AuctionZip Review

Monday, July 7th

2025 Online Auction Site Reviews

AuctionZip

• Historical, unique, and high-end inventory
• Traditional bidding-war auctions
• User-friendly interface
• Quick signup with Google
• Find 4,000+ items in key item searches
• Pay through credit card, PayPal, or check
• "A+” rating and accreditation from the BBB

If you're the kind of person who relishes the excitement of standing amidst a bustling auction hall, ready to bid like a classic in-person auction, then AuctionZip is tailor-made for you. This online platform captures the spirit of traditional auctions by allowing you to bid in real time on a unique array of items with over 25,000 auctioneers and 13 million auction buyers. What sets AuctionZip apart is the broad range of items and the wide number of high-value items like diamonds or entire homes. The allure of finding something truly unusual or collectible is one of the standout features of AuctionZip.

Sign up with Google

Navigating the website is a breeze. You can start browsing right away for items on your wishlist. However, if you want to buy (or sell), you'll need to make an account. It's totally free to join plus you can sign up with your Google account, making it easy to access your AuctionZip anytime you want.

Authentic bidding-style auctions

It's hard not to admire the site's audacious approach. As a platform for exploration and the occasional leap into the unknown, Auction Zip stands out in the crowd of larger auction websites. The bidding style is a little different here than at other competitors. The site is designed to offer real-time bidding. While this can be a commitment, as it requires your online presence during the auction, it is often lauded as being more "authentic” and customers tend to get deeply invested in auctions. There's something undeniably addictive about tracking the bidding wars as they unfold. However, if you're more interested in the "buy it now” approach, you may not be the ideal shopper for AuctionZip.

Impressive inventory with unique items

If you're looking for unique finds, AuctionZip is the place for you. For example, just on the front page, we saw a World War II German helmet, a set of Winchester guns, an old Corvette, and a 1976 Mustang. This only scratches the surface of the items you can find on AuctionZip. While the uniqueness of the items can be appealing, some of them might veer towards the peculiar side: many of the items on the front page of AuctionZip might not appeal to all shoppers. On top of rare items, you can also shop by state for auction items that are local to you, which is a helpful feature at AuctionZip.

How does it compare?

Now, to compare the range of inventory between different online auctions, we checked out the common shopping searches. Remember, these are results at the time of this review; inventory at AuctionZip may change by the time you start browsing. We checked out a standard accessory (watches), a "rare” search (autographed items), and a tech item (an iPad) to see how AuctionZip compares to other companies. Here's what we found:

• Watches: 4,084 results
• Autographs: 3,702 results
• iPads: 9 results

While AuctionZip has an impressive inventory for most of our search terms, it's a little light on modern technology.

Specializes in antique and high-end items

It's not hard to see that AuctionZip's specialty is in old and novelty items. Whether you're looking to buy a home on auction or a car, you can find it on AuctionZip. Some of the finds on the featured page include a 12-acre home starting at $1,020,000. More standard auction items might be more difficult to find, but if you're looking for a unique score like classic cars or a new home, this is a great option for you.

Buy items "as is”

There isn't a specific return policy as AuctionZip works like a traditional in-person auction, where you buy the items in whatever condition they're currently in. Each individual auction house working through AuctionZip chooses a method of payment. Some ask for cash or checks while others accept credit cards or PayPal. So, if there's a problem with your order, you'll probably have to go through your payment method or contact the auction house directly. However, in most cases, you're agreeing to buy items "as is” and AuctionZip has no specific policy regarding returns.

High BBB score, but low reviews

AuctionZip has an impressive "A+” rating from the Better Business Bureau. However, from third-party review sites, AuctionZip doesn't have the best reputation. The average score across multiple review sites is just 1.5 stars out of 5. Customers complained that in many cases AuctionZip didn't honor their bid. One reviewer showed photos of their submitted bid of $800 and the same item selling for $650 to another bidder, which was understandably frustrating. Many customers are frustrated with the "real” auction process and complain about losing out on items to other bidders. Since this is the primary risk of this kind of site, many of the reviews simply show that if you're not prepared for the "authentic” bidding experience, AuctionZip might not be for you.

Perfect place for unique or historical items

The bottom line is AuctionZip is a traditional auction site, where you bid against other customers in real time. If this isn't your thing, you might want to move on, but if you're interested in those real bidding wars, AuctionZip can be a place where you can find unique items not offered anywhere else. The company offers an impressive inventory of standard items like watches or autographed items, as well as cars, homes, diamonds, and real historical artifacts. With easy sign-up and a solid score from the BBB, AuctionZip stands out despite the lower ratings from reviewers. If you're looking for the most unique items, this is the place for you. And if it brings up its reviewer ratings, AuctionZip has the potential to rank even higher.