Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

The Best Olive Oil Clubs

Which Olive Oil Club is the Best?

To discover the huge difference in quality that fresh olive oil can make in your cooking, and even as a condiment, you can try an olive oil club. Olive oil clubs are a fantastic way to get a curated collection of the best olive oils in the country or on the planet, depending on the club you join.

These clubs source the most delicious varieties from all over the world. They do all the homework and deliver you the finest quality olive oils. Most of the clubs also believe in educating people about different olive oils and offer educational resources so you can gain experience to know how to curate olive oils for your own palate and cooking preferences. It can be a wonderful adventure - or a dependable way to have consistent, quality oils.

Saturday, February 15th

2025 Olive Oil Club Reviews

Top Consumer Reviews Best-In-Class Blue Ribbon Award Fresh Pressed Olive Oil Club Review 5 Star Rating

Fresh Pressed Olive Oil Club

5 Star Rating
  • Priced at $99 to $139 per quarter
  • 3 bottles per delivery
  • Guaranteed to receive three different olive oils quarterly, hand selected by world-renowned "Olive Oil Hunter” T.J. Robinson
  • Hand-selected olive oils are rush delivered at the peak of their just-pressed flavor
  • Every shipment includes a Quarterly Pressing Report newsletter
  • Nice gifting options
  • No minimum number of quarters are required to join and membership can be canceled anytime
  • 100% money-back guarantee, no questions asked
Top Consumer Reviews Best-In-Class Blue Ribbon Award

The Fresh Pressed Olive Oil Club rushes every order to your door straight from the artisanal farm it came from. Every oil is independently lab-certified to be 100 percent extra virgin olive oil. T.J. Robinson has an exclusive arrangement with one of the world's top artisanal farms, and the olive oil he selects for club members is not available anywhere else in America. He has created a single link that connects the world's finest olive oils directly to the consumer. This man is passionate about olive oil and has a library of videos, newsletters, blog posts, and articles about the many aspects and importance of fresh olive oil. He really believes in his product, so much so that he offers a no-questions-asked 100% money-back guarantee.

Three varieties every quarter

Every quarter you will receive three bottles of fresh olive oil - one each of mild, medium, and robust oils. You can choose from two subscriptions:

  • Large ($139) - Three 500-mL bottles per quarter
  • Small ($99) - Three 250-mL bottles per quarter

Shipping is always free, and there is a 100% money-back guarantee. Past shipments include olive oil from Australia, Spain, Chile, Greece, New Zealand, Israel, Croatia, France, and Italy. Deliveries are mid-to-late March, June, September, and December, depending on Mother Nature's schedule. You will be charged 7 days before shipping and receive a tracking number for your shipment.

Best Olive Oil Clubs

Freshest possible olive oil

Fresh Pressed Olive Oil Club exclusively ships via plane, ensuring its freshness at your door, unlike other subscriptions and clubs that use cargo ships. Fresh Pressed Olive Oil Club also sources from the different hemispheres, so you can still get oil straight from the harvest even during North American winters.

Recipes, insights, and adventures

The Quarterly Pressing Report is one thing that sets Fresh Pressed Olive Oil Club apart from others. Filled with recipes and insights, it is also like a travel journal. Read about TJ's adventures in sourcing and procuring these oils. These reports showcase his ability as a storyteller to share your olive oil's journey. This is also why this club is a wonderful gift idea. T.J.'s positivity and passion are evident, and the education members receive about understanding quality olive oils is impressive. In addition, Fresh Pressed Olive Oil has a wonderful social media presence with lovely photos, informative videos, and frequent posts.

Everyone loves this olive oil

From at-home mom chefs to retired Navy Seals and everyone in between, everyone loves the olive oils from the Fresh Pressed Olive Oil Club. Even those who didn't prefer robust oils actually enjoyed T.J's picks. Fresh Pressed Olive Oil Club has a gift for choosing oils that everyone will like. And if you don't, there is always that 100% money-back guarantee. There is also an online form, phone number, and email address for members to contact customer service about their preferences or any concerns they may have.

Best Olive Oil Clubs

Hassle-free gifting

Gifting from Fresh Pressed Olive Oil Clubs is easy. There is a dedicated page on the website for gifts, and you can choose from a continuing subscription with no expiration, a one-year subscription, or a one-time gift. Because these oils appeal to a wide palate, you can be sure your gift recipient will love it.

#1 olive oil club

The amazing quality and taste, along with the stories of the producers and the olive oil journey itself, ultimately drew us in. Reviews of this oil have been consistently positive. One reviewer summed it up by saying that for every review he's ever done, he looks for something wrong, but in the case of Fresh Pressed Olive Oil, the only "con" is that you might run out of olive oil before the next quarter. Not to worry, Fresh Pressed has a few extras on hand if you want to buy more bottles. For all of these reasons, Fresh Pressed Olive Oil is our number one club.

