Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

The Best Pasta of the Month Clubs

Which Pasta Club is the Best?

Have you ever thought about what your favorite pasta shape is? Are you a fan of long, flat linguine? Maybe you like bowtie pasta (farfalle) and its fun little ridges. Or, you might be a shell pasta (conchiglie) fan for the amount of sauce you can get in one bite. Whether you're a home chef trying to make restaurant-quality carbonara, or you're just trying to get a taste of this Italian classic, we get it.

So, what is a pasta club? Well, it's exactly like other subscription clubs (like cupcakes or makeup), where you'll get pasta delivered to your door each month. Plus, if you know a home chef in your life who needs noodles ASAP, most sites offer a range of prepaid subscription boxes that let you send a pasta subscription as a gift. It's a great way to try different kinds of pasta from around the world, support artisanal chefs, and explore new shapes and flavors of your favorite food item.

Sunday, February 9th

2025 Pasta of the Month Club Reviews

Top Consumer Reviews Best-In-Class Blue Ribbon Award Amazing Clubs Review 5 Star Rating

Amazing Clubs

5 Star Rating
  • Pricing from $40.95 to $42.95 per month or $128.85 to $491.40 prepaid
  • Pay monthly or one-time
  • Includes pasta and sauce
  • 2 unique flavors of pasta and sauce per package
  • Refunds for unshipped packages
  • Great for gifting
  • Free shipping in the continental US
  • 4.9-star average rating
  • "A+” rating from the BBB
Top Consumer Reviews Best-In-Class Blue Ribbon Award

Amazing Clubs is a top pick for subscription fans, especially those who are looking for a site that has variety. With 44 different clubs available for subscription, you'll never get bored with the selection at Amazing Clubs. You can find wine, brownies, flowers, cheeses, and pasta all at this one-stop shop. Amazing Clubs got started in 2003 and currently provides clubs that ship across the US. Known for its focus on quality, Amazing Clubs promises a "gourmet” experience, and the pasta is sourced from gourmet kitchens that only use all-natural ingredients.

Customizable delivery options

Signing up for the Pasta of the Month Club at Amazing Clubs is a simple pick-and-choose process with flexible options. First, pick between a monthly payment plan or a one-time payment (best for gifting). The monthly payment plan includes 3-month, 6-month, 12-month, seasonal, and ongoing payment frequencies. You can choose whether you want to receive your shipment every month or bimonthly. Amazing Clubs also allows you to customize when you want your deliveries to start (you can buy a membership in January, but schedule it to start in June). If you go with the one-time payment plans, you get the same frequencies as the monthly payments (minus the ongoing option).

Best Pasta of the Month Clubs

2 kinds of pasta and sauces in every box

The Amazing Clubs Pasta of the Month Club includes gourmet pastas and sauces. The menu offers options from award-winning chefs, popular restaurants, and novelty pasta makers around the world. Each package comes with 2 pastas and 2 sauces, so you can make yourself several high-quality meals with each delivery. Some of the previous shipments included flavors and pastas like:

  • Pasta
    • Chipotle Angel Hair
    • Tuscan Herb Trumpets
    • Garlic Parsley Fettuccine
    • Sweet Potato Mafaldine
    • Porcini Mushroom Pappardelle
    • Green Bell Pepper Raditore
    • Cracked Pepper Rigatoni
    • Olive & Rosemary Fettuccine
  • Sauce
    • Roasted Tomato Garlic
    • Mushroom Marinara
    • Three Cheese Vodka Sauce
    • Roasted Garlic
    • Portobello
    • Truffle

Pricing from $40.95 to $42.95 per month or $128.85 to $491.40 prepaid

The Pasta of the Month Club will change prices depending on the frequency you choose and the length of time you want your pasta delivered for. Here's what you can expect:

  • Monthly
    • Ongoing membership: $42.95 per month
    • Every 3 months: $42.95 per month
    • Every 6 months: $41.95 per month
    • Every 12 months: $40.95 per month
    • Seasonal: $42.95 per month (billed every three months)
  • One-time
    • Every 3 months: $128.85
    • Every 6 months: $251.70
    • Every 12 months: $491.40
    • Seasonal: $171.80

100% free shipping

At Amazing Clubs, shipping is free for all deliveries within the continental US. This means most customers can enjoy their pasta club subscription without worrying about added shipping costs - just focus on the price of your pasta box. While the site's "About” page mentions international shipping, we weren't able to complete checkout with an international address. The shipping form during checkout requires a US-style address with a state and zip code, which is worth keeping in mind if you're hoping to give a pasta subscription to someone outside the US.

Best Pasta of the Month Clubs

Refunds for unused boxes

Amazing Clubs offers a "They'll Love It” guarantee for all the subscription boxes on its website. The guarantee states that if you're not satisfied with your pasta shipment, Amazing Clubs will help you out by getting your membership canceled or sending you a replacement for the shipment you had issues with. If you choose cancellation, you'll get a full refund for any deliveries you haven't received yet. For example, if you cancel your subscription 2 months into a 12-month subscription, you'll be reimbursed for the remaining 10 months of your plan.

No complaints about pasta or sauce

One of Amazing Clubs' stand-out features is its customer service. The company currently holds an "A+” rating from the Better Business Bureau and a 4.9-star average on Trustpilot. Subscribers (former and current) praise how easy it is to join the various clubs on Amazing Clubs and find the process user-friendly, whether they want to subscribe for themselves or send pasta as a gift. Reviews across Trustpilot show compliments for the helpfulness and responsiveness of Amazing Clubs' customer support team. As for the Pasta of the Month Club, specifically, Amazing Clubs has a 4.4-star average out of 5, according to feedback left by those who have used the club before. The pasta was praised for its quality and unique flavors that most customers had never tried before. Multiple customers particularly praised the red sauces included with the club.

