Medicare Advantage Plans Reviews

Best Medicare Advantage Plans in New York

We've analyzed the best Medicare Advantage Plans to help you find the right solution for your needs.

The Best Medicare Advantage Plans in New York

Where can I find the best Medicare Advantage Plans in New York? New York has you hopping between errands, so you'll probably want to check Medicare Advantage options online when you've got a quiet minute. You can plug in your ZIP, pull up plan details, and sort by your doctors or prescriptions without trekking to multiple offices. You'll usually spot $0-premium options alongside plans with richer extras, and you can preview provider networks before you even pick up the phone. If you split time between boroughs and upstate, you can still filter by county so the results actually fit your routine.

The Best Medicare Advantage Plans in New York

5.0

EXCELLENT

1

Best Option

  • Quoted prices $0 to $202 monthly premium
  • $58.73 to $110.59/month in prescriptions
  • Coverage in all 50 states

Read Full Review

EXCELLENT

5.0

On the eHealth website

4.5

GREAT

2

Great

  • Quoted prices $0 to $169 monthly premium
  • $0 to $47/month in prescriptions
  • Broker for insurance

Read Full Review

GREAT

4.5

On the SmartMatch website

4.0

VERY GOOD

3

Very Good

  • Quoted monthly prices from $0 to $168
  • $47/month in prescriptions
  • Helpful online resources

Read Full Review

VERY GOOD

4.0

On the SelectQuote website

3.9

VERY GOOD

4

Very Good

  • Quoted prices $0 to $202 monthly premium
  • $45 to $47/month in prescriptions
  • Online quotes available

Read Full Review

VERY GOOD

3.9

On the Blue Cross Blue Shield website

3.5

GOOD

5

Good

  • Quoted prices $0 to $19 monthly premium
  • $61.85 to $153.89/month in prescriptions
  • Sells its own insurance

Read Full Review

GOOD

3.5

On the Aetna website

3.0

AVERAGE

6

Average

  • Quoted monthly prices from $0 to $138
  • $61.85 to $157.91/month in prescriptions
  • Sells its own insurance

Read Full Review

AVERAGE

3.0

On the Humana website

2.0

SUBPAR

7

Subpar

  • Quoted prices $0 to $34 monthly premium
  • $68.26 to $84.41/month in prescriptions
  • Standalone provider with its own insurance

Read Full Review

SUBPAR

2.0

On the United Healthcare website

1.5

WEAK

8

Weak

  • Quoted prices $0 monthly premium
  • $91.85/month in prescriptions
  • Online quotes available

Read Full Review

WEAK

1.5

On the Cigna website

1.0

POOR

9

Poor

  • Prices based on other companies
  • Broker model

Read Full Review

POOR

1.0

On the HealthCare website

0.9

POOR

10

Poor

  • Broker model
  • Coverage in all 50 states
  • Online resources

Read Full Review

POOR

0.9

On the GoHealth website

Continued from above...

Where Can I Find the Best Medicare Advantage Plans in New York?

New York has you hopping between errands, so you'll probably want to check Medicare Advantage options online when you've got a quiet minute. You can plug in your ZIP, pull up plan details, and sort by your doctors or prescriptions without trekking to multiple offices. You'll usually spot $0-premium options alongside plans with richer extras, and you can preview provider networks before you even pick up the phone. If you split time between boroughs and upstate, you can still filter by county so the results actually fit your routine.

In Buffalo, you could see one mix of HMO and PPO options, while a search tied to Syracuse might show a different lineup because benefits and networks vary by county. You can time your move during the Annual Enrollment Period - October 15 through December 7 - or use the January 1 through March 31 Medicare Advantage Open Enrollment if you already have an MA plan and want a one-time switch. New York also gives you Special Enrollment if you qualify for Extra Help or Medicaid, or if you move. You can scan plan summaries online to confirm prescription tiers, copays for specialists, and dental or vision allowances before you commit.

You might notice star badges next to plan names, and you can use those - CMS posts Star Ratings from 2 to 5 - to quickly gauge quality. In New York, you can usually find multiple 4-star choices, and you can click through to see preventive care scores, member experience, and drug safety measures. You can also check each plan's maximum out-of-pocket, since every Medicare Advantage plan sets one, and that cap matters once appointments start to add up. If your medications are pricey, you can look into New York's EPIC program alongside Extra Help, because those can lower your Part D costs inside many MA-PD options.

