Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.
To discover the huge difference in quality that fresh olive oil can make in your cooking, and even as a condiment, you can try an olive oil club. Olive oil clubs are a fantastic way to get a curated collection of the best olive oils in the country or on the planet, depending on the club you join.
These clubs source the most delicious varieties from all over the world. They do all the homework and deliver you the finest quality olive oils. Most of the clubs also believe in educating people about different olive oils and offer educational resources so you can gain experience to know how to curate olive oils for your own palate and cooking preferences. It can be a wonderful adventure - or a dependable way to have consistent, quality oils.
Saturday, February 15th
T.J. Robinson hand-selects adventurous olive oils for subscribers to his Fresh Pressed Olive Oil Club. He prides himself on offering exclusive olive oils through artisanal sources that are just for club members. Freshness is paramount and orders are rush delivered so subscribers can enjoy super fresh, exclusive olive oils. Also included are great gifting options, and a risk-free guarantee. Fresh Pressed Olive Oil Club is #1 in our book.
Amazing Clubs are experts at subscriptions, and this is clear with their Olive Oil Club. Each shipment comes with a 12- to 20-ounce bottle of hard-to-find, small batch extra virgin olive oil from around the world. Shipping is included and so are gourmet breadsticks. This is all for less than $40 per month. Amazing Clubs provides a worry-free experience with their exclusive "They'll Love It!" guarantee. Amazing Clubs is rated as our #2 pick among olive oil clubs because of their stellar customer service and excellent gift-giving options.
People will make a pilgrimage to Michigan from New York City to visit Zingerman's retail outlets and taste their high-quality foods, including their curated olive oils. Your first shipment includes a beautifully handmade terraced olive oil dipping plate and every shipment includes a 100% satisfaction guarantee, no returns required. Zingerman's brand has been recommended by Better Homes and Gardens, Oprah, and Hilary Swank, just to name a few. Zingerman's has a whole range of outlets in Ann Arbor, from a coffee shop to a creamery to farms -and they even offer food tours. This is an olive oil club that might lead to a road trip to Michigan.
Club Corto is your exclusive invitation to enjoy a finely-stocked pantry of their high-quality olive oil as long as you are a member. Although the price is a bit higher and there are fewer varieties, this olive oil will stay fresh in your pantry because of the FlavorLock package that doesn't allow oxygen to get into the oil. You receive a complimentary bottle of the current year's harvest with each membership. With a beautiful website full of recipes and inspiration, and access to chef-led cooking classes, this isn't just an olive oil - it's an experience. That being said, there are not any really great gifting options and the lack of variety keep Club Corto from landing among our top olive oil clubs.
Another California-based olive oil club, Brightland offers products made by family farmers and local makers. Brightland's promise is that there is a little bit of sunshine in every bottle of their beautifully-packaged olive oils. Brightland Olive Oil Club allows members to change their subscription anytime, and it offers subscriptions that make great gifts - like a curated combination "The Salad Dressing Bundle.” However, the stringent return policy and mixed reviews regarding the olive oil's flavor landed Brightland with a just-above-average rating.
The Olive Oil Lovers Club is committed to providing subscribers with an enjoyable experience in tasting different unique olive oils. They offer not only a club but a place for novices and experts to learn new things about choosing olive oils. With free shipping and responsive customer service, they are definitely doing some things very well. They also offer oils from centuries-old olive trees. This club, while offering delicious olive oils, does not offer great gift-giving options, and subscribers will never know what is coming. On top of that, the stiff penalty for returning olive oil is enough for us not to recommend this club as a top pick.
Before Frog Hollow Farm even started to sell olive oil, the owners went on an extended visit to Italy to learn and understand traditional olive oil-growing techniques. They chose four Tuscan varieties of olives to grow and used their knowledge of these traditional techniques in producing their olive oils. This organic olive oil is definitely farmed with love and sustainability in mind. However, the olive oil is only a small part of Frog Hollow Farm's business, and subscribers may feel that in the lack of variety and educational information included in each shipment.
Gourmet Cooking and Living is a family-owned business that sells olive oils, vinegars and other products via their olive oil club, which is the heart of their business. Gourmet Cooking and Living's Olive Oil Club is dedicated to the most healthy olive oil they can source organically. But, compared with the other subscription options on our list, this club comes up short in many ways. We recommend you look at Gourmet Cooking and Living's competitors first.
Kosterina is a family-owned company that started out with a passion to get pure olive oils into the hands of home cooks in America. They made their own that is "authentically Mediterranean, delicious to smell, taste, and cook with, and, above all, loaded with health benefits.” If polyphenol content is important to you, Kosterina has greater than 500 mg/kg, 8-10x more than your typical olive oil. But, with this oil available at a number of big-box retailers and a lack of variety in the subscription, Kosterina doesn't really impress as an olive oil club.
The Olive Press has three club levels to choose from, and these subscriptions are highly customizable. These olives are handpicked, and that makes them a little more expensive than other olive oil clubs. The subscription is great for those local to the farm, as they offer discounts on olive oil tastings and events. While the customizable subscription is nice, there is not much by way of gift options, and the penalty for canceling early is pretty hefty at $75. For this reason, The Olive Press' olive oil club winds up with a low ranking on our list.
Be prepared for a shock. The excellent, fresh olive oils you will receive from any club will be a new experience. The fresher the olive oil is, the more you will taste a peppery, grassy flavor note in the back of your throat. Some clubs also infuse their oils with garlic, ginger, or lemon. One even offers bacon-infused olive oil - and best of all, any of these oils make lovely gifts.
How does an olive oil club work? Such subscriptions generally deliver monthly, though some clubs offer deliveries every 2, 3, 4, or 6 months. They will source the olive oil, select delicious options, and ship it to you. You choose how often you want to receive it. It's that simple.
Once you find the right club, you only need to choose how much olive oil you want delivered, where you'd like it to come from, whether or not it's a gift for someone else, and how often you want it delivered.
It's pretty easy to find a club that is the perfect fit - whether you are treating yourself or a friend. There are clubs for those who want to buy with sustainability in mind, clubs for the adventurous palates, clubs for the discerning at-home chef, and more.
With all the olive oil clubs available, how do you know which club to choose? Here are some things to think about as you decide:
Olive oil clubs are plentiful, so Top Consumer Reviews has ranked today's most popular subscriptions to help you choose. Buon Appetito!
Select any 2 Olive Oil Clubs to compare them head to head