Top-quality service and pasta

If you're looking for a place to give you the pasta of your dreams with zero hassle, Amazing Clubs is the best place to look. With unique pasta flavors and tasty sauces, you can easily grab a couple of meals in each box. Plus, with rave reviews for the pasta as well as the customer support team at Amazing Clubs, you have nothing to lose by subscribing long-term or buying the Pasta of the Month Club as a gift. For these reasons, Amazing Clubs earns a perfect 5 stars in our review.

Sfoglini Review 4.5 Star Rating

Sfoglini

4.5 Star Rating
  • Pricing from $110 to $215 prepaid
  • Prepaid
  • 6 packages of pasta
  • 3 semolina and 3 specialty flavors in each shipment
  • Does not auto-renew
  • Shipping included in costs
  • Some gluten-free pastas offered
  • 4.7-star average from third-party retailers

Sfoglini is a brand you might recognize if you're a frequent shopper at green and whole-food marketplaces for your groceries. Sold primarily at stores like Whole Foods, The Fresh Market, FreshDirect, Wild Nature Market, and more, you might have seen (and enjoyed) Sfoglini pasta before. This pasta specialist (pronounced Sfo-lee-nee) is known for its grain pasta made from semolina sourced from local flour mills in the USA. All of the pasta flavors are made and packaged in Hudson Valley, New York, and offer an impressive variety of boxed pasta shapes for you to enjoy.

Two memberships and quarterly shipments

There are two pasta club lengths to choose from at Sfoglini: the Half-Year of Pasta and the Year of Pasta. These are prepaid subscriptions, and at this point in time Sfoglini does not offer a month-to-month plan. Regardless of the shipment length you choose, you will get deliveries quarterly, and the subscriptions do not auto-renew. This makes the Sfoglini pasta subscriptions particularly great as gifts.

Best Pasta of the Month Clubs

Six pastas in every box

Each box includes six slow-dried kinds of pasta with a mix of semolina bases, specialty grains, and unique flavors. All of the boxes include recipes to help you turn your Sfoglini boxes into full meals. The breakdown of pasta types includes 3 total semolina pasta styles and 3 special pasta flavors (with limited edition flavors). Here are some of the pastas we saw in the listings for the clubs:

  • Rigatoni (semolina)
  • Rye Trumpets
  • Saffron Malloreddus
  • Whole Grain Reginetti
  • Einkorn Macaroni

Pricing from $110 to $215 prepaid

Sfoglini's pasta clubs are prepaid, so the full price includes the entire period you choose. The Half-Year Pasta of Pasta costs $110. This will be two shipments (one every quarter from when you start) which makes it a total shipment of 12 pastas. The Year of Pasta club costs $215 and also ships quarterly and at 6 pastas per shipment. This means the total subscription includes 24 different boxes of Sfoglini noodles.

Shipping is included in the price

The fees for shipping are included in the total price, so you won't be charged extra for delivery at the time of checkout or when your individual boxes are sent out. This is super helpful compared to other sites that have shipping charges that aren't visible until you check out, or high flat rates in addition to the cost of the subscription box. However, Sfoglini makes it simple and the price you see is the price you get (including shipping).

Refunds for mistakes within 30 days

Sfoglini has a 30-day refund policy. This applies to items damaged when you receive them or if something is wrong with the pasta itself. You will need to return the pasta if you want a full refund. You will be responsible for the return shipping costs if you need to send back your pasta, and only unopened boxes will be accepted for return or refund.

Best Pasta of the Month Clubs

High praise for pasta quality

Notably, almost all of the reviews for Sfoglini's pasta on its own website are a full 5 stars. There is no page for Sfoglini on the Better Business Bureau, and with no feedback on sites like Trustpilot or Sitejabber, we had to rely on reviews found on third-party retailers to see what customers say about Sfoglini's pasta. The good news? The feedback is resoundingly positive. Sfoglini has a 4.7 out of 5 stars on average. Customers note that the pasta tastes better than some fresh pasta they've bought from grocery stores. Those who were given pasta clubs as gifts also praised the quality and thickness of the noodles, noting they are perfect for holding sauce.

Best option for authentic Italian pasta

With impressive feedback from customers, this boxed pasta hits the mark for almost everyone. With tons of pasta (even with only quarterly shipments), you can expect plenty of noodle goodness delivered right to your door. While we'd love to see a more supportive refund policy, the overall experience of shopping for pasta at Sfoglini is worth it. And with competitive pricing and extremely tasty pasta, you can get an authentic Italian dinner (or send one to a loved one) right away. For these reasons, Sfoglini earns an excellent rating in our review.

Bona Furtuna Review 4 Star Rating

Bona Furtuna

4 Star Rating
  • Pricing from $87 to $219 prepaid
  • Prepay for several months
  • 2 pastas per box
  • Organic and vegan
  • Serves 8-9 people
  • Free shipping
  • Refunds within 30 days
  • 4.9-star average rating

If you're looking for the real deal when it comes to Italian pasta, Bona Furtuna is going to be your next stop. This pasta club is based on the La Furtuna Estate outside Corleone, Sicily. This 300-hectare organic farm promises impressive natural ingredients with a push to preserve heirloom vegetables and support the natural ecosystem of the Sicilian countryside. Their commitment to Sicilian heritage isn't just about growing olives and heirloom tomatoes; it extends to the pasta as well, with a guarantee of 100% organic ingredients and handmade pasta straight from Italy.

