Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

The Lobster Guy Review

Monday, October 25th

2021 Lobster Company Reviews

Top Consumer Reviews Best-In-Class Blue Ribbon Award The Lobster Guy Review 5 Star Rating

The Lobster Guy

5 Star Rating
  • Cost: Two 1.25- lb. live lobsters: $31.99
  • Shipping: $40
Top Consumer Reviews Best-In-Class Blue Ribbon Award

At first glance, The Lobster Guy doesn't look like the most polished store on the market - you might even wonder if it's legitimate! But, if you want the freshest lobster at the best prices, backed by a customer service team that has thousands of happy clients, you won't want to miss everything Captain Tim (AKA "The Lobster Guy") has to offer.

Best Pricing

You'll find the absolute best pricing on lobsters when you shop on this site. We looked at how much each retailer in our review charged for two live lobsters of approximately 1-1.5 lbs., including shipping, and The Lobster Guy came in first place at just over $70. That doesn't take into account the 10% discount we spotted, prominently featured at the top of the site. And, this company will price match if you find a lower price somewhere else (but we doubt you will!).

Tons Of Options

Not in the mood to prepare a live lobster? No problem! This store has tons of options, from whole cooked lobsters to tails, or even just the meat itself. Want to go bigger? Be sure to check out the Lobster Dinners section of the site and see how much your mouth waters as you browse what Captain Tim has. Here are just a few ideas to get your stomach growling:

  • Lobster Shore Dinner: for $126.99 (free shipping), you'll get two 1.25-lb. live Maine lobsters, fresh littleneck clams, lobster bisque and clam chowder. The Classic Maine Lobster Dinner is similar, minus the bisque and with the addition of Maine mussels - for $5 less.
  • Lobster Clam Bake: for $94 (plus shipping), you'll get two 1.25-lb. live lobsters, two quarts of little neck clams, two pieces of sausage wrapped in flounder fillet, two servings of red potatoes/sweet potatoes/onions/corn on the cob, plus two lobster bib and pick sets - complete with cooking tin and instructions!
  • Maine Lobster Seafood Extravaganza Dinner: you'll pay $126.99 (plus shipping) for two 1.25-lb. live Maine lobsters, one pound of sea scallops, a half-pound of hand-picked crab meat, one pound of large cocktail shrimp with an order of Capt. Tim's cocktail sauce, plus one container each of clam chowder and lobster bisque.

Delicious Extras

And, if you really want to make it a meal to remember, don't miss all of The Lobster Guy's extras. Desserts include old favorites like chocolate cake and brownies, plus unique treats like pina colada cake and chocolates in the shape of lobsters and clams. Appetizers abound, from seafood dips to crab or lobster cakes and many more - and don't miss the calamari if you squeal for squid!

Best Lobster Stores

Gifts Made Easy

Of course, you can send anything on the site as a gift, but The Lobster Guy takes it one step further to make it even easier: on every product listing is a checkbox that says, "send this item as a gift certificate". If you're not sure when would be a good day for your lobster to arrive, this is a great way to delight your lucky recipient - without giving them the scare of opening a surprise delivery containing a live animal! (Or, on the less interesting side, you want to make sure they're home to receive the package, so they can get it into the fridge, freezer, or cooking pot!)

Attention To Detail

Let's talk straight: The Lobster Guy isn't the only retailer on the market with low lobster prices. Why buy from him? That's easy - there's no other store that offers those prices AND his attention to detail. We loved reading through hundreds of reviews from customers who have trusted him with their most special occasions, knowing that everything would arrive fresh and exactly on time. Better yet, when there have been any problems - because even Captain Tim can't control the weather or FedEx, or guarantee that every single lobster survives in transit - this company consistently goes above and beyond to make it right in any way they can.

Glowing Reputation

You'll find the same glowing reputation on The Lobster Guy's listing with the Better Business Bureau. The BBB gives this company an "A+" rating as well as accreditation, which is hard to find in the lobster marketplace.

