out of luck here.

Still in business but not many hot sauce club reviews

The company is definitely still up and running: you can see lots of posts through their social media channels, despite the website having a copyright date of several years ago. Most of the customer reviews focus on the taco shop, though, and not necessarily on the hot sauce club or the sauces themselves.

Too much hassle involved

But, frankly, it feels like once Mikey V's opened their taco joint in 2022, that's where their attention went - and not to their online storefront or their hot sauce club in particular. The flavors you could get through this club might be amazing, but you're going to have to endure a subpar purchasing experience just to get there. And, requiring customers to pay via PayPal isn't exactly ideal. All of this combines to earn Mikey V's hot sauce club one of the lowest rankings on our list: simply put, there are better options out there than are much more customer-centric (and easier to set up).

Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

Today, hot sauce has transcended cultural boundaries and has become a staple in kitchens around the world, inspiring a vibrant subculture of hot sauce enthusiasts. Hot sauce owes its popularity to the complex interplay between its primary ingredients: chili peppers, vinegar, salt, and various spices.

The Scoville Heat Scale measures the spiciness of peppers, making it possible to create sauces with different levels of heat, from mild to mouth-numbingly intense. Hot sauce not only tantalizes taste buds but also triggers the release of endorphins, leading to a pleasurable sensory experience akin to a culinary adventure.

But not everyone is fortunate enough to have a variety of hot sauce flavors on their local supermarket shelves. Not to worry. Hot sauce clubs have emerged as a unique way for enthusiasts to explore new and exciting flavors on a regular basis. These clubs offer subscription-based plans that deliver carefully curated selections of hot sauces to members' doorsteps.

Now, the fun part: choosing which hot sauce club to get into. You've got lots of options out there, so how can you decide which one gets your subscription? Here are a few ways to compare the hot sauce plans you're considering:

  • Variety. Hot sauce clubs offer a diverse selection of sauces ranging in heat levels, ingredients, and flavor profiles. Some clubs focus on local artisanal brands, while others span global hot sauce producers, giving you access to a wider range of tastes and sensations.
  • Cost. The cost of hot sauce club memberships varies based on factors such as the number of bottles per shipment, the frequency of deliveries, and the exclusivity of the sauces included. Check to see if shipping is included in what you're paying too.
  • Flexibility. The best hot sauce clubs offer flexible subscription options, letting you adjust delivery frequencies, skip shipments, or pause memberships when needed.
  • Satisfaction guarantee. Every so often, you might get a hot sauce that just doesn't work for you. Or maybe it arrives in less-than-perfect condition. Can you get a no-fuss refund or replacement?
  • Reputation. What do other hot sauce fanatics say about their experience with the club? Do they say it's a good value with plenty of new flavors to try? Has the company been favorably rated by the Better Business Bureau?

Hot sauce clubs offer a dynamic way to explore a vast landscape of fiery flavors, and the experts at Top Consumer Reviews have researched and ranked today's most popular subscriptions. Celebrate your love of spicy foods with a red-hot and fun monthly delivery of hot sauce!

The Best Hot Sauce Clubs Compare Hot Sauce Clubs Compare Hot Sauce Club Reviews What are the best Hot Sauce Clubs Best Hot Sauce Club Reviews

Hot Sauce Club FAQ

All over the world! Hot sauce clubs provide sizzling flavors usually produced in small batches by artisans from Texas to Tijuana. You won't be able to find these unique hot sauces in any grocery store near you.
Most hot sauce clubs offer flexible plans. You can get a package every month to every three months, and your plan can range from a one-off delivery to monthly shipments for a full year.
No. You'll usually pay between $14-$20 per month. Hot sauce clubs generally include one full-size bottle in each delivery, but some give you two bottles for just a little extra cash.
Shipping costs are often included with your subscription price. Check the details of the hot sauce club you're considering to be sure.
Nearly always. These hot sauce clubs want you to love their products - and to tell others about them! - so they put a lot of effort into curating a killer selection every month. If something isn't quite right - your bottle leaked, the flavor is off, and so on - you can usually get a refund or replacement just by contacting their customer service team.
While you typically can't select the individual products that go into your hot sauce club packages, most plans let you indicate a preferred heat level of mild, medium or hot. That selection will apply to all of the deliveries in your membership term; however, some clubs give you a "surprise me" option where your heat level can vary from month to month.
Most hot sauce clubs include a fun newsletter with each delivery, detailing the origin of the sauce, making recipe suggestions, and maybe even a joke or two. A few memberships throw in some tasty extras from time to time, like a spicy snack or a meat rub.
Definitely! Some providers make it easy to give a hot sauce club as a gift, with emailed announcements and/or handwritten notes included in the first delivery. And, if you're lucky recipient absolutely loves one of the hot sauces they get, it may be possible to order more a la carte directly from the retailer.
The Best Reviews of Hot Sauce Clubs