Choose between 3- or 6-month frequencies

The only real decision you need to make for the Bona Furtuna Pasta Subscription is how long you want to join. Bona Furtuna offers a 3-month and a 6-month subscription period, and you can also choose if you want sauce in your delivery or to forgo sauce and just focus on the pasta itself. From there, you can just add your membership to the cart and get started.

Best Pasta of the Month Clubs

2 pastas per month

The Pasta Subscription at Bona Furtuna comes with 100% organic and artisan pastas. You'll also get a gourmet recipe that you can follow to make an authentic Italian dish right from home. Every box includes 2 pasta flavors from Bona Furtuna's Ancient Grain Pasta collection. There are around 8-9 servings of pasta in every box, and each pasta will be a different shape. The sauce is optional, but if you choose to add sauce, you'll get two unique sauces each month too. All of the pasta, sauces, and pestos are vegan (though there aren't gluten-free options at this time). Some of the pasta you can expect includes:

  • Rigatoni
  • Spaghetti
  • Bucatini
  • Linguine

Most of the pasta at Bona Furtuna is plain pasta (without add-ins or flavoring), so you can create homemade meals without worrying about flavor matching. But if you're looking for something more adventurous, you might feel like you're missing out here.

Pricing from $87 to $219 prepaid

You can't pay month-to-month at Bona Furtuna, so both of the prices are for prepaid plans. There are two options for each: with sauce and without sauce. The difference is about $30. Here's what you can expect:

  • 3 months
    • Without sauce: $87
    • With sauce: $117
  • 6 months
    • Without sauce: $165
    • With sauce: $219

Bona Furtuna also suggests you buy their olive oils or spices if you want to be able to complete the included recipes with Bona Furtuna ingredients.

Shipping is free

Shipping for Bona Furtuna is free on all the boxes. So, you won't have to pay any shipping fee at the time of purchase or when your orders are sent out each month. Bona Furtuna is one of the many sites that use the popular Shop app for payment processing, so you can track your order from the second you place it as you wait for your tasty pasta.

Best Pasta of the Month Clubs

Refunds offered in 30 days

Bona Furtuna offers a 30-day refund policy to support its customers. If you aren't happy with a Bona Furtuna product, you can return it within 30 days for a full refund. There weren't any specifics about if you decide to cancel your subscription before the end of the term. So, you may want to check with their service team prior to subscribing if you're worried about needing to cancel in the middle of a subscription, as that might be past their 30-day window and not eligible for a refund.

Solid feedback from customers on Bona Furtuna

Bona Furtuna doesn't have a lot of buzz, regrettably. While there are some articles for this pasta maker on news platforms like The New York Times, the company currently doesn't have a page on the Better Business Bureau, nor does it have any presence on third-party review sites like Trustpilot or Sitejabber. We did find some reviews on Bona Furtuna, but there were only 8 total comments. While the 4.9-star average is impressive, we'd like to see more feedback from outside the Bona Furtuna website to be sure reviews aren't being curated.

An up-and-coming pasta club

While this is going to be a great stop if you want an authentic piece of Italy sent to your pasta box each month, those looking for complex flavors in their pasta might be disappointed. Overall, the free shipping, solid refund policy, and impressive commitment to organic ingredients earn Bona Furtuna a solid rating, but without further feedback from trusted review sites, it can't rank higher... yet. But, we have a feeling Bona Furtuna is a company that's going to grow fast, so if you want to get ahead of the curve, check out their organic pasta club ASAP.

Pappardelle's Review 4 Star Rating

Pappardelle's

4 Star Rating
  • Pricing from $43 to $48 per month
  • Pay monthly
  • 2 pastas in every box
  • Includes extras for a full recipe
  • Best to subscribe for yourself
  • Gluten-free
  • $15 shipping fee on each delivery
  • 4.4-star average rating

Pappardelle's was started by David Bowen and Bill Curtis in Denver, CO. The company was opened in 1984 to create fresh pasta with never-before-seen flavors. The pasta at Pappardelle's is deeply researched to create high-quality new pasta based on traditional Italian methods. The company started off selling six flavors: egg, spinach, cracked pepper, garlic parsley, lemon pepper, and tomato basil. Now, Pappardelle's uses a method of drying pasta to preserve its selections, so that it can be sold both in local markets and online.

Pick from three pasta genres

There is one Pasta of the Month Club at Pappardelle's, but it is broken into three pasta flavor options: Regions of the World, Mystery Box, and Gluten-Free Pasta. Pappardelle's calls these "genres” of pasta. You can also choose a 1-month, 3-month, or 6-month subscription for each genre. Then, all you need to do is complete the checkout process to get your pasta club started.

Best Pasta of the Month Clubs

2 kinds of pasta in every package

Depending on the package you choose, you'll get a different selection of pasta. The Regions of the World Club includes pasta that is sourced from North America to Asia. You'll get 2 artisan pasta types, 2 recipes for the pasta, one "specialty item” valued between $15 to $20, and swag. With the Mystery Box Club, you'll get 2 pasta types that are selected by the Pappardelle's tasting panel each month. These will be flavors and shapes that you may not find for sale on the website. The full box includes all the same extras as the Regions of the World Club. Finally, the Gluten-Free Box includes pasta made with rice, corn, quinoa, and tapioca flour. You'll get 2 gluten-free pastas and the same add-ons as the other boxes.

Pricing from $43 to $48 per month

Both the Mystery Box and the Regions of the World Box are the same cost. 1 month costs $45 per month, 3 months costs $44 per month, and 6 months costs $43 per month for either box type. The only subscription that is slightly more expensive is the Gluten-Free Box which costs $48 per month for 1 month, $47 per month for 3 months, and $46 per month for 6 months.

