Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

The Cat's Pajamas Review

Monday, April 15th

2024 Pajama Store Reviews

The Cat's Pajamas Review 4 Star Rating

The Cat's Pajamas

4 Star Rating
  • Offers women's pajamas + some "Mommy & Me" styles + some men's options
  • Hundreds of styles to choose from
  • Sizes typically available in XS-2XL
  • Prices typically range from $60 to $136
  • Free shipping/returns on orders over $100
  • 30-day return window (from ship date, not delivery date)
  • In business since 1998

Since its inception in Berkeley in 1998, The Cat's Pajamas has been a beacon of stylish, consciously crafted sleepwear, delighting customers with indulgent comfort and playful designs. Now headquartered in sunny Santa Monica near Bergamot Station, the company continues to honor its roots while embracing innovation, offering new patterns, cuts, and luxurious fabrics like the 100% cotton Luxe Pima and the Pima Knit blend of Pima Cotton, Modal, and elastane. With a commitment to California-made pajamas and an expansion to Peru to utilize the exquisite Pima cotton sourced from the Andes Mountains, the company prioritizes sustainability and fair labor practices.

Mostly for women

The vast majority of the sleepwear offered by this pajama store is for women. Theoretically, you could browse all of the options at once, but it's probably easier if you choose a style, fabric, or print that you might prefer. And, if you're shopping for a seasonal set, look for that option in the site navigation (Valentine's Day, Christmas, and so on).

Everything from classic to quirky

Not sure where to start? Try using the Best Sellers link to see some of The Cat's Pajamas' most loved styles. The Classic Pima Knit Pajama offers the most basic two-piece look; it comes in five colors and sizes from XS-2XL (though the 1XL and 2XL were out of stock at the time of our visit to the online store). Across nearly 350 reviews, these pajamas earned a near-perfect 4.9-star average, with plenty of ladies saying that these are the most comfy PJs they've ever owned. Want some jammies that no one else at the PJ party will be wearing? Check out the Sushi Flannel sets, available in two patterns and also featured in the Best Sellers category. Whether you want a crazy pattern or a classic design, The Cat's Pajamas will give you plenty to choose from.

Best Pajama Stores

Some styles for men and children

Because The Cat's Pajamas primarily offers sleepwear for women, there's no need for us to try and compare what they offer for matching family sets. However, there are some styles in the "Mommy & Me" section, and a few options for men as well.

Free shipping on $100+

Look for a pop-up while you're shopping The Cat's Pajamas: we were offered a 10% discount for signing up for the pajama store's newsletter with our email address. Prices here usually fall in the $60 to $136 range, but you'll have to spend more than $100 to qualify for free shipping and returns.

30-day return timeframe but fast exchanges

Speaking of returns, you'll have 30 days from the shipping date (not the date of delivery) to request a refund or exchange on your pajamas. They have to be in unworn, unwashed, and undamaged condition to qualify. The good news is that if you're looking to do an exchange, you can get an instant credit on the site; select the new size or style you're looking for, and as soon as The Cat's Pajamas receives notification that the original PJs have been turned over to the postal carrier for the return, they'll send out your new sleepwear.

Best Pajama Stores

Lots of 5-star reviews on most pajamas

Although we couldn't find a rating for this pajama store with the Better Business Bureau, and the ratings left at Trustpilot only averaged out to a "just okay" 3.3 stars out of 5, we're not concerned. When you look at the reviews across all the styles of PJs sold by The Cat's Pajamas, it's clear that most of them are quite popular (to the tune of perfect 5-star ratings).

Easily earns a high rating for women's pajamas

If you're looking for cute or classic women's jammies in super-comfortable fabrics, be sure to check out what The Cat's Pajamas has in stock. While their lack of options for the rest of the family keep this pajama store from earning our highest rating, the quality of the PJs and their popularity with women across the size and age spectrum have earned The Cat's Pajamas a high rating here.

Where is the Best Place to Buy Pajamas?

Picture this: it's the end of a long day, you've tucked yourself into bed, and what's the icing on the relaxation cake? Pajamas! Ah yes, those cozy, comfy, and sometimes downright quirky clothes that can make bedtime feel like a luxurious affair.

Gone are the days when you have to buy pajamas from a department store. From indie designers crafting one-of-a-kind prints, to specialty shops offering personalized pajamas tailored to your wildest dreams, the online pajama-sphere is bursting with creativity. Whether you're into celestial patterns, quirky animals, or retro vibes, there's a pair of pajamas out there with your name on it.

