We evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.
Thursday, July 10th
If you have always enjoyed Greek olives and olive oil, Kosterina olive oil is a suitable choice for you. Sourced from family farms in Greece, Kosterina Olive Oil is very high quality and delicious. It is also organic. The Kosterina brand is a passion project and it shows right when you first visit its beautiful website. This oil isn't exclusive to the club, though - you can find it at Target and Whole Foods.
"Subscription” based on how many bottles you want
Kosterina lets you choose how many bottles you'd like in your subscription. Original EVOO? That's $25 for a 375 mL bottle. Spicy red pepper, Greek herb and lemon, or garlic-infused? $27. When you click on "subscribe”, you'll save 10% and get a discount on your shipping fees. If your subscription order is over $75, you'll qualify for free delivery.
Customize your subscription easily
The website is full of additional add-on products, and you can completely customize your subscription by size, frequency, and flavor. The model Kosterina uses is very similar to many other online retailers' "subscribe and save” programs, so it's pretty familiar and user-friendly.
Beautiful packaging
Kosterina Olive Oil is not only delicious; it comes beautifully packaged. These oils are so pretty that they'd make for a perfect gift. We were really impressed with the packaging in their other products as well (vinegars).
Great reviews
We've found in the past and now that reviews for Kosterina average a perfect 5/5 stars. People love the flavor notes and the consistency of the olive oil. Some people try Kosterina and never use another oil.
Not exclusive
Unlike other olive oil clubs, Kosterina doesn't offer exotic or exclusive olive oils. In fact, we found their oils are available at retailers like Whole Foods and Target. A unique, exclusive gift is not offered when you subscribe, unlike some of the olive clubs on our list.
Limited gift options
While Kosterina loves the idea of customers gifting their olive oils, their subscription system isn't really set up for more than a note on a packing slip. There are no newsletters or "perks” offered. It's unlikely that this club will make the recipient feel like this is more than just another delivery.
Not really a club, more of a subscribe and save
We are impressed with the subscribe and save options for those who would like to save money compared with buying it at retailers like Target and Whole Foods, but with the limited options for gifting and the absence of any exclusive perks for subscribers outside of reduced shipping costs, this club doesn't make the cut.
To discover the huge difference in quality that fresh olive oil can make in your cooking, and even as a condiment, you can try an olive oil club. Olive oil clubs are a fantastic way to get a curated collection of the best olive oils in the country or on the planet, depending on the club you join.
These clubs source the most delicious varieties from all over the world. They do all the homework and deliver you the finest quality olive oils. Most of the clubs also believe in educating people about different olive oils and offer educational resources so you can gain experience to know how to curate olive oils for your own palate and cooking preferences. It can be a wonderful adventure - or a dependable way to have consistent, quality oils.
Be prepared for a shock. The excellent, fresh olive oils you will receive from any club will be a new experience. The fresher the olive oil is, the more you will taste a peppery, grassy flavor note in the back of your throat. Some clubs also infuse their oils with garlic, ginger, or lemon. One even offers bacon-infused olive oil - and best of all, any of these oils make lovely gifts.
How does an olive oil club work? Such subscriptions generally deliver monthly, though some clubs offer deliveries every 2, 3, 4, or 6 months. They will source the olive oil, select delicious options, and ship it to you. You choose how often you want to receive it. It's that simple.
Once you find the right club, you only need to choose how much olive oil you want delivered, where you'd like it to come from, whether or not it's a gift for someone else, and how often you want it delivered.
It's pretty easy to find a club that is the perfect fit - whether you are treating yourself or a friend. There are clubs for those who want to buy with sustainability in mind, clubs for the adventurous palates, clubs for the discerning at-home chef, and more.
With all the olive oil clubs available, how do you know which club to choose? Here are some things to think about as you decide:
Olive oil clubs are plentiful, so Top Consumer Reviews has ranked today's most popular subscriptions to help you choose. Buon Appetito!
Select any 2 Olive Oil Clubs to compare them head to head