Shipping costs around $15

Regrettably, shipping is not free at Pappardelle's. On each order, you'll be charged a fee of $15 for shipping, on top of the monthly cost for the subscription box. This makes an already somewhat expensive monthly cost for pasta much higher. Your $43 per month box (if you subscribe for a year) would cost $58 per month instead after shipping. Since many rival pasta clubs offer free shipping, this makes Pappardelle's less competitive.

Keep an eye out for auto-renewal

The cancellation policy at Pappardelle's states that there is no limit on canceling your subscription. If you don't want to be charged for the subscription, you'll want to cancel before your next package ships. Pappardelle's policy notes that "some” subscriptions will auto-renew (even if you choose 12 months), but they don't list which subscriptions do so. You may want to double-check that you've successfully unsubscribed if you only want your Pappardelle's Pasta Club for a limited time. This could also make Pappardelle's more problematic for gifting.

Best Pasta of the Month Clubs

High praise for pasta flavors

Like many pasta clubs in our review, Pappardelle's does not have a page on the Better Business Bureau, nor does it have reviews on popular sites like Trustpilot or Sitejabber. The only place we found third-party reviews during our research was Yelp. According to customers who visited Pappardelle's in person, the company has a solid 4.4 stars out of 5. Customers love the flavors and samples of different items, and offer high praise for the unique flavors of the pasta. Favorite flavors include Lemon Pepper Pappardelle and Aglio e Olio Spaghetti. Customers recommend getting the pasta any time you're in the area of a place that sells Pappardelle's.

Solid choice if you want brand-new pasta flavors

If you're looking for standout pasta flavors and boxes that give you a bit of everything, you'll want to check out Pappardelle's right away. While these boxes are a little more pricey than the average subscription boxes, you are getting high-quality pasta along with a range of extras. Each package offers 2 pasta dishes that work with every diet (including gluten-free if you need it). With some issues with auto-renewal and a lack of online reviews outside of Yelp, it earns a strong rating in our review overall, but it is one of our top pasta club recommendations if you want to try new flavors you've never seen before.

Flying Noodle Review 3.5 Star Rating

Flying Noodle

3.5 Star Rating
  • Pricing from $42.95 per month or $128.85 to $491.40 prepaid
  • Pay monthly or prepay
  • 2 pastas and 2 sauces per box
  • Serves up to 10 people
  • Free shipping
  • 100% satisfaction guarantee
  • "A” rating from the BBB

Flying Noodle might have a whimsical-sounding name, but it's more than just a fun and tasty noodle shop. This site specializes in Italian-inspired gourmet gifts and subscription boxes. You can find a range of foods, drinks, and treats like beer, coffee, pizza, cheesecake, and pasta. Flying Noodle was founded in 1995, and it hopes to be a go-to destination for food clubs that are perfect for gifts or for giving yourself a treat or culinary adventure.

Two different pasta-inclusive clubs

Flying Noodle's pasta shipment is called the "Pasta of the Month” club. But the site can be a little confusing: if you click on "Pastas and Sauces” on the navigation menu, Flying Noodle says right now that it's "building” the part of the site where the pasta will be sold. However, if you look in the "Gift of the Month Clubs” section, you'll see another place to click on "Pasta”. That's where you'll find the Pasta of the Month Club. You can subscribe to the club on an ongoing basis or a prepaid plan. Flying Noodle offers a recurring month-to-month, seasonal, 3-month, 6-month, or 12-month plan if you want an ongoing membership or just three 3-, 6-, or 12-month plans if you want to prepay and send pasta as a gift.

Best Pasta of the Month Clubs

What's included: 1-2 pastas and sauces per month

The Pasta of the Month Club includes 2 pasta types and 2 specialty sauces in each package. The pasta will include one flavored pasta and one natural (just the noodles). The selection feeds 8-10 people per box. If you want to try something with a little less pasta in it, you can go for the Dinner of the Month Club. This option offers an "Italian themed, gourmet meal” each month that includes a gourmet pasta, a sauce, and one additional item like an appetizer, drink, or dessert. Each monthly shipment will feed 2-4 people. With either box, you'll get a newsletter that will give you the lowdown on upcoming shipments. However, there aren't any details on past shipments or pasta specifics on the website before you buy. Flying Noodle does offer vegan sauces.

Pricing from $42.95 per month or $128.85 to $491.40 prepaid

The cost for the Pasta of the Month Club depends on whether you want to order continuously or prepay for a one-time subscription (best for gifting). Here's how the prices shake out:

  • Ongoing
    • Monthly: $42.95 per month
  • Prepaid
    • 3 months: $128.85
    • 6 months: $251.70
    • 12 months: $491.40
    • Seasonal: $171.80

The prices are the same whether you prepay or pay monthly, but if you select the club as a "gift” (even for yourself) you won't be scheduled for automatic renewal. The ongoing payment option will renew until you cancel.

Shipping is 100% free

The Pasta of the Month Club, like all clubs at Flying Noodle, has 100% free shipping. You don't have to worry about any additional costs when you subscribe to the pasta club at Flying Noodle. Regardless of whether you choose an ongoing or prepaid membership, each shipment of tasty pasta only costs the price of the box.

100% satisfaction guarantee

Flying Noodle backs every order with a 100% satisfaction guarantee. The company promises that if you're dissatisfied with their Pasta of the Month Club for any reason, they'll step in to resolve the issue ASAP. If Flying Noodle can't resolve your concerns for you, you can cancel your membership at any time. If you prepaid for your subscription, you'll be refunded for any boxes you haven't received yet.