Meanwhile, when you're bouncing between Rochester and Yonkers to see family, you might prefer a PPO that could give you out-of-network flexibility, while an HMO might suit you if your doctors all sit inside one system near home. You can verify prior-authorization rules, referral requirements, and telehealth benefits right on the plan pages - that saves you surprise headaches after enrollment. You can also look for add-ons like OTC cards and dental cleanings, which show up clearly in New York plan comparisons. If you'd rather talk it through, you can line up a free counseling session with New York's HIICAP, then hop back online to enroll once you've made your call.

If all of this sounds like a lot, don't worry. We've got your back. To simplify the process of finding Medicare Advantage Plans that are worth your time, we've put together a few criteria that might help you sort it all out:

To help you keep it simple and focus on your health and well-being, Top Consumer Reviews has reviewed and ranked the best Medicare Advantage Plans available today. This way, you can save time and money as you join (or change to) a new plan. We hope our research will help you find the best deals, the friendliest reps, and the top coverage so you can enjoy your golden years stress-free!

Slide Down Image Left Slide Image FAQ Image Slide Image Twirl Image

Medicare Advantage Plan FAQ

What is Medicare Advantage?
Medicare Advantage Plans are a way of getting your Medicare Part A and Part B coverage through private companies approved by Medicare. These insurers have to follow specific rules in order to participate. These plans typically operate with an HMO or PPO structure, requiring you to use in-network providers for maximum benefits. Some customers appreciate getting their services bundled from an insurance company they already trust, often with extra benefits not found with Original Medicare.
Who is eligible to get a Medicare Advantage plan?
If you have Medicare Part A and Part B, and there's a plan that is available where you live, you're eligible for Medicare Advantage. Bear in mind that Advantage policies are almost always network-based: if you live in another state during the year, your plan may not offer benefits in both places.
Are there any deadlines I should be aware of?
Yes! You can enroll in a Medicare Advantage plan either when you first sign up for Medicare A & B or during the yearly enrollment period from October 15 through December 7. Once you're enrolled in a plan, you can switch to a different one or back to Original Medicare from January 1 through March 31. There are also special enrollment periods for certain life events, like moving to a different address, losing your current coverage, or your contract not being renewed.
What's the difference between Advantage and Medigap?
There are many differences between these two types of additional Medicare coverage. Medicare Supplement Plans, or Medigap, are designed to pay the out-of-pocket costs not paid by Medicare itself. These plans don't include prescription drugs, tend to have higher premiums than Advantage coverage, and you'll pay more if you don't enroll early on in your Medicare coverage. On the other hand, Medicare Advantage Plans are usually much lower in premiums and higher in out-of-pocket costs. Advantage policies often have prescription drug benefits. But, Medicare Advantage doesn't pay any of the costs that original Medicare doesn't cover. You can't be enrolled in both a Medigap plan and an Advantage plan at the same time.
Will dental, vision and/or hearing coverage be included?
That depends on the plan you select. However, one of the reasons Advantage plans are so attractive is because many of them do include dental, vision, or hearing benefits - or all three!
Will prescription drugs be covered?
That also depends on the plan you choose. Almost every Medicare Advantage plan will still have out-of-pocket costs for prescriptions. When getting a quote, have your medications handy: many online quote platforms and insurance brokers will ask for the name and dosage, to provide you with an accurate estimate of what you'll spend for those specific prescriptions with a given Advantage policy.
How much will I likely pay in premiums?
Believe it or not, there are Medicare Advantage policies that have $0 monthly premiums. Of course, you get what you pay for - and if you want broader coverage and lower deductibles/out-of-pocket costs, your premiums will be higher.
Should I buy my Medicare Advantage plan through a broker or directly from the insurer?
That's a matter of preference. But, it can be helpful to start your search by using a website that offers quotes from multiple insurers, so that you can get a feel for what's available in your area. Many of these referring websites can walk you through the entire application process with any company you select, without pressuring you to choose one over another. On the other hand, if you already know which insurer you want - or maybe there's only one available where you live - there's nothing wrong with getting your plan right from the insurance company.

