Who's better?

Sittercity vs GreatAuPair

We've analyzed the best Nanny Agencies to help you find the right solution for your needs.

2025 Nanny Agency Reviews

Here you can see how Sittercity and GreatAuPair match up head-to-head in a battle for the Best Nanny Agencies in 2025.

Winner

Sittercity

  • Hourly rates from $10 to $50
  • Membership fees from $35 to $90 per period (monthly, every 3 months, or annually)
  • Browse a few nannies or let Sittercity pick for you

Sittercity is an online nanny agency that lets you find every type of caregiver, from full-time and part-time nannies to occasional babysitters and newborn specialists. The platform verifies each nanny's identity and lets you customize your search by location, hours, and experience, but you'll need a paid membership to contact candidates directly. While Sittercity has a reasonably high rating on Trustpilot, a "D-" rating from the BBB and complaints about rising membership costs make it a less appealing choice in our review.

GreatAuPair

  • Weekly pricing from $100 to $1,000
  • Nannies reach out to your listings
  • Background checks for all nannies

GreatAuPair connects families with certified au pairs and nannies from around the world, offering background checks in over 300 countries and a secure platform with fraud prevention tools. This nanny agency focuses on cultural exchange programs, allowing families to host live-in caregivers for up to two years. While GreatAuPair has strong safety features and an "A+" BBB rating, poor customer feedback about unreliable caregivers makes it a less dependable choice for finding trusted help.

In today's fast-paced world, more families are turning to nanny agencies to help manage the demands of work, home, and childcare. There's so much that goes into caring for a family, and sometimes having an extra set of hands around to help can make your day-to-day significantly easier.

While in years past, finding a nanny was about going in person or conducting tedious interviews for weeks to find the right fit, nanny agencies offer a much better process. These online platforms put the best nanny options right at your fingertips. These directories often highlight skills, experience, and references so you can find a professional nanny who can create a personalized experience for you, your children, and your family life.

Choosing a nanny can offer more stability than traditional childcare services, too. A dedicated nanny provides specialized attention and builds a deeper bond with your child than you might find in a regular daycare. Nannies will work with your child (or children) to learn and adapt to routines, meals, and activities. Unlike daycare centers, where staff turnover and large group settings are common, a nanny becomes an extension of your home life, offering consistency and comfort for your children, and an agency is the best way to get a trusted nanny.

One of the biggest advantages of using an online nanny agency is the level of security and vetting that modern platforms provide. Top-rated nanny sites take screening seriously, requiring background checks, employment verification, and detailed reference reviews before a caregiver ever appears in search results. Many sites even offer secure messaging systems and interview scheduling tools, so you can communicate with potential nannies directly without sharing personal contact information too early. This structure helps protect both parties and builds trust before a final hiring decision is made.

Finding a nanny online can also be far more cost-effective than relying on traditional placement agencies. Many online platforms allow you to choose between different membership levels or pay-per-use options instead of paying high placement fees. This flexibility makes it easier for you to find help within your budget. A platform like this can also help you find a new placement if your old nanny moves or has scheduling conflicts.

So, if you're ready to add some extra help to your family life, picking out a nanny from a top nanny agency is your next step. But if you're not sure where to start, don't sweat. We've put together some factors that can help you narrow down the best sites to find the right nanny for your family:

No matter what your reason is for wanting to hire a nanny, we've got your back. You deserve a little stress-free time, and a nanny can help you get it. To get you in the swing of the nanny scene, Top Consumer Reviews has researched and ranked the most popular nanny agencies out there today. This way, you can trust that the nanny you hire is the best pick for you. Who knows, you might even find your real-life Mary Poppins!