Best Pasta of the Month Clubs

Solid rating from the BBB

Flying Noodle holds an "A” rating with the Better Business Bureau, which shows a solid reputation, but we had difficulty finding detailed reviews for this service on other third-party review sites. There were no customer reviews or complaints on Trustpilot or Sitejabber. While the company does feature some testimonials on the Flying Noodle website, it's hard to determine if these reviews are curated or not. For now, we are a little reserved about Flying Noodle's public reputation.

A competitive pasta package, but needs more buzz

There are some pros and cons to consider with Flying Noodle. The selection of pasta (with flavor and plain selections) sounds great, but without a menu to look through, we're not sure what the past orders have been or future orders will be, so it's somewhat of a surprise. The lack of reviews and difficulty navigating the site, too can be a drawback. However, with an impressive satisfaction guarantee and free shipping, there are some competitive aspects for the pasta club at Flying Noodle. For this reason, it earns an above-average rating with the opportunity to move up in the future as it improves its online presence.

Pennsylvania Macaroni Co Review 3 Star Rating

Pennsylvania Macaroni Co

3 Star Rating
  • Pricing from $140 to $500 prepaid
  • Pay monthly or one-time
  • 2 lb. of pasta per package
  • 1 pasta type
  • Great for gifting
  • Free shipping if you buy meatballs
  • 5-star average rating

Pennsylvania Macaroni Co was founded in the late 1940s by Robert and Salvatore Sunseri as a place to sell olive oil, spices, Italian cheese, and other specialty food products. Today, the third generation of the Sunseri family has a brick-and-mortar shop in the Strip District of Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. The online store now brings the home-grown Italian feel straight to your doorstep with a variety of pasta club options (and other shipments too, like meatballs).

Site is a little cluttered, but does the job

While we love a family-owned business, there can be some drawbacks, and one of those is sometimes the quality of the website. While it's not the simplest browsing experience, Pennsylvania Macaroni Co does give you everything you need to sign up for the Pasta of the Month Club right on one page. You just need to do a bit of scrolling to find what you need. There are three subscription lengths to choose from: 3 months, 6 months, and 1 year. You'll also have the option to choose a frequency of deliveries every month or every other month. These are all shown as separate listings. There are also listings for Pasta Club gift cards, which you can buy if you want to send Pennsylvania Macaroni Co's Pasta of the Month Club as a gift.

Best Pasta of the Month Clubs

2 lb of pasta in every box

The Pasta of the Month Club at Pennsylvania Macaroni Co includes 2 lb. of fresh pasta and 32 oz. of sauce. The box's contents usually feed 4-5 people. You can add meatballs to any of the boxes for an additional charge. Otherwise, you'll just get pasta and sauce. At the bottom of the long scrolling window (appearing like separate listings), you can choose your pastas from the following:

  • Fresh Rosemary Linguine
  • Fresh Mushroom Linguine
  • Tomato Basil Linguine
  • Saffron Linguine
  • Egg Bucatini

The only option that wasn't linguine on the listed menu was Pennsylvania Macaroni Co's Egg Bucatini, which was odd. The site does not say if these selections rotate or if they are standard every month.

Pricing from $140 to $500 prepaid

The prices depend on which length of subscription you wish to purchase. The 3-month club option is $140, the 6-month club is $280, and the 1-year club is $550. If you want to add meatballs, it is an additional $23.97 for the 3-month plan, $47.94 for the 6-month plan, and $95.88 for the 1-year plan. At the time of our review, there was not a monthly ongoing membership for Pennsylvania Macaroni Co.

Shipping is only free with meatballs

Unfortunately, shipping is quite costly at Pennsylvania Macaroni Co. The charge is a one-time fee that covers shipping across all boxes, but it can be a bit shocking upfront. For the 3-month club, the shipping fee is $60, for 6 months it is $110, and for 12 months it is $210. There is a way to score free shipping, and that's to add meatballs to your order. For everyone except residents of California, Nevada, Utah, Idaho, Oregon, and Washington, you can get 100% free shipping if you add meatballs to your subscription.

Guarantee offered for damaged items

Pennsylvania Macaroni Co promises that every product will arrive in a safe condition (safe to eat). If there is something wrong with your package or it is damaged in any way, you will need to email Pennsylvania Macaroni Co. In order to qualify for a refund or another order resolution (like a reshipment), you'll need to take photos of the damage. There is no other reason listed for receiving a refund or reshipment.

Best Pasta of the Month Clubs

Positive local reviews, but complaints about pasta

There are no reviews available for Pennsylvania Macaroni Co on the Better Business Bureau or trusted third-party review sites like Trustpilot or Sitejabber. We did find some reviews on Tripadvisor from locals and travelers who love the Pittsburgh location. Pennsylvania Macaroni Co earns a resounding 5-star average from shoppers who've bought groceries and goods in person. However, the few reviews about pasta specifically noted that Pennsylvania Macaroni Co was "really lacking” in variety. The pasta wasn't made with unique add-ins (like spelt or emmer) and all were made of wheat.

A good option, but missing variety

If you're looking for something that has that family-owned or home-grown feel, Pennsylvania Macaroni Co is a great place to look. However, it comes in as a middle-tier pasta club option in our review for a few reasons. First, you can't get free shipping unless you buy extras, which makes the price of the boxes much less affordable. Plus, with no third-party reviews (and some complaints about the lack of variety in pasta) Pennsylvania Macaroni Co is less competitive than some of the other pasta clubs in our review. However, we love the Pennsylvania Macaroni Co's high scores on Yelp, so it earns a balanced rating in our review. It may be a fun pasta club for a little while, but if you want more than linguine, you may need to explore a different subscription for better variety.

