Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

Picaboo Review

Friday, July 19th

2024 Photo Book Company Reviews

Picaboo Review 2.5 Star Rating


2.5 Star Rating
  • Pricing starts between $19.99 to $69.99
  • 36 themes available
  • 100% satisfaction guarantee
  • "B-" rating from the BBB

Picaboo got its name from a fun fishing trip to Picabo, ID, where the founders playfully combined it with the game "Peek-A-Boo" and the name of the business was born. The company was started in 2002 by two friends, Howard Field and Kevin McCurdy, who believed that memories are very important in life and should be kept, shared, and enjoyed in special ways. They began the company in Palo Alto, CA, where the company is still based.

36 themes for easy selection

There are 36 total themes available from Picaboo. This is a pretty slim number compared to other companies, but it does make it easy to make a decision. The themes are all separated into manageable categories like basic, baby, books and journals, celebrations, holidays, seasons, travel, and more. On top of this, you also have options for landscape or square photo books. In general, the impression at Picaboo is that they want to make the choices as simple as possible while still offering creative designs.

Good features for beginners

Compared to our highest-rated sites, Picaboo doesn't offer as many advanced features. The selection of photo book types is pretty slim, but it does make it easier to pick out what you want. Overall, the company caters to less experienced photo book designers who seek a simpler approach. However, some customers have reported uneven photo quality in prints and photo books ordered from Picaboo. While professionals may scrutinize the end product, for most users Picaboo's services will suffice.

Best Photo Book Companies

Prices start as low as $19.99

When it comes to customization, Picaboo offers three photo book choices on its website. These style choices each include a standard price, which can increase if you add extras to the photo book. The types of photo books available include:

  • Classic which starts at $24.99
  • Seamless Lay-Flat which starts at $69.99
  • Premium Mini Books which start at $19.99

This is nice because it offers budget options and more premium selections; however, we do wish there were more styles to compete with services on our list that have 5 or 6 types of photo books.

100% satisfaction may be limited to company error

Picaboo provides a 100% guarantee on their photo books, promising to fix and replace any discrepancies between the design process and the final product. However, the company has a limited return policy, indicating that they may only exchange or refund products in case of errors on their part.

Best Photo Book Companies

Customers aren't pleased with service

While Picaboo has received notable recognition, having been featured on several prominent platforms like the Today Show, DailyCandy, and The Wall Street Journal, its reputation seems to have fallen recently. The company used to hold an "A+" rating from the Better Business Bureau, but currently, that rating has fallen to a "B-" . Further, the reviews on verified third-party review sites are pretty unimpressive. Across three different review sites, the average star rating for Picaboo is just 1.7 stars out of 5. Customers complain about the customer service at Picaboo, and others say that the creation process is too complicated for how much they pay for the books.

Not ideal unless you like it simple

Overall, Picaboo serves as a basic platform for creating simple photo books. While some themes may not align with modern preferences and there aren't many options to choose from, the platform caters to those who prioritize simplicity over extensive features. Overall, we recommend higher-rated services than Picaboo, especially considering the decline in popularity and ratings recently. However, if you're really interested in a simple design, Picaboo could be worth checking out.

Where is the Best Place to Get Photo Books Out There Today?

Photo books are a fantastic way to keep our special memories in a tangible, beautiful format instead of just storing pictures on computers or in boxes. They are perfect for different occasions, like giving them as anniversary gifts, thoughtful birthday presents, or even creating yearly projects to decorate coffee tables, making it easy to look back on good times.

For example, weddings and engagements have become extra special with the rise of personalized photo books. Couples use their wedding or engagement photos to create these books, allowing guests to sign and leave heartfelt messages during the wedding reception. This makes photo books an important part of people's lives as they become a way to treasure precious moments, experiences, and important events.

