Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

Puckerbutt Pepper Company Review

Sunday, March 3rd

2024 Hot Sauce Club Reviews

Puckerbutt Pepper Company Review 2.5 Star Rating

Puckerbutt Pepper Company

2.5 Star Rating
  • Priced at $10 + shipping for month-to-month or $109.99 + shipping for 1-year subscription
  • Selection: Sauces chosen for you each month
  • Amount: 1 bottle
  • Duration: Ongoing or 12 months
  • Frequency: Monthly
  • Shipping: Not included
  • Pay in full or month-to-month
  • Satisfaction guaranteed

Puckerbutt Pepper Company is the creation of "Smokin'" Ed Currie, a breeder of chili peppers who holds the Guinness World Record for growing the hottest chili pepper in the world - not once but twice. Have some fun going through the videos and links on the company website: see Rhett and Link or Chili Klaus eat one of Smokin' Ed's Carolina Reapers, or read what The New Yorker had to say about the record-holding heat of the peppers used to make the hot sauces here.

One bottle each month

The hot sauce club offered by Puckerbutt Pepper Company is a little light on details. You'll get one bottle every month - not necessarily just from Smokin' Ed's own kitchen, but maybe one that he's found and is excited about - along with a note describing the hot sauce and why he finds it interesting. And, if you're a big fan of what this company makes on its own, subscribers to the hot sauce club here will get early access to anything new coming from the kitchen.

Month-to-month or year-long subscription

You've got two options for setting up your hot sauce subscription at Puckerbutt Pepper Company: either pay $10 for a month-to-month recurring plan, or pay $109.99 for a year-long membership. Shipping isn't included in the cost of the hot sauce club, but it's not that expensive either: when we added the 12-month subscription to our cart, we were only charged $6.07 for the entire plan, not per month. On the other hand, the month-to-month plan came with a fee of $4.81 per month for shipping, bringing the total price to $14.81 for one bottle of hot sauce. That's not too far off from most rival hot sauce clubs on our list.

Best Hot Sauce Clubs

Zero gift-giving tools

While you can definitely give the Puckerbutt Pepper Company's hot sauce clubs as a gift, there's nothing that makes it stand out. Other than entering a different address for shipping and billing, the store doesn't offer the ability to designate the subscription as something being gifted: no note, no scheduling in advance for a special occasion, and so on.

Club would benefit from customer reviews

This company has a solid reputation overall, with an "A+" from the Better Business Bureau, positive feedback for its in-person locations, and a decent number of reviews on individual hot sauces in the online store. But, there's no place for hot sauce club subscribers to leave any feedback, making it a challenge to determine if this club is a winner or yet another wannabe.

Room to improve

If you like supporting small businesses and you don't mind taking a chance on a lesser-known hot sauce club, Puckerbutt Pepper Company might be worth a look. But, for us, it just doesn't come with anything that catches our attention. We'd be happy to bump up this store's rating in the future once more details about the included hot sauces are provided (or even some ratings for the club itself), but for now it ranks low on our list.

Which Hot Sauce Club is the Best?

Thinking that a hot sauce is the perfect gift for a friend or the ultimate way to treat yourself? You're right. Most hot sauce clubs come with easy-breezy gift-giving features, from fun newsletters to jazz up the overall experience with serving suggestions and background info on the hot sauce makers, to hassle-free scheduling of a gift notification and the first delivery.

Hot sauce, a condiment with ancient roots, has evolved from being a simple addition to meals to becoming a beloved flavor enhancer that boasts a wide range of tastes and heat levels. Its history dates back to ancient civilizations like the Mayans and Aztecs, who used spicy concoctions to enhance their dishes and believed in the medicinal properties of chili peppers.