Amazing Clubs Review 4.5 Star Rating

Amazing Clubs

4.5 Star Rating
  • Priced from $37.95/month
  • Free shipping
  • Each shipment includes one 12- to 20-oz bottle
  • Gourmet breadsticks are included with each delivery
  • Most flexible olive oil subscription
  • Extra discounts are offered regularly
  • Gift announcements can be sent ahead of shipment, even on the same day
  • 100% satisfaction guarantee

Operating since 2003 with over 3 million satisfied customers, Amazing Clubs is a reliable subscription club with world-class customer service. There are 3, 6, and 12 month options for flexibility, and if customers are ever unhappy, Amazing Clubs will make it right, or the customer has an option to cancel. Many of these olive oils are exclusive products that are only available via subscription. Amazing Club's large subscriber base enables them to get the lowest prices on high-quality oils, which they then pass on to you. If you're looking for a gift for someone who has everything, Amazing Clubs is a wonderful place to look. This company really delivers stellar customer service and excellent value. Their olive oil club is a perfect example of quality, flexibility, and customer service done right.

Sneak peek at past offerings

Amazing Clubs demonstrates their confidence in their selection of high-quality, unique olive oils by allowing you to view past deliveries before you subscribe. You can be sure it's the right fit for you or that friend who loves exclusive olive oils. Some examples of previous shipments include Oilladi, Giovanni Alessandro, Aria Greek EVOO, and Azeol Portuguese EVOO.

Skip a month

Once you subscribe, you will be able to see in advance what olive oils are going to be shipped. If you or your recipient don't like the selection, just skip that month. Amazing Clubs will add an extra month to the end of the subscription.

Best Olive Oil Clubs

Breadsticks included

Each month, you will receive one bottle of fine, handcrafted olive oil, weighing between 12 and 20 ounces (about the same as the 350 and 500 mL bottles you will find elsewhere). You'll also get a selection of gourmet breadsticks to dip. Every month's package includes The Olive Press newsletter. The newsletter is full of details about where your oil and breadsticks come from, fun facts about olive oil, recipes, serving suggestions, and more.

Great flexibility

You can choose between three, four, six, and twelve total deliveries. You have the option to receive deliveries either monthly or every other month. You also get to choose which month you'd like deliveries to start. Amazing Clubs always ships your olive oil during the last week of the month, regardless of when you start the plan.

Worry-free gift giving - even last minute

If you're giving this olive oil club as a gift, you can have the announcement arrive at any time you'd like. Provide the email address of the intended recipient and specify the delivery window. Your recipient will be able to see the tracking information on all future shipments and skip any deliveries they wish.

Best Olive Oil Clubs

Corporate gifting made simple

Do you own your own business and want to impress your clients? Amazing Clubs has over $50 million in corporate gift and reward programs to their credit, and they pride themselves on having the best customer service in the industry. Their team of professionals knows you are counting on them to make you look good, and they are interested in helping to exceed your expectations, whether you require ten gifts or ten thousand.

They will absolutely love it - guaranteed

Gift-giving in the modern age can be challenging. It's difficult to predict if the receiver will appreciate it or not. Amazing Clubs will not disappoint. Customer feedback consistently indicates that their gift was not only well-received but also frequently requested as a future gift by their clients. Some clients call monthly to thank the company for the subscription. Others who are natives of the Italian countryside rave about how it "tastes like home.” According to these reviews, the quality and taste are top-notch. Even if there is a problem with an extra rough UPS handler or if some other issue arises, Amazing Clubs is quick to provide a friendly and satisfying resolution. If you need to cancel the subscription for any reason, Amazing Clubs will refund you for any unshipped oils. It's a REAL guarantee.

Top-notch olive oil club

It's clear why Amazing Clubs has 3 million satisfied customers. And it's clear why this is a reliable gift-giving option. You, a client, or a friend will receive a tasty olive oil and breadsticks combination to try every month or every other month, as well as a fun newsletter filled with fascinating facts and recipes, all for a terrific price and an iron-clad guarantee. If you're looking for exceptional value and an unforgettable experience, Amazing Clubs' Olive Oil Club is the perfect choice.

Zingerman's Review 4 Star Rating

Zingerman's

4 Star Rating
  • Prices range from $53.33 to $67.50/month, depending on subscription length
  • The first shipment includes handmade terraced olive oil dipping plates, a $35 value
  • The website allows the gifter to download and print a card
  • 2, 4, or 6-month subscription options
  • 100% satisfaction guarantee, no return required
  • Offers information on the sources of the olive oils as part of the subscription

The Wall Street Journal chose Zingerman's as the "best overall” food club; Drew Barrymore and other celebrities leave rave reviews about them. Atlantic Monthly reviews Zingerman's as "the country's leading olive oil purveyor.” They are an institution in specialty food shipping and have extensive experience, especially when it comes to olive oil.

Three subscriptions to choose from

Zingerman's knows how to do a subscription. Their Monthly Rare Olive Oil Club offers three subscriptions, featuring 500-mL bottles:

  • 2 months for $135
  • 4 months for $215
  • 6 months for $320

Zingerman's is consistent, and you will always know what is coming in your shipments.