Slide Down Image Left Slide Image FAQ Image Slide Image Twirl Image

Nanny Agency FAQ

What is a nanny?
A nanny is an individual hired to take care of one of more children in a household. They are employed by the guardians of the children to take care of them, usually long-term. A nanny might live in the same home as the kids or come to the house to take care of them frequently. Unlike a babysitter, a nanny is usually not used for a short-term job.
What duties can a nanny perform?
A nanny's primary duty is to care for and watch over the children of the family they work for. In addition, they might make meals for the children, do laundry, clean the home, drive kids to and from school and other activities, and anything else agreed upon between the nanny and their employer.
What is the cost of hiring a nanny?
There are many factors that play into the cost of a nanny. Some factors include how many hours a day they work, how many children they care for, what responsibilities they perform while they are working, qualifications, and more. It is not uncommon for nannies to be paid an hourly rate bi-weekly or once a month. For a live-in nanny who works every day, it is also possible to agree to pay on a salary basis. Different nannies come with different rates that they usually choose themselves.
How do I choose the best nanny for my children?
To choose the best nanny, start by thinking about the qualities you want in a trustworthy nanny. Do you want them to be first aid certified? Do they need a driver's license? Do your kids feel most comfortable with a male or female? Narrowing down some basic requirements you set will help as you browse through the list of candidates. From there you can read their bios, message with them, and then interview them to see who you feel most comfortable with.
What ages of kids do nannies take care of?
Nannies can watch over kids who are infants all the way up to teenagers. You'll want to make sure that the nanny you hire has a history of working with children the same ages that you have. Some nannies are specifically qualified to work with infants and they know how to safely feed them, put them down for naps, and provide first aid if necessary.
What is the difference between a nanny and an au pair?
By definition, au pairs are young people who come from overseas to care for young children. They come on a cultural exchange visa to enter a country legally. Nannies are anyone within your home country who are qualified to take care of children either part-time or full-time. They are paid according to the country's standards, whereas an au pair receives pocket money from the host family.
Are all nannies required to have background checks?
Unfortunately, not all nanny agencies require their candidates to have background checks. However, most of them allow the option for employers to run them. It's important to review the background check of a nanny before hiring them or run one of your own. This will ensure an added level of safety for your children.
Can I conduct a trial run on the nanny I'm interested in?
Many companies allow you to have a nanny come to your home and work on a trial basis. This short period allows your kids to get to know the nanny and express to you how comfortable they are with them and see if they get along well. It also lets the nanny know if they think they will work well with the kids and be able to accomplish all of their responsibilities safely.

Compare Any 2 Products

Nanny Lane
Care
The Nanny League
Nanny Authority
Nanny Poppinz
Hello Nanny
Sittercity
Babysitter's Registry
Jovie
GreatAuPair
vs
Nanny Lane vs CareNanny Lane vs The Nanny LeagueNanny Lane vs Nanny AuthorityNanny Lane vs Nanny PoppinzNanny Lane vs Hello NannyNanny Lane vs SittercityNanny Lane vs Babysitter's RegistryNanny Lane vs JovieNanny Lane vs GreatAuPairCare vs The Nanny LeagueCare vs Nanny AuthorityCare vs Nanny PoppinzCare vs Hello NannyCare vs SittercityCare vs Babysitter's RegistryCare vs JovieCare vs GreatAuPairThe Nanny League vs Nanny AuthorityThe Nanny League vs Nanny PoppinzThe Nanny League vs Hello NannyThe Nanny League vs SittercityThe Nanny League vs Babysitter's RegistryThe Nanny League vs JovieThe Nanny League vs GreatAuPairNanny Authority vs Nanny PoppinzNanny Authority vs Hello NannyNanny Authority vs SittercityNanny Authority vs Babysitter's RegistryNanny Authority vs JovieNanny Authority vs GreatAuPairNanny Poppinz vs Hello NannyNanny Poppinz vs SittercityNanny Poppinz vs Babysitter's RegistryNanny Poppinz vs JovieNanny Poppinz vs GreatAuPairHello Nanny vs SittercityHello Nanny vs Babysitter's RegistryHello Nanny vs JovieHello Nanny vs GreatAuPairSittercity vs Babysitter's RegistrySittercity vs JovieSittercity vs GreatAuPairBabysitter's Registry vs JovieBabysitter's Registry vs GreatAuPairJovie vs GreatAuPair GreatAuPair vs JovieGreatAuPair vs Babysitter's RegistryGreatAuPair vs SittercityGreatAuPair vs Hello NannyGreatAuPair vs Nanny PoppinzGreatAuPair vs Nanny AuthorityGreatAuPair vs The Nanny LeagueGreatAuPair vs CareGreatAuPair vs Nanny LaneJovie vs Babysitter's RegistryJovie vs SittercityJovie vs Hello NannyJovie vs Nanny PoppinzJovie vs Nanny AuthorityJovie vs The Nanny LeagueJovie vs CareJovie vs Nanny LaneBabysitter's Registry vs SittercityBabysitter's Registry vs Hello NannyBabysitter's Registry vs Nanny PoppinzBabysitter's Registry vs Nanny AuthorityBabysitter's Registry vs The Nanny LeagueBabysitter's Registry vs CareBabysitter's Registry vs Nanny LaneSittercity vs Hello NannySittercity vs Nanny PoppinzSittercity vs Nanny AuthoritySittercity vs The Nanny LeagueSittercity vs CareSittercity vs Nanny LaneHello Nanny vs Nanny PoppinzHello Nanny vs Nanny AuthorityHello Nanny vs The Nanny LeagueHello Nanny vs CareHello Nanny vs Nanny LaneNanny Poppinz vs Nanny AuthorityNanny Poppinz vs The Nanny LeagueNanny Poppinz vs CareNanny Poppinz vs Nanny LaneNanny Authority vs The Nanny LeagueNanny Authority vs CareNanny Authority vs Nanny LaneThe Nanny League vs CareThe Nanny League vs Nanny LaneCare vs Nanny Lane
See the Best Nanny Agencies in Your State
Only the Best Reviews