Scratch Pasta Co Review 3 Star Rating

Scratch Pasta Co

3 Star Rating
  • Priced at $35 per month
  • Pay monthly
  • 2 packages of boxed pasta
  • Up to 10 different listed flavors
  • Shipping flat rate of $8.95 to $14
  • Gluten-free
  • 4.5-stars from Facebook feedback

Scratch Pasta Co is one of the newer pasta clubs in our review. Founded in 2017, Scratch Pasta Co promises that its products are all hand-made in small batches from ingredients that are local to Lynchburg, VA. The best part? This retailer is all about pasta, so unlike some other sites in our review that offer a range of clubs or different grocery items, Scratch Pasta Co is locked in on noodles. Whether you want traditional egg noodles, unique squid ink varieties, or spinach-based pasta, there are a few really solid pasta varieties here.

Pick from three subscription lengths

If you want to grab a Pasta of the Month Club subscription from Scratch Pasta Co, you'll want to go to the "Shop” tab and then to "Gifting”. From there, you'll see the three lengths of the Pasta of the Month Club available. You can choose a membership for 3 months, 6 months, and 12 months. Each membership is charged monthly, but you're only committed to the amount of time you've selected. So, the 3-month club will charge you once per month for three months. From there, all you need to do is hit "Subscribe”.

Best Pasta of the Month Clubs

2 pasta flavors every month

Each box of this Pasta of the Month Club includes 2 boxes of pasta and 1-2 additional items from Scratch Pasta Co's online shop. Each monthly box is supposed to have a unique set of items, so you shouldn't get repeats. However, when we looked at the online menu, there were only 10 different pasta flavors. So, depending on whether or not these rotate throughout the year, you may end up getting at least 2 repeat flavors if you choose a yearly club membership. Here are some of the standout flavors we saw:

  • Squid ink campanelle
  • Spinach fusilli
  • Tomato, basil, and garlic fusilli
  • Semolina fusilli
  • Lemon basil gemelli
  • Porcini mushroom paccheri

Priced at $35 per month

The pricing is simple and is set up to reflect the monthly payments you'll make before each shipment. For the 3-month club, you'll pay $35 per month. The cost is the same for the 6-month club and the 12-month club as well. There is no discount for committing to a longer period; it just gives you a chance to have pasta for a longer term without needing to think about renewal. Occasionally, there will be discounts too. For example, at the time of our review, all of the boxes were on sale for $26 per month rather than $35, making them even more affordable.

Shipping costs $8.95 to $14

Each box does cost separately for shipping, so you can expect an additional charge of $8.95 per month on top of the cost of your subscription box. If you want to have each box gift-wrapped (for sending it to a loved one, perhaps), the flat rate shipping will be $14 instead. While most boxes offer free shipping, the cost overall for Scratch Pasta Co remains relatively low even with the cost of shipping on top of the price of the subscription.

No listed policy for refunds

We struggled to find any details about refunds on the Scratch Pasta Co website. There isn't any information on the "About” page, and the site doesn't currently have an FAQ section of the site to go off of either. We reached out to the Scratch Pasta Co customer service team to see if we could get more details via phone and email and did not hear back from Scratch Pasta Co at the time of our review. Not our favorite customer service experience...

Best Pasta of the Month Clubs

Limited reviews but high praise for service

Like many of the pasta clubs in our review, there isn't a massive presence online for Scratch Pasta Co. The company doesn't have a page with the Better Business Bureau and it isn't rated on trusted third-party review sites like Sitejabber and Trustpilot. There are a handful of ratings on Facebook that earn Scratch Pasta Co a 4.5-star average and one local 5-star review on Yelp. Most of the reviews are impressed by the boxed pasta (what you'll receive in the orders), but they say the fresh pasta you can get in-house is much better.

Good, but could use more attention to detail

Scratch Pasta Co is a good pasta club if you're looking for unique flavors, but it may miss the mark if you want brand-new pasta varieties every single month for a year. With only 10 listed flavors, you might see a few repeats if you subscribe for a year or longer. Also, with no specific refund policy, it's hard to know what to expect from Scratch Pasta Co. While reviews that we found are positive overall, the lack of feedback in general leaves some questions about how popular this pasta maker is as a whole. For now, the pasta club here earns a "just average” rating with the opportunity to earn a higher score in the future.

The Salty Dough Review 2.5 Star Rating

The Salty Dough

2.5 Star Rating
  • Pricing at $15.99 per month
  • Pay monthly
  • 1 pasta each month
  • 4 rotating flavors
  • Free shipping
  • 5-day refund policy

The Salty Dough was started by a self-proclaimed foodie, Stephanie. She's made a career from photographing food and decided to start her own company where she gets to be in charge of the foods for a change. Her Italian-style kitchen is based in Houston, TX, and specializes in pasta with fresh-milled, organic flour. The pasta types made at The Salty Dough are all based on Stephanie's family recipes and include a range of tasty and unique flavors that stand out from the pack.

Month-to-month shipments only

There is one Pasta of the Month club option at The Salty Dough, and it delivers to your door every month. There aren't any prepaid subscription plans. This monthly club auto-renews, but you can skip a month or cancel your membership at any time. While this is a little more limited than some of the other services in our review, the inclusions in the boxes are competitive. It just may not be an ideal site for giving a pasta club as a gift because of its month-to-month structure.

Best Pasta of the Month Clubs

1 pasta, but not many flavors to try

In every monthly shipment, The Salty Dough will send you 1 box of pasta, 1 new recipe, and a blended seasoning packet. The downside is that the flavors for pasta may be somewhat limited. On The Salty Dough, the only flavors listed for a la carte purchase are Spinach Conchiglie, Black Pepper & Garlic Linguine, Tomato & Basil Rigatoni, and Lemon & Rosemary Fettuccine. There aren't any other flavors (or even just basic egg noodles) at The Salty Dough. You can likely expect repeat shipments of the same four flavors throughout the year.

