Thumbtack Review: Personal Trainers

We've analyzed the best Personal Trainers to help you find the right solution for your needs.

2026 Personal Trainer Reviews

Where is the Best Place to Find a Personal Trainer Online?  Getting fit is one of the most significant steps toward caring for yourself. Many people find that going to the gym by themselves, though, can be overwhelming - especially if they're not sure what to do with all the machines and weights. Often even long-time gym members need help leveling up their workout and creating a targeted fitness plan for building muscle, or need support for an injury they want to strengthen.

2.5

FAIR

9

Fair

  • Monthly cost: $280 to $680
  • In-person and online training
  • Choose your schedule
  • Specialized workout plans for different sports or goals
  • Includes diet, exercise, and more
  • Database of personal trainers
  • 5-star rating on many individual trainers
  • "A-" rating from the BBB

FAIR

2.5

On the Thumbtack website

Thumbtack is another site that offers database-style access to local personal trainers. So, rather than relying on an app or videos to train you, you use the Thumbtack search to find a personal trainer in your area who can give you a full hands-on workout experience. Thumbtack doesn't just do personal training either. You can find all sorts of businesses or projects, including house cleaning, handyman help, lawn care, pet care, and more.

Pick the individual that works for you

For the personal trainers on Thumbtack, there are many different areas of focus to choose from. In our area, we saw weight loss, basketball, event prep, assistance with pain and injuries, and beyond. All of the trainers have their own reviews as well as a list of how many individuals have hired them through Thumbtack. You can also see the details of the personal trainers' work history and credentials on their pages. However, we saw fewer individuals who listed certifications on Thumbtack than with other sites in our review.

Best Personal Trainers

Not as many trainers as some sites

When you sign up, you can select filters to narrow your search and limit the results. Thumbtack will suggest the top three based on your preferences, but if you don't like them, you can keep scrolling to find the rest. As a bonus, we noted that many personal trainers on Thumbtack offer couples and group lessons, so you can work out with a partner or friends. However, Thumbtack had fewer personal trainers in our area than some other database-style websites did. For our location, there were 8 total trainers available.

Cost from $280 to $680 per month

The cost of personal training through Thumbtack depends on the trainer you choose. In our area, prices range from $35 per session to $85 per session. However, these are only estimated prices. To get a full price schedule from Thumbtack's professionals, you have to fill out a form and message the individual trainer. Keep in mind that they only want serious inquiries only, as the pros do need to pay a fee to communicate with potential clients on Thumbtack. If we put those session costs into a monthly plan at 2 sessions per week for four weeks, you're looking at an average monthly cost of $280 to $680.

Get that personal touch

If you're a fan of in-person or guided personal training, this platform could be for you. Rather than worrying about self-starting and keeping track of your workouts on your own, you'll have a person to help you be accountable (and cheer you on) while you're working toward your fitness goals. Plus, you'll get the bonus of knowing that the workouts are tailored to your specific body, with the opportunity to make adjustments to a routine in real time as your trainer sees how you're working with the sets.

Best Personal Trainers

Superb trainers, but questionable marketing

Currently, Thumbtack as a business holds an "A-" rating from the Better Business Bureau. However, Thumbtack earns a more middle-tier rating from third-party review sites like Trustpilot, where the site has a 3.7-star average out of 5. Most of the complaints for this business are from the professionals (the people offering personal training and other services on this platform). According to negative reviews, Thumbtack is "stealing" money and charging exorbitant prices for leads. For example, one professional noted that they ended up paying $60 when they received inquiries that never led to bookings. Some other professionals said they never even communicated with the leads or inquiries and still got charged for them regardless. While the reviews for the individual personal trainers on Thumbtack are fantastic (most of them have a full 5 stars for their quality of service), the platform has some concerning practices.

Doesn't stack up against other databases

While you can find some impressive personal trainers at Thumbtack, there are a few drawbacks to using this platform over others in our review. For one, there are fewer total personal trainers at Thumbtack when compared to other database-style websites (and given the expenses that professionals face on this platform, we're not exactly surprised). Second, the final prices aren't available until you submit an inquiry, but you may only want to do this if you're very serious about the individual, since they'll be paying for your inquiry whether or not you decide to secure their personal training services. With other more helpful (and professional-friendly) databases out there, Thumbtack comes in just below average in our review.

