Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

Bay Alarm Medical vs Medical Guardian

Wednesday, August 17th

2022 Medical Alert System Reviews

Bay Alarm Medical Review 5 Star Rating

Bay Alarm Medical

5 Star Rating
  • "A+" Better Business Bureau rating
  • Extremely high customer ratings
  • 30-day risk free trial
  • Made and monitored in the USA
  • Free ground shipping
  • No hidden fees
  • First month of service free
Top Consumer Reviews Best-In-Class Blue Ribbon Award

Bay Alarm Medical is a fantastic company with useful product options, competitive prices, and sky-high customer reviews. Their prices are transparent and they offer a 30-day trial for all buyers to test out their equipment before committing to month-to-month service. It's easy to get a hold of a team member from Bay Alarm to get any questions answered. This is a place you can confidently buy from and know that you're getting good products as well as the highest-quality service. We have no hesitations in giving Bay Alarm Medical our top rating.

Medical Guardian Review 2.5 Star Rating

Medical Guardian

2.5 Star Rating
  • "A+" Better Business Bureau rating
  • U.S. based monitoring
  • Call for a free month of service
  • On-the-go and in-home products
  • Free shipping

Medical Guardian is comparable to other medical alert systems with their on-the-go and at-home product options for seniors. They list their prices right on their website and offer perks like free shipping and free lockboxes if you sign up for an annual contract. You can cancel service at any time, but many customers report that this is difficult to do. Although they have the equipment and technology most people are looking for in a medical alert system, Medical Guardian doesn't perform well with respect to customer satisfaction, so this is not the most reliable company to select.

What is the Best Place to Purchase a Medical Alert System?

Medical alert systems have grown in popularity over the years due to their ability to get a person life-saving help in the case of an emergency. Many senior citizens prefer to stay in their homes for as long as possible rather than move to a care facility - and that presents certain risks if they aren't being routinely monitored. A medical alert system can quickly contact emergency services in the event of a fall or other unexpected health issue to protect the safety of the wearer 24/7.

Seniors typically wear medical alert systems around their wrist or neck for convenience. Certain companies offer wall or shower-mounted devices as well. Using them is as easy as clicking a single button to get in touch with an operator and reach out for immediate emergency help. As an added safety measure, some systems automatically detect when the wearer has fallen to make sure they aren't left alone when they are unable to press the button.

The Best Medical Alert Systems Compare Medical Alert Systems Compare Medical Alert System Reviews What are the best Medical Alert Systems Best Medical Alert System Reviews

Medical Alert System FAQ

A medical alert system is often used by seniors who want to "age in place" rather than move to an independent/assisted living facility. Using a button on a pendant or wrist strap, they can let loved ones and/or emergency responders know that they need help due to a fall or medical situation.
Most systems on the market include a wearable panic button and round-the-clock remote monitoring. You can choose a plan that covers in-home use only or one that includes coverage when the wearer is out and about.
That depends on the person using the system and what kind of help they might need. Some medical alert systems include automatic fall detection, GPS tracking, and even smartwatch features like heart rate monitoring and tracking health goals.
Pricing varies, but you can anticipate monthly service fees ranging from $19.95 to $56.95 - the higher your coverage, the more you'll pay per month. You'll also need to factor in equipment costs: some service providers let you choose between buying it outright (lower monthly fees) and renting it (higher monthly fees).
Unfortunately, you won't get coverage for a medical alert system through Original Medicare or Medicaid. But, if you have a supplemental insurance plan, you might be able to get a discount. Check with your carrier if this applies to you.
The majority of medical alert systems come with a 30-day trial or money-back guarantee. However, with respect to the equipment, you'll want to read the fine print to understand your provider's terms if something goes wrong with your panic button or with any other devices down the line.
Yes. Very few medical alert providers lock you into a long-term contract. Most often, you'll get a prorated refund for any prepaid months of coverage once you return rented equipment. Plus, you have that initial trial period of 15-30 days that's offered by most medical alert services.
Your best bet is to see what other customers have to say. Look for reviews, preferably on third-party sites not affiliated with the provider. Another great resource is the Better Business Bureau: an "A+" rating and accreditation are good signs that you or your loved one will be well-protected by a particular medical alert service.
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

There are more medical alert options popping up all the time, so it's wise to do your research and make sure you find the best one for you or your loved one. Some tried and true companies have been around for years and have a lot of customer feedback while others are brand new with updated features and technologies.