The Best Hot Sauce Clubs Compare Hot Sauce Clubs Compare Hot Sauce Club Reviews What are the best Hot Sauce Clubs Best Hot Sauce Club Reviews

Hot Sauce Club FAQ

All over the world! Hot sauce clubs provide sizzling flavors usually produced in small batches by artisans from Texas to Tijuana. You won't be able to find these unique hot sauces in any grocery store near you.
Most hot sauce clubs offer flexible plans. You can get a package every month to every three months, and your plan can range from a one-off delivery to monthly shipments for a full year.
No. You'll usually pay between $14-$20 per month. Hot sauce clubs generally include one full-size bottle in each delivery, but some give you two bottles for just a little extra cash.
Shipping costs are often included with your subscription price. Check the details of the hot sauce club you're considering to be sure.
Nearly always. These hot sauce clubs want you to love their products - and to tell others about them! - so they put a lot of effort into curating a killer selection every month. If something isn't quite right - your bottle leaked, the flavor is off, and so on - you can usually get a refund or replacement just by contacting their customer service team.
While you typically can't select the individual products that go into your hot sauce club packages, most plans let you indicate a preferred heat level of mild, medium or hot. That selection will apply to all of the deliveries in your membership term; however, some clubs give you a "surprise me" option where your heat level can vary from month to month.
Most hot sauce clubs include a fun newsletter with each delivery, detailing the origin of the sauce, making recipe suggestions, and maybe even a joke or two. A few memberships throw in some tasty extras from time to time, like a spicy snack or a meat rub.
Definitely! Some providers make it easy to give a hot sauce club as a gift, with emailed announcements and/or handwritten notes included in the first delivery. And, if you're lucky recipient absolutely loves one of the hot sauces they get, it may be possible to order more a la carte directly from the retailer.
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

Today, hot sauce has transcended cultural boundaries and has become a staple in kitchens around the world, inspiring a vibrant subculture of hot sauce enthusiasts. Hot sauce owes its popularity to the complex interplay between its primary ingredients: chili peppers, vinegar, salt, and various spices.

The Scoville Heat Scale measures the spiciness of peppers, making it possible to create sauces with different levels of heat, from mild to mouth-numbingly intense. Hot sauce not only tantalizes taste buds but also triggers the release of endorphins, leading to a pleasurable sensory experience akin to a culinary adventure.

But not everyone is fortunate enough to have a variety of hot sauce flavors on their local supermarket shelves. Not to worry. Hot sauce clubs have emerged as a unique way for enthusiasts to explore new and exciting flavors on a regular basis. These clubs offer subscription-based plans that deliver carefully curated selections of hot sauces to members' doorsteps.

Now, the fun part: choosing which hot sauce club to get into. You've got lots of options out there, so how can you decide which one gets your subscription? Here are a few ways to compare the hot sauce plans you're considering:

  • Variety. Hot sauce clubs offer a diverse selection of sauces ranging in heat levels, ingredients, and flavor profiles. Some clubs focus on local artisanal brands, while others span global hot sauce producers, giving you access to a wider range of tastes and sensations.
  • Cost. The cost of hot sauce club memberships varies based on factors such as the number of bottles per shipment, the frequency of deliveries, and the exclusivity of the sauces included. Check to see if shipping is included in what you're paying too.
  • Flexibility. The best hot sauce clubs offer flexible subscription options, letting you adjust delivery frequencies, skip shipments, or pause memberships when needed.
  • Satisfaction guarantee. Every so often, you might get a hot sauce that just doesn't work for you. Or maybe it arrives in less-than-perfect condition. Can you get a no-fuss refund or replacement?
  • Reputation. What do other hot sauce fanatics say about their experience with the club? Do they say it's a good value with plenty of new flavors to try? Has the company been favorably rated by the Better Business Bureau?

Hot sauce clubs offer a dynamic way to explore a vast landscape of fiery flavors, and the experts at Top Consumer Reviews have researched and ranked today's most popular subscriptions. Celebrate your love of spicy foods with a red-hot and fun monthly delivery of hot sauce!

The Best Reviews of Hot Sauce Clubs