Pasta of the Month Clubs Reviews

Best Pasta of the Month Clubs in New York

We've analyzed the best Pasta of the Month Clubs to help you find the right solution for your needs.

The Best Pasta of the Month Clubs in New York

Where can I find the best Pasta of the Month Clubs in New York? In New York, you're scrolling for a pasta-of-the-month setup that actually earns its space in your kitchen. Instead of guessing at a deli aisle, you can size up subscription menus, shipping windows, and add-ons right on the page. You'll notice options that promise bronze-die spaghetti one month and stuffed shapes the next. With a couple of clicks, you'll lock in a cadence that fits your weeknights.

The Best Pasta of the Month Clubs in New York

5.0

EXCELLENT

1

Best Option

  • Pricing from $40.95 to $42.95 per month or $128.85 to $491.40 prepaid
  • Pay monthly or one-time
  • Includes pasta and sauce

Read Full Review

EXCELLENT

5.0

On the Amazing Clubs website

4.5

GREAT

2

Great

  • Pricing from $110 to $215 prepaid
  • Prepaid
  • 6 packages of pasta

Read Full Review

GREAT

4.5

On the Sfoglini website

4.0

VERY GOOD

3

Very Good

  • Pricing from $87 to $219 prepaid
  • Prepay for several months
  • 2 pastas per box

Read Full Review

VERY GOOD

4.0

On the Bona Furtuna website

3.9

VERY GOOD

4

Very Good

  • Pricing from $43 to $48 per month
  • Pay monthly
  • 2 pastas in every box

Read Full Review

VERY GOOD

3.9

On the Pappardelle's website

3.5

GOOD

5

Good

  • Pricing from $42.95 per month or $128.85 to $491.40 prepaid
  • Pay monthly or prepay
  • 2 pastas and 2 sauces per box

Read Full Review

GOOD

3.5

On the Flying Noodle website

3.0

AVERAGE

6

Average

  • Pricing from $140 to $500 prepaid
  • Pay monthly or one-time
  • 2 lb. of pasta per package

Read Full Review

AVERAGE

3.0

On the Pennsylvania Macaroni Co website

2.9

AVERAGE

7

Average

  • Priced at $35 per month
  • Pay monthly
  • 2 packages of boxed pasta

Read Full Review

AVERAGE

2.9

On the Scratch Pasta Co website

2.5

FAIR

8

Fair

  • Pricing at $15.99 per month
  • Pay monthly
  • 1 pasta each month

Read Full Review

FAIR

2.5

On the The Salty Dough website

2.0

SUBPAR

9

Subpar

  • Pricing from $38 to $40 per month
  • Monthly payments only
  • 1 package of pasta per box

Read Full Review

SUBPAR

2.0

On the Guidetti's website

Continued from above...

Where Can I Find the Best Pasta of the Month Clubs in New York?

In New York, you're scrolling for a pasta-of-the-month setup that actually earns its space in your kitchen. Instead of guessing at a deli aisle, you can size up subscription menus, shipping windows, and add-ons right on the page. You'll notice options that promise bronze-die spaghetti one month and stuffed shapes the next. With a couple of clicks, you'll lock in a cadence that fits your weeknights.

From your couch, you can sort boxes by shape, flour, or sauce style. With more than 350 recognized pasta shapes in the world, you'll love clubs that rotate beyond rigatoni into lesser-seen mafaldine or busiate. Given that the average American eats around 20 pounds of pasta a year, a monthly delivery of roughly a couple of pounds can fit right in without crowding your pantry. You'll also spot details like slow-dried, bronze-extruded dough - a rougher surface that helps sauce cling.

On a Monday in Buffalo, you might favor clubs that post a clear cutoff - say, orders placed by Tuesday ship the same week - so a box lands before the weekend. If you're in Rochester, you'll probably check whether dried pasta ships in 3-5 business days and whether glass-jar sauces come cushioned for winter. Since dried pasta is shelf-stable, you can choose ground shipping and still feel fine about freshness. You can also look for tracking texts, which make lobby pickups in apartment buildings a whole lot easier.

After digging into the fine print, you'll likely notice how New York handles sales tax on food. Most unprepared groceries - dried pasta counts - are generally exempt from state sales tax when shipped to your address, while prepared items and certain gift-style bundles can be taxed, especially if handling or mixed contents get bundled together. You can confirm that in the checkout summary before you commit. You'll also want skip-a-month controls, flexible terms, and packaging that uses recyclable cardboard rather than foam.

When that first box lands in Albany, you can scan recipe cards or QR codes and plan dinner around what your market's got. On humid July nights in New York, you'll probably welcome air-dried shapes that cook fast and leave the stove off sooner. If you care about sourcing, you can filter for semolina from specific mills or heritage wheat and pick a delivery cadence that matches your schedule. With the right setup, you'll turn a simple weeknight into something you'd text photos of to friends - sauce clinging, pasta al dente, plates quiet.

