Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

Private Island Party Review

Monday, April 15th

2024 Party Planning Supply Store Reviews

Private Island Party Review 1.5 Star Rating

Private Island Party

1.5 Star Rating
  • Free shipping on orders of $100+
  • 30-day return policy
  • Lots of unique party favors
  • Extremely low prices

Private Island Party's website screams low quality. Their website is riddled with spelling and grammatical errors, it doesn't look like it has been updated in years, and the flashy pictures and pop-ups are unprofessional. There is no "About Us" page on this website, only a long description of why the company thinks people should buy from them. This includes promises of fantastic customer service, an intuitively designed website (we laughed at that one), the highest quality of items, a passion for doing good business, and everything else a company would want customers to think.

Smorgasbord of categories

The categories of products at Private Island Party are random. They include bulk sunglasses, costume accessories, holidays, political facemasks, cheap party supplies, children space (an odd name for an inventory of costumes, party favors, candy, and party supplies for kids), novelties, seasonal products, costumes, and more. The cheap party supplies section includes:

  • Tableware
  • Party favors
  • Gift bags
  • Party decorations
  • Gift boxes
  • Birthday party supplies
  • Personalized party goods
  • Costume accessories under $2
  • Inflatables
  • Barware
  • Face masks

Lots of themes, but few matching items

We'll give credit to Private Island Party for their long list of party themes they have supplies for and the inventory of trinkets, decor, and essentials needed for throwing a party. However, not every theme has a full selection of items that match. For example, if you're throwing a mermaid party, you'll find a bunch of party favors like bracelets, bubbles, notebooks, and pencils, but not tableware, balloons, or decor to match. You'd have to buy plain colors from the "cheap party supplies section" to go along with the theme.

Unusually low prices

One thing Private Island Party claims is definitely true: they are cheap. You can get a 50 pack of napkins for just $1 or 100 balloons for $6. If you want giant angel wing accessories for your party, a 12 pack is only $18. Full Halloween costumes can be purchased for under $20 here. We love low prices just like the next person, but sometimes they are too low and it makes us skeptical of quality and delivery. Sometimes prices really are too good to be true and we wouldn't be surprised if this is the case here.

Best Party Planning Supply Stores

Free shipping on orders over $100

If you spend $100 or more, you'll get free shipping from Private Island Party. At most any other store, spending $100 would be easy, but you would have to buy quite a bit here to reach that point. For just a few items, shipping that takes a week or so to arrive will be about $7 and can be as much as $24.50 for 3-day shipping.

30-day returns with restocking fees

You can make returns to Private Island Party as long as you fill out their return authorizations form online first. You'll have 30 days from when your order was delivered to send back your items. Returns come with a 30% restocking fee and the cost of return shipping, so this is less than ideal. However, you can get 100% of the product price in the form of a store credit if you choose that instead. Private Island Party says that you can't return sunglasses simply because you're unhappy with quality and anything that has touched the body cannot be returned.

Poor ratings

The "C" rating from the Better Business Bureau was actually higher than we imagined Private Island Party's rating would be. They have very few customer ratings, but all of the ones we found were bad. In short, people say their customer service, shipping speeds, and quality are poor. We gathered that this was probably the case from the first 3 minutes of being on the website, so it's unfortunate that customers have paid money for things that didn't turn out as they hoped. Private Island Party has earned our lowest rating.

Where is the Best Place to Find Party Supplies?

Everyone loves a party! Whether it's for you or a loved one, big celebrations are some of life's most exciting and memorable events. Worthwhile reasons to throw a party include birthdays, graduations, weddings, sports games, housewarming, new job, retirement, and more. But let's be honest - you don't really need an excuse to host a big event.

With online party supply stores, customers can easily find decorations to make parties bigger, better, and more unique, whatever the occasion. If you do happen to have a specific theme in mind for your party, you'll be able to find everything from napkins to photo backdrops that match. Some novel ideas are Hollywood glamour, luau, 90's retro, masquerade ball, punk, taco bar, murder mystery, and more.

The Best Party Planning Supply Stores Compare Party Planning Supply Stores Compare Party Planning Supply Store Reviews What are the best Party Planning Supply Stores Best Party Planning Supply Store Reviews