On the Thumbtack website

Continued from above...

Where is the Best Place to Find a Personal Trainer Online?

Getting fit is one of the most significant steps toward caring for yourself. Many people find that going to the gym by themselves, though, can be overwhelming - especially if they're not sure what to do with all the machines and weights. Often even long-time gym members need help leveling up their workout and creating a targeted fitness plan for building muscle, or need support for an injury they want to strengthen.

Either way, a personal trainer is a great option to up your gym game. A talented personal trainer will whip you into shape, but on your terms and with a plan that fits your body, workout style, and goals.

A lot of folks think that personal trainers are for top athletes. And, while a personal trainer can be essential for those who need to complete specific goals for a sport or competition, a workout beginner can get just as much out of a personal trainer as a gym pro. Grabbing a personal trainer as a newbie can help you through the weeds of discovering what movements are safe for your body, how to use equipment properly, and how to see the results you want as quickly as possible.

There are innumerable benefits to getting a personal trainer (at any level). For one, you can be sure you'll have more effective workouts (workouts that serve a purpose for your body and your goals, and increased difficulty where needed to keep your body challenged). The process also includes a personalized experience where your trainer analyzes your current fitness level, health concerns, and previous injuries, and creates a tailored workout plan for your needs. Plus, your customized plan can offer you support in and out of the gym - including nutrition and recovery practices that will help you when you're not working out.

Finding a good personal trainer can be tricky, though. You'll want to make sure and check on potential candidates' education, areas of expertise, experience, and any certifications. The best certification agencies include the National Academy of Sports Medicine (NSAM), the National Exercise Trainers Association (NETA), the National Strength and Conditioning Association (NSCA), the American Council of Exercise (ACE), and the American College of Sports Medicine (ACSM). Checking to see if your preferred personal trainer has a background in sports medicine (or a degree) is a good rule of thumb to know you're getting the proper advice from a medically-sound background.

While, at the end of the day, selecting a personal trainer is a super individualized process (you will need to like the trainer and spend a decent amount of time with him or her), we can help you get started on your search. To make sure you find the best personal trainer for your fitness goals, we've put together some factors to help you narrow the options:

To help you find the right place to kickstart your fitness journey, Top Consumer Reviews has reviewed and ranked today's most popular platforms for hiring personal trainers online. This way you can focus on getting your gains and trusting that your trainer is there to help keep you on track!

