Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

Amazing Clubs vs The Salty Dough

Sunday, February 9th

2025 Pasta of the Month Club Reviews

Amazing Clubs Review 5 Star Rating

Amazing Clubs

5 Star Rating
  • Pricing from $40.95 to $42.95 per month or $128.85 to $491.40 prepaid
  • Pay monthly or one-time
  • Includes pasta and sauce
  • 2 unique flavors of pasta and sauce per package
  • Refunds for unshipped packages
  • Great for gifting
  • Free shipping in the continental US
  • 4.9-star average rating
  • "A+” rating from the BBB
Top Consumer Reviews Best-In-Class Blue Ribbon Award

Amazing Clubs stands out as a fantastic option for subscription enthusiasts of all kinds. With 44 unique clubs (and a competitive option for pasta), Amazing Clubs comes highly praised by Trustpilot and the BBB alike. With free shipping, customizable delivery schedules, and an impressive customer satisfaction guarantee, Amazing Clubs earns top marks for its quality across the board. For this reason, it stands out as the perfect gift or personal treat for pasta lovers.

The Salty Dough Review 2.5 Star Rating

The Salty Dough

2.5 Star Rating
  • Pricing at $15.99 per month
  • Pay monthly
  • 1 pasta each month
  • 4 rotating flavors
  • Free shipping
  • 5-day refund policy

The Salty Dough is a small, Houston-based pasta company that offers a budget-friendly Pasta of the Month Club at just $15.99. Each shipment features one pasta and you'll go through four rotating varieties throughout your subscription. While its fun, Italian-inspired flavors are exciting, the total lack of customer reviews earns this service a lower-than-average rating due to being less established than its competitors. For these reasons, The Salty Dough rates as just below average for now - but it's worth keeping an eye on as it grows.

Which Pasta Club is the Best?

Have you ever thought about what your favorite pasta shape is? Are you a fan of long, flat linguine? Maybe you like bowtie pasta (farfalle) and its fun little ridges. Or, you might be a shell pasta (conchiglie) fan for the amount of sauce you can get in one bite. Whether you're a home chef trying to make restaurant-quality carbonara, or you're just trying to get a taste of this Italian classic, we get it.

So, what is a pasta club? Well, it's exactly like other subscription clubs (like cupcakes or makeup), where you'll get pasta delivered to your door each month. Plus, if you know a home chef in your life who needs noodles ASAP, most sites offer a range of prepaid subscription boxes that let you send a pasta subscription as a gift. It's a great way to try different kinds of pasta from around the world, support artisanal chefs, and explore new shapes and flavors of your favorite food item.

The Best Pasta of the Month Clubs Compare Pasta of the Month Clubs Compare Pasta of the Month Club Reviews What are the best Pasta of the Month Clubs Best Pasta of the Month Club Reviews

Pasta of the Month Club FAQ

Like most online clubs, you choose a subscription plan, select your preferences (like delivery frequency or subscription length), and the club sends off a box of pasta for you. Once a month (or other frequencies if you choose) you'll get tasty pasta (or pastas) and sometimes complementary items like sauces, spices, or recipe cards. It's a convenient and delicious way to make your pasta nights more authentic.
This depends on the club. At most pasta makers, you can expect a mix of classic and unique varieties like spaghetti, rigatoni, pappardelle, or fusilli. Some clubs focus on gourmet or handmade pasta, while others feature international styles like Asian, gluten-free, or even plant-based pasta. Many clubs also include fun seasonal shapes or rare cuts you may not find locally.
This also depends on where you shop. Some pasta clubs offer options to change out the pasta included in your box. For example, you might be able to pick your own pasta in every shipment or ask for the company to change your pasta to gluten-free varieties. While not many pasta clubs offer changes to the orders, many of the clubs that have online menus where you can buy pasta directly let you choose your preferred styles and flavors.
Prices typically range from $16 to $60 per month, depending on the quality of the pasta, the quantity, and any add-ons included in your shipments. Clubs that offer premium ingredients or specialty sauces may be more expensive. Keep an eye out for discounts, though. You might get a lower monthly price for a longer subscription commitment or a larger order.
Definitely! Most pasta clubs focus on shelf-stable products like dried or packaged fresh pasta that won't have any issues during transit. If fresh or refrigerated pasta is included, it's shipped appropriately and includes instructions for storage and prep when it arrives at your door.
Most pasta clubs are flexible when it comes to managing your account. You can pause, skip a delivery, or cancel your subscription without any penalties. If you prepay for a subscription, you'll often be given partial refunds for the portion of your subscription that you haven't used. Make sure you check the pasta clubs' terms for a full rundown on the particular policies.
Pasta subscriptions make fantastic gifts for foodies, home cooks, or anyone who loves Italian cuisine. Most clubs offer easy gifting options like prepaid memberships that don't auto-renew. You can also sometimes add features like personalized notes or gift wrapping to make the monthly shipments more special for your loved ones.
Many do! While some clubs focus solely on pasta, others include delicious sauces, seasonings, or oils to complete your meal. Recipe cards are common even if you don't get tasty extras, so you can run to your local grocery and grab what you need to make an authentic Italian dinner.
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