  • First month: Zingerman's Peranzana from Marina Colonna in Italy
  • Second month: OLV Oil from the Flores family in Spain
  • Third month: La Spineta from the Pellegrino family in Southern Italy
  • Fourth month: Acushia from the Moreira family in Portugal
  • Fifth month: Roi from the Boeri family in Liguria (Northern Italy)
  • Sixth month: Onsa's Oil from the Mahjoub family in Tunisia

The $320 plan comes with all six olive oil varieties on the list. With every club, the shipping is free, and the first delivery comes with a handmade terraced olive oil dipping plate.

Best Olive Oil Clubs

Incredible guarantee

Zingerman's has been reviewed by Zagat as the best overall and best service for gourmet online shopping, and we can see why. Their unbeatable guarantee is an online shopper's dream. If for any reason you aren't satisfied with your olive oil, they offer a hassle-free refund with no return of the product required. Return policies like this can give you confidence that you will always be satisfied.

Friendly atmosphere

Zingerman's website is fun, friendly and nostalgic. It is not overwhelming and very simple to navigate. Signing up for the olive oil club is really easy, and the approachable atmosphere of the website makes it an enjoyable experience to shop there.

Gift-giving experts

After spending just a few minutes on the website, it became clear to us that Zingerman's knows gift-giving. You can purchase this club with confidence that you'll not only receive consistently excellent oil oils but a myriad of information regarding the sourcing of the olive oil, how to use the olive oil you've received, and don't forget that terraced dipping plate.

Best Olive Oil Clubs

Gift-giving features

Zingerman's also offers a free downloadable card you can print out to give to a future recipient, so they can know something delicious is coming to them. You can also choose when the first arrival will come, with the earliest arrival date being about a week from the initial order. If it's a last-minute gift, you can also pay for priority arrival. Another nice feature is you can customize each month's gift message for the entire subscription all at once.

Absolute excellence

Zingerman's is not cheap. But, as one reviewer online put it, "the quality is so good, your wallet stops hurting after the first bite.” The absolute excellence, both in customer service and consistently high quality, make it a top-rated olive oil club in our books. The "unbeatable” guarantee and friendly ordering experience make it a fantastic pick.

Corto Review 4 Star Rating

Corto

4 Star Rating
  • Priced from $222 per year
  • Free shipping in the continental US
  • Stay fresh FlavorLock package keeps olive oil as fresh as the day you opened it
  • Membership includes a complimentary limited edition bottle of the current year's harvest
  • Access to chef-led cooking classes
  • Beautiful website with lots of recipes and inspiration

Club Corto offers members the exclusive opportunity to join a virtual olive oil tasting. Club Corto is ideal for the home chef who appreciates fresh, quality olive oil.

The perfect club for at-home and professional chefs

If cooking is a hobby you take seriously, this club is a wonderful choice. The chef-led cooking classes are a fantastic value. If you are a professional chef, you can enjoy the same superior quality at home as in your restaurant.

The FlavorLock packaging keeps oil fresh after opening

As oil dispenses out of the FlavorLock boxes, the bag holding the olive oil inside the box collapses, keeping air out. This is the only packaging that protects olive oil from flavor-damaging light and air from the moment it is filled until it reaches its empty state. If freshness is important to you, you should try this olive oil club.

Best Olive Oil Clubs

No flavored oils included

This subscription is strictly for olive oil, grown fresh in Corto's own California groves. Corto sells specialty olive oils as standalone purchases. For those, there are no subscriptions available.

Olive oil is delivered in bulk quantities

There are two options for membership, both of which include a lot of olive oil. The two membership options are:

  • Two deliveries of (2) 500-mL bottles and (1) 3L (yes, three-liter) stay-fresh FlavorLock box of olive oil
  • Three deliveries of (1) 3L FlavorLock box of olive oil

That adds up to eight or nine liters for the year, depending on which membership you choose.

Membership extras

In addition to the oil in the subscription, Corto will give you an extra 500 mL bottle of the current year's Limited Edition Harvest oil. This will ship out in December. Don't forget about the chef-led cooking classes and expert-led virtual olive oil tasting experiences.

Best Olive Oil Clubs

Strong social media presence

Corto prides itself on reaching out to the community and educating people on the value of fresh olive oil. They have a strong online presence and maintain lovely social media channels.

All sales final

There are no returns or refunds for the olive oil. But, fortunately, you won't be surprised by an end-of-year auto-renewal: it is a one-time purchase. Even though there are no returns, subscribers have the ability to modify their upcoming orders, skip an order, or cancel the subscription.

A fantastic option for serious at-home chefs

Corto's Olive Oil Club gets a higher score than other similar olive oil clubs because of its FlavorLock packaging, beautiful online presence, and value for those who entertain or cook at home frequently. Fresh olive oil will consistently fill your pantry throughout the year. However, Corto failed to reach the top tier of clubs due to the absence of a gift membership option and a lack of variety.

