Where Can You Find the Best Ice Cream Clubs? You love ice cream. We're not talking "grabs a pint at the grocery store every now and then" kind of love. We're talking "has a dedicated freezer drawer, owns more than one ice cream scoop, maybe even planned a road trip around regional creameries" kind of adoration. If that sounds like you, it might be time to stop rationing your sweet tooth and start living the dream with an ice cream subscription.
Fair
If you've ever wished you could sample ice cream from the country's most buzz-worthy creameries without leaving your house, Goldbelly's ice cream club might catch your eye. And on paper, it sounds kind of dreamy: pints of ice cream or gelato (or even ice cream sandwiches) from legendary spots like Nancy's Fancy, packed in dry ice and delivered to your doorstep every month. But once you dig into the details (and the price tag), the excitement may start to melt away.
Big names, small details
Every box you get from Goldbelly's club includes either 5-6 pints of ice cream or up to two dozen ice cream sandwiches. The brands vary each month and are selected from Goldbelly's curated roster of cult-favorite creameries. What you don't get is any advance notice of what's coming, and there's no way to customize your subscription based on dietary restrictions or personal preferences. That's a big downside, compared with other ice cream clubs we evaluated, and especially when Goldbelly used to at least tell you some of the makers and flavors that were included in previous months' deliveries. We wish they would bring that back.
More expensive than most
So, what will you pay for your monthly mystery box? Goldbelly charges $99.95 per delivery. That's fairly expensive but not completely out of range if you happen to get 6 pints of ice cream, but can you imagine paying almost $100 for just six ice cream sandwiches (the minimum amount Goldbelly says could be in your box)? For what it's worth, you pay the same whether you choose a monthly recurring subscription or you prepay for 3, 6, or 12 months - but at least the shipping is always included in the price.
Slow start, long wait
One of the most frustrating parts of this subscription is how long it takes to get going. If you sign up right after the 25th of the month - say, June 26th - you're looking at a delivery that won't arrive until mid-to-late August. That's nearly eight weeks of waiting for ice cream you've already paid for. And while Goldbelly says you'll be receiving premium frozen treats, you won't know which ones until they show up at your door.
A slightly better track record - on paper
Goldbelly now holds an "A" rating with the Better Business Bureau, an improvement from the "B" it previously carried. That's a step in the right direction. But when you dig into customer reviews across the company (not just the ice cream club), there are still plenty of complaints about melted deliveries, long delays, and inconsistent service. To their credit, Goldbelly's support team usually replies quickly, but their response often boils down to "not really our fault," especially when weather or shipping issues are involved.
A luxury splurge that might not be worth the spend
In the end, Goldbelly's ice cream club has the name recognition and premium branding to make it sound like a top-tier experience. But the lack of transparency on flavors and makers, delayed start dates, and higher-than-average price point make it hard to recommend - especially when there are other clubs out there offering more info upfront (and with lots of successful deliveries to satisfied customers). Goldbelly still lands at the bottom of our list.
Continued from above...
You love ice cream. We're not talking "grabs a pint at the grocery store every now and then" kind of love. We're talking "has a dedicated freezer drawer, owns more than one ice cream scoop, maybe even planned a road trip around regional creameries" kind of adoration. If that sounds like you, it might be time to stop rationing your sweet tooth and start living the dream with an ice cream subscription.
Ice cream clubs are pretty much what they sound like: curated boxes of premium frozen treats, delivered right to your door on a monthly (or sometimes quarterly) basis. Each shipment is a delicious surprise - usually featuring small-batch pints in classic and seasonal flavors, or even gourmet collaborations that go way beyond your standard chocolate and vanilla. Think brown sugar bourbon swirl, balsamic fig, lavender honeycomb, or cookie dough made with actual browned butter and flaky sea salt. Yeah, we're drooling too.
What makes ice cream subscriptions so much fun is that they turn a casual treat into a full-on event. You don't just eat a scoop - you unwrap a box of joy, discover a new brand or flavor profile, and feel a little spoiled by the fact that someone packed a cooler of hand-churned decadence just for you.
And these days, your options are as diverse as the dessert trucks at a food festival. Some subscriptions stick with the classics, while others go wild with inventive (and sometimes polarizing) flavors. You'll find brands that highlight women-owned creameries, farm-to-table producers, or dairy-free innovators who are turning coconut milk and cashew cream into something magical. Whether you're a flavor thrill-seeker or a die-hard vanilla devotee, there's an ice cream club with your name on it.
Best of all, most subscriptions are super flexible. You can gift one to a friend, skip a month if your freezer's full, or stock up ahead of summer parties. They make killer birthday gifts, breakup pick-me-ups, or self-care splurges - because honestly, who doesn't need a little frozen comfort now and then?
Still, not all ice cream subscriptions are created equal. Some come with nationwide shipping and perfect packaging; others might arrive a little less frozen than you'd hoped. Some brands rotate through seasonal offerings, while others stick to a set menu. And pricing? It ranges from "surprisingly affordable" to "this better come with gold leaf and a custom spoon." So before you sign up for a year's worth of frosty goodness, here are a few things to look for when comparing clubs:
Whether you're treating yourself or surprising someone else, ice cream subscriptions are a joyful way to indulge. So grab your spoon (and maybe a backup one for sharing), because the experts here at Top Consumer Reviews have done the oh-so-tasty work of rating today's most popular ice cream clubs - so that you can bring the magic of the creamery straight to your front porch.
Compare Any 2 Products
Top Products.
Top Reviews.
Top Consumer Reviews.
Reviews
Browse through thousands of reviews.
Social Media
Like us? Follow us! We'd love to have you join our community.
Newsletter
Stay up to date with the latest reviews. We'll keep you informed, and we'll never sell your information to anyone.