If you're a penne fan, or looking for some good-old-fashioned spaghetti, pasta is a classic meal that comes in so many shapes and sizes that you can spend years trying new ones and still find more shapes (rotini, fettuccine, or ravioli, anyone?). While most of us think of Italy when we think of our favorite pasta dishes, there's evidence that the Etruscans made pasta back in 400 BCE.

Food historians believe that pasta arrived in Italy through trade in the Mediterranean and began its widespread popularity in the 13th century. From there, it became a country classic with pasta dishes like macaroni, ravioli, gnocchi, and vermicelli showing up across Italy. Today, it's estimated that Italians eat over 60 lb. of pasta per person per year.

So, what's the difference between high-end pasta versus the stuff you get at the grocery store? Well, for those of you who've had homemade pasta, you already know: the flavors, the freshness, and the texture of the pasta are beyond amazing when you compare it to the shelf-stable boxes you find at your local supermarket. If you want that restaurant-quality flavor in your home-cooked pasta dishes, grabbing a subscription to a pasta club is one of the best ways to get artisanal, top-quality noodles delivered right to your door.

If you're worried about dietary restrictions, don't be. Most pasta clubs offer options for gluten-free, so that those who are unable to eat gluten can still enjoy the delights of a home-cooked pasta dish. Whether you want packs with just pasta or one that helps you out with extra seasoning, sauce, and sometimes cheese too (to really get your inner chef going), there's a pasta club out there to fulfill your Italian dinner craving.

If you're ready to have your friends asking to come to your place for dinner instead of the local Olive Garden, but you don't know which vendor to choose, don't worry. Here are some factors that can help you find the best pasta club for your home chef needs:

  • Cost. Subscription clubs are usually priced based on frequency. So, depending on how long you plan to get pasta, you might pay a different overall cost. Some sites let you prepay too, so make sure you check out the month-to-month value versus the prepaid totals. Also, make sure that you get enough pasta to make the price make sense. You want at least a few meals out of your box (or a lot of extras) to make it worth it. Don't forget to factor in any shipping fees, too.
  • Variety. There are tons of pasta types, shapes, and flavors out there - it can be hard to choose. Make sure you pick a vendor that doesn't limit your choices in each shipment. Some sites may have much more pasta to choose from, and these one-stop shops are ideal if you're an adventurous eater. Make sure they have the kind of pasta you're craving and plenty of options to keep your subscription from being repetitive.
  • Reputation. Be sure to check out your chosen pasta club on third-party review sites like Trustpilot or the Better Business Bureau. Check the verified reviews to see what pasta lovers just like you have to say about your chosen site. Look for comments on flavor, customer service, and refunds, to make sure you get the experience you deserve.

To help you find the best way to bring your home chef dreams to life, Top Consumer Reviews has researched and ranked the top pasta clubs available today. Now you can enjoy your favorite noodles year-round and know there's always more on the way. Bon appetit!

The Best Reviews of Pasta of the Month Clubs