Brightland Review 3.5 Star Rating

Brightland

3.5 Star Rating
  • Priced from a little over $30 per month for a 375-mL bottle
  • You can change your monthly olive oil subscription anytime
  • Offers subscriptions for curated combinations, like Pizza Night or The Salad Dressing Bundle
  • Olive oil boasts a smoking point of 410 degrees Fahrenheit
  • Free shipping is available on everything in the shop for subscribers
  • Beautiful social media presence
  • Gift multiple people at once
  • Subscribers receive free gifts quarterly

The Instagram community has fallen in love with Brightland Olive Oil, a California-made olive oil that rivals those from Spain, Italy, or Greece. Brightland makes a playful reference to their California-sourced products by claiming their olive oils will leave you in a "golden state," and their customers agree. Brightland has a beautiful website that is also very educational. The Brightland "Field Notes” blog is full of useful information for anyone who enjoys quality olive oils. They also offer add-ons to club member subscriptions.

Change your olive oil subscription at any time

Whether you want to add another flavor of olive oil or change your subscription entirely, Brightland makes it easy. Their subscription model is very modern and simple to modify. In case you run out early in the month, you can add another bottle, or you can change it from robust to mild in your account hub.

Subscribers receive free quarterly surprises

Once a quarter, Brightland will send subscribers a special surprise gift, like a sourdough starter or seeds for the garden. We love a free gift!

Best Olive Oil Clubs

Curated "capsules” make for a wonderful gift

Brightland has curated different combinations of oils, vinegars, and honeys with what they call "capsules” and "sets." These packages include "The Salad Dressing Bundle” or "Pizza Night." These packages serve as excellent gifts or recurring subscriptions for weekly pizza nights or weekday salads at work. We love the attractive packaging, too. We agree with satisfied customers that they are pretty enough to display on the counter.

Website challenges

While the website is beautiful, subscribing to the oils is confusing. It took clicking on each product to discover that some oils and products aren't subscription-based. The FAQ stated that we could add the "Subscription” to our cart, but it didn't work. We could only click on each product to add subscriptions for that particular product. That means you should expect your "subscription” to cost at least $30 per delivery.

Gift-giving choices

While the digital gift cards at Brightland are really cute, these seem to be more geared toward a one-time gift rather than a subscription, although a subscription is possible. There is little information on how a subscription recipient would be able to update or change anything about their subscription. On the other hand, selecting "Corporate Gifts" took us to a page where we could conveniently ship to multiple recipients simultaneously or optionally send an "e-gift," allowing recipients to select items of similar price and customize their own package. However, this is a one-time gift, not a gift subscription.

Best Olive Oil Clubs

Free shipping on everything

Not every olive oil or curated capsule is eligible for a subscription, but these one-time purchases are available to subscribers for free shipping at any time.

Field Notes take your knowledge up a notch

One of our favorite things about Brightland is their beautiful online presence. Their blog, "Field Notes,” is full of information, recipes, and eye candy that will definitely add to your experience. They even have a "Bookshelf” section recommending or reviewing different cookbooks.

Bitterness isn't always bad

While some criticize Brightland's olive oils' bitterness, they assert that this bitterness, a result of early-season harvest, signifies freshness and adds to their olive oils' distinctive "grassy" taste. Most reviewers actually liked the grassy notes, but if that isn't something you think you will like, it may be best to try a "mini” version before investing in the Brightland olive oil subscription, as all sales are final from Brightland.

Best Olive Oil Clubs

No returns

Unlike other olive oil clubs, Brightland does not accept returns. All sales are considered final. And, unless the customer has purchased Carbon Offset + Shipping Protection, Brightland will not guarantee anything. The website provides a link to file a claim for those who have purchased the shipping protection. Those without shipping protection can contact Brightland via email to find a potential solution. Please note, however, that Brightland assumes no responsibility for the olive oil after shipment.

Instagram worthy, but...

We appreciate the social media presence, the attractive blog, the effortless subscription changes, and the benefits for subscribers. However, the return policy and the necessary shipping protection are definitely not a plus. This olive oil club is a riskier choice than others because of its price tag, especially when some customers have expressed dissatisfaction due to the excessively bitter flavor notes. It might be enjoyable to subscribe to the Salad Dressing Bundle or even a delicious vinegar and oil "capsule” as a monthly staple. It's worth checking out, and the packaging is so lovely that a curated Brightland olive oil combination would make an Instagram-worthy gift. See if Brightland olive oil is what you're searching for, but check out its higher-ranked rivals too.

Olive Oil Lovers Review 3.5 Star Rating

Olive Oil Lovers

3.5 Star Rating
  • Subscriptions start at around $35 per month
  • Unique offerings include olive oil crafted from centuries-old olive trees
  • Free shipping
  • Responsive customer service
  • Options for 3, 6, or 12-month gift subscription
  • Beautiful and informative social media channels

Founded in 2012, Olive Oil Lovers began based on a passion for olive oil. This passion began with traveling around the Mediterranean basin, trying many varieties of extra virgin olive oil. Not content with the lack of quality olive oils to be found in the United States, the founders decided to be a bridge between delicious olive oil and consumers in the United States.

Unique offerings

Olive Oil Lovers sources unique olive oils, like their centennial oils. They also have oils from all over the world, including flavored oils. Subscriptions here start at about $35/month.

