We evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

Aura vs Identity Defense

Tuesday, June 17th

2025 Identity Theft Protection Service Reviews

Aura Review 4.5 Star Rating

Aura

4.5 Star Rating
  • $12 per month for 1 person
  • $22 per month for 2 people
  • $37 per month for a family plan
  • $1 million in insurance per person
  • Credit tracking
  • Bank, home, and auto tracking
  • Antivirus protection
  • VPN
  • Email aliases
  • Smart Vault encryption
  • Top-rated mobile apps
  • "A+” rating and accreditation from the BBB

Aura, established in 2014, is a user-friendly and modern identity protection service that offers a range of security features at attractive prices. They monitor all three major credit bureaus, provide a $1 million insurance coverage in case of identity theft, and provide tools like antivirus protection, password management, VPN, email aliases, and more. Their plans cater to individuals, couples, and families, with competitive pricing and a top-rated mobile app for added convenience. Aura's exceptional customer service and "white glove" treatment have earned them high praise from customers and third-party review sites, and they earn a high spot in our rankings as well.

Identity Defense Review 2 Star Rating

Identity Defense

2 Star Rating
  • $8.99 to $29.99 per month for one person
  • $1 million in ID insurance
  • Credit tracking
  • Antivirus protection
  • Social media tracking
  • VPN
  • Has a mobile app
  • Parent company has an "A+” rating from the BBB

Identity Defense faces several transparency and website issues that affect its credibility. While they offer $1 million in ID theft insurance and varying plan features, their pricing isn't as cost-effective as it initially appears, and only services one individual rather than families. Furthermore, the company's limited popularity and poor mobile app ratings result in a low ranking in this review, suggesting that other more established and trusted identity theft protection providers may be a better choice.

Where Can You Get the Best Protection from Identity Theft?

In an age where our lives are increasingly online, the risk of falling victim to identity theft is a growing concern for individuals and families alike. Fortunately, to combat this concerning situation, services have emerged to help protect you and your loved ones from identity theft and other security dangers. By safeguarding your personal information from malicious actors, these companies work around the clock to keep you safe in the digital space.

Why is this necessary now more than ever? The rise of the internet has revolutionized the way we live, work, and interact with the world. Yet, this digital evolution has also given rise to a new breed of criminals who exploit the vulnerabilities of our interconnected lives. Through choosing weak passwords, clicking on malware, or even replying to the wrong email, it's all too easy to become a victim of identity theft in the online space.

The Best Identity Theft Protection Services Compare Identity Theft Protection Services Compare Identity Theft Protection Service Reviews What are the best Identity Theft Protection Services Best Identity Theft Protection Service Reviews

Identity Theft Protection Service FAQ

When someone takes advantage of your personal information - Social Security number, birthdate, name, etc. - to make purchases, open new accounts, or get a tax refund, it's defined as identity theft. More than three million cases of identity theft are reported on average each year - and that's just in the United States!
Keep an eye on the various accounts you have: banks, credit cards, insurance, and so forth. Identity theft can show up as unexplained withdrawals, missing bills or other mail, phone calls from debt collectors about accounts you never opened, or even conditions in your medical records that you've never had. All of these are red flags that someone is fraudulently using your identity.
If someone uses your personal information to get a new credit card, receive a tax refund, or take out a loan, you should report it to the Federal Trade Commission through their Identity Theft website. You should also contact the three main credit bureaus - TransUnion, Experian and Equifax - and have them place a fraud alert on your credit reports. Notify each company where you discover that fraud has occurred as well. Finally, contact your local police department to file a report. Fortunately, if you are a subscriber to an identity theft protection service, such fraud will likely be caught very early on and make it less likely that any long-term damage was done to your credit history.
Keeping your personal information secure is one of the best ways of stopping identity thieves. This includes shredding documents that have your personal and/or financial information before recycling them or putting them in the trash. Stay aware of the ways scammers are currently trying to get people to give up their information, such as phishing schemes or robocalls.[2] If you're not confident that you can stay on top of monitoring your identity, it is well worth it to subscribe to an identity theft protection plan.
Most services take a two-pronged approach to identity protection: prevention and repair. Once you become a subscriber, these systems monitor your information to detect security breaches and any attempts to use your identity. You're notified when any suspicious activity occurs, and if you have any funds stolen the service will typically help you recover the money.
Definitely not - and keep in mind that any money you spend will be far less than the cost of repairing your credit if your identity is stolen! You can get basic identity theft coverage for less than $7/month. There are also couple/family plans available that can protect everyone in your household.
Yes, most credit card companies actively track your spending habits and freeze your account if they suspect that a charge is fraudulent. That's a great resource that doesn't cost you a penny. However, your credit card companies aren't also tracking your bank accounts, health insurance and medical records, online profile or status with the IRS. And, your credit card issuer isn't going to help you repair your credit history if your identity is stolen. Using an identity theft protection plan is the most robust way to keep an eye on all of the places your personal information could be used illegally - and to fix things if a breach occurs.
Absolutely. In fact, identity thieves place a high premium on stolen Social Security numbers of minors, because it can often be a very long time before the theft is discovered: imagine going to apply for a credit card for the first time, only to find out that someone else had been using your identity for years! If you're considering an identity theft protection plan, be sure to find out what options are available for the children in your family: their coverage is usually deeply discounted when compared with the costs for adults.
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

