Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.
Tuesday, October 19th
SelectQuote Senior is one of several brokers that refers prospective clients to various insurance companies for Medicare Supplement Plans. You'll get quotes for 20+ different providers through this service, depending on which companies are issuing policies where you live. Those companies may include Aetna, Cigna, Anthem and Humana; all insurers with whom they partner are at least A- rated. The business itself has an "A+" rating and accreditation from the BBB, which means that in the company's 36 years in operation, they've done a good job of treating their clients fairly and honestly.
You'll need to answer a series of questions online in order to look at plans through SelectQuote. These questions include:
From there, you are asked for your zip code, state, first and last name, phone number and email address. Notice that there's a checkbox for you to indicate if you'd like a free copy of "Health Matters: A Guide to Your Medicare Options". It's automatically checked, so be sure to uncheck it if you'd rather not get the guide.
Many providers of Medicare Supplement Plans state in their fine print that you're consenting to receiving lots of calls, texts, or (e)mail when you give them your contact info. SelectQuote Senior only lists three partners that will have permission to contact you, and they specify that you can call their toll-free number directly (855-356-4854) if you'd like to speak with them before providing that kind of information.
Get a call in 15 minutes
Let's say you go ahead and enter your information. What happens next? If it's during regular business hours, you'll get a call within 15 minutes; otherwise, they'll reach out to you the next business day. You may also get some preliminary quotes if you scroll down; we were given options from AARP Medicare Advantage, Medigap, FirstQuoteMedicare, and several others. Unfortunately, clicking to see our rates just redirected us to those companies' sites - where we had to start the process of entering our information and getting quotes all over again.
Quick initial quote
We reached out via SelectQuote's toll-free number (855-318-0531) to get a more accurate idea of the rates for our selected profile: a woman from Wisconsin that just turned 65, no tobacco use, and who was looking for the equivalent of a Plan G. We only had to give the agent our name and zip code to get a quote: no personal details required. After eight minutes on hold (listening to an annoying pinging sound like radar on a submarine!), we were then connected to "an office in our area".
30 minutes later, a transfer to another agent
After apologizing for the inexplicably long wait, the representative took some basic details like name, state and birthdate. It also took quite a while for his computer to load any quotes, which may have been due to his working from home. We were then transferred to a second agent after another long hold because his computer wasn't loading quotes for anyone living in WI. At this point, we had already spent 30 minutes on the phone and hadn't even gotten close to a quote yet. The rep was very apologetic.
Never heard that before
...and then the call got dropped when the first agent passed us to the second one. Fortunately, the second rep called us back, and we were able to get a quote. She too gave us an initial Plan G quote from Aetna, but when we asked her if she was referring to the Aetna Base plus riders to make the Wisconsin coverage equivalent to the Plan G in other states, she said she had never heard that before - and had actually never sold a Plan G supplement in WI.
Got the quote... finally
Her research showed that the premium, including the necessary riders, would be $137.00 for that Aetna plan, and in her system it was called a Part G Equivalent. There was an additional rider to cover travel emergencies in foreign countries, and that would bring the total to $153.50 per month. Both of those have that same $198 annual deductible.
What happens after the coverage has been selected and the premiums have been paid? SelectQuote Senior will keep in touch on an annual basis, and may touch base throughout the year to see how things are going. They will also reach out to their clients if they get wind of any changes and see if a switch in providers or plans might be a good option to consider. We appreciate that kind of service; not every Medicare Supplement Plan broker offers it.
Almost an hour to get our quotes
While it might have just been a temporary technical issue on their end, it's worth noting that the entire process of getting a quote through SelectQuote Senior took the better part of an hour. We found comments from other customers who had the same experience with dropped calls and transfers that went nowhere - over six months prior to our calls to SelectQuote Senior.
Still some strong positives
You might be wondering, then, why this service still gets a relatively high ranking. We can't overlook the company's overall reputation for quality, shown by their BBB rating and thousands of 4-and 5-star ratings from happy clients on independently-verified sites. We appreciate the service they offer after the policy has been selected, and that all of the partner insurers they use have been vetted as reputable options.
If you can get past the technical glitches - and you have the patience for what might turn out to be a long phone call - we recommend that you take a look at what SelectQuote Senior can offer you with respect to Medicare Supplement Plans.
If you or a loved one is approaching the age of 65, or will be qualified for Medicare Parts A and B soon for another reason, it's the ideal time to start shopping around for supplemental coverage.
You are probably already aware that your Medicare insurance pays for most of your costs - but not all. That's why Medicare Supplement plans are often known as "Medigap": they close the distance between the 80% that's covered and the 20% that isn't, so that you have fewer or no out-of-pocket costs.
Medicare Supplement Plans are given letter names, so it can be easy to wind up confused. Plus, plans and their coverage are always changing. For example, Plan F was considered the go-to package, but it was discontinued for anyone starting coverage after January 1, 2020. Its replacement at the time, Plan G, offered similar benefits - fully covering that extra 20% and more - but added an annual deductible to the equation.
Another factor to keep in mind is the "guaranteed issue period". For the six months following your 65th birthday, you can get a Medicare Supplement Plan with no requirements beyond paying your premiums. By law, you can't be excluded for any health conditions, although your premiums will be higher if you're a smoker. But, once that grace period concludes, insurers can require more detailed information about your health conditions such as diabetes or heart conditions, and you can expect your premiums and available plans to change accordingly.
When buying a Medicare Supplement Plan, you have two basic routes: buy directly from an insurance company or go through a broker. Going to an insurance company you already trust can be an appealing option. You'll typically find the best rates for that particular insurer. On the other hand, using a broker often gives you access to not just your favorite insurance company but many others. So, with one process you can get the best rates from a number of providers at the same time - including that rate you got when you contacted the insurance company directly.
Whether you decide to use a broker or to buy directly from an insurance company, it's wise to do your research beforehand. The last thing you want is for an eager rep to steer you towards a plan that doesn't fit your needs, so take the time to browse several providers' websites before getting in touch. However, because Medicare rules state that all plans have to be sold in person or on the phone, you'll eventually have to speak with someone to finalize your Medicare Supplement Plan.
TopConsumerReviews.com has reviewed and ranked the best Medicare Supplement Plans available today. We hope our in-depth evaluations help you save time and money by giving you the information you need to choose the best provider and plan for your needs!
Select any 2 Medicare Supplement Plans to compare them head to head