Here you can see how Go Medigap (eHealth) and Aetna match up head-to-head in a battle for the Best Medicare Supplement Plans in 2026.
Operating since 2005, the company known as GoMedigap (now part of eHealth) w orks under the name eHealth, though it is the same site. The company offers a comprehensive range of Medicare Supplement Plans, serving over 35,000 seniors nationwide. While the slower quote process and potential hidden fees are concerns, the impressive user reviews and reputation of the company make up for those concerns completely. eHealth's Rate Watch feature, proactive monitoring of premiums, and ethical practices contribute to its "A+" rating from the BBB and numerous 5-star reviews, earning it a trustworthy rating.
Aetna, with over 160 years of insurance experience, is a reliable choice for Medicare Supplement Plans. The company offers next-day coverage initiation for Plan G, stands out for transparent online quotes, and provides competitive premiums. However, detailed plan information is lacking online, requiring a call for accurate pricing information. Aetna serves 21 states, and its customer service is available 7 days a week. While the pricing is competitive, some transparency issues and customer complaints impact the overall rating. Still, they remain a competitive option overall.
If you or a family member is nearing 65 - or if you'll qualify for Medicare Parts A and B for other reasons - now's a great time to explore extra coverage for your Medicare. Original Medicare covers a lot, but it doesn't pay for everything. That's where a Medicare Supplement plan - often called "Medigap" - can help pick up the costs that slip through the cracks. Take a moment to compare benefits, premiums, and enrollment windows now so you're set up before bills arrive.
These plans help close the gap left by Medicare - the roughly 20% of costs it doesn't cover - so you pay less out of pocket and feel more confident about your coverage. They act as a safety net for copays, coinsurance, and deductibles, and you can choose options that fit your budget and health needs.
Medicare Supplement plans are labeled by letters to tell them apart, and that alone can be confusing. The lineup keeps changing, so it's no wonder people get turned around when a longtime favorite like Plan F - closed to new enrollees after January 1, 2020 - gives way to Plan G, which offers similar benefits but leaves you with an annual deductible. Keeping up with these shifts helps you focus on the coverage you truly need and avoid what you don't. It's also smart to revisit your options each year - and ask questions - so your coverage keeps pace with your health and budget.
As you plan your Medicare path, keep the guaranteed-issue window on your radar - the six months after your 65th birthday when you can enroll in a Medicare Supplement plan with nothing more than paying the premium. It's a brief but important opportunity, and missing it may mean medical underwriting, fewer options, or higher costs later. Set a reminder now so you don't let that window slip by.
In practical terms, you can't be turned away for existing conditions during the six-month window, but smokers should expect to pay more. After that grace period ends, insurers can dig deeper into your health history - for example, asking about diabetes or heart disease - and those details may raise your premiums or limit which plans you can choose. It's wise to review your options before the deadline so you're ready for any added questions.
Buying a Medicare Supplement plan usually comes down to two routes: go straight to an insurance company or work through a broker. Sticking with a carrier you already know can feel simple - you keep a relationship you trust and may find the lower rates or reliable claims support you're used to. A broker, on the other hand, opens up the wider market so you can compare plans and prices side by side, including quotes from your preferred insurer. Before you choose, think about whether you want a single familiar contact or a broader view of options, and take a moment to weigh customer service, financial strength, and how rates have changed over time.
Whether you go through a broker or buy directly from an insurer, the real key to choosing a Medicare Supplement plan is doing your homework. You can start by browsing different carriers' websites to get a sense of pricing and plan options, but Medicare rules mean these policies must ultimately be sold in person or over the phone, so you'll need to speak with a representative to complete enrollment. As you compare, jot down quotes and ask about household discounts and underwriting rules - identical standardized benefits can be priced very differently from one company to the next.
If you're not sure where to start with your Medicare Supplement Plan, we've put together a few things that might help you narrow down your options:
To help you stress less about your Medicare plans, Top Consumer Reviews has reviewed and ranked the best Medicare Supplement Plans available today. This way, you can save both time and money in your search. All you need to worry about is finding the best provider using our handy list and detailed reviews and getting back to enjoying your golden years stress-free!
Compare Any 2 Products
Top Products.
Top Reviews.
Top Consumer Reviews.
Reviews
Browse through thousands of reviews.
Social Media
Like us? Follow us! We'd love to have you join our community.
Newsletter
Stay up to date with the latest reviews. We'll keep you informed, and we'll never sell your information to anyone.