The 9 Best Jewelry Subscription Boxes
Which Jewelry Subscription Box is the Best?
Jewelry subscription boxes have gained popularity as a convenient and exciting way to explore new accessories while adding an element of surprise with every delivery. The offerings vary widely, ranging from high-end, designer pieces to trendy, costume jewelry.
One of the key attractions of jewelry subscription boxes is the diversity of styles they offer. Whether you prefer classic, minimalist designs, bohemian chic, or bold statement pieces, there's a subscription service geared towards your aesthetic. Some subscriptions even allow you to customize your preferences, so that each and every box suits your personal style.
Saturday, March 22nd
2025 Jewelry Subscription Box Reviews
Reclaimed With Love
If you're on the hunt for a jewelry subscription that you'll feel proud to join, look no further than Reclaimed With Love. This subscription offers upcycled demi-fine jewelry for women, men, and kids. Founded by NES Group, a leader in recycled metals, this subscription embodies the essence of repurposing and reimagining, aiming to disrupt the fast fashion cycle and promote environmental stewardship. Each month, a curated box of premium jewelry arrives at your doorstep, crafted with care and ready to elevate your style and conscience according to your preference profile. With affordable pricing starting at just $14 per month for one piece, plus glowing reviews from happy subscribers, Reclaimed With Love is our absolute favorite jewelry box subscription.
Heidi Hull Designs
With Heidi Hull Designs' jewelry subscription box, you're embarking on a journey into stunning craftsmanship and meaningful impact. Heidi's unexpected foray into jewelry design while teaching in New Zealand led to the creation of her "Everyday Everywhere" collection, praised for its quality and versatility. Beyond aesthetics, Heidi's commitment to social causes shines through, supporting organizations combating poverty and human trafficking. Each subscription box delivers 2-3 top trending pieces, including necklaces, earrings, and bracelets, from Heidi's collection, priced at $48 per delivery with free shipping. Gift subscriptions are available for 1-12 months or quarterly, offering flexibility and delightful surprises. Although this subscription doesn't have much in the way of reviews, Heidi Hull Designs stands out for offering direct interaction with the designer and high-quality jewelry, earning it one of our highest rankings among jewelry subscription boxes.
Emma & Chloé
Do you love trendy jewelry that always suits your style? Look no further than Emma & Chloé. With a monthly subscription, you'll receive one piece of Paris-designed jewelry valued between $50 to $120 for just $35, including shipping, or opt for an annual subscription upfront and pay only $30 per month. Choose between gold-tone, silver-tone, or let Emma & Chloé surprise you. Your selection could include a ring, a necklace or earrings, but if you don't have pierced ears, don't worry - they'll send you clip-on earrings. With a 14-day refund policy and surprise extras included in most boxes, Emma & Chloé makes it simple to enjoy new jewelry every month. This is one of our most recommended jewelry subscription boxes.
Penny + Grace
Penny + Grace designs and manufactures all of the pieces of jewelry you'll get in their subscription box, and you can easily see what subscribers have gotten in previous shipments. You can opt to get 1, 2, or 3 pieces of new jewelry each month, and Penny + Grace's generous, customer-centric policy allows for returns within 30 days. You get a lot of input on what you receive, including the ability to hand-select each piece of jewelry sent in your first box. If you love the style of jewelry you see on the Penny + Grace site (and on their popular IG posts), there's no reason not to give this jewelry subscription box a try.
Gelry
With Gelry, a jewelry subscription available on the Cratejoy platform, you'll receive three costume jewelry pieces each month, including earrings, rings, necklaces, and bracelets, along with a cute jewelry bag. Pricing starts at $24.90 per box for month-to-month subscriptions, with discounted rates on prepaid plans lasting 3, 6, or 12 months. Gelry stands out for its customization options, allowing you to specify preferences such as ring size, earrings preference, and preferred styles, as well as a subscription just for teens (or younger girls). Gift subscriptions are easy to set up, and customer feedback is largely positive, with prompt responses from Gelry representatives to address any issues reported. Overall, Gelry offers an affordable and enjoyable jewelry subscription experience.
mintMONGOOSE
Cratejoy gives you access to the mintMONGOOSE jewelry subscription box, a membership that's earned more than a thousand 5-star customer reviews over the years. You get a two-piece set of jewelry in every delivery, along with a cute postcard explaining the inspiration behind the design. mintMONGOOSE also lets you indicate your preference for metal tone (silver, gold, or rose gold) and whether or not you'd like to include earrings in your set. You won't pay more than $30/month, and you'll save if you prepay for a longer subscription. While we can't give mintMONGOOSE one of our highest ratings due to a lack of more recent reviews from customers, this is an affordable option you could try for a month and see if you like what you get.
