Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

Blue Nile Review

Thursday, June 20th

2024 Lab Grown Diamond Store Reviews

Blue Nile Review 3.5 Star Rating

Blue Nile

3.5 Star Rating
  • Over 22,000 lab-grown loose diamonds to choose from, priced from $900 to $33,000+
  • Wide range of diamond settings for engagement rings
  • Small selection of lab-grown diamond earrings, bracelets, and necklaces beyond engagement rings
  • Free shipping on all orders in the US, including complimentary overnight on orders over $1,000
  • Free virtual consultations
  • 30-day returns, no charge for return shipping
  • In business for 20+ years
  • "A+" rated and accredited by the BBB

Since its start in 1999, Blue Nile has served over two million customers with nearly five million unique pieces of jewelry. Originally an online-only jewelry store, Blue Nile has grown to include retail locations in 17 states.

Get a discount if you subscribe to messages

Like many online jewelry stores, Blue Nile offers a pop-up discount if you register your email address. It's a little less generous than their rivals, though: just $50 off a purchase of $1,000 or more.

Very limited designs for ready-made jewelry

That discount isn't the only thing that's limited at Blue Nile. This jeweler's selection of ready-to-ship lab-grown diamond jewelry caught us off guard with how few choices there were. When you click on Eternity Rings, Pendants, Stud Earrings, Anniversary Rings, or Tennis Bracelets, you'll be taken to exactly ONE design of each. Yes, you can tweak things by specifying the total carat weight, but that's it. If you want any other style, or you prefer rose gold to white gold, sorry - Blue Nile just isn't going to offer that.

Great for lab-grown diamond engagement rings

But, if you're shopping for a loose man-made diamond to make into an engagement ring, Blue Nile's got you covered with over 22,000 stones to choose from. They range in price from just under $900 to $33,000+. You can purchase the stone alone or have it in a setting: when you select the diamond you want, you can either add it to your basket or save it for a ring, and then you'll be shown all of the settings that are a suitable match. You can move the image around to see a 360 degree view of the stone at any angle, or set up a virtual appointment to get a one-on-one consultation with a Blue Nile diamond expert to ask questions and get guidance in selecting the perfect piece.

Best Lab Grown Diamonds

Generous customer benefits

Blue Nile has quite a few free perks to offer customers. Those include free secure shipping on all orders, free returns within 30 days (they pay the shipping on what you send back), free lifetime warranty (manufacturing defects only), and free upgraded packaging (like presentation boxes for engagement rings and cloth pouches for smaller jewelry pieces). You can also take advantage of Blue Nile's price matching and diamond upgrade program.

Consistently ranks high with shoppers

What do customers say about the Blue Nile experience? The Better Business Bureau reports good things, giving the jeweler an "A+" rating and accreditation with only 18 complaints filed there over the last 12 months. Both on the BBB site and in other places you might look, expect Blue Nile to average at least 4 out of 5 stars in shopper ratings. Most people praise the quality of the jewelry, saying it lives up perfectly to expectations, and that customer service is typically on point.

Larger selection would be nice

So why doesn't Blue Nile land higher in our rankings? It mostly comes down to selection. If you're buying a lab-grown diamond specifically for an engagement ring, you're going to love what this jewelry store offers. On the other hand, if you were hoping to have several designs of earrings to choose from - not just studs but hoops and dangles, for example - or a broad array of bracelet styles besides tennis, Blue Nile's lab-grown diamond jewelry inventory will leave you disappointed. For that, you'll need to shop elsewhere, and that keeps Blue Nile from a top rating - at least within the category of lab-created diamonds.

Where Can You Find the Best Lab Grown Diamonds?

Lab-grown diamonds, also known as synthetic or cultured diamonds, are man-made gemstones that are created in a laboratory environment using advanced technological processes that mimic the natural conditions under which diamonds form in the earth's mantle.

Sounds pretty technical, but the amazing thing is that these diamonds are essentially identical in chemical, physical, and optical properties to natural diamonds mined from the earth. They are also graded on the same 4Cs scale used for natural diamonds, which stands for cut, clarity, color, and carat weight. All of the same sparkle factor? Yes, please!

The Best Lab Grown Diamond Stores Compare Lab Grown Diamond Stores Compare Lab Grown Diamond Store Reviews What are the best Lab Grown Diamond Stores Best Lab Grown Diamond Store Reviews

Lab Grown Diamond Store FAQ

Lab-created diamonds are gemstones that are grown in a laboratory instead of being mined from the earth. They have the same chemical, physical, and optical properties as natural diamonds.
Yes! They have the same characteristics as natural diamonds and can only be distinguished from natural diamonds using specialized equipment. Your lucky recipient - or your friends at girls' night - will never know.
Lab-created diamonds are usually considered more ethical than natural diamonds because they are not associated with environmental destruction or human rights abuses. However, the environmental impact of producing lab-created diamonds and the working conditions of lab workers may also be factors to consider.
Yes, lab-created diamonds are typically less expensive than natural diamonds of the same quality and size. This is because the cost of producing lab-created diamonds is lower than mining natural diamonds.
Unfortunately, no. These man-made gemstones have lower resale value than natural diamonds because they are not as rare. However, this may change as lab-created diamonds become more popular and widely accepted in the jewelry industry.
Lab-created diamonds are made using two different methods: High Pressure High Temperature (HPHT) and Chemical Vapor Deposition (CVD). HPHT mimics the natural diamond formation process by subjecting a small diamond seed to high temperature and pressure. CVD uses a gas mixture to deposit carbon atoms onto a diamond seed, which eventually grows into a diamond.
100%. They have the same hardness, toughness, and resistance to scratching and chipping.
Absolutely! They are a popular and ethical alternative to natural diamonds and offer the same beauty and durability. It's a great way to get a stunning ring at a much lower price than you'd spend for jewelry with natural gemstones. And unless you tell her (or him), your intended will never know the difference.
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

Better yet, lab-grown diamonds are generally less expensive than natural stones of the same size and quality. And, if you've ever been concerned by the idea of "blood diamonds" , lab-grown stones are perfect for you: they don't involve the environmentally damaging (and often unethical) practices associated with natural diamond mining.