You'll want to find a company that gives transparent pricing information and makes it as easy as possible to use their device. Medical alert systems are important, and companies shouldn't make your purchase confusing or unnecessarily expensive. Shopping online helps you compare retailers and find your best option.

Since there are many companies that sell medical alert systems, we have provided important information for you to consider when shopping around:

  • Cost: How much will you have to spend for the equipment? What is the price of the ongoing monitoring fees? Are you able to get pricing right away or will the company make you talk to a sales representative beforehand?
  • Contracts: Do you have to commit to a long-term contract in order to sign up for a company's services? Or can you go month-to-month? How easy is it to cancel if you are unsatisfied with the product or no longer need it?
  • Variety of features: Does the medical alert system come with automatic fall detection? How many devices does the company offer to wear and put around your house? Does the product have good range in case the wearer walks outside or happens to fall in a more remote corner of the house?
  • Reputation: What do customers say about their experience with the product and customer service? Does the medical alert system work reliably or have people experienced issues with it? Is the company accredited and rated by the Better Business Bureau?

TopConsumerReviews.com has reviewed and ranked the best places to purchase a medical alert system. We hope this information helps you find the best product to ensure safety and give peace of mind to you or the senior in your life.

Compare Medical Alert Systems

Select any 2 Medical Alert Systems to compare them head to head

best-medical-alert-systems
  • Bay Alarm Medical
  • LifeFone
  • LifeStation
  • MobileHelp
  • ADT
  • Medihill
  • Alert 1
  • Philips Lifeline
  • Medical Guardian
  • Life Alert
  • ResponseLINK
  • Rescue Alert
Bay Alarm Medical vs LifeFone Bay Alarm Medical vs LifeStation Bay Alarm Medical vs MobileHelp Bay Alarm Medical vs ADT Bay Alarm Medical vs Medihill Bay Alarm Medical vs Alert 1 Bay Alarm Medical vs Philips Lifeline Bay Alarm Medical vs Medical Guardian Bay Alarm Medical vs Life Alert Bay Alarm Medical vs ResponseLINK Bay Alarm Medical vs Rescue Alert LifeFone vs LifeStation LifeFone vs MobileHelp LifeFone vs ADT LifeFone vs Medihill LifeFone vs Alert 1 LifeFone vs Philips Lifeline LifeFone vs Medical Guardian LifeFone vs Life Alert LifeFone vs ResponseLINK LifeFone vs Rescue Alert LifeStation vs MobileHelp LifeStation vs ADT LifeStation vs Medihill LifeStation vs Alert 1 LifeStation vs Philips Lifeline LifeStation vs Medical Guardian LifeStation vs Life Alert LifeStation vs ResponseLINK LifeStation vs Rescue Alert MobileHelp vs ADT MobileHelp vs Medihill MobileHelp vs Alert 1 MobileHelp vs Philips Lifeline MobileHelp vs Medical Guardian MobileHelp vs Life Alert MobileHelp vs ResponseLINK MobileHelp vs Rescue Alert ADT vs Medihill ADT vs Alert 1 ADT vs Philips Lifeline ADT vs Medical Guardian ADT vs Life Alert ADT vs ResponseLINK ADT vs Rescue Alert Medihill vs Alert 1 Medihill vs Philips Lifeline Medihill vs Medical Guardian Medihill vs Life Alert Medihill vs ResponseLINK Medihill vs Rescue Alert Alert 1 vs Philips Lifeline Alert 1 vs Medical Guardian Alert 1 vs Life Alert Alert 1 vs ResponseLINK Alert 1 vs Rescue Alert Philips Lifeline vs Medical Guardian Philips Lifeline vs Life Alert Philips Lifeline vs ResponseLINK Philips Lifeline vs Rescue Alert Medical Guardian vs Life Alert Medical Guardian vs ResponseLINK Medical Guardian vs Rescue Alert Life Alert vs ResponseLINK Life Alert vs Rescue Alert ResponseLINK vs Rescue Alert
Compare the Best Medical Alert Systems
- VS -
Review the Best Medical Alert Systems
See the Best Medical Alert System
The Best Reviews of Medical Alert Systems