Sisters of Anarchy Review

Thursday, March 27th

2025 Ice Cream Club Reviews

Sisters of Anarchy

• Selection: 4-6 pints per delivery
• Priced from $45.60 to $70/month plus $19 in shipping per delivery
• Club can last for 3, 4 (quarterly), 6 or 12 months
• Deliveries can be monthly or every other month
• Can choose each pint's flavor, a predetermined selection of flavors, or a surprise assortment

Who knew ice cream could be so... edgy? The Sisters of Anarchy, that's who. Starting with their "”WOManifesto” and going deep into their history as multi-generational lovers of the frozen treat, the family team behind this ice cream club is committed to being truly "farm-to-cone” - making all ice cream on site in Vermont and growing most of the flavor elements (like blueberries and raspberries) right on the farm.

Hands-off or choose-your-own adventure

As you might expect from an ice cream club with "anarchy” in the name, this subscription gives you a lot of freedom to choose: get four to six pints in your delivery, and you get to decide if you want to create-your-own flavor arrangement, go with a preset selection of flavors, or let the Sisters surprise you. You can also get your deliveries each month or every other month, for a club length of 3, 4 (quarterly), 6, or 12 months.

Creative flavors with fun names

So, what kinds of flavors are we talking about here? Take a look at some of the Sisters of Anarchy's hallmark concoctions:

• Chocolate Anarchy: super-rich dark chocolate
• Crystal Blue Persuasion: blueberries in vanilla ice cream
• Dirty Ann and Chaste Ann: yellow Anne raspberries in chocolate and vanilla ice cream, respectively
• I Really Love Your Peaches: purple ice cream made from aronia berries, mixed with peaches
• Overtime: coffee ice cream with red raspberries
• Beefy Blonde: a "breakfast ice cream” with maple, blueberries, and bacon

Themed packs or be surprised

You'll want to look through the club's themed flavor packs (Soccer Mom Special with Anarchy, Peaches, Overtime, Nine to Five, Snap) and see if there's one that has your favorite picks. If not, you can choose the Make Your Own 6-Pack and get just your must-have ice cream flavors. Or, let the Sisters pick a 4-pack or 6-pack for you - and you can enter any allergies or flavor preferences in the notes on your order, in case there's something you need to avoid. The one wrinkle we found is that two flavors (Dirty Ann and Chaste Ann) were out of stock at the time of our review, and so many of the pre-arranged selections were actually unavailable.

One-off or subscribe

All of the options here let you buy it as a one-off order, but we're here to talk about ice cream subscriptions. If that's what you're looking for, make sure to click on the button for "subscribe and save up to 5%” You'll choose if you want ice cream every month for 3/6/12 months, every other month for three total deliveries, or every three months for 12 total deliveries.

Total cost not available until checkout

What do the subscriptions cost at Sisters of Anarchy? Here's where it gets a little tricky: you won't see the price until you choose which club you want and add it to your cart, and the only discount for subscribing is if you go for a 12-month plan (which saves you 5%). So, depending on how you configure your deliveries, you should expect to pay anywhere from $45.60 (a four-pack every month for 12 months) to $70 (a 6-pack) per ice cream shipment. That sounds pretty impressive - until you get further into the checkout and find that the $19 per delivery in shipping fees isn't included in the monthly price. Still, that's right on par with the other ice cream clubs we evaluated - and what else would you expect for gourmet flavors like these?

This ice cream has lots of fans

People seem to universally love the ice cream made by Sisters of Anarchy, whether they're buying and enjoying it locally or having it shipped across the country. We had fun looking through customer photos of different flavor combinations and all of the places where they sat and took a minute to just savor the moment. There's not a mountain of feedback out there, but what's there is enthusiastic (and satisfied).

Committed to social justice

The one area where this ice cream club might not be a good fit is if your views don't align with the company's. The Sisters are very passionate about specific social causes, and that hasn't always been received well by customers who just wanted some amazing ice cream. On the other hand, that could be your perfect ice cream club - one that not only tastes incredible but also goes to support causes you believe in.

Definitely worth a look

At the end of the day, Sisters of Anarchy comes in solidly above average as an ice cream club. It's an excellent choice for anyone who needs more say-so in the flavors they get, whether that's for allergies or just personal preference, and we love how most of the flavor features like fruit are grown right on site. You definitely won't get that with anything at your local supermarket. While we were a little disappointed that so many packages weren't available (because of the two out-of-stock flavors), that's no reason to completely skip over this otherwise-impressive ice cream subscription. Particularly if you like supporting women-owned businesses, you should give Sisters of Anarchy a look.