Slide Down Image Left Slide Image FAQ Image Slide Image Twirl Image

Personal Trainer FAQ

What is a personal trainer?
A personal trainer works with clients to design plans for exercise, nutrition and/or flexibility goals. While anyone can say that they're a personal trainer, certain certifications can demonstrate that they've put in the work to learn best practices for working with clients effectively and safely. Look for a personal trainer with certification(s) from NASM, ACE, ISSA, NFPT, or ACSM, which are widely recognized as experts in the industry.
How often should I work with a personal trainer?
That will depend on you. What are your goals? What is your current level of fitness/experience? Most experts recommend meeting with a trainer for 1-2 sessions a week for up to 6 weeks, especially if you're a beginner. But, if you are fairly comfortable with working out - you know how to do various exercises with good form and just need someone to give you a structured plan - you might be able to cut that timeframe down.
Can a personal trainer help me with nutrition?
Yes and no. If your trainer is also certified within the nutrition field, he or she can prescribe meal plans. However, most personal trainers don't have dual certifications and can only make nutrition suggestions based on gym performance or weight loss/muscle gain efforts - like recommending that you count macros, get enough rest and water, and when to time your meals based on your exercise schedule. If you want a day-to-day schedule of what to eat, you'll need to work with a nutritionist in addition to your personal trainer in most cases.
Where can I find a personal trainer?
If you have a gym membership, there are probably options for working one-on-one with a trainer on staff there - but that might not be the best way to get a personal trainer that's well-suited to your personality, needs and goals. We recommend using an online personal trainer site, either to find highly-recommended professionals in your area or to choose a virtual program you can use at your convenience.
Are there personal trainers I can work with virtually?
Absolutely! While you'll lose the advantage of having someone right next to you in the gym, you gain plenty of perks. Virtual personal training is often much less expensive than an in-person format, and you get much more customized workout plans. This is a great option if you're working out at home or need options you can take on the road with you.
Can I work with a personal trainer if I don't have a gym membership?
Yes. There's a growing network of personal trainers who specialize in providing in-home workouts. Even if you choose an online personal trainer, you can tell them what equipment you have at home if any, and they'll design a plan that incorporates whatever you have available. There are plenty of exercises that can be done simply with your own bodyweight!
How much does it cost to work with a personal trainer?
That depends on many different factors. If you choose an in-person trainer, you can expect hourly rates anywhere from $20 to $100+, while online/virtual personal training is typically $200/month or less. For face-to-face personal training, rates are impacted by the experience level of the trainer you choose and your geographic area as well.
Do personal trainers offer any kind of satisfaction guarantee?
Sometimes. It's more common to find free trials, satisfaction guarantees and refund policies when you choose an online personal training platform. In-person trainers usually charge as you go; you wouldn't get money back for training sessions that already happened, but you wouldn't have to pay for future sessions if you were unhappy with the service. And, of course, no personal trainer is going to guarantee specific results - since what you do the other 23 hours of the day is going to have a big impact on your success, beyond what you accomplish in your personal training sessions.

Compare Any 2 Products

Fitness Trainer
Future Fitness
Forge
Trainwell
Trainerize
Born Fitness
HitchFit
Shred
Thumbtack
Zing Coach
Transform
Trainiac
vs
Fitness Trainer vs Future FitnessFitness Trainer vs ForgeFitness Trainer vs TrainwellFitness Trainer vs TrainerizeFitness Trainer vs Born FitnessFitness Trainer vs HitchFitFitness Trainer vs ShredFitness Trainer vs ThumbtackFitness Trainer vs Zing CoachFitness Trainer vs TransformFitness Trainer vs TrainiacFuture Fitness vs ForgeFuture Fitness vs TrainwellFuture Fitness vs TrainerizeFuture Fitness vs Born FitnessFuture Fitness vs HitchFitFuture Fitness vs ShredFuture Fitness vs ThumbtackFuture Fitness vs Zing CoachFuture Fitness vs TransformFuture Fitness vs TrainiacForge vs TrainwellForge vs TrainerizeForge vs Born FitnessForge vs HitchFitForge vs ShredForge vs ThumbtackForge vs Zing CoachForge vs TransformForge vs TrainiacTrainwell vs TrainerizeTrainwell vs Born FitnessTrainwell vs HitchFitTrainwell vs ShredTrainwell vs ThumbtackTrainwell vs Zing CoachTrainwell vs TransformTrainwell vs TrainiacTrainerize vs Born FitnessTrainerize vs HitchFitTrainerize vs ShredTrainerize vs ThumbtackTrainerize vs Zing CoachTrainerize vs TransformTrainerize vs TrainiacBorn Fitness vs HitchFitBorn Fitness vs ShredBorn Fitness vs ThumbtackBorn Fitness vs Zing CoachBorn Fitness vs TransformBorn Fitness vs TrainiacHitchFit vs ShredHitchFit vs ThumbtackHitchFit vs Zing CoachHitchFit vs TransformHitchFit vs TrainiacShred vs ThumbtackShred vs Zing CoachShred vs TransformShred vs TrainiacThumbtack vs Zing CoachThumbtack vs TransformThumbtack vs TrainiacZing Coach vs TransformZing Coach vs TrainiacTransform vs Trainiac Trainiac vs TransformTrainiac vs Zing CoachTrainiac vs ThumbtackTrainiac vs ShredTrainiac vs HitchFitTrainiac vs Born FitnessTrainiac vs TrainerizeTrainiac vs TrainwellTrainiac vs ForgeTrainiac vs Future FitnessTrainiac vs Fitness TrainerTransform vs Zing CoachTransform vs ThumbtackTransform vs ShredTransform vs HitchFitTransform vs Born FitnessTransform vs TrainerizeTransform vs TrainwellTransform vs ForgeTransform vs Future FitnessTransform vs Fitness TrainerZing Coach vs ThumbtackZing Coach vs ShredZing Coach vs HitchFitZing Coach vs Born FitnessZing Coach vs TrainerizeZing Coach vs TrainwellZing Coach vs ForgeZing Coach vs Future FitnessZing Coach vs Fitness TrainerThumbtack vs ShredThumbtack vs HitchFitThumbtack vs Born FitnessThumbtack vs TrainerizeThumbtack vs TrainwellThumbtack vs ForgeThumbtack vs Future FitnessThumbtack vs Fitness TrainerShred vs HitchFitShred vs Born FitnessShred vs TrainerizeShred vs TrainwellShred vs ForgeShred vs Future FitnessShred vs Fitness TrainerHitchFit vs Born FitnessHitchFit vs TrainerizeHitchFit vs TrainwellHitchFit vs ForgeHitchFit vs Future FitnessHitchFit vs Fitness TrainerBorn Fitness vs TrainerizeBorn Fitness vs TrainwellBorn Fitness vs ForgeBorn Fitness vs Future FitnessBorn Fitness vs Fitness TrainerTrainerize vs TrainwellTrainerize vs ForgeTrainerize vs Future FitnessTrainerize vs Fitness TrainerTrainwell vs ForgeTrainwell vs Future FitnessTrainwell vs Fitness TrainerForge vs Future FitnessForge vs Fitness TrainerFuture Fitness vs Fitness Trainer
See the Best Personal Trainers in Your State
Only the Best Reviews