New York Post on MSN

Squatting nanny allegedly makes couple’s lavish $1M upstate NY ...

A wealthy couple who thought they had found their dream nanny to help with their newborn daughter soon found themselves in a living nightmare when the caregiver allegedly refused to leave their lavish ...

Thu, 30 Oct 2025

Only the Best Reviews

The Irish Sun

My neighbour wants my parking spot for their nanny – I refused and ...

A WOMAN has already got into a neighbour war after just moving into her new house. Taking to social media, she revealed that now her neighbour was trying to get revenge after she refused to give ...

Sun, 09 Nov 2025

Only the Best Reviews

New York Post

Grandfather, 83, stabbed to death with screwdriver by ...

A heroic Michigan grandfather checking in on his 3-year-old granddaughter was allegedly stabbed to death with a screwdriver by her nanny — who later chased the tot’s uncle down the street, naked and ...

Thu, 30 Oct 2025

Only the Best Reviews

Fox News on MSN

Nanny found with suspected psychedelic mushrooms accused of fatal ...

Michigan nanny Samantha Rae Booth faces murder and abuse charges after allegedly killing 83-year-old David Ong while caring for his granddaughter over the weekend.

Tue, 28 Oct 2025

Only the Best Reviews

The Kansas City ...

‘Hero’ grandfather dies protecting 3-year-old from nanny attack, ...

The nanny, who was described as being in a “manic state,” repeatedly stabbed the grandfather with a screwdriver, authorities said.

Wed, 29 Oct 2025

Only the Best Reviews

TooFab

Nanny Stabs Grandfather to Death With Screwdriver, Chases Uncle and ...

Samantha Rae Booth faces multiple charges, including first-degree murder, second-degree child abuse, assault with a dangerous weapon, and three counts of resisting/obstructing police after allegedly ...

Wed, 29 Oct 2025

Only the Best Reviews

Parade Pets on MSN

Beagle Sweetly 'Guarding' New Human Sibling During Nap Wins Nanny of ...

Former NFL star Matt Kalil’s wife, Keilani Asmus, shared a sweet family video with their toddler hours after Kalil’s ex-wife, Haley Baylee, spilled “private” details on the reason behind their divorce ...

Wed, 05 Nov 2025

Only the Best Reviews

WXYZ-TV Channel 7

Nanny charged in murder of child's grandfather at Royal Oak home

The woman who is charged with the deadly stabbing of an elderly man in Royal Oak will be arraigned on Tuesday morning.

Tue, 28 Oct 2025

Top Products.  

Top Reviews.  

Top Consumer Reviews.

Reviews 

Browse through thousands of reviews.

Social Media 

Like us?  Follow us!  We'd love to have you join our community.

Newsletter 

Stay up to date with the latest reviews. We'll keep you informed, and we'll never sell your information to anyone.