Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

Amazing Clubs vs Olive My Pickle

Monday, February 10th

2025 Pickle of the Month Club Reviews

Amazing Clubs Review 5 Star Rating

Amazing Clubs

5 Star Rating
  • $19 per jar with free shipping
  • Available in 3, 6, or 12-month subscriptions
  • Two 16-24 oz jars of artisanal pickles delivered monthly
  • Small-batch, gourmet pickles from independent, family-owned US kitchens
  • Wide variety including traditional, sweet, spicy, and bread & butter pickles
  • "They'll Love It" satisfaction guarantee
  • Perfect BBB rating ("A+”) and 4.9/5 on Trustpilot
  • Monthly newsletter with product information and fun facts
  • Corporate gifting options available with bulk discounts
  • Easy cancellation policy with credit/refunds for unshipped items
  • Personalized gift messaging available
Top Consumer Reviews Best-In-Class Blue Ribbon Award

If you're ready to expand your pickle horizons beyond the grocery store shelf, Amazing Clubs' pickle of the month club is worth checking out. You'll receive two jars of artisanal pickles each month from small, family-owned kitchens across the US, with varieties ranging from classic dills to more adventurous flavors. While the base price per jar is a bit steep at $19, the free shipping helps offset the cost, and their stellar customer service and satisfaction guarantee make this a risk-free purchase. Their corporate gifting options and flexible subscription lengths add nice touches to an already solid service. Given their perfect BBB rating and near-perfect customer reviews, we're confident in giving Amazing Clubs' pickle of the month club our highest 5-star

Olive My Pickle Review 4.5 Star Rating

Olive My Pickle

4.5 Star Rating
  • 3-item subscription box starts at $41.82 with free shipping ($13.94 per item), up to 12 items for $117.11 ($10.84 per item)
  • Raw, unpasteurized fermented pickles made through traditional lactofermentation process
  • Rich in probiotics and beneficial for gut health
  • Every batch pH tested for safety
  • 6-month shelf life from packaging date
  • Wide variety including pickles, olives, kimchi, sauerkraut, and fermented green beans
  • Specialty LiveBrine probiotic drink options available
  • Free shipping on all orders
  • Certified Kosher products
  • Over 9,000 customer reviews with photos and serving suggestions

If you're looking to upgrade your pickle game while supporting your gut health, Olive My Pickle offers a fascinating twist on traditional pickles through their ancient fermentation process. You'll find these aren't your standard grocery store cucumbers - they're probiotic-rich, complexly-flavored fermented foods that might take some getting used to. Their subscription service can help make these premium pickles more affordable, and they offer an impressive variety beyond just pickles, including olives, kimchi, and even probiotic brine drinks. While the price point is definitely on the higher side and the fermented taste isn't for everyone, we think the quality and health benefits make these pickles worth trying.

Which Pickle of the Month Club is the Best?

Are you tired of grocery store pickles that lack that perfect crunch and authentic flavor? Whether you're a casual snacker or a passionate pickle connoisseur, pickle of the month clubs offer an exciting way to explore artisanal varieties delivered right to your doorstep.

From traditional kosher dills to innovative flavors like gin-brined spears or honey mustard chips, these clubs provide access to unique, small-batch creations you won't find in stores. But just like the wide variety of pickles themselves, pickle of the month clubs can vary greatly in the pickles they deliver and the options they offer.

The Best Pickle of the Month Clubs Compare Pickle of the Month Clubs Compare Pickle of the Month Club Reviews What are the best Pickle of the Month Clubs Best Pickle of the Month Club Reviews

Pickle of the Month Club FAQ

Pickle of the month clubs are subscription services that deliver artisanal and gourmet pickles to your door regularly. You'll typically receive monthly shipments from small, family-owned kitchens across the US, offering unique flavors and varieties you won't find in regular stores.
Today's pickle clubs offer an impressive range of options, from traditional kosher dills to creative varieties like honey mustard, gin-brined, and wasabi-flavored pickles. Many also include other pickled vegetables and fermented foods. Some clubs let you customize selections or exclude certain varieties, while others operate as surprise boxes with new flavors each month.
Customization options vary by service. Some let you build your own monthly bundle from multiple varieties, including classic dill, spicy, and specialty flavors. Others curate surprise selections from small-batch producers, focusing on unique and exclusive varieties. Many services offer different subscription tiers or allow you to specify preferences like heat level.
Most pickle of the month clubs offer flexible subscription management. Some require a minimum commitment period, like 3 months, while others let you cancel anytime with credit or a refund for unshipped items. Many also offer the ability to skip deliveries or adjust delivery frequency to match your consumption rate.
Most pickle clubs offer good value when considering the quality and uniqueness of their products. Monthly subscriptions typically range from $10 to $19 per jar, with some clubs including free shipping. While this is more expensive than grocery store pickles, you're getting artisanal, small-batch products often made with premium ingredients and unique recipes you can't find elsewhere.
Quality guarantees vary between clubs. Some offer comprehensive satisfaction guarantees and will replace or refund orders with no questions asked, while others only cover shipping damage reported within a few days. The best clubs have clear policies about returns and replacements, especially for broken jars or leaking products.
Most pickle clubs use secure packaging methods including temperature-controlled containers, insulated mailers, or ice packs during warm weather. Some use plastic containers to prevent breakage, while others carefully package glass jars with protective materials. Delivery typically takes 2-7 days, depending on location and shipping method.
Storage life varies by preservation method. Traditional vinegar-brined pickles typically last 3-8 weeks after opening when refrigerated. Fermented varieties can last up to 6 months when properly stored. Most clubs recommend refrigerating their products upon arrival for optimal crunch and flavor, though some shelf-stable varieties don't require immediate refrigeration.
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

Some pickle of the month clubs take a "surprise and delight" approach, curating unique selections each month from gourmet producers across the country. Others put you in control, letting you handpick your favorites from their available varieties - perfect for those who know exactly what they like or have specific dietary preferences. Options can range from traditional cucumber pickles to fermented vegetables like kimchi, asparagus, or beets.

Monthly pickle subscriptions typically range from $10 to $19 per jar, with most offering free (or reasonable) shipping. Some focus on traditional fermentation methods that promote gut health, while others specialize in creative flavor combinations and variety. Subscriptions usually include 2-4 jars per delivery, with jar sizes ranging from 16 to 32 ounces.

When shopping for a pickle of the month club, several factors deserve your consideration:

  • Delivery frequency and flexibility. Most clubs offer monthly deliveries, though some provide bi-monthly or quarterly options. Look for services that allow you to pause or modify your subscription.
  • Storage and shelf life. Most artisanal pickles require refrigeration and can last 2-6 months when properly stored. Check whether your subscription includes temperature-controlled shipping.
  • Shipping and packaging. Some pickle of the month clubs include shipping in their subscription price, while others charge separately. Look for secure packaging to prevent breakage and consider whether temperature control is provided.
  • Reputation and reviews. Check customer reviews and ratings from independent sources. Look for companies with good standing on review sites and with organizations like the Better Business Bureau.

Top Consumer Reviews has evaluated the best pickle clubs available online, comparing factors like price, variety, shipping policies, and customer satisfaction. Whether you're treating yourself or searching for a unique gift, we'll help you find the perfect pickle of the month club to satisfy your craving for crispy, flavorful pickles delivered right to your door.

The Best Reviews of Pickle of the Month Clubs