Where is the best place to find a great nanny agency? In today's fast-paced world, more families are turning to nanny agencies to help manage the demands of work, home, and childcare. There's so much that goes into caring for a family, and sometimes having an extra set of hands around to help can make your day-to-day significantly easier.
Fair
Sittercity is a nanny agency that does it all. You can find every kind of child care on Sittercity: full-time, part-time, after-school only, daytime, mother's helpers, newborn care, infant care, and more. This is more than just an agency, too; it's an online marketplace that promises you're 5x more likely to find a nanny here than with a competing nanny agency (read further to see how true this is). The company is currently owned by Bright Horizons and is designed as a subscription-style website for seeking nannies and childcare.
Vetting is done as part of your membership
Sittercity offers in-house vetting and background checks, but those aren't completed until you ask for one. This is part of the membership structure where you get background checks included. But Sittercity doesn't do the vetting prior to you asking for a nanny to interview. The listings for nannies include the years of experience and any helpful items like certifications (first aid and CPR are popular), and any individual reviews for particular nannies, so you can pick someone who is highly rated by other families at this nanny agency.
You need a membership to talk to nannies
Signing up for Sittercity is simple. You just need to make a quick account and then answer a few questions about the type of care you want and your current location. You can also ask for a regular sitter, a one-time sitter, an occasional sitter, or a full 2-5 workday nanny. Finally, when you're done filling out your nanny listing, Sittercity will ask you to pick a membership. While you can casually browse some nannies in your area on this nanny agency, you will have to pay for a membership to contact the nannies directly. You can choose a 1-month, 3-month, or 12-month membership. The costs for these options are $35 per month, $49 for 3 months, and $90 for the year.
ID-verified nannies
While Sittercity doesn't do all the background checks when nannies join, they do verify that the individuals are who they say they are with legal ID verification and photo verification. You can also do all of your chatting on the Sittercity app, so that you have additional security to protect your communication with nannies and make sure you aren't getting scammed.
Hourly rates from $10 to $50
Sittercity's pricing is something you choose. The sliding scale ranges from $10 to $50 an hour for a nanny. The nanny agency will also tell you what the average pay is in your area, so you can pick a price that will give you the most options. Sittercity told us that parents near our area generally pay around $23 per hour, which was higher than what we were told for the same zip code on other nanny agency sites.
Mixed reviews and concerning reports of increasing costs
Sittercity's reputation on the Better Business Bureau actually falls under its parent company, Bright Horizons. However, this nanny agency doesn't have a top-notch score. Currently, Bright Horizons only has a "D-" rating from the BBB. On the bright side, it has a competitive 4.2-star rating out of 5 from Trustpilot. On the other hand, most of the recent reviews were just 1-star ratings. Customers say that the costs are too high to join as a membership for the nanny applications that you get out of it. Further, customers have trouble with accounts getting suspended unexpectedly for things like sharing site links when speaking with a nanny on the app. There were a few reviews (as of this year) that were still a full 5 stars, and these were generally specific praise for individual nannies.
Not bad, but nothing special
Sittercity, sadly, doesn't quite live up to its promise to be 5x more likely to secure you a solid nanny. While you can browse nannies yourself, you have to pay for a membership to use the website further than a quick sneak peek. While it's on par cost-wise with other membership-style nanny agencies, it doesn't stand out in the reviews. With a "D-" rating from the BBB as well, there just isn't anything that really makes Sittercity pop. For this reason, it earns a slightly below-average rating in our review.
Continued from above...
In today's fast-paced world, more families are turning to nanny agencies to help manage the demands of work, home, and childcare. There's so much that goes into caring for a family, and sometimes having an extra set of hands around to help can make your day-to-day significantly easier.
While in years past, finding a nanny was about going in person or conducting tedious interviews for weeks to find the right fit, nanny agencies offer a much better process. These online platforms put the best nanny options right at your fingertips. These directories often highlight skills, experience, and references so you can find a professional nanny who can create a personalized experience for you, your children, and your family life.
Choosing a nanny can offer more stability than traditional childcare services, too. A dedicated nanny provides specialized attention and builds a deeper bond with your child than you might find in a regular daycare. Nannies will work with your child (or children) to learn and adapt to routines, meals, and activities. Unlike daycare centers, where staff turnover and large group settings are common, a nanny becomes an extension of your home life, offering consistency and comfort for your children, and an agency is the best way to get a trusted nanny.
One of the biggest advantages of using an online nanny agency is the level of security and vetting that modern platforms provide. Top-rated nanny sites take screening seriously, requiring background checks, employment verification, and detailed reference reviews before a caregiver ever appears in search results. Many sites even offer secure messaging systems and interview scheduling tools, so you can communicate with potential nannies directly without sharing personal contact information too early. This structure helps protect both parties and builds trust before a final hiring decision is made.
Finding a nanny online can also be far more cost-effective than relying on traditional placement agencies. Many online platforms allow you to choose between different membership levels or pay-per-use options instead of paying high placement fees. This flexibility makes it easier for you to find help within your budget. A platform like this can also help you find a new placement if your old nanny moves or has scheduling conflicts.
So, if you're ready to add some extra help to your family life, picking out a nanny from a top nanny agency is your next step. But if you're not sure where to start, don't sweat. We've put together some factors that can help you narrow down the best sites to find the right nanny for your family:
No matter what your reason is for wanting to hire a nanny, we've got your back. You deserve a little stress-free time, and a nanny can help you get it. To get you in the swing of the nanny scene, Top Consumer Reviews has researched and ranked the most popular nanny agencies out there today. This way, you can trust that the nanny you hire is the best pick for you. Who knows, you might even find your real-life Mary Poppins!
Compare Any 2 Products
Top Products.
Top Reviews.
Top Consumer Reviews.
Reviews
Browse through thousands of reviews.
Social Media
Like us? Follow us! We'd love to have you join our community.
Newsletter
Stay up to date with the latest reviews. We'll keep you informed, and we'll never sell your information to anyone.
