Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

Trupanion vs Nationwide

Saturday, December 14th

2024 Pet Insurance Company Reviews

Trupanion Review 2.5 Star Rating

Trupanion

2.5 Star Rating
  • Monthly premium of $378.15 for an 8-year-old mixed-breed large dog in Illinois
  • Deductible options from $0 to $1,000 in $50 increments
  • Coverage for hereditary & congenital conditions
  • Advanced dentistry coverage included
  • Pet Owner Assistance package available for additional fee
  • Direct pay option with participating vets
  • 5-day waiting period for injury coverage
  • Operates in the US, Puerto Rico, and Australia

Trupanion advertises their 90% reimbursement rate and no annual payout limits as perks, but are they really when it means your monthly premiums will be significantly higher than competitors that allow you to adjust your rates and limits to fit your budget? While Trupanion promises not to increase rates based on your pet's age, many customers experience substantial price hikes over time anyway. Trupanion doesn't offer add-ons to cover exam fees and preventive care. We're concerned by the company's legal troubles, too. Despite some positives, like direct pay, good dental coverage and their Pet Owners Assistance package with liability coverage for property damage, Trupanion is difficult to recommend over other options in the pet insurance market.

Nationwide Review 2 Star Rating

Nationwide

2 Star Rating
  • Pricing: Starts at $7/month for cats, $13/month for dogs, and $9/month for exotic pets
  • $10.36 per month for our example dog
  • Covers cats, dogs, and exotic pets
  • Flexible deductible options: $250, $500, or $1,000
  • Multiple reimbursement rate options: 50%, 70%, or 80%
  • Annual maximum payout options of $2,500 or $5,000 for accident coverage
  • Ability to use any veterinarian
  • Offers separate Wellness coverage add-on
  • 14-day waiting period after policy's effective date

Nationwide may be the only insurance company in this review that insures exotic pets, but their coverage falls far behind what other pet insurance providers offer. You won't get illness coverage until your second term, and there is no coverage for hereditary and congenital conditions or behavioral issues. The company was embroiled in controversy when they canceled the policies of older pet owners to save themselves money. We cannot recommend Nationwide for your pet insurance needs.

What is the Best Pet Insurance Company?

If you're a pet owner, chances are you've thought about how to care for your furry friend in the event of an emergency. Veterinary bills can add up quickly, especially if your pet needs surgery or treatment for a chronic illness. Pet insurance can help cover these unexpected costs, making it easier to provide the best care for your pet without breaking the bank.

From puppies prone to accidents to older cats with ongoing health needs, pet insurance can be a valuable tool to help you manage costs while giving your pet the treatment they deserve.Pet insurance comes in a few different types, which vary based on the coverage they offer. For instance, some plans only cover accidents, such as a broken leg from a fall, while others offer more comprehensive coverage that includes illnesses, wellness checkups, and vaccinations.

The Best Pet Insurance Companies Compare Pet Insurance Companies Compare Pet Insurance Company Reviews What are the best Pet Insurance Companies Best Pet Insurance Company Reviews

Pet Insurance Company FAQ

Generally speaking, all ages are welcome when it comes to providing your pet with pet insurance. As the pet gets older rates may be more expensive than if you would have gotten coverage at a younger age. Please keep in mind some companies have age restrictions for when they can accept a dog or cat into their insurance plan. Typical restrictions are around 12+ years of age.
No one can forecast when your dog or cat is going to digest something they shouldn't have or have an accident related injury. Luckily, pet insurance helps to protect the pet owner against unexpected veterinary bills that can reach into the $1,000s.
It is recommended to get pet insurance before winter or summer seasons. During those seasons, there are more dangerous elements that are exposing your pet to potential illness and accidents. As far as age goes for the puppy, insurance companies recommend getting your pet insurance when your new best friend arrives home.
Typically, insurance companies only insure cats and dogs. But some companies will insure dogs, horses, other large animals, cats, other small animals, rodents, reptiles, and birds.
Depending on the company, a pet insurance claim can be sent via several different methods. Methods can include email, fax, or regular mail. When completing a claim make sure to include all of your paid vet bill invoices, and any other required documents. When the claim is processed it will either be accepted with a reimbursement, more information needed (i.e. incomplete claim form), or denial (i.e. due to non-coverable services)
Of course, your pet insurance travels with you, wherever you go. Some insurance companies may have restrictions when it comes to international travel. Make sure to check with your pet insurance company if you plan on taking your furry friend across the border.
It depends greatly on which company and plan you decide to go with. Most pet insurance companies cover accidents and illnesses after a waiting period. If the illness is a preexisting condition, you're likely not to receive any coverage. It's important you understand the fine print of any plan you may decide to go with.
In general, veterinarians do not handle pet insurance claims. Veterinarians and the owner make choices for the pet's medical care and overall health. If the care is covered by the insurance, the insurance company will reimburse the owner a percentage of the bill (depending on the chosen insurance plan's coverage) after the care and service has been performed.
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

Basic accident-only plans tend to be more affordable, but they won't help if your pet develops a long-term health condition. Comprehensive plans may include preventive care as well, though they often come with higher monthly premiums. Other policies cover hereditary or congenital conditions, which can be particularly important if your pet is a breed known for specific health issues.

The cost of pet insurance depends on factors like your pet's age, breed, and health history, as well as the type of coverage you choose. Monthly premiums can range from under $10 to over $100, so understanding the differences among plans can save you money in the long run. Additionally, different insurance companies have various reimbursement models and payout limits. Some plans reimburse a percentage of each vet bill, while others have annual limits, meaning you'll want to consider how much you're likely to spend on your pet's healthcare each year.

It's important to choose the right pet insurance plan the first time. If you decide to switch to another provider later, any health issues your pet has developed in the meantime will be considered pre-existing conditions by the new provider and not covered. You should also be aware that "upgrading” to a better policy from the same provider can technically be considered canceling your old policy, meaning the conditions your pet is currently covered for may become considered pre-existing.

Here are some key factors to keep in mind when shopping for pet insurance:

  • Coverage options. Decide whether you want a plan that covers only accidents or one that includes illnesses and preventive care. Comprehensive plans can offer peace of mind, but they come with a higher price tag.
  • Reimbursement structure. Look at how each plan reimburses you for vet bills. Some cover a percentage of each bill (like 80% or 90%), while others have a fixed payout per condition. Choose the one that best matches your budget and expected vet expenses.
  • Annual limits and deductibles. Most plans have a yearly or per-condition deductible. Be sure you understand the amount you'll need to pay out of pocket before coverage kicks in. Plans with lower deductibles tend to cost more per month but cover costs sooner.
  • Breed-specific coverage. Certain breeds are prone to genetic health issues. Make sure your policy covers any conditions common in your pet's breed if you think it could be a future concern.
  • Claims process. Filing a claim can take anywhere between 2 days and 30. Choose a provider that doesn't require a lot of back-and-forth about medical records. Some providers even pay your vet directly, no claim necessary.
  • Customer reviews and reputation. A company's reputation can tell you a lot about its service quality. Reading reviews can give you insight into how well claims are handled and how easy the process is overall.

Top Consumer Reviews has evaluated and ranked the best pet insurance companies available. We hope this review helps you find the best service for your pet, so you can feel confident they're covered, no matter what life brings.

See the Best Pet Insurance Company
The Best Reviews of Pet Insurance Companies