Where Can You Find the Best Ice Cream Clubs? You love ice cream. We're not talking "grabs a pint at the grocery store every now and then" kind of love. We're talking "has a dedicated freezer drawer, owns more than one ice cream scoop, maybe even planned a road trip around regional creameries" kind of adoration. If that sounds like you, it might be time to stop rationing your sweet tooth and start living the dream with an ice cream subscription.
Best Option
Read Full Review
Amazing Clubs continues to be the top pick for ice cream subscriptions, thanks to its reliable delivery, crowd-pleasing flavors, and unbeatable customer service. You get four curated pints each month, with a preview of what's coming - and the option to skip any shipment you don't want. Prices are fair (shipping included), gift-giving is a breeze, and their satisfaction guarantee is the best in the business. If you want a delicious, no-stress ice cream subscription, start with Amazing Clubs.
Great
Read Full Review
McConnell's Pint of the Month Club delivers four pints of premium, small-batch ice cream in each delivery, with a focus on clean ingredients, local sourcing, and unique flavor combos. While you can't customize your box, you can skip a month anytime. The subscription is well-priced for the quality, and McConnell's long-standing reputation and "A+" BBB rating add extra peace of mind if this is your first time trying an ice cream subscription. If you're into craft ice cream that's as thoughtful as it is tasty, this club might be your new favorite.
Great
Read Full Review
Salt & Straw's ice cream club brings bold, chef-driven flavors and social impact to your doorstep with five pints per shipment. You can choose from three flavor collections - including a rare dairy-free option - and skip months when needed. It's pricier than some clubs, but the quality and mission make it worthwhile. With Salt & Straw's melt-free guarantee, a stellar reputation, and a deep commitment to local communities, this is a subscription for people who want their ice cream to stand for something (and taste amazing too).
Great
Read Full Review
Jeni's ice cream club delivers four pints of premium, inventive frozen treats each month - including flavors you might be the first to try. While there's no flavor customization, you can skip a shipment if needed. It's one of the more affordable clubs at around $65 per box (shipping included), and the brand's "A+" BBB rating and loyal fanbase make it a trustworthy pick. If you love Jeni's playful style and bold flavor combos, this ice cream club is an easy yes.
Very Good
Read Full Review
Sisters of Anarchy offers a farm-to-cone ice cream club that's packed with bold flavors, small-batch quality, and serious personality. You can choose your own pints or let them surprise you, with delivery options that suit any schedule. Expect creative combos like raspberry coffee or lemon pie, often made with fruit grown right on their Vermont farm. While pricing isn't clear until checkout and shipping is on the steep side, the flexibility and flavor selection at Sisters of Anarchy more than make up for it. If you're into ice cream with a side of activism and authenticity, this club's got your name on it.
Good
Read Full Review
Flying Noodle's Ice Cream of the Month Club might fly under the radar, but it's a surprisingly strong pick - especially if you're looking for something flexible, gifting-friendly, and filled with fun flavors. Each month brings four curated pints of ice cream or gelato from small-batch producers, and you'll get a preview before every shipment so you can skip if needed. With prices starting around $70.95 per month (shipping included) and a solid satisfaction guarantee, Flying Noodle's ice cream club is a great blend of variety, value, and customer care.
Good
Read Full Review
eCreamery's ice cream club delivers four pints of premium, small-batch ice cream to your door each month - and does it reliably. You can't customize flavors or skip shipments to avoid allergens, but the rotating lineup includes both best-sellers and creative seasonal options. While the price is on the higher side, shipping is included, and the quality consistently wins over customers. With a top-tier BBB rating and lots of 5-star reviews, eCreamery's subscription is a dependable (if not the most flexible) choice for ice cream lovers.
Good
Read Full Review
High Point Creamery's ice cream club is a flavorful, small-batch subscription from a beloved Denver-area shop. You'll get four pints per shipment featuring signature and seasonal scoops like Cookies (3 Ways) & Cream and Mango Coconut Lassi. The pricing is reasonable and shipping is included, but the club's structure could use some polish - there's (still) not much upfront info on gift options, skipping deliveries, or previewing flavors unless you call or email (and the answers we got put this club a bit behind the competition). Still, if you want bold, creative ice cream from an indie maker, High Point Creamery's club is a sweet choice worth considering.
Fair
Read Full Review
Goldbelly's ice cream club promises big-name pints and ice cream sandwiches from famous creameries across the country - but the reality doesn't always live up to the hype. At $99.95 per month, it's one of the most expensive options out there, and you don't get to choose flavors or even see what's coming in advance. Your subscription can take up to two months to start, and while the company has an improved "A" rating with the BBB, plenty of customers still report issues with melted or delayed deliveries. Goldbelly ranks below average as an ice cream subscription that might leave you disappointed.
Continued from above...
You love ice cream. We're not talking "grabs a pint at the grocery store every now and then" kind of love. We're talking "has a dedicated freezer drawer, owns more than one ice cream scoop, maybe even planned a road trip around regional creameries" kind of adoration. If that sounds like you, it might be time to stop rationing your sweet tooth and start living the dream with an ice cream subscription.
Ice cream clubs are pretty much what they sound like: curated boxes of premium frozen treats, delivered right to your door on a monthly (or sometimes quarterly) basis. Each shipment is a delicious surprise - usually featuring small-batch pints in classic and seasonal flavors, or even gourmet collaborations that go way beyond your standard chocolate and vanilla. Think brown sugar bourbon swirl, balsamic fig, lavender honeycomb, or cookie dough made with actual browned butter and flaky sea salt. Yeah, we're drooling too.
What makes ice cream subscriptions so much fun is that they turn a casual treat into a full-on event. You don't just eat a scoop - you unwrap a box of joy, discover a new brand or flavor profile, and feel a little spoiled by the fact that someone packed a cooler of hand-churned decadence just for you.
And these days, your options are as diverse as the dessert trucks at a food festival. Some subscriptions stick with the classics, while others go wild with inventive (and sometimes polarizing) flavors. You'll find brands that highlight women-owned creameries, farm-to-table producers, or dairy-free innovators who are turning coconut milk and cashew cream into something magical. Whether you're a flavor thrill-seeker or a die-hard vanilla devotee, there's an ice cream club with your name on it.
Best of all, most subscriptions are super flexible. You can gift one to a friend, skip a month if your freezer's full, or stock up ahead of summer parties. They make killer birthday gifts, breakup pick-me-ups, or self-care splurges - because honestly, who doesn't need a little frozen comfort now and then?
Still, not all ice cream subscriptions are created equal. Some come with nationwide shipping and perfect packaging; others might arrive a little less frozen than you'd hoped. Some brands rotate through seasonal offerings, while others stick to a set menu. And pricing? It ranges from "surprisingly affordable" to "this better come with gold leaf and a custom spoon." So before you sign up for a year's worth of frosty goodness, here are a few things to look for when comparing clubs:
Whether you're treating yourself or surprising someone else, ice cream subscriptions are a joyful way to indulge. So grab your spoon (and maybe a backup one for sharing), because the experts here at Top Consumer Reviews have done the oh-so-tasty work of rating today's most popular ice cream clubs - so that you can bring the magic of the creamery straight to your front porch.
Compare Any 2 Products
Top Products.
Top Reviews.
Top Consumer Reviews.
Reviews
Browse through thousands of reviews.
Social Media
Like us? Follow us! We'd love to have you join our community.
Newsletter
Stay up to date with the latest reviews. We'll keep you informed, and we'll never sell your information to anyone.