Has It All

The Lobster Guy has it all: competitive prices on ocean-fresh lobster and other seafood, affordable shipping costs, plenty of gift-giving options, dozens of extras like appetizers and accessories, and, best of all, phenomenal customer service. It's easy to see why this retailer earns our first-place ranking, and we can't recommend them more highly for your lobster - or other seafood - purchase.

Where Can You Get the Freshest Lobster on the Market?

Unless you happen to live right on the coast, you may feel stumped trying to answer that question. In the past, many supermarkets had a tank of live lobsters ready to take home and prepare for a superlative meal. You're not likely to find that today, even at specialty grocery stores.

They say that you can buy anything online, and fortunately that applies to lobster! Yes, that's right: you can buy everything from live lobsters to surf-and-turf packages and have it delivered fresh to your home. (Of course, if you're shipping them live, you might want to warn anyone that could be getting the package off the doorstep!)

The Best Lobster Companies Compare Lobster Companies Compare Lobster Company Reviews What are the best Lobster Companies Best Lobster Company Reviews

Lobster Company FAQ

Crab meat tends to have a sweeter taste than lobster. Crab is usually flaky, while lobster meat is dense.
That depends on if you're cooking a live whole lobster or a precut tail. Most stores that sell lobster will give you instructions for cooking it in several different ways, but most involve putting the live lobster into boiling water, headfirst. (If you prefer a more humane approach, put the live lobster in a freezer for two hours just prior to cooking.)
Yes and no. When you cook a whole lobster, you'll hear a high-pitched sound like a whistle being blown or a scream. That's the sound made as a cooking lobster overheats: it's the air rushing out of the holes in the body. But, that sound happens whether the lobster is alive or dead, so it's not actually screaming.
That's an easy one: it only turns red after you cook it! Most live Maine lobsters are a black-green color, but other varieties can be yellow, calico, blue and white.
The first question is, "Is it really dead?" It might just be sluggish after being shipped, so try touching its eye and see if it responds (weird, right?). But yes, you can cook lobster within 8 hours of when it likely died. After you prepare it, check the tail meat: if it's firm, you're good to go. If it's watery, mushy or loose, you should probably throw it out (and request a refund!).
The most traditional way is to dip the meat in melted butter. Other popular options are soups and chowders, pasta (especially ravioli and macaroni), or with steak as a surf-and-turf combo.
Absolutely! Many online retailers have been successfully delivering lobster around the nation for decades. They know exactly how to package your lobster so that it arrives in perfect condition - and most of them have rock-solid satisfaction guarantees if anything happens in transit.
Yes! Some lobster companies specialize in gift-giving options, like surf-and-turf packages or complete dinners with appetizer, main lobster course, and dessert. Almost every online lobster business has gift certificates, so that your lucky recipient can choose their own lobster package and delivery date.
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

There are a number of companies that go above and beyond to deliver ocean-fresh lobster, especially as a one-of-a-kind gift. Why send a boring gift card from a generic online store when you can have everything your lucky recipient needs for a mouthwatering dinner - from the lobster itself to the melted butter, shell crackers and seafood forks, and tasty extras like clam chowder and dessert! Or, you can opt for a gift certificate and let your special someone choose their own lobster package.

As you decide where to buy your lobster online, how can you tell which store should get your business? Here are several factors to consider as you compare your options:

  • Price. For the type of lobster you want - size, quantity, live or precooked, etc. - what will you pay? Is shipping included in that price?
  • Options. Does the retailer carry a variety of choices, both for your own use and for gift-giving? Can you specify the date you want your lobster to arrive? Are you able to get whole lobster live or precooked, or just the tails? What add-ons (e.g. soup, dessert, shell crackers) are offered?
  • Availability. How likely is it that the lobster you want is in stock? Can you order year-round?
  • Reputation. What do other customers say about the lobster from a particular store? Does it arrive fresh and on time? How well does the customer service team handle any problems that arise? Is there a satisfaction guarantee?

TopConsumerReviews.com has reviewed and ranked the best online retailers of Lobster available today. We hope this information helps you get the perfect lobster for your next special meal!

The Best Reviews of Lobster Companies