Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

Goldbelly Review

Sunday, March 3rd

2024 Ice Cream Club Reviews

Goldbelly Review 2 Star Rating


2 Star Rating
  • Selection: 5-6 pints of ice cream OR 6-24 ice cream sandwiches each month
  • Priced at $89.95 per month
  • Shipping is included in the price
  • Club can last for 3, 6, 9, or 12 months
  • "B" rated and accredited by the BBB

Goldbelly is a curated online marketplace for gourmet food and food gifts that are delivered nationwide in the United States. The company was founded in 2013 by Joe Ariel and is based in New York City. The platform features a wide range of iconic and legendary foods and gifts from well-known restaurants, small businesses, and food makers across the country.

Ice cream sandwiches or pints in each box

So, what does the ice cream subscription at Goldbelly look like? Every delivery comes with a selection of treats from the nation's top creameries - which could include 5-6 pints of ice cream or 6-24 ice cream sandwiches (or a combination of the two). You won't necessarily know in advance what to expect, but Goldbelly offers the following list as examples of what you could get in any given month:

  • Nancy Silverton's Nancy's Fancy Gelato
  • Austin's Lick Honest Ice Creams
  • LA's Amazing Coolhaus Ice Cream Sandwiches
  • North Carolina's Oprah's Favorite Nye's Cream Sandwiches
  • San Francisco's Popular Humphry Slocombe Ice Cream

About $90/month

You can choose a club length of 3, 6, 9, or 12 months, with deliveries coming every month. This ice cream club costs $89.95 per month, but at least that includes the shipping fees. Just don't get too excited when you see the pop-up offering you $15 off your Goldbelly order: feel free to use it on a one-off purchase, but it won't be valid for any subscription purchase (including ice cream).

Not the most customer-friendly club

Unfortunately, Goldbelly is one of the least-customizable ice cream clubs we've encountered - in fact, it's not possible to modify it at all. Allergies? Flavors you don't like? Too bad. You also might have to wait a good long while for your deliveries to start: we were looking to order around the middle of the month, and the soonest we could get our ice cream to start was a ship date of the 21st of the following month.

Best Ice Cream Clubs

Customer feedback is hard to access

Do customers think that Goldbelly's ice cream subscription is worth it? That's hard to say: the site shows that all subscriptions have an impressive 4.9 out of 5 star average, but they don't actually let you look at the customer reviews. Plus, they're not separated by the subscription type: we don't care if people like their NYC or sandwich clubs when we're shopping for the best ice cream membership.

Lackluster performance

We were also irritated by the fact that Goldbelly was still proudly advertising its "A+" rating from the Better Business Bureau - despite the fact that, at the time of our evaluation, the rating had been dropped down to a "B" for having over 200 complaints filed in the last three-year period. These complaints almost always rant about products that arrive with melted dry ice and in poor condition, and that doesn't bode well for ice cream! Plus, almost every complaint says that Goldbelly's customer service initially offered a store credit only, and it was only after filing with the BBB that the response included a refund option as well.

Skip this ice cream club

Overall, Goldbelly's ice cream club fails to impress us. It's more expensive than other subscription options, less flexible, and there's a real chance that your ice cream will be reduced to a puddle by the time it reaches your doorstep. No thank you. We strongly recommend that you look at the higher-ranked ice cream clubs on our list instead of giving Goldbelly your business.

Where Can You Find the Best Ice Cream Clubs?

Are you an ice cream enthusiast? Do you enjoy indulging in a variety of delectable flavors, savoring each creamy spoonful? If so, then ice cream club subscriptions might just be your ticket to frozen bliss. These delightful memberships have grown in popularity and offer a convenient and exciting way to sample a wide range of mouthwatering ice cream flavors, delivered right to your doorstep.

So why subscribe to an ice cream club when you can just go to the grocery store? Well, maybe you don't want that hassle every time you need a frosty treat. With a subscription, you don't need to worry about making frequent trips to the store or standing in long lines in the heat of the summer, waiting for your cone to be passed already-dripping through the counter window. Ice cream is delivered directly to your home - well-packaged, of course, to stay nice and cold until you can pop it in your freezer.

