The 6 Best Pickle of the Month Clubs
Which Pickle of the Month Club is the Best?
Are you tired of grocery store pickles that lack that perfect crunch and authentic flavor? Whether you're a casual snacker or a passionate pickle connoisseur, pickle of the month clubs offer an exciting way to explore artisanal varieties delivered right to your doorstep.
From traditional kosher dills to innovative flavors like gin-brined spears or honey mustard chips, these clubs provide access to unique, small-batch creations you won't find in stores. But just like the wide variety of pickles themselves, pickle of the month clubs can vary greatly in the pickles they deliver and the options they offer.
Monday, February 10th
2025 Pickle of the Month Club Reviews
Amazing Clubs
If you're ready to expand your pickle horizons beyond the grocery store shelf, Amazing Clubs' pickle of the month club is worth checking out. You'll receive two jars of artisanal pickles each month from small, family-owned kitchens across the US, with varieties ranging from classic dills to more adventurous flavors. While the base price per jar is a bit steep at $19, the free shipping helps offset the cost, and their stellar customer service and satisfaction guarantee make this a risk-free purchase. Their corporate gifting options and flexible subscription lengths add nice touches to an already solid service. Given their perfect BBB rating and near-perfect customer reviews, we're confident in giving Amazing Clubs' pickle of the month club our highest 5-star
Olive My Pickle
If you're looking to upgrade your pickle game while supporting your gut health, Olive My Pickle offers a fascinating twist on traditional pickles through their ancient fermentation process. You'll find these aren't your standard grocery store cucumbers - they're probiotic-rich, complexly-flavored fermented foods that might take some getting used to. Their subscription service can help make these premium pickles more affordable, and they offer an impressive variety beyond just pickles, including olives, kimchi, and even probiotic brine drinks. While the price point is definitely on the higher side and the fermented taste isn't for everyone, we think the quality and health benefits make these pickles worth trying.
Kaylin and Kaylin
If you're craving authentic New York-style pickles on the West Coast (or anywhere else), Kaylin and Kaylin's monthly pickle club might be right up your alley. You'll get to choose from 11 creative varieties of chips, spears, and whole pickles, including their wildly popular Honey Mustard chips that customers can't stop raving about. While the shipping costs can be a bit steep for smaller orders and you'll need to commit to at least three months, the quality and variety make it worth considering - especially with their sweet 15% discount for new customers. We think this farmer's market success story delivers a solid pickle of the month club experience, even if it's not quite perfect.
Pickle Licious
If you're a pickle aficionado looking for variety, Pickle Licious offers an impressive array of flavors, from classic kosher dill to adventurous options like wasabi and firecracker. Started by a single mom who turned her passion into an award-winning business, this pickle of the month club delivers fresh, crunchy pickles right to your door every month. While the quality and taste seem top-notch based on customer feedback, the shipping costs (often matching the price of the pickles themselves) give us pause. Though we'd love to give this subscription a higher recommendation, the shipping fees and limited window for addressing delivery issues make us suggest exploring other pickle clubs first.
Pacific Pickle Works
If you're looking to expand your pickle palate beyond basic dills, Pacific Pickle Works could be your new favorite pickle of the month club. This Santa Barbara-based company crafts creative pickled vegetables with unique flavor combinations, delivering their artisanal creations right to your door every quarter. While their shipping costs are steep and their website could use some work on transparency, their innovative products (like gin-brined pickles and spicy pickled beets) make up for these shortcomings. They're not perfect, but pickle enthusiasts who love trying new things will definitely want to check them out.
Month Club Store
If you're looking for a pickle of the month club that won't break the bank, Month Club Store's service might catch your eye with its reasonable pricing and included shipping. You'll get two mystery jars of pickles each month from various gourmet producers, though if you're picky about your pickles, you can only exclude sweet varieties. While the company has been around for nearly two decades, the complete lack of customer reviews and limited tracking information gives us pause. Given the mystery-box nature of the service and zero testimonials to back up Month Club Store's quality claims, we can only give this pickle of the month club an average rating - it might be worth trying if you're an adventurous snacker, but we'd think twice before gifting it.
Continued from above...
Some pickle of the month clubs take a "surprise and delight" approach, curating unique selections each month from gourmet producers across the country. Others put you in control, letting you handpick your favorites from their available varieties - perfect for those who know exactly what they like or have specific dietary preferences. Options can range from traditional cucumber pickles to fermented vegetables like kimchi, asparagus, or beets.
Monthly pickle subscriptions typically range from $10 to $19 per jar, with most offering free (or reasonable) shipping. Some focus on traditional fermentation methods that promote gut health, while others specialize in creative flavor combinations and variety. Subscriptions usually include 2-4 jars per delivery, with jar sizes ranging from 16 to 32 ounces.
When shopping for a pickle of the month club, several factors deserve your consideration:
- Delivery frequency and flexibility. Most clubs offer monthly deliveries, though some provide bi-monthly or quarterly options. Look for services that allow you to pause or modify your subscription.
- Storage and shelf life. Most artisanal pickles require refrigeration and can last 2-6 months when properly stored. Check whether your subscription includes temperature-controlled shipping.
- Shipping and packaging. Some pickle of the month clubs include shipping in their subscription price, while others charge separately. Look for secure packaging to prevent breakage and consider whether temperature control is provided.
- Reputation and reviews. Check customer reviews and ratings from independent sources. Look for companies with good standing on review sites and with organizations like the Better Business Bureau.
Top Consumer Reviews has evaluated the best pickle clubs available online, comparing factors like price, variety, shipping policies, and customer satisfaction. Whether you're treating yourself or searching for a unique gift, we'll help you find the perfect pickle of the month club to satisfy your craving for crispy, flavorful pickles delivered right to your door.
Pickle of the Month Club FAQ
Compare Pickle of the Month Clubs
Select any 2 Pickle of the Month Clubs to compare them head to head
Trending Pickles News
Related Pickle of the Month Club Reviews
Since you're interested in Pickle of the Month Clubs, here are some other reviews you might find interesting.
Newest Reviews