Party Planning Supply Store FAQ

Whether you're having a small gathering or planning a huge company-wide party with hundreds of people, party planning supply stores can help you take care of all the small details. Many companies have in-house designers that can make customized party goods like invitations, drink coasters, ribbon, gift bags, candles, and any other item you want at your event. Party planning supply stores help you stay on-theme and accessorize for special events.
There is a lot that goes into planning a party. What will the entertainment be for your guests? What will they eat? How will you invite them to the party in the first place? You have to know how to decorate, what gifts you want to give the guests (if any), and coordinate who will make it all happen. It can be overwhelming when you get put in charge of an important event, so party planning supply stores help take care of a lot of the essentials.
One of the best things about party planning supply stores is that you can make it completely your own. Some companies allow you to upload your own art or graphics to be printed on invitations, napkins, plates, bags, masks, cups, and other accessories. You can choose your colors, a theme, and select from a variety of different styles of products. On the other hand, if you want to keep things simple, party planning supply stores also offer a wide range of products that look amazing without having to customize them.
The cost of party supplies will totally depend on what you're buying and how much. Most of the time you'll be buying in bulk, which actually ends up being a better deal than if you are only buying a few of something. For example, if you want 300 personalized napkins, you might expect to pay about $115. If you want 300 customized party favor bags, you will pay around $130. You could pay $300 for high quality, frosted cups, and so on. The quantity of each product and the variety of things you buy will largely determine your end cost. It is a good idea to set a budget beforehand so you can shop wisely! You can also usually get a discount on your purchase if you sign up for a company's email list!
Some companies offer vendor referral services. This means you can choose the service you need (e.g. artists, bakeries, balloons, flowers, musicians, photography, etc.), your location, and the radius you want to shop within and get recommendations. This is a fast way to find a list of contacts to reach out to for your party planning needs.
If you're planning a party that doesn't already have a set theme, it's fun to browse party supply stores to get ideas. This way you can see what products are available for your potential theme and choose your favorites. Some party planning supply stores have photos of real weddings and parties to give customers ideas of how other people have pulled events together and how they've decorated.
It's never too early to start planning a party! You might find that the products you need are backordered or take a while to customize. You'll also probably think of more ideas as time goes on, so you'll want to give yourself enough leeway to make sure you get everything perfect. There is nothing more stressful than feeling like you aren't going to be ready for a big event you're in charge of. We recommend starting at least 6-8 weeks before a party is going to take place to decide a theme, put together a guest list, find a venue, and secure your entertainment.
Unless the party planning supply store sends you items that are defective or have a misprint, it's unlikely that you'll get a refund on customized products. If you change your mind about what you've ordered or realize you made a mistake, you'll probably have to eat the cost if it was personalized in any way. If you buy pre-designed products, you'll have a better chance of qualifying for a refund if it's within the company's designated timeframe. Be sure to read up on the return policy of a company before buying anything from them.
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

Just browsing the seemingly infinite selection of party supplies online will give you more than enough theme ideas. You'll be able to transform your space with props, tablecloths, backdrops, balloons, streamers, plates, and much more. The sky's the limit for party supplies these days, so your hardest job will be narrowing down the most important items for your celebration.

You have easy online access at your fingertips to throw a memorable celebration. You can compare pricing, customer reviews, inventory, shipping speeds, and more between retailers to make planning as convenient and affordable as possible. Whether you're throwing a party for your teenager's sweet 16 or celebrating your dad's retirement, you're sure to find everything you need to make them feel special and create a party that is talked about for years to come.

Before choosing a party supply store, we suggest you keep the following criteria in mind:

  • Price. Find a store that allows you to get the most out of your money. You won't want to spend too much of your budget on just the essentials like plates, tablecloths, and napkins. Find an affordable selection that makes it possible to get unique party favors and photo-worthy props to create your party space without blowing your budget.
  • Selection. There is nothing better than browsing products that get your creative juices flowing. With a big selection of products, you will save time coming up with ideas for decorations because they will be laid out for you to consider.
  • Return Policy. What if you order enough supplies for 100 people, but only 80 show up? Make sure you can return extra supplies you don't need or that you decide not to use. Planning a party is often a guessing game as far as attendance, so you'll want some flexibility when deciding how many products to order.

To help you identify the best party supply stores, TopConsumerReviews.com has reviewed and ranked a variety of options. We hope this information helps you find everything you need to create memorable events this year!

Compare Party Planning Supply Stores

Select any 2 Party Planning Supply Stores to compare them head to head

  • Oriental Trading
  • Wholesale Party Supplies
  • Zazzle
  • Ultimate Party Superstore
  • Party City
  • For Your Party
  • Discount Party Supplies
  • Paper Mart
  • Private Island Party
Oriental Trading vs Wholesale Party Supplies Oriental Trading vs Zazzle Oriental Trading vs Ultimate Party Superstore Oriental Trading vs Party City Oriental Trading vs For Your Party Oriental Trading vs Discount Party Supplies Oriental Trading vs Paper Mart Oriental Trading vs Private Island Party Wholesale Party Supplies vs Zazzle Wholesale Party Supplies vs Ultimate Party Superstore Wholesale Party Supplies vs Party City Wholesale Party Supplies vs For Your Party Wholesale Party Supplies vs Discount Party Supplies Wholesale Party Supplies vs Paper Mart Wholesale Party Supplies vs Private Island Party Zazzle vs Ultimate Party Superstore Zazzle vs Party City Zazzle vs For Your Party Zazzle vs Discount Party Supplies Zazzle vs Paper Mart Zazzle vs Private Island Party Ultimate Party Superstore vs Party City Ultimate Party Superstore vs For Your Party Ultimate Party Superstore vs Discount Party Supplies Ultimate Party Superstore vs Paper Mart Ultimate Party Superstore vs Private Island Party Party City vs For Your Party Party City vs Discount Party Supplies Party City vs Paper Mart Party City vs Private Island Party For Your Party vs Discount Party Supplies For Your Party vs Paper Mart For Your Party vs Private Island Party Discount Party Supplies vs Paper Mart Discount Party Supplies vs Private Island Party Paper Mart vs Private Island Party
Compare the Best Party Planning Supply Stores
- VS -
Review the Best Party Planning Supply Stores
The Best Reviews of Party Planning Supply Stores