The Best Pajama Stores Compare Pajama Stores Compare Pajama Store Reviews What are the best Pajama Stores Best Pajama Store Reviews

Pajama Store FAQ

There are lots of types of pajamas! Sleep shirts, sleep sets with coordinating tops/bottoms, pajama pants paired with a favorite t-shirt, robes, onesies and nighties are the most common options you'll see when shopping for pajamas.
That's a matter of preference, and probably has a lot to do with temperature. If you tend to overheat at night, you're not going to want heavy flannel at bedtime! For those with texture sensitivities, a satin or silk may be ideal - or irritating! Your most comfortable pajamas will be whatever material and design lets you rest at the right temperature, fits comfortably, and doesn't get in the way of a good night's sleep.
Absolutely! That's one of the biggest trends in pajama retailers: selling matching sets for the holidays, for photos, you name it. Not every store carries these sets (especially not if it's a retailer that specializes in women's pajamas only), but you'll find plenty of possibilities for those cute matchy-matchy moments.
Selection and pricing, of course. Most brick-and-mortar stores don't carry a huge selection at any given time, and you might have a hard time finding the size and style you want. That's especially true if you're shopping out of season: maybe you need something lightweight for a winter getaway to the Caribbean, or you're taking your Southern self up to Alaska for a once-in-a-lifetime camping trip and your thin cotton jammies aren't going to cut it. Many online stores carry all types of pajamas year-round.
You can easily spend less than $20 on pajamas - or over $100! If you're buying matching pajamas for men, women and children, don't be surprised by a price tag of at least $30 per person. Just shopping for yourself? Your cost will depend on the material, design and brand - and it's okay to treat yourself to luxurious sleepwear for many delightful nights of rest, too!
How about "free" ? Many stores will give you complimentary delivery, though you may need to meet a certain order amount to qualify.
Check the return policy before you buy, especially if you're usually tough to fit. Most stores let you send your pajamas back within 30 days of purchase, but they'll usually need to be in unworn condition with the tags attached.
You do you...but picture yourself being awakened by a smoke alarm in the middle of the night and running out to the street, well, buck. Sure, that's not super likely, but it could happen! In some cases, sleeping in the nude would be frowned upon, and if you're a sleepwalker it's probably even more important to have some jammies on!
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

The history of pajamas is a fascinating journey through time, taking us back to ancient civilizations like the Egyptians and Indians who draped themselves in loose-fitting garments for sleep. Fast forward to the 17th and 18th centuries, pajamas became all the rage in the West, thanks to the influence of exotic Eastern cultures. These early versions were more like loose trousers and jackets, often made from silk or cotton, and were reserved for the elite.

Nowadays, pajamas come in all shapes, sizes, and styles, catering to every taste and preference imaginable. There are classic button-up sets for those who like to keep it timeless, cozy fleece onesies for the perpetual kids-at-heart, and silky slips for those who prefer a touch of elegance even in dreamland. Let's not forget about the novelty pajamas adorned with everything from cartoon characters to punny phrases, perfect for adding a splash of whimsy to your bedtime routine.

One of the best things about pajamas in the modern age is the ease of finding the perfect pair with just a few clicks. Thanks to the wonders of online shopping, you can explore a vast universe of sleepwear options without ever having to leave your cozy cocoon. Want a matching set for a family photo? No problem. Planning a stay-in-your-PJs vacation or a pajama-themed holiday party? The internet has you covered, quite literally.

Ready to slip off into sleep or set up that perfect Christmas card photo with matching PJs? Here are some things to keep in mind as you pick the right pajama store:

  • Selection. Naturally, the first consideration is the selection. The more options a pajama store has, the more likely you are to find the PJs you're picturing.
  • Price. What's your budget? In the world of pajamas, you'll find everything from inexpensive nighties under $10 to linen sets at $200+.
  • Returns. Clothes can be tricky to buy online when it comes to fit and feel. The best online pajama stores understand that, and want you to feel at ease with taking a chance on their sleepwear, so look for a retailer that has a hassle-free return and/or exchange policy.
  • Reviews. Look for a pajama store that provides customer reviews on their PJs. That's an easy way to see how they look and feel in real life. Also see what shoppers have said about the retailer itself. Is it easy to get help from customer service if needed?

Whether you're a pajama purist who swears by classic styles, or a pajama pioneer forging new fashion frontiers, one thing's for sure: the world of pajamas is a whimsical wonderland just waiting to be explored. That's why the experts at Top Consumer Reviews have taken a close look at today's most popular online pajama stores: there's no need to settle for boring bedtime attire when you can let your imagination run wild and slumber in style!

The Best Reviews of Pajama Stores