High-quality oils with helpful information

A quick perusal of their website and social media channels shows that Olive Oil Lovers cares about quality. Their best-selling Oro del Desierto Organic Picual has an overall rating of 4.9 stars. For these oils, Olive Oil Lovers includes easy-to-read information on flavor notes, aromas, pairing ideas, and detailed descriptions.

Great customer service

Olive Oil Lovers Club gets excellent reviews, and in the event of a less than five-star review, their customer service is quick to reach out for a positive resolution.

Best Olive Oil Clubs

Free shipping, not so easy returns

The cost of shipping is included in your club subscription. However, if products arrive damaged, customers must send photos of the product, packaging, and shipping label. If a product just didn't live up to your expectations, you can return it, but you will be charged a 25% return fee. If you made an order accidentally and need to return it, it will cost you $9.95.

Not many options as a gift

A much-requested option for gift-giving is a gift box or special gift packaging, but this company has yet to offer this as an option. Instead, there is a space to include a brief note on the packing slip. If you want your recipient to feel like this is a special gift, this probably isn't the club for you.

Great olive oil, not club-focused

While the olive oils offered at Olive Oil Lovers are high quality and expertly curated, we just didn't get the feeling that the club was a priority for this company. The lack of gift packaging is a big letdown. And, with no information on past oil selections and no information on what size bottle or what kind will be shipped, it's just too many surprises, especially with their strict return policy. We love the quality but can't recommend Olive Oil Lovers as a club.

Frog Hollow Farm Review 3 Star Rating

Frog Hollow Farm

3 Star Rating
  • Certified organic Tuscan-style cold-pressed extra virgin olive oil, grown in small batches
  • Prices for a 375-mL bottle start at about $160 for a 3-month subscription
  • Free carbon-neutral shipping
  • Satisfaction guaranteed

Frog Hollow Farm practices organic regenerative farming on 280 acres in California. They are proud to offer certified organic Tuscan-style cold-pressed extra virgin olive oil to club members. Not only is Frog Hollow Farm in the business of olive oil, they also grow high-quality fruits.

Subscription options

Frog Hollow Farm subscriptions are available for 3, 6, or 12 months and can be paid in full using the credit card option or over time using Affirm through ShopPay or Sezzle. This price currently includes shipping.

  • Around $160 (300 mL) or $177 (500 mL) for a three-month subscription
  • Around $320 (300 mL) or $350 (500 mL) for a six-month subscription
  • Around $640 (300 mL) or $705 (500 mL) for a 12-month subscription

No specialty olive oils

Although the olive oil is of high quality, there is no variation in the kind of oil you receive. The only options are what size bottle (375 mL versus 500 mL) you will receive. If you are looking to try a variety of flavors or types of olive oil, this isn't the club for you.

Organic price tag

This subscription is definitely one of the more expensive ones, and while there are options for four interest-free payments over time, Frog Hollow Farm's annual price tag of around $600 to $700 for its olive oil club is definitely not on the low side. The cost of small batches and organic certification should be considered here.

Best Olive Oil Clubs

Variety in add-ons

This is a great choice if you are interested in getting other products from Frog Hollow Farm. This is where you can find variety, not in their olive oil.

Those who order it, love it

Frog Hollow Farm's olive oil is well-liked by most people who have tried or subscribed. Reviewers say the freshness and taste are excellent. Those who've tasted it at restaurants often decide to go home and purchase a subscription because they enjoyed it so much. One reviewer said, "From its fresh, light, green olive smell to the same light fruity, slightly peppery taste, this oil is amazing. I cook with it, put it on salad greens, popcorn, and dip bread in it.” If price doesn't factor in your decision, this may be an olive oil you'd want to try first to see if you'd like to commit to a subscription.

We love the farm, but the olive oil club is average

Although Frog Hollow Farm offers beautiful gift sets and recipes on their website, they primarily focus on their other products, such as fruits and pantry items. Most of the recipes and educational information do not mention olive oil at all. If you're simply seeking a high-quality organic option, this olive oil club may be a suitable fit. This subscription would also be perfect for people who exclusively love the Frog Hollow Farm taste because they've been to the farm in person. However, it doesn't meet the expectations that most individuals have for an olive oil club, particularly when it's a gift. Because Frog Hollow Farm is more focused on other products, as well as the lack of flavors and varieties, it lacks that "special delivery” feeling that accompanies other olive oil club shipments. Accordingly, it earns a "just average” rating.

Gourmet Cooking & Living Review 2.5 Star Rating

Gourmet Cooking & Living

2.5 Star Rating
  • Informative and beautiful social media channels
  • Option to bundle a special product of the month (jarred vegetables, pastas) for an additional fee
  • Organic olive oils from a different region of Italy each month
  • Each oil is shipped with a detailed olive oil profile, tasting notes, an intro to the farmer, and a seasonal recipe
  • Olive oil is around $36 per month with volume discounts
  • Flexible subscriptions are available

The Gourmet Cooking and Living Italian Olive Oil Club is a small, customer-focused business that takes pride in providing customizable subscriptions that are also suitable for gifting. Their goal is to bring their passion and love for Italian olive oils to the consumer. Founded in 2009, they claim to be the first and longest-running Italian Olive Oil of the Month Club. Gourmet Cooking and Living Olive Oil Club offers a monthly olive oil accompanied by a detailed olive oil profile, tasting notes, a "get to know you” article about the farmer that made the olive oil, and a seasonal recipe.