The Times of India ...

Anne Hathaway’s fitness trainer reveals four things she prioritises ...

Anne Hathaway's fitness trainer, Monique Eastwood, shared four key priorities for women entering perimenopause. She emphasizes building strong foundations with a focus on stability, balance, mobility, ...

Sat, 09 May 2026

Only the Best Reviews

New York Post

I’m a fitness trainer and weigh over 200 pounds — clients love me

Growing up as the fat kid in her neighborhood on Long Island, Morit Summers, 36, hated who she saw in the mirror. She weighed over 200 pounds, and doctors pushed fad diets and weight loss surgery on ...

Mon, 21 Nov 2022

Only the Best Reviews

Business Insider

3 personal trainers share tips they wish they'd known when they ...

Three personal trainers said beginners often make similar mistakes that cost them time and progress. Going to the gym with a plan can help keep you on track, as well as motivate you. Properly warming ...

Fri, 21 Apr 2023

Only the Best Reviews

Yahoo

Celebrity personal trainers share the 3 biggest mistakes people make ...

It can be tempting to follow extreme diets and workout regimens when trying to get fit and lose fat. Personal trainers who work with celebrities advised making gradual but sustainable changes instead.

Thu, 02 Jan 2025

Only the Best Reviews

Black Enterprise

Personal Trainers Who Focus On Elder Fitness

People are living longer—and growing older. In fact, between 2010 and 2020, the nation experienced a growth spurt in the older population, the fastest since 1880-1890. According to the U.S. Census ...

Wed, 28 Jan 2026

Only the Best Reviews

PopSugar

These 13 BIPOC Fitness Trainers on Instagram Are Motivating Us to Get ...

If you need a little fitness inspiration while scrolling through your Instagram feed, you'll want to follow these BIPOC certified personal trainers. They post strength-training workouts, HIIT workouts ...

Mon, 29 Nov 2021

Top Products.  

Top Reviews.  

Top Consumer Reviews.

Reviews 

Browse through thousands of reviews.

Social Media 

Like us?  Follow us!  We'd love to have you join our community.

Newsletter 

Stay up to date with the latest reviews. We'll keep you informed, and we'll never sell your information to anyone.