However, there's no need to live in fear when you can employ the services of identity theft protection experts. These services are the first line of defense against the unauthorized use of your personal information, offering proactive monitoring, rapid response, and invaluable guidance to ensure that your identity remains firmly in your control.

There are lots of ways a company can help you protect your identity. Leading identity theft protection services offer a variety of features to maintain your security 24/7. These include monitoring of your credit reports and dark web surveillance, to robust insurance policies that mitigate potential losses. These services employ cutting-edge technology and experienced professionals to keep your identity safe.

Identity protection experts recommend that individuals stay consistently alert when it comes to safeguarding their personal information. Employing simple strategies such as securely shredding documents containing sensitive data and practicing discretion when sharing personal details on social media can go a long way in preventing identity theft. However, it's important to acknowledge that scammers are persistent and always on the lookout for ways to compromise your security.

Identity theft services have been growing in popularity due to the increasing number of data breaches and cyberattacks in recent years. In 2020 and 2021, there were several high-profile data breaches, exposing the sensitive personal information of millions of people. These incidents, coupled with the rising awareness of identity theft risks, drove many consumers to seek protection through identity theft services.

Thankfully, identity theft protection is not a luxury; it's easy to get enrolled right away. Many consider it a necessity in today's digital age. If you're not sure where to start, though, that's okay. Your security is important, so we took the time to check out all the top services for you. Here are a few factors that can help you narrow down your choices:

  • Cost. Considering that identity theft protection is an ongoing concern, you'll want to check budgeting options in the long term. How much do you want to spend? Are you looking for month-to-month payments or annual commitments? Knowing what you want to spend and when will help you narrow down your options.
  • Insurance. Sometimes even with protection, things can go wrong. So make sure you check out the insurance coverage amount at the identity theft protection services. Most offer a minimum of $1 million per person, though there are some services that offer even higher insurance rates.
  • Family vs. single. Everyone has a different family situation, so you might want to protect just yourself or maybe add a spouse. Or maybe you've got kids (grandkids?) and parents you're looking at too. Check out which plans offer family or child security on top of singles' packages to make sure a service offers protection that meets your needs.
  • Reputation. Reputation is a big deal with identity theft. If customers aren't happy with the protection they've gotten, you'll want to stay away. Your safety is the most important thing, so ratings from the Better Business Bureau and verified customer reviews are essential to know whether an identity theft protection service is trustworthy or not.

Because we take the safety of your identity seriously, Top Consumer Reviews has evaluated and rated the best places to go to protect yourself against identity theft. We hope this helps you feel more secure about your digital life and return to being stress-free about your identity and personal information!

Compare Identity Theft Protection Services

Select any 2 Identity Theft Protection Services to compare them head to head

best-identity-theft-products
See the Best Identity Theft Protection Service
The Best Reviews of Identity Theft Protection Services