Share the journey

Gourmet Cooking and Living is most passionate about sharing your olive oil's journey from pressing to delivery via their social media accounts. They want their club members to get to know the farmers and see the pride they take in producing their oils. They do a phenomenal job of this via their social media channels.

Best Olive Oil Clubs

Product of the Month add-on

If you're considering pairing your olive oil with organic jarred tomatoes from Puglia, biodynamically produced balsamic vinegar from Modena, ancient grain pastas, cured vegetables, or medicinal honeys, you can add the Gourmet Cooking and Living Product of the Month to your subscription for under $15 per month and get something new and delicious delivered to your door with your olive oil.

Custom subscriptions

The Gourmet Cooking and Living Italian Olive Oil Club prides itself on flexible subscriptions. You can choose to receive an order every month or every other month. They offer 10% discounts for subscription extensions and multiple-bottle subscriptions, but expect to pay about $36/month for your olive oil delivery. Each month your olive oil will arrive in an eco-friendly gift box. There are also gift subscriptions available.

Website issues

The website is very sparse on information and uses a simple drop-down menu for purchases. Notable exclusions are a page detailing previous olive oil selections and a FAQ section. At the very bottom, the shipping and returns link is in small print. There is no real explanation as to how a gift subscription will work, either. Additionally, there is no information available about how previous or current customers feel about the club.

Best Olive Oil Clubs

You pay for shipping for any returns of damaged items

How about returns with this olive oil club? You may return damaged or defective merchandise within 10 days of the original purchase date for a full refund, but you must pay for shipping charges.

Good intentions, but not a great club

The Gourmet Cooking and Living Italian Olive Club was born out of one family's passion for fresh, flavorful, organic olive oil, but passion alone is not enough to make a wonderful club. Despite our deep desire to love this club, its basic website and the required shipping charges for returns force us to pass on it. It just doesn't quite make the cut.

Kosterina Review 2.5 Star Rating

Kosterina

2.5 Star Rating
  • Pricing starts around $25/bottle
  • Subscriptions can be customized
  • Olive oil is harvested early for maximum freshness
  • Beautiful packaging
  • Available in 500mL or 375mL sizes
  • Oils and products are organic
  • All subscriptions give a 10% discount
  • Pay in 4 with Klarna offered

If you have always enjoyed Greek olives and olive oil, Kosterina olive oil is a suitable choice for you. Sourced from family farms in Greece, Kosterina Olive Oil is very high quality and delicious. It is also organic. The Kosterina brand is a passion project and it shows right when you first visit its beautiful website. This oil isn't exclusive to the club, though - you can find it at Target and Whole Foods.

"Subscription” based on how many bottles you want

Kosterina lets you choose how many bottles you'd like in your subscription. Original EVOO? That's $25 for a 375 mL bottle. Spicy red pepper, Greek herb and lemon, or garlic-infused? $27. When you click on "subscribe”, you'll save 10% and get a discount on your shipping fees. If your subscription order is over $75, you'll qualify for free delivery.

Customize your subscription easily

The website is full of additional add-on products, and you can completely customize your subscription by size, frequency, and flavor. The model Kosterina uses is very similar to many other online retailers' "subscribe and save” programs, so it's pretty familiar and user-friendly.

Best Olive Oil Clubs

Beautiful packaging

Kosterina Olive Oil is not only delicious; it comes beautifully packaged. These oils are so pretty that they'd make for a perfect gift. We were really impressed with the packaging in their other products as well (vinegars).

Great reviews

We've found in the past and now that reviews for Kosterina average a perfect 5/5 stars. People love the flavor notes and the consistency of the olive oil. Some people try Kosterina and never use another oil.

Not exclusive

Unlike other olive oil clubs, Kosterina doesn't offer exotic or exclusive olive oils. In fact, we found their oils are available at retailers like Whole Foods and Target. A unique, exclusive gift is not offered when you subscribe, unlike some of the olive clubs on our list.

Best Olive Oil Clubs

Limited gift options

While Kosterina loves the idea of customers gifting their olive oils, their subscription system isn't really set up for more than a note on a packing slip. There are no newsletters or "perks” offered. It's unlikely that this club will make the recipient feel like this is more than just another delivery.

Not really a club, more of a subscribe and save

We are impressed with the subscribe and save options for those who would like to save money compared with buying it at retailers like Target and Whole Foods, but with the limited options for gifting and the absence of any exclusive perks for subscribers outside of reduced shipping costs, this club doesn't make the cut.