The Best Ice Cream Clubs Compare Ice Cream Clubs Compare Ice Cream Club Reviews What are the best Ice Cream Clubs Best Ice Cream Club Reviews

Ice Cream Club FAQ

An ice cream club subscription is a membership service that delivers a curated selection of ice creams to your doorstep on a regular basis. It allows you to explore a variety of flavors and brands without the need to shop for ice cream yourself.
The frequency of deliveries varies among different ice cream clubs. Some may deliver monthly, while others may have bi-monthly or quarterly deliveries. It ultimately depends on the specific club and the subscription plan you choose.
Yes, some ice cream clubs offer customization options. They allow you to personalize your ice cream selection based on your preferences, dietary needs, or flavor exclusions. Just be aware that sometimes this "customization" is really just letting you know in advance what flavors are coming and giving you the option to skip that month's delivery.
Yes, many ice cream clubs feature novel and/or seasonal flavors as part of their offerings. These flavors are often crafted by talented ice cream artisans, providing subscribers with exclusive access to special creations that may not be available in traditional retail stores or even the company's own scoop shops!
Maybe, but they're not so easy to find. Obviously, the hardest allergy or sensitivity to avoid with an ice cream club is... dairy! But if your particular allergens are nuts or other ingredients often found in ice cream, you'll probably need to do a little extra research before signing up for any specific club. You can always reach out to the club's customer service team too.
Absolutely! Ice cream club subscriptions make fantastic gifts. You can surprise a friend, family member, or loved one with a membership and treat them to a delightful assortment of ice creams. It's a thoughtful and unique present that brings joy and indulgence. Look for any extras that the club offers, like personalized gift cards or scheduling an announcement to be emailed on the date of your choice, to make your gift-giving extra-special.
Ice cream clubs take special care in packaging their products to maintain freshness during transit. They generally use insulated containers and dry ice to keep the ice cream frozen throughout the delivery process. This ensures that the ice cream arrives in excellent condition and is ready to be enjoyed right away or popped in your freezer for later.
Most ice cream clubs provide flexibility in managing your subscription. You can usually pause or skip deliveries for a certain period if you're going on vacation or need a break. Canceling the subscription is typically straightforward and can be done online or by contacting customer support, and refunds will usually be prorated for any upcoming months that won't be delivered.
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

And let's not forget about variety. Ice cream club subscriptions provide an unparalleled variety of flavors. These clubs often curate a diverse selection, ranging from classic favorites like vanilla and chocolate to innovative combinations such as salted caramel pretzel or strawberry cheesecake. You'll have the opportunity to sample flavors you may not find elsewhere. It's like having an ice cream expert as your personal guide, introducing you to hidden gems and unique concoctions you might have never tried otherwise.

Subscribing to an ice cream club can be a cost-effective option for ice cream enthusiasts. Many clubs offer subscription packages that provide better value for your money compared to buying individual pints or scoops from a grocery store or ice cream parlor. Additionally, some clubs offer discounts, free shipping, or special promotions to their members, allowing you to enjoy premium ice cream without breaking the bank.

And let's not forget about one of the best aspects of ice cream clubs - they're fun! Each delivery is like a mini celebration, as you eagerly await the arrival of new flavors or favorites that you've selected in advance. This anticipation adds a sense of excitement and joy to your ice cream consumption, turning it into a delightful ritual.

If you want to purchase an ice cream club subscription for yourself, or as a gift for someone else, here are a few things to keep in mind as you choose the perfect one to satisfy your sweet tooth:

  • Quantity. How much ice cream comes in every delivery? Most clubs come standard with four different pints per shipment, but a few include even more.
  • Price. What will you pay for your ice cream club? Is shipping included in the monthly fee? Do you pay upfront for the whole subscription term, or can you pay as each delivery ships?
  • Flavor Selection. Many ice cream clubs ship you a predetermined selection of flavors, but what if you don't like something that's on the schedule? Can you swap a flavor for something else, or skip that month's delivery and tack another one on the end of your plan? Of course, one of the perks of an ice cream club is trying flavors that might not even be available to the public, so don't be afraid to get adventurous.
  • Reputation: Research the ice cream club's reputation, customer reviews, and testimonials to gauge the overall satisfaction of existing subscribers. Look for clubs known for excellent customer service and consistently delivering high-quality ice cream flavors.

Ice cream club subscriptions offer a delightful journey through a myriad of flavors, providing convenience, variety, discovery, and sweet surprises. From classic to gourmet creations, there's an ice cream club for everyone, and Top Consumer Reviews has done the not-so-hard work of ranking today's most popular options. With the perfect ice cream club, you'll be on your way to experiencing frozen joy-in-a-spoonful and savoring the sweetest treats with each delivery.

The Best Reviews of Ice Cream Clubs