If you're ready to have your friends asking to come to your place for dinner instead of the local Olive Garden, but you don't know which vendor to choose, don't worry. Here are some factors that can help you find the best pasta club for your home chef needs:

To help you find the best way to bring your home chef dreams to life, Top Consumer Reviews has researched and ranked the top pasta clubs available today. Now you can enjoy your favorite noodles year-round and know there's always more on the way. Bon appetit!

Slide Down Image Left Slide Image FAQ Image Slide Image Twirl Image

Pasta of the Month Club FAQ

How does a pasta club work?
Like most online clubs, you choose a subscription plan, select your preferences (like delivery frequency or subscription length), and the club sends off a box of pasta for you. Once a month (or other frequencies if you choose) you'll get tasty pasta (or pastas) and sometimes complementary items like sauces, spices, or recipe cards. It's a convenient and delicious way to make your pasta nights more authentic.
What kinds of pasta are included?
This depends on the club. At most pasta makers, you can expect a mix of classic and unique varieties like spaghetti, rigatoni, pappardelle, or fusilli. Some clubs focus on gourmet or handmade pasta, while others feature international styles like Asian, gluten-free, or even plant-based pasta. Many clubs also include fun seasonal shapes or rare cuts you may not find locally.
Can you customize your club?
This also depends on where you shop. Some pasta clubs offer options to change out the pasta included in your box. For example, you might be able to pick your own pasta in every shipment or ask for the company to change your pasta to gluten-free varieties. While not many pasta clubs offer changes to the orders, many of the clubs that have online menus where you can buy pasta directly let you choose your preferred styles and flavors.
How much does a pasta club cost?
Prices typically range from $16 to $60 per month, depending on the quality of the pasta, the quantity, and any add-ons included in your shipments. Clubs that offer premium ingredients or specialty sauces may be more expensive. Keep an eye out for discounts, though. You might get a lower monthly price for a longer subscription commitment or a larger order.
Will pasta stay fresh during delivery?
Definitely! Most pasta clubs focus on shelf-stable products like dried or packaged fresh pasta that won't have any issues during transit. If fresh or refrigerated pasta is included, it's shipped appropriately and includes instructions for storage and prep when it arrives at your door.
Can you pause or cancel your subscription?
Most pasta clubs are flexible when it comes to managing your account. You can pause, skip a delivery, or cancel your subscription without any penalties. If you prepay for a subscription, you'll often be given partial refunds for the portion of your subscription that you haven't used. Make sure you check the pasta clubs' terms for a full rundown on the particular policies.
Can you send a pasta club as a gift?
Pasta subscriptions make fantastic gifts for foodies, home cooks, or anyone who loves Italian cuisine. Most clubs offer easy gifting options like prepaid memberships that don't auto-renew. You can also sometimes add features like personalized notes or gift wrapping to make the monthly shipments more special for your loved ones.
Do pasta clubs include sauces or recipes?
Many do! While some clubs focus solely on pasta, others include delicious sauces, seasonings, or oils to complete your meal. Recipe cards are common even if you don't get tasty extras, so you can run to your local grocery and grab what you need to make an authentic Italian dinner.