The Olive Press Review 1.5 Star Rating

The Olive Press

1.5 Star Rating
  • Prices from $60/month to $160/quarter
  • Subscriptions can be customized as often as every month
  • Three club levels to choose from
  • Subscriptions include discounts on olive oil tastings and events
  • Sourced from small lot, sustainably grown olives
  • 30-day refund policy
  • Olives are handpicked for best quality

The Olive Press, based in California, is committed to environmental consciousness and responsible farming practices. Growing olives using organic and sustainable farming methods, they are determined to minimize their ecological footprint and preserve biodiversity on their farms. You are not just buying olive oil; you are supporting sustainability. Founded in 2013 by Ed Stolman, the man who pioneered the first olive oil in the Sonoma region, The Olive Press was founded on sustainability and "mindful farming.” For those living near Sonoma and Napa or taking a trip to California, these sustainable, carefully-farmed groves are open to visitors.

Three clubs to choose from

When you choose an olive oil subscription from The Olive Press, you've got three options:

  • The Daily Dose (between $60 to $80 per month): This subscription comes with 100% California extra virgin olive oil and balsamic vinegar, and subscribers can choose two bottles or more from a selected list and delivery frequency: every month, every two months, or every four months. The subscription can be adjusted anytime. All subscription orders are shipped at a $10 flat rate.
  • The Press Club (about $75 per quarter plus shipping): Subscribers receive approximately 3 bottles per shipment with 25% off quarterly shipments delivered January, April, July, and October. Subscribers must commit to one year of membership. Free shipping on subscriptions over $85.
  • The Amphora Club (starts at $160 per quarter): This club includes two shipments annually of 5 bottles of oil and vinegar selections with additional pantry and kitchen supplies, with a 25% discount during the club shipment on oils and vinegars. Shipments are delivered in March and September. Subscribers must commit to one year of membership. This club offers free shipping.

Custom subscriptions

Even the least expensive subscription - The Daily Dose Club - offers some customization. The Press Club and the Amphora Club offer a fully customizable experience.

Fun perks included

The Press Club and Amphora Club offer 20% discounts on all products during shipping months. They also offer 25% discounts from their retail stores, complimentary olive oil tasting tickets (one member plus up to 3 guests), and early access discount tickets to events. It's a wonderful perk for those who live near the Sonoma or Napa farms, but isn't much of a benefit for non-locals.

Best Olive Oil Clubs

Penalty for canceling early

While the Daily Dose subscription club has no penalty for canceling, the other two club levels charge a $75 penalty for canceling before the year commitment is complete. The only other option is to ask to skip a quarter.

No information on gift subscriptions

While there is an option to add a gift message, this olive oil club doesn't have any other information on gift subscriptions. There is no information on how a gifted subscriber would customize their subscription.

We wouldn't recommend this club

The Olive Press is very popular among locals who visit their retail locations. For those who really want quality, handpicked olives in their olive oil and a commitment to mindfulness where a high price tag is not a problem, this olive oil is a fantastic choice. But compared with other olive oil clubs that have specialized newsletters, personally curated recipes, a list of past olive oils that have been sent out, and are much less expensive, this one failed to impress us. In addition, the $75 cancellation penalty was the final straw that knocked The Olive Press Olive Oil Club to the bottom of our rankings.

Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

Be prepared for a shock. The excellent, fresh olive oils you will receive from any club will be a new experience. The fresher the olive oil is, the more you will taste a peppery, grassy flavor note in the back of your throat. Some clubs also infuse their oils with garlic, ginger, or lemon. One even offers bacon-infused olive oil - and best of all, any of these oils make lovely gifts.

How does an olive oil club work? Such subscriptions generally deliver monthly, though some clubs offer deliveries every 2, 3, 4, or 6 months. They will source the olive oil, select delicious options, and ship it to you. You choose how often you want to receive it. It's that simple.

Once you find the right club, you only need to choose how much olive oil you want delivered, where you'd like it to come from, whether or not it's a gift for someone else, and how often you want it delivered.

It's pretty easy to find a club that is the perfect fit - whether you are treating yourself or a friend. There are clubs for those who want to buy with sustainability in mind, clubs for the adventurous palates, clubs for the discerning at-home chef, and more.

With all the olive oil clubs available, how do you know which club to choose? Here are some things to think about as you decide:

