Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

Gourmet Cooking & Living vs Kosterina

Tuesday, November 12th

2024 Olive Oil Club Reviews

Gourmet Cooking & Living Review 2.5 Star Rating

Gourmet Cooking & Living

2.5 Star Rating
  • Informative and beautiful social media channels
  • Option to bundle a special product of the month (jarred vegetables, pastas) for an additional fee
  • Organic olive oils from a different region of Italy each month
  • Each oil is shipped with a detailed olive oil profile, tasting notes, an intro to the farmer, and a seasonal recipe
  • Olive oil is around $36 per month with volume discounts
  • Flexible subscriptions are available

Gourmet Cooking and Living is a family-owned business that sells olive oils, vinegars and other products via their olive oil club, which is the heart of their business. Gourmet Cooking and Living's Olive Oil Club is dedicated to the most healthy olive oil they can source organically. But, compared with the other subscription options on our list, this club comes up short in many ways. We recommend you look at Gourmet Cooking and Living's competitors first.

Kosterina Review 2.5 Star Rating

Kosterina

2.5 Star Rating
  • Pricing starts around $25/bottle
  • Subscriptions can be customized
  • Olive oil is harvested early for maximum freshness
  • Beautiful packaging
  • Available in 500mL or 375mL sizes
  • Oils and products are organic
  • All subscriptions give a 10% discount
  • Pay in 4 with Klarna offered

Kosterina is a family-owned company that started out with a passion to get pure olive oils into the hands of home cooks in America. They made their own that is "authentically Mediterranean, delicious to smell, taste, and cook with, and, above all, loaded with health benefits.” If polyphenol content is important to you, Kosterina has greater than 500 mg/kg, 8-10x more than your typical olive oil. But, with this oil available at a number of big-box retailers and a lack of variety in the subscription, Kosterina doesn't really impress as an olive oil club.

Which Olive Oil Club is the Best?

To discover the huge difference in quality that fresh olive oil can make in your cooking, and even as a condiment, you can try an olive oil club. Olive oil clubs are a fantastic way to get a curated collection of the best olive oils in the country or on the planet, depending on the club you join.

These clubs source the most delicious varieties from all over the world. They do all the homework and deliver you the finest quality olive oils. Most of the clubs also believe in educating people about different olive oils and offer educational resources so you can gain experience to know how to curate olive oils for your own palate and cooking preferences. It can be a wonderful adventure - or a dependable way to have consistent, quality oils.

The Best Olive Oil Clubs Compare Olive Oil Clubs Compare Olive Oil Club Reviews What are the best Olive Oil Clubs Best Olive Oil Club Reviews

Olive Oil Club FAQ

It depends on the Olive Oil Club. Some clubs send you olive oil from artisanal farms around the world, while other clubs focus on olive oils from a particular region in the U.S.
There are usually a number of options you can select from. Depending on the club you choose, your olive oil will be delivered anywhere from once a month to once every 3 months.
Some are definitely more expensive than others. You can expect to pay anywhere from $27 to $82 per month for your olive oil club deliveries.
It depends. Some clubs offer a 100% satisfaction guarantee, while others don't offer one at all. If this is important to you, make sure you understand what the club offers before you join.
Some clubs offer free shipping on all orders, while others will charge you for each delivery. Be sure to understand what your costs are before you sign up for a club.
Yes! Some Olive Oil clubs have been around for many years and have developed a loyal fan base. You should feel safe buying from an established olive oil club.
Many Olive Oil clubs will send you a newsletter with each delivery. These newsletters tell you more about the olive varieties and producers of the bottles in your shipment.
Absolutely! If you have an olive oil lover in your life, a club membership would make a fun and unique gift. They will be reminded of you throughout the year.
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

Be prepared for a shock. The excellent, fresh olive oils you will receive from any club will be a new experience. The fresher the olive oil is, the more you will taste a peppery, grassy flavor note in the back of your throat. Some clubs also infuse their oils with garlic, ginger, or lemon. One even offers bacon-infused olive oil - and best of all, any of these oils make lovely gifts.

How does an olive oil club work? Such subscriptions generally deliver monthly, though some clubs offer deliveries every 2, 3, 4, or 6 months. They will source the olive oil, select delicious options, and ship it to you. You choose how often you want to receive it. It's that simple.

Once you find the right club, you only need to choose how much olive oil you want delivered, where you'd like it to come from, whether or not it's a gift for someone else, and how often you want it delivered.

It's pretty easy to find a club that is the perfect fit - whether you are treating yourself or a friend. There are clubs for those who want to buy with sustainability in mind, clubs for the adventurous palates, clubs for the discerning at-home chef, and more.