However, lab-grown diamonds have a few small drawbacks. One major concern is that they may not hold their value over time as well as natural diamonds, since they aren't as rare or unique. Additionally, some people may prefer the idea of owning a natural diamond as a symbol of their love or commitment - even if lab-created stones are undetectable as such to the average person's eye.

When you realize that some jewelers offering lab-grown diamonds have an inventory of over 100,000 stones to choose from, you might feel a little overwhelmed. Take a deep breath, try to enjoy the process a little, and use these ideas to make your shopping easier:

  • Filters. The quickest way to narrow down thousands upon thousands of choices is through smart use of filters. Most sites will let you select your preferred stone shape (round, oval, heart, pear) and set a price range. If you already know what clarity or color parameters you'll accept, indicate those as well.
  • Consultations. It can be confusing to create an engagement ring or other custom piece of jewelry, or even to understand the ins and outs of lab-grown diamonds. Some retailers offer consultations, either virtually via video call or in-person at a location near you. Take advantage of this service if you're feeling nervous or you just want an extra set of eyes to look over your design or purchase.
  • Customer benefits. Know what to expect with any jewelry store you're considering. How long will you have to make a return if the "Will you marry me?" doesn't get a "yes" answer, or if those earrings just don't look as good in person as they did online? What's the warranty coverage? Is there a price match guarantee if you find a similar lab-created diamond somewhere else?
  • Reputation. Other shoppers' feedback is a great way to gauge if a retailer of lab-grown diamond jewelry is doing a good job. Check out customer photos of the rings, bracelets, and so on: how do they look in the "real world" ? Is there any pattern of complaints? Has the store received a favorable grade from the Better Business Bureau?

Shopping for jewelry made with lab-grown diamonds can be an exhilarating experience, and Top Consumer Reviews has evaluated and ranked today's most popular retailers to give you an advantage as you browse. We hope this information helps take the edge off any nervousness you might be feeling, so that you can find - or create - the perfect piece of jewelry for that proposal, anniversary, or "just because" moment.

Compare Lab Grown Diamond Stores

Select any 2 Lab Grown Diamond Stores to compare them head to head

best-lab-grown-diamonds
  • James Allen
  • Grown Brilliance
  • Ritani
  • 12FIFTEEN
  • VRAI
  • Blue Nile
  • Brilliant Earth
  • Zales
  • Reeds Jewelers
  • Helzberg Diamonds
  • Kay Jewelers
  • Jared
James Allen vs Grown Brilliance James Allen vs Ritani James Allen vs 12FIFTEEN James Allen vs VRAI James Allen vs Blue Nile James Allen vs Brilliant Earth James Allen vs Zales James Allen vs Reeds Jewelers James Allen vs Helzberg Diamonds James Allen vs Kay Jewelers James Allen vs Jared Grown Brilliance vs Ritani Grown Brilliance vs 12FIFTEEN Grown Brilliance vs VRAI Grown Brilliance vs Blue Nile Grown Brilliance vs Brilliant Earth Grown Brilliance vs Zales Grown Brilliance vs Reeds Jewelers Grown Brilliance vs Helzberg Diamonds Grown Brilliance vs Kay Jewelers Grown Brilliance vs Jared Ritani vs 12FIFTEEN Ritani vs VRAI Ritani vs Blue Nile Ritani vs Brilliant Earth Ritani vs Zales Ritani vs Reeds Jewelers Ritani vs Helzberg Diamonds Ritani vs Kay Jewelers Ritani vs Jared 12FIFTEEN vs VRAI 12FIFTEEN vs Blue Nile 12FIFTEEN vs Brilliant Earth 12FIFTEEN vs Zales 12FIFTEEN vs Reeds Jewelers 12FIFTEEN vs Helzberg Diamonds 12FIFTEEN vs Kay Jewelers 12FIFTEEN vs Jared VRAI vs Blue Nile VRAI vs Brilliant Earth VRAI vs Zales VRAI vs Reeds Jewelers VRAI vs Helzberg Diamonds VRAI vs Kay Jewelers VRAI vs Jared Blue Nile vs Brilliant Earth Blue Nile vs Zales Blue Nile vs Reeds Jewelers Blue Nile vs Helzberg Diamonds Blue Nile vs Kay Jewelers Blue Nile vs Jared Brilliant Earth vs Zales Brilliant Earth vs Reeds Jewelers Brilliant Earth vs Helzberg Diamonds Brilliant Earth vs Kay Jewelers Brilliant Earth vs Jared Zales vs Reeds Jewelers Zales vs Helzberg Diamonds Zales vs Kay Jewelers Zales vs Jared Reeds Jewelers vs Helzberg Diamonds Reeds Jewelers vs Kay Jewelers Reeds Jewelers vs Jared Helzberg Diamonds vs Kay Jewelers Helzberg Diamonds vs Jared Kay Jewelers vs Jared
Compare the Best Lab Grown Diamond Stores
- VS -
Review the Best Lab Grown Diamond Stores
The Best Reviews of Lab Grown Diamond Stores