  • Club focus. What is your focus? Are you passionate about organic, regenerative farming? Do you prefer small-lot sourced oils? Are you interested in becoming an olive oil expert? Are you looking for adventure and curious about the different countries where the olive oil is produced? Look at each club and find one that matches your lifestyle and focus.
  • Origin and flavor. Are you only interested in olive oil from Tuscany? Do you have Portuguese ancestry and want to try its olive oil? Perhaps you just came back from a vacation to Greece and you are craving the olive oil you tried in that adorable little restaurant in Lesbos. Maybe you want to be more sustainable and choose olive oils from California. Do you like intense, robust flavor and the idea of attending or creating an olive oil tasting party, or do you prefer an everyday cooking olive oil? Look at the club that most closely matches your flavor and/or origin preferences.
  • Variety or consistency? Do you want a new experience with every delivery or would you prefer a consistent olive oil every month? Would you like add-ons? Many olive oil clubs also offer jarred vegetables and/or fruits, breadsticks, vinegars, or even skin care to add on to your oil club subscription.
  • In the pantry or on the counter? How much olive oil do you want or need in a month? Are you interested in stocking your pantry in bulk or are you leaning toward a beautifully-designed bottle for daily use to display on your counter? Freshness is a key factor in this decision: if you don't go through a lot of olive oil, or if you are trying many different varieties, it may be beneficial to go with a smaller delivery.
  • Return or cancellation policy. We all love delicious olive oil, but what happens if you join a club and receive a damaged package? What if you just really don't like the olive oil selection for a month? What does the club offer in the form of a returns policy when these issues arise? What commitment is required if you decide in the middle of your subscription that you need a break? Is there a penalty for canceling a subscription early? Each club has different policies, so it's a good idea to check before you commit so you won't be surprised in the event that an issue like this comes up.
  • Gifting options and perks. Club subscriptions can make a perfect gift for a family member, friend, or client. Does the club have special perks that will make the receiver feel special? Some offer really amazing newsletters, complimentary breadsticks or surprise treats, or even dipping plates or access to cooking classes or olive oil tastings.

Olive oil clubs are plentiful, so Top Consumer Reviews has ranked today's most popular subscriptions to help you choose. Buon Appetito!

The Best Olive Oil Clubs Compare Olive Oil Clubs Compare Olive Oil Club Reviews What are the best Olive Oil Clubs Best Olive Oil Club Reviews

Olive Oil Club FAQ

It depends on the Olive Oil Club. Some clubs send you olive oil from artisanal farms around the world, while other clubs focus on olive oils from a particular region in the U.S.
There are usually a number of options you can select from. Depending on the club you choose, your olive oil will be delivered anywhere from once a month to once every 3 months.
Some are definitely more expensive than others. You can expect to pay anywhere from $27 to $82 per month for your olive oil club deliveries.
It depends. Some clubs offer a 100% satisfaction guarantee, while others don't offer one at all. If this is important to you, make sure you understand what the club offers before you join.
Some clubs offer free shipping on all orders, while others will charge you for each delivery. Be sure to understand what your costs are before you sign up for a club.
Yes! Some Olive Oil clubs have been around for many years and have developed a loyal fan base. You should feel safe buying from an established olive oil club.
Many Olive Oil clubs will send you a newsletter with each delivery. These newsletters tell you more about the olive varieties and producers of the bottles in your shipment.
Absolutely! If you have an olive oil lover in your life, a club membership would make a fun and unique gift. They will be reminded of you throughout the year.

Compare Olive Oil Clubs

Select any 2 Olive Oil Clubs to compare them head to head

best-olive-oil-clubs
  • Fresh Pressed Olive Oil Club
  • Amazing Clubs
  • Zingerman's
  • Corto
  • Brightland
  • Olive Oil Lovers
  • Frog Hollow Farm
  • Gourmet Cooking & Living
  • Kosterina
  • The Olive Press
Fresh Pressed Olive Oil Club vs Amazing Clubs Fresh Pressed Olive Oil Club vs Zingerman's Fresh Pressed Olive Oil Club vs Corto Fresh Pressed Olive Oil Club vs Brightland Fresh Pressed Olive Oil Club vs Olive Oil Lovers Fresh Pressed Olive Oil Club vs Frog Hollow Farm Fresh Pressed Olive Oil Club vs Gourmet Cooking & Living Fresh Pressed Olive Oil Club vs Kosterina Fresh Pressed Olive Oil Club vs The Olive Press Amazing Clubs vs Zingerman's Amazing Clubs vs Corto Amazing Clubs vs Brightland Amazing Clubs vs Olive Oil Lovers Amazing Clubs vs Frog Hollow Farm Amazing Clubs vs Gourmet Cooking & Living Amazing Clubs vs Kosterina Amazing Clubs vs The Olive Press Zingerman's vs Corto Zingerman's vs Brightland Zingerman's vs Olive Oil Lovers Zingerman's vs Frog Hollow Farm Zingerman's vs Gourmet Cooking & Living Zingerman's vs Kosterina Zingerman's vs The Olive Press Corto vs Brightland Corto vs Olive Oil Lovers Corto vs Frog Hollow Farm Corto vs Gourmet Cooking & Living Corto vs Kosterina Corto vs The Olive Press Brightland vs Olive Oil Lovers Brightland vs Frog Hollow Farm Brightland vs Gourmet Cooking & Living Brightland vs Kosterina Brightland vs The Olive Press Olive Oil Lovers vs Frog Hollow Farm Olive Oil Lovers vs Gourmet Cooking & Living Olive Oil Lovers vs Kosterina Olive Oil Lovers vs The Olive Press Frog Hollow Farm vs Gourmet Cooking & Living Frog Hollow Farm vs Kosterina Frog Hollow Farm vs The Olive Press Gourmet Cooking & Living vs Kosterina Gourmet Cooking & Living vs The Olive Press Kosterina vs The Olive Press
Compare the Best Olive Oil Clubs
- VS -
Review the Best Olive Oil Clubs
The Best Reviews of Olive Oil Clubs