The Best Photo Book Companies Compare Photo Book Companies Compare Photo Book Company Reviews What are the best Photo Book Companies Best Photo Book Company Reviews

Photo Book Company FAQ

Photo Books are available year-round, ranging in celebration type, shapes and sizes. Photobooks can be used for any life event, keeping the memory within wedding albums, yearbooks, travel adventures, and more. A lot of companies allow the customer to pick a style and size to best fit for the occasion. When it comes to the type of cover, many companies have softcover, image-wrap hardcover, debossed hardcover, flush mount, or deluxe hardcover, to name a few.
Depending on the size, and type, the number of photos can range from 50 to 800 per photo book. On average a typical photobook has about 20 pages that are customizable. Each page can contain several photos and if you run out of pages, most companies will add a page for an additional cost.
Photo books range in value of $15.99 to $39.99 depending on the company, size, material, style, and number of pages. Some companies offer discounts upon first purchase and include monthly free promos. Cover styles can include softcover, hardcover, and leather. Paper type options can range from the base type of semi-gloss finish to premium matte lay flat.
Photo books come in all shapes and sizes. Standard photo books normally start at 8.5-inch x 8.5-inch and can get larger or smaller. The maximum size available is 12-inch x 12-inch. The minimum size offered is 5.5-inch x 4-inch. Some companies do offer layout size options as well.
Delivery can take anywhere from 2 to 3 weeks depending on the what you order. Bulk deliveries may take longer than the normal to receive. Shipping costs vary on the specific service and size of the package.
Most companies have you start out with picking either a theme/style of photobook, whether it is modern, simple, birthday, wedding, you name it they will have it. Then you select the size of the photobook and the type of cover and paper within. Finally, the fun begins, insert photos. For some people it may be easier to have the photos already downloaded on your device before you upload them to the photobook
Customization can differ per company. Customization can include size, style, type, format, color, font, quality, page style, and number of pages. Some companies offer bulk bundles of photo books (like yearbooks for schools).
Depending on the company, if you are not satisfied with your purchase you can return your product with a full refund. Most companies offer a customer satisfaction guarantee and excellent customer service options. Make sure to check the site has a customer satisfaction guarantee before purchasing.
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

In the past, making a photo book was a lot of work. It involved printing loads of photos, getting binders, stickers, fancy paper, and special tools for adding cool borders. Hours were spent carefully gluing the pages together and writing descriptions for each picture. Although some people enjoyed this scrapbooking process, it took a lot of time and resulted in big, bulky books that took up a lot of space.

Thankfully, in today's digital age, photo books are easier to make than ever. Many people opt to create photo books online due to their convenience and endless creative possibilities. With just a few clicks, you can capture family vacations, document special events, or preserve moments with loved ones. The ability to create photo books online has led to a significant rise in the number of people who now choose to immortalize their cherished moments in these beautifully designed keepsakes.

What's really fantastic about online photo books is how flexible and customizable they are. They can be super simple with just photos laid out neatly, or they can be like fancy scrapbooks with fun borders, stickers, and our own text. For example, if you're making a photo book about your beach vacation, some websites even offer special themes that let you add seashell stickers, "sandy" texture pages, and frames with palm trees to match the beachy pictures.

That's pretty awesome, right? So, no matter what style you like or what you want to remember, creating a photo book gives you the freedom to be as creative and personal as you want.

If you're looking for a fresh new way to collect your photographs, or you just have some memories that need to be shared, don't worry. There are so many places to get photo books these days that it can be overwhelming. Fortunately, we've done the research to help you find the photo service that caters to your unique needs and crafts a photo book made just for you.

To help you get started we've put together some tips to point you in the right direction:

  • Cost: Compare the photo book cost with other competitors. Check if you pay per page or for the entire book, regardless of its size. You may also want to see if there are extra costs for delivery, or if that's included in the price of the photo book.
  • Customization: Depending on what you need your photo book for, you may want to look for various size options and choose between softcover and hardcover books. Ensure there are ample choices for fonts, colors, borders, stickers, themes, and photo arrangements.
  • Features: To make sure that you have the best experience creating your photo book, you may want to prioritize user-friendly websites that offer easy navigation and straightforward tools for creating your photo book. Avoid platforms that may cause confusion and frustration during the creation process.
  • Customer feedback: Ultimately, customers like you are some of the best people to check in with when making your decision. They, like you, have a clear idea of their preferences and have made photo books with these companies before. So make sure you check out customer feedback and BBB ratings to ensure that photo service is the one that meets customers' needs.

To help you find the best spot to get a photo book today, Top Consumer Reviews has assessed and ranked different photo services to put together a beautiful collection of your favorite memories. Whether you're seeking a wedding photo book or something to track memories for your little ones, there are options out there for everything (even the DIYers who want to be more hands-on). We hope this takes out the stress of photo book creation and helps you get back to organizing the memories most important to you!

See the Best Photo Book Company
The Best Reviews of Photo Book Companies