Compare Any 2 Products

eHealth
SmartMatch
SelectQuote
Blue Cross Blue Shield
Aetna
Humana
United Healthcare
Cigna
HealthCare
GoHealth
vs
eHealth vs SmartMatcheHealth vs SelectQuoteeHealth vs Blue Cross Blue ShieldeHealth vs AetnaeHealth vs HumanaeHealth vs United HealthcareeHealth vs CignaeHealth vs HealthCareeHealth vs GoHealthSmartMatch vs SelectQuoteSmartMatch vs Blue Cross Blue ShieldSmartMatch vs AetnaSmartMatch vs HumanaSmartMatch vs United HealthcareSmartMatch vs CignaSmartMatch vs HealthCareSmartMatch vs GoHealthSelectQuote vs Blue Cross Blue ShieldSelectQuote vs AetnaSelectQuote vs HumanaSelectQuote vs United HealthcareSelectQuote vs CignaSelectQuote vs HealthCareSelectQuote vs GoHealthBlue Cross Blue Shield vs AetnaBlue Cross Blue Shield vs HumanaBlue Cross Blue Shield vs United HealthcareBlue Cross Blue Shield vs CignaBlue Cross Blue Shield vs HealthCareBlue Cross Blue Shield vs GoHealthAetna vs HumanaAetna vs United HealthcareAetna vs CignaAetna vs HealthCareAetna vs GoHealthHumana vs United HealthcareHumana vs CignaHumana vs HealthCareHumana vs GoHealthUnited Healthcare vs CignaUnited Healthcare vs HealthCareUnited Healthcare vs GoHealthCigna vs HealthCareCigna vs GoHealthHealthCare vs GoHealth GoHealth vs HealthCareGoHealth vs CignaGoHealth vs United HealthcareGoHealth vs HumanaGoHealth vs AetnaGoHealth vs Blue Cross Blue ShieldGoHealth vs SelectQuoteGoHealth vs SmartMatchGoHealth vs eHealthHealthCare vs CignaHealthCare vs United HealthcareHealthCare vs HumanaHealthCare vs AetnaHealthCare vs Blue Cross Blue ShieldHealthCare vs SelectQuoteHealthCare vs SmartMatchHealthCare vs eHealthCigna vs United HealthcareCigna vs HumanaCigna vs AetnaCigna vs Blue Cross Blue ShieldCigna vs SelectQuoteCigna vs SmartMatchCigna vs eHealthUnited Healthcare vs HumanaUnited Healthcare vs AetnaUnited Healthcare vs Blue Cross Blue ShieldUnited Healthcare vs SelectQuoteUnited Healthcare vs SmartMatchUnited Healthcare vs eHealthHumana vs AetnaHumana vs Blue Cross Blue ShieldHumana vs SelectQuoteHumana vs SmartMatchHumana vs eHealthAetna vs Blue Cross Blue ShieldAetna vs SelectQuoteAetna vs SmartMatchAetna vs eHealthBlue Cross Blue Shield vs SelectQuoteBlue Cross Blue Shield vs SmartMatchBlue Cross Blue Shield vs eHealthSelectQuote vs SmartMatchSelectQuote vs eHealthSmartMatch vs eHealth
See the Best Medicare Advantage Plans in Your State
Only the Best Reviews

The Motley Fool on ...

3 things you need to know about Medicare Advantage's open enrollment ...

During Medicare Advantage's open enrollment period, you can make one change to your coverage only. You can either switch to a different Medicare Advantage plan, or you can drop Medicare Advantage and ...

Sat, 17 Jan 2026

Only the Best Reviews

Los Angeles Magazine

Kaiser Permanente Hit With $556M Medicare Fraud Settlement

The healthcare giant agreed to a $556 million settlement over claims it overstated illnesses to increase Medicare Advantage reimbursements.

Tue, 20 Jan 2026

Only the Best Reviews

The Motley Fool on ...

Medicare Advantage will officially exclude these items in 2026

In 2026, the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) is imposing new restrictions on what's covered. The Medicare Advantage plan is a popular alternative to original Medicare, as it often ...

Thu, 15 Jan 2026

Only the Best Reviews

MedPage Today

Kaiser Permanente to Pay $556 Million in Record Medicare Advantage ...

In the largest Medicare Advantage fraud settlement to date, Kaiser Permanente (KP) has agreed to pay $556 million to settle Justice Department allegations that it billed the government for medical ...

Fri, 16 Jan 2026

Only the Best Reviews

Yahoo

Medicare Advantage overpayments will total $76B this year: MedPAC

The findings are “very depressing,” one commissioner said. Still, it’s a smaller sum than in 2025, thanks to the continued phase-in of a new risk adjustment model.

Fri, 16 Jan 2026

Only the Best Reviews

WBIW

What the 2026 Medicare Advantage changes mean for seniors

In January 2026, the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) implemented new restrictions that roll back parts of a 2018 expansion allowing Medicare ...

Tue, 13 Jan 2026

Top Products.  

Top Reviews.  

Top Consumer Reviews.

Reviews 

Browse through thousands of reviews.

Social Media 

Like us?  Follow us!  We'd love to have you join our community.

Newsletter 

Stay up to date with the latest reviews. We'll keep you informed, and we'll never sell your information to anyone.