$15.99 per month with free shipping

The cost of the Pasta of the Month Club at The Salty Dough is one of the high points of the subscription: it's only $15.99 per month. The box doesn't have any add-ons or extras, so what you see is what you'll get. Plus, shipping is 100% free, so your monthly shipments will be $15.99 per delivery for pasta, a recipe, and seasoning each month without fail.

Refunds offered for damaged goods

The subscription policy specifically states that you'll receive repeat deliveries from The Salty Dough. Your payment details will be stored, and you can cancel or change your subscription at any time. To avoid being charged, you'll need to cancel before the next shipment is posted to your account. If your items arrive damaged, you can contact The Salty Dough within 5 days of when you receive the shipment, and the company will provide you with a refund if something is wrong with your pasta.

No buzz for The Salty Dough

Regrettably, there are zero reviews for The Salty Dough online. Yep. Zero. We checked the Better Business Bureau, Trustpilot, Sitejabber, Facebook, and even Yelp. No dice. Some of the individual items have 5-star ratings on The Salty Dough, but most of the kinds of pasta do not have any reviews on them yet. For now, The Salty Dough remains a bit of a question mark in terms of what customers and foodies think about this pasta club and its fun flavors.

Best Pasta of the Month Clubs

Not established enough yet

At the end of the day, our research shows that The Salty Dough leaves a lot of questions unanswered since it doesn't have any online presence to speak of. However, we still suggest you check it out. It's got some fun flavors, and the cost of the subscription is inexpensive. While it isn't one of our top picks yet, if it manages to work on its reputation, we can see The Salty Dough being a very popular choice. Keep it in mind if you want a low-cost flavorful option, but if you're looking for something more established check out one of our top pasta clubs instead.

Guidetti's Review 2 Star Rating

Guidetti's

2 Star Rating
  • Pricing from $38 to $40 per month
  • Monthly payments only
  • 1 package of pasta per box
  • Includes sauce, veggies, and sides for a meal
  • Free shipping in the continental US
  • Limited cancellations

Guidetti's is an independent shop that offers a range of Italian-style wine, coffee, and gelato too. On top of its sweeter menu items, Guidetti's imports a variety of items directly from Italy. Guidetti's is known for its in-person retail location which is meant to be a great place to "stop by” for coffee or wine after dinner. However, for the majority who aren't nearby to visit Guidetti's in person, ordering from their menu online is going to be the best bet to get high-quality Italian fare (like pasta).

3, 6, and 12 months of pasta

There is only one Pasta Club at Guidetti's, but you'll find it in three different listings on the website. Each listing is for a different subscription length (3, 6, or 12 months). Since they're all in separate listings, you'll want to start browsing on the "Gifts & Subscriptions” page to find all three. As a bonus, most of the subscription boxes can be made with gluten-free pasta; you just need to contact Guidetti's directly to let them know before you subscribe.

Best Pasta of the Month Clubs

1 pasta box and other extras

In each monthly shipment, you'll get 1 package of Italian pasta, a sauce or specialty tomatoes and spices, and one or two favorites from the Italian Pantry. The Pasta Club boxes are created to include helpful items for a simple pasta meal. The box will include a recipe, though it may suggest additional ingredients (like meat or veggies) to help make your pasta even more authentic, but these are optional inclusions. While the actual listings don't say what pastas you'll find, you can search available kinds of pasta on Guidetti's "Pantry”. Here's what we found:

  • Trecce
  • Lasagnette
  • Linguine
  • Gluten-Free Bucatini
  • Lanterne
  • Lumache
  • Gluten Free Fidanzati Capresi

Pricing from $38 to $40 per month

The pricing for all the boxes is billed monthly, so you'll be charged the listing price each month. But, the months are limited to the listed payment periods, so you'll need to re-subscribe to continue. For the 3-month and 6-month subscriptions, the monthly cost is $40. With the 12-month subscription, you get a small discount at $38 per month instead. As an additional benefit, you'll also get a 10% in-store discount on other purchases.

Shipping is free in the contiguous US

Guidetti's offers free shipping on all of its orders, including subscription boxes and individual items. This is for anyone living in the contiguous United States. If you live in Alaska or Hawaii, you'll be charged a flat-rate shipping fee of $5. That shipping is added to each box delivered, so you can expect an additional charge every month with the subscription plans.

Cancellation offered on two subscriptions only

The cancellation policy at Guidetti's notes that you can cancel a 3- or 6-month subscription at any time after your first payment and up to 7 days before your next scheduled payment. If you purchase a 12-month subscription, there is no cancellation allowed, so you are committing to the entire year (which is why the payments are discounted). There is no listed refund policy for items in the subscription boxes.

Best Pasta of the Month Clubs

Not a lot of buzz outside of Yelp

Like many pasta clubs that started as local eateries and groceries, Guidetti's only has reviews on Yelp. It currently does not have a page on the Better Business Bureau nor on trusted third-party review sites like Sitejabber or Trustpilot. Yelp shows a 3.6-star average rating for Guidetti's and reviews highly praise the atmosphere of the marketplace, but there are some poor reviews for the gelato. In general, there isn't a great deal of feedback on the pasta, specifically, leaving us with questions on the quality of the pasta club here overall.

Not a stand-out for flavor or support

While this site offers a decent "build your own pasta meal” approach to a pasta club, you may be disappointed by this site if you're looking to try a lot of pasta or unique flavors. Plus with limited third-party reviews and cancellation policies only for two of the three subscription lengths, you may not feel as supported by this company as with other pasta clubs in our review.

Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

If you're a penne fan, or looking for some good-old-fashioned spaghetti, pasta is a classic meal that comes in so many shapes and sizes that you can spend years trying new ones and still find more shapes (rotini, fettuccine, or ravioli, anyone?). While most of us think of Italy when we think of our favorite pasta dishes, there's evidence that the Etruscans made pasta back in 400 BCE.

Food historians believe that pasta arrived in Italy through trade in the Mediterranean and began its widespread popularity in the 13th century. From there, it became a country classic with pasta dishes like macaroni, ravioli, gnocchi, and vermicelli showing up across Italy. Today, it's estimated that Italians eat over 60 lb. of pasta per person per year.

So, what's the difference between high-end pasta versus the stuff you get at the grocery store? Well, for those of you who've had homemade pasta, you already know: the flavors, the freshness, and the texture of the pasta are beyond amazing when you compare it to the shelf-stable boxes you find at your local supermarket. If you want that restaurant-quality flavor in your home-cooked pasta dishes, grabbing a subscription to a pasta club is one of the best ways to get artisanal, top-quality noodles delivered right to your door.

If you're worried about dietary restrictions, don't be. Most pasta clubs offer options for gluten-free, so that those who are unable to eat gluten can still enjoy the delights of a home-cooked pasta dish. Whether you want packs with just pasta or one that helps you out with extra seasoning, sauce, and sometimes cheese too (to really get your inner chef going), there's a pasta club out there to fulfill your Italian dinner craving.

If you're ready to have your friends asking to come to your place for dinner instead of the local Olive Garden, but you don't know which vendor to choose, don't worry. Here are some factors that can help you find the best pasta club for your home chef needs:

  • Cost. Subscription clubs are usually priced based on frequency. So, depending on how long you plan to get pasta, you might pay a different overall cost. Some sites let you prepay too, so make sure you check out the month-to-month value versus the prepaid totals. Also, make sure that you get enough pasta to make the price make sense. You want at least a few meals out of your box (or a lot of extras) to make it worth it. Don't forget to factor in any shipping fees, too.
  • Variety. There are tons of pasta types, shapes, and flavors out there - it can be hard to choose. Make sure you pick a vendor that doesn't limit your choices in each shipment. Some sites may have much more pasta to choose from, and these one-stop shops are ideal if you're an adventurous eater. Make sure they have the kind of pasta you're craving and plenty of options to keep your subscription from being repetitive.
  • Reputation. Be sure to check out your chosen pasta club on third-party review sites like Trustpilot or the Better Business Bureau. Check the verified reviews to see what pasta lovers just like you have to say about your chosen site. Look for comments on flavor, customer service, and refunds, to make sure you get the experience you deserve.

To help you find the best way to bring your home chef dreams to life, Top Consumer Reviews has researched and ranked the top pasta clubs available today. Now you can enjoy your favorite noodles year-round and know there's always more on the way. Bon appetit!

The Best Pasta of the Month Clubs Compare Pasta of the Month Clubs Compare Pasta of the Month Club Reviews What are the best Pasta of the Month Clubs Best Pasta of the Month Club Reviews

Pasta of the Month Club FAQ

Like most online clubs, you choose a subscription plan, select your preferences (like delivery frequency or subscription length), and the club sends off a box of pasta for you. Once a month (or other frequencies if you choose) you'll get tasty pasta (or pastas) and sometimes complementary items like sauces, spices, or recipe cards. It's a convenient and delicious way to make your pasta nights more authentic.
This depends on the club. At most pasta makers, you can expect a mix of classic and unique varieties like spaghetti, rigatoni, pappardelle, or fusilli. Some clubs focus on gourmet or handmade pasta, while others feature international styles like Asian, gluten-free, or even plant-based pasta. Many clubs also include fun seasonal shapes or rare cuts you may not find locally.
This also depends on where you shop. Some pasta clubs offer options to change out the pasta included in your box. For example, you might be able to pick your own pasta in every shipment or ask for the company to change your pasta to gluten-free varieties. While not many pasta clubs offer changes to the orders, many of the clubs that have online menus where you can buy pasta directly let you choose your preferred styles and flavors.
Prices typically range from $16 to $60 per month, depending on the quality of the pasta, the quantity, and any add-ons included in your shipments. Clubs that offer premium ingredients or specialty sauces may be more expensive. Keep an eye out for discounts, though. You might get a lower monthly price for a longer subscription commitment or a larger order.
Definitely! Most pasta clubs focus on shelf-stable products like dried or packaged fresh pasta that won't have any issues during transit. If fresh or refrigerated pasta is included, it's shipped appropriately and includes instructions for storage and prep when it arrives at your door.
Most pasta clubs are flexible when it comes to managing your account. You can pause, skip a delivery, or cancel your subscription without any penalties. If you prepay for a subscription, you'll often be given partial refunds for the portion of your subscription that you haven't used. Make sure you check the pasta clubs' terms for a full rundown on the particular policies.
Pasta subscriptions make fantastic gifts for foodies, home cooks, or anyone who loves Italian cuisine. Most clubs offer easy gifting options like prepaid memberships that don't auto-renew. You can also sometimes add features like personalized notes or gift wrapping to make the monthly shipments more special for your loved ones.
Many do! While some clubs focus solely on pasta, others include delicious sauces, seasonings, or oils to complete your meal. Recipe cards are common even if you don't get tasty extras, so you can run to your local grocery and grab what you need to make an authentic Italian dinner.
The Best Reviews of Pasta of the Month Clubs