Champaign Jewelers
With Brilliant Box from Champaign Jewelers, you get access to your own personal jewelry stylist who hand-selects pieces based on your preferences. Whether you're into rose gold, sterling silver, or 14K gold, they'll curate items that match your style. Although it's not technically a subscription anymore, you can still work with the "Sparkle Squad" to create a similar experience. Priced between $225 and $2,000 per box, each tier offers a selection of high-quality jewelry with a retail value ranging from $350 to $2800+. While there isn't direct feedback for the Brilliant Box, customers praise the team at Champaign Jewelers for their helpfulness and creativity. Although this isn't a traditional subscription (hence the just-average rating here), the personalized service and exquisite pieces are sure to deliver a memorable jewelry experience.
Rocksbox
Owned by Signet Jewelers (the same parent company as Kay, Jared, and James Allen, among others), Rocksbox puts a different spin on jewelry subscription boxes: you're renting three pieces of designer jewelry each month, and your monthly fee is a credit that can be used towards purchasing anything you fall in love with. While we like the idea in theory, and we really appreciate how detailed Rocksbox lets you get with your style profile, numerous subscribers say that this company overpromises and underdelivers. People report getting jewelry that's in very used condition, feeling pressured to buy pieces they don't want to keep, and having a hard time canceling their subscription. With so many options on our list that get much more love from subscribers (and without the hassle of renting what they send), Rocksbox earns a lower rating in our review.
Cate & Chloe
With Cate & Chloe's VIP Jewelry Subscription Box, you'll receive three pieces of costume jewelry in every delivery, ranging from necklaces to bracelets and earrings, most with a focus on sparkly diamond-type designs. Priced at $59.99 per month, you'll pay roughly $20 per item, with shipping included, and with slight savings possible if you prepay for a set subscription term. However, we have concerns regarding the quality of the jewelry and customer service. While some pieces in the a la carte shop receive high ratings, others are described as feeling like plastic and falling apart easily. Customer service responsiveness is lacking, with unanswered requests for help and shoppers reporting trouble getting exchanges. We've also got our doubts about the company's identity and product claims. Earning a below-average rating, Cate & Chloe's subscription may be a disappointment. You'll get better value and service elsewhere.
Continued from above...
Subscriptions cater to different price points, with some focusing on high-quality, fine jewelry crafted from precious metals and gemstones, while others offer fashion-forward pieces made from less expensive materials. Consider your budget and whether you're looking to invest in timeless pieces or experiment with trendy accessories.
Some subscriptions operate on a rental model, allowing you to borrow and return pieces for a monthly fee, usually with the option to purchase items you've tried and loved at a discounted price. Decide whether you prefer the flexibility of renting or the ownership of purchasing, taking into account your wear frequency and desire for variety.
And let's not forget gift-giving. For that special someone who seems to have everything, you can always set up a jewelry subscription box for the next birthday or anniversary. Most services let you enter a gift message and let you pay upfront for the whole length of the membership, without having it automatically renew when the subscription ends.
Not sure which one to choose? There are so many great options. Here are five criteria you can use to zero in on which jewelry subscription box is right for you (or for your lucky recipient):
- Quality of jewelry. Whether you're going for fine jewelry, demi-fine jewelry, or just fun costume pieces, you still want it to be well made.
- Cost and value. Consider the price of the subscription relative to the quality and quantity of jewelry received, as well as any additional perks or benefits offered.
- Flexibility. Evaluate the subscription options available, including frequency of deliveries, ability to skip months, and ease of cancellation.
- Style. Check out what the subscription shows from previous boxes. Are those pieces a good fit with your personal style? How likely are you to love what comes in each box, month after month?
- Customer satisfaction. Are people happy with the jewelry they receive and with the overall service of the jewelry subscription? Can people leave reviews for the company and for the individual pieces? Does the subscription have a good reputation? Has anyone had trouble canceling the subscription when the time comes?
Whether you're trying to add some flair and fun to your everyday look or to get some new statement pieces in the rotation for your work wardrobe, jewelry subscription boxes are a great way to do it. To help you pick the right one, the experts at Top Consumer Reviews have researched and ranked some of today's most popular memberships. We hope you'll find the right one to elevate your accessory collection and express your unique personality!
Jewelry Subscription Box FAQ
Compare Jewelry Subscription Boxes
Select any 2 Jewelry Subscription Boxes to compare them head to head
Trending Jewelry Subscription Box News
Related Jewelry Subscription Box Reviews
Since you're interested in Jewelry Subscription Boxes, here are some other reviews you might find interesting.
Newest Reviews