With all the olive oil clubs available, how do you know which club to choose? Here are some things to think about as you decide:

  • Club focus. What is your focus? Are you passionate about organic, regenerative farming? Do you prefer small-lot sourced oils? Are you interested in becoming an olive oil expert? Are you looking for adventure and curious about the different countries where the olive oil is produced? Look at each club and find one that matches your lifestyle and focus.
  • Origin and flavor. Are you only interested in olive oil from Tuscany? Do you have Portuguese ancestry and want to try its olive oil? Perhaps you just came back from a vacation to Greece and you are craving the olive oil you tried in that adorable little restaurant in Lesbos. Maybe you want to be more sustainable and choose olive oils from California. Do you like intense, robust flavor and the idea of attending or creating an olive oil tasting party, or do you prefer an everyday cooking olive oil? Look at the club that most closely matches your flavor and/or origin preferences.
  • Variety or consistency? Do you want a new experience with every delivery or would you prefer a consistent olive oil every month? Would you like add-ons? Many olive oil clubs also offer jarred vegetables and/or fruits, breadsticks, vinegars, or even skin care to add on to your oil club subscription.
  • In the pantry or on the counter? How much olive oil do you want or need in a month? Are you interested in stocking your pantry in bulk or are you leaning toward a beautifully-designed bottle for daily use to display on your counter? Freshness is a key factor in this decision: if you don't go through a lot of olive oil, or if you are trying many different varieties, it may be beneficial to go with a smaller delivery.
  • Return or cancellation policy. We all love delicious olive oil, but what happens if you join a club and receive a damaged package? What if you just really don't like the olive oil selection for a month? What does the club offer in the form of a returns policy when these issues arise? What commitment is required if you decide in the middle of your subscription that you need a break? Is there a penalty for canceling a subscription early? Each club has different policies, so it's a good idea to check before you commit so you won't be surprised in the event that an issue like this comes up.
  • Gifting options and perks. Club subscriptions can make a perfect gift for a family member, friend, or client. Does the club have special perks that will make the receiver feel special? Some offer really amazing newsletters, complimentary breadsticks or surprise treats, or even dipping plates or access to cooking classes or olive oil tastings.

Olive oil clubs are plentiful, so Top Consumer Reviews has ranked today's most popular subscriptions to help you choose. Buon Appetito!

Compare Olive Oil Clubs

Select any 2 Olive Oil Clubs to compare them head to head

best-olive-oil-clubs
  • Fresh Pressed Olive Oil Club
  • Amazing Clubs
  • Zingerman's
  • Corto
  • Brightland
  • Olive Oil Lovers
  • Frog Hollow Farm
  • Gourmet Cooking & Living
  • Kosterina
  • The Olive Press
Fresh Pressed Olive Oil Club vs Amazing Clubs Fresh Pressed Olive Oil Club vs Zingerman's Fresh Pressed Olive Oil Club vs Corto Fresh Pressed Olive Oil Club vs Brightland Fresh Pressed Olive Oil Club vs Olive Oil Lovers Fresh Pressed Olive Oil Club vs Frog Hollow Farm Fresh Pressed Olive Oil Club vs Gourmet Cooking & Living Fresh Pressed Olive Oil Club vs Kosterina Fresh Pressed Olive Oil Club vs The Olive Press Amazing Clubs vs Zingerman's Amazing Clubs vs Corto Amazing Clubs vs Brightland Amazing Clubs vs Olive Oil Lovers Amazing Clubs vs Frog Hollow Farm Amazing Clubs vs Gourmet Cooking & Living Amazing Clubs vs Kosterina Amazing Clubs vs The Olive Press Zingerman's vs Corto Zingerman's vs Brightland Zingerman's vs Olive Oil Lovers Zingerman's vs Frog Hollow Farm Zingerman's vs Gourmet Cooking & Living Zingerman's vs Kosterina Zingerman's vs The Olive Press Corto vs Brightland Corto vs Olive Oil Lovers Corto vs Frog Hollow Farm Corto vs Gourmet Cooking & Living Corto vs Kosterina Corto vs The Olive Press Brightland vs Olive Oil Lovers Brightland vs Frog Hollow Farm Brightland vs Gourmet Cooking & Living Brightland vs Kosterina Brightland vs The Olive Press Olive Oil Lovers vs Frog Hollow Farm Olive Oil Lovers vs Gourmet Cooking & Living Olive Oil Lovers vs Kosterina Olive Oil Lovers vs The Olive Press Frog Hollow Farm vs Gourmet Cooking & Living Frog Hollow Farm vs Kosterina Frog Hollow Farm vs The Olive Press Gourmet Cooking & Living vs Kosterina Gourmet Cooking & Living vs The Olive Press Kosterina vs The Olive Press
Compare the Best Olive Oil Clubs
- VS -
Review the Best Olive Oil Clubs
The Best Reviews of Olive Oil Clubs