Compare Any 2 Products

Amazing Clubs
Sfoglini
Bona Furtuna
Pappardelle's
Flying Noodle
Pennsylvania Macaroni Co
Scratch Pasta Co
The Salty Dough
Guidetti's
vs
Amazing Clubs vs SfogliniAmazing Clubs vs Bona FurtunaAmazing Clubs vs Pappardelle'sAmazing Clubs vs Flying NoodleAmazing Clubs vs Pennsylvania Macaroni CoAmazing Clubs vs Scratch Pasta CoAmazing Clubs vs The Salty DoughAmazing Clubs vs Guidetti'sSfoglini vs Bona FurtunaSfoglini vs Pappardelle'sSfoglini vs Flying NoodleSfoglini vs Pennsylvania Macaroni CoSfoglini vs Scratch Pasta CoSfoglini vs The Salty DoughSfoglini vs Guidetti'sBona Furtuna vs Pappardelle'sBona Furtuna vs Flying NoodleBona Furtuna vs Pennsylvania Macaroni CoBona Furtuna vs Scratch Pasta CoBona Furtuna vs The Salty DoughBona Furtuna vs Guidetti'sPappardelle's vs Flying NoodlePappardelle's vs Pennsylvania Macaroni CoPappardelle's vs Scratch Pasta CoPappardelle's vs The Salty DoughPappardelle's vs Guidetti'sFlying Noodle vs Pennsylvania Macaroni CoFlying Noodle vs Scratch Pasta CoFlying Noodle vs The Salty DoughFlying Noodle vs Guidetti'sPennsylvania Macaroni Co vs Scratch Pasta CoPennsylvania Macaroni Co vs The Salty DoughPennsylvania Macaroni Co vs Guidetti'sScratch Pasta Co vs The Salty DoughScratch Pasta Co vs Guidetti'sThe Salty Dough vs Guidetti's Guidetti's vs The Salty DoughGuidetti's vs Scratch Pasta CoGuidetti's vs Pennsylvania Macaroni CoGuidetti's vs Flying NoodleGuidetti's vs Pappardelle'sGuidetti's vs Bona FurtunaGuidetti's vs SfogliniGuidetti's vs Amazing ClubsThe Salty Dough vs Scratch Pasta CoThe Salty Dough vs Pennsylvania Macaroni CoThe Salty Dough vs Flying NoodleThe Salty Dough vs Pappardelle'sThe Salty Dough vs Bona FurtunaThe Salty Dough vs SfogliniThe Salty Dough vs Amazing ClubsScratch Pasta Co vs Pennsylvania Macaroni CoScratch Pasta Co vs Flying NoodleScratch Pasta Co vs Pappardelle'sScratch Pasta Co vs Bona FurtunaScratch Pasta Co vs SfogliniScratch Pasta Co vs Amazing ClubsPennsylvania Macaroni Co vs Flying NoodlePennsylvania Macaroni Co vs Pappardelle'sPennsylvania Macaroni Co vs Bona FurtunaPennsylvania Macaroni Co vs SfogliniPennsylvania Macaroni Co vs Amazing ClubsFlying Noodle vs Pappardelle'sFlying Noodle vs Bona FurtunaFlying Noodle vs SfogliniFlying Noodle vs Amazing ClubsPappardelle's vs Bona FurtunaPappardelle's vs SfogliniPappardelle's vs Amazing ClubsBona Furtuna vs SfogliniBona Furtuna vs Amazing ClubsSfoglini vs Amazing Clubs
See the Best Pasta of the Month Clubs in Your State
Only the Best Reviews

Yahoo

This One-Pot Lemon Garlic Shrimp Pasta Is Your New Dinner Party Go-To

This easy 30-minute pasta recipe transforms ingredients that you already have in your kitchen into a posh, seafood dish you'll want to serve at your next dinner party. And since t ...

Fri, 10 Jul 2026

Only the Best Reviews

Tasting Table on MSN

The major complaint Olive Garden customers have with its pasta

Fast casual chain Olive Garden is beloved for many things. And while fans continue to rave about the breadsticks, some feel the pasta falls short.

Sun, 12 Jul 2026

Only the Best Reviews

Parade on MSN

I tried the viral 'frozen lemon pasta' recipe: Here's my honest review

An unexpected technique gives a surprising twist to this classic Italian dish.

Sun, 12 Jul 2026

Only the Best Reviews

USA TODAY on MSN

Don't let your pasta salad sit in the heat too long. Here's why.

Some of the ingredients commonly included in pasta salad aren't healthy, but others are. There are ways to further improve the health of the dish.

Sat, 04 Jul 2026

Only the Best Reviews

AOL

34 Pasta Casseroles That Make Weeknight Dinners Easier

Nothing satisfies a crowd of hungry folks quite as swiftly and thoroughly as a cheesy, creamy pasta casserole. Whether whipping up a busy weeknight dinner or stocking your freezer for the holidays, ...

Sun, 12 Jul 2026

Only the Best Reviews

Salon.com on MSN

The creamiest lemon pasta salad

Whipped cottage cheese gives this sunny summer salad protein paired with plenty of fresh citrus ...

Wed, 08 Jul 2026

Only the Best Reviews

CNN on MSN

TikTok ‘granfluencer’ shows us how to make her favorite pasta dish

84-year-old Nonna Silvana is no ordinary Italian grandma – she has millions of followers on social media and was just voted Italy’s TikTok “Creator of the Year.” Her fans follow to watch her cook ...

Fri, 10 Jul 2026

Only the Best Reviews

AOL

16 Canned Ingredients That Work Well In Pasta Salad

One wonderful thing about pasta salad is its chameleon-like ability to absorb a variety of flavor profiles. Try out these ingredients to hone your picnic fave!

Sun, 12 Jul 2026

Top Products.  

Top Reviews.  

Top Consumer Reviews.

Reviews 

Browse through thousands of reviews.

Social Media 

Like us?  Follow us!  We'd love to have you join our community.

Newsletter 

Stay up to date with the latest reviews. We'll keep you informed, and we'll never sell your information to anyone.