Thursday, March 27th
2025 Pickle of the Month Club Reviews
Kaylin and Kaylin
- 2-4 jars per month at $14 to $16 per jar
- 11 unique pickle varieties including chips, spears, and whole pickles
- Popular Honey Mustard pickle chips consistently receive rave reviews
- Temperature-controlled shipping keeps pickles fresh for up to 7 days in transit
- Refrigerated pickles stay fresh for up to 5 months
- Free shipping on orders over $75
- Started as successful farmer's market business with strong local following
- Ships Monday through Saturday via USPS Priority with tracking
- 15% off first order for new customers
Kaylin and Kaylin began when a New Yorker moved to the West Coast and realized he missed New York pickles. He started a farmer's market stall in the spring of 2020, and the demand from his new customers during lockdown was so high that he was able to stay in business with online orders. Thus, Kaylin and Kaylin as an online pickle club was born.
Delivery of 2-4 jars every month
Kaylin and Kaylin's "Build Your Own Monthly Bundle” pickle subscription plan allows you to choose 2, 3, or 4 jars. Just select your preference and click "customize my box” to pick your varieties. Pickle chip options include Bread & Butter, Classic Dill, Honey Mustard, Jalapeño, Spicy Dill, and Sweet Heat. Spears and whole pickle options include Classic Dill, Horseradish, Kosher Dill, Jalapeño, and Spicy Garlic. That's 11 options total, which is comparable to Kaylin and Kaylin's competitors.
Honey Mustard pickle chips are a fan favorite
Kaylin and Kaylin might show up on your TikTok or Instagram For You Page, since they send popular content creators jars of their pickles in exchange for a review. In the videos we watched, their Honey Mustard chips were everyone's favorite, and the customers who have left reviews on Kaylin and Kaylin's website agree. It's their bestseller, and one customer writes, "Actually bought these by accident. […] But every time I sit down and want a snack, this is the first thing I go for.”
No early cancellations
The 2-jar plan comes with a 10% discount, while the 3 and 4-jar plans offer 15% off. With the 15% discount, jars cost $14-$16 each - which works out to be about $0.50 an ounce at 32 ounces a jar. Keep in mind that all subscriptions require a 3-month minimum commitment - you can't cancel until after your third delivery. There aren't any longer pickle of the month club options available, such as 6-month or annual plans. Keep an eye out for an offer of 15% off your first order, too, in case you decide to place a one-time order to get started.
Refrigerated pickles last 5 months
Kaylin and Kaylin pickles need to be refrigerated. When shipped, they'll be in temperature-controlled packaging that keeps them safe for up to 7 days, but after taking them out of the box, they need to go in the fridge. They can be left out of the fridge for a max of 72 hours before they lose their crunch and flavor, and they'll stay good in the fridge for up to five months.
Free shipping on orders over $75
While Kaylin and Kaylin's $12.75 shipping fee for orders under $75 might make you wince (especially compared to rivals offering free shipping), it's actually quite reasonable when you consider that some pickle companies charge a whopping $30 or more. Plus, you'll get free shipping if you order $75 worth of pickles, which isn't hard to do if you're stocking up. Orders ship Monday through Saturday via USPS Priority. Delivery might take 1-2 weeks during busy periods, but you'll at least get tracking information to keep tabs on your precious pickle cargo.
Return and refund policy is unclear
Kaylin and Kaylin has no formal return or refund policy. In an FAQ answer, they provide an email address to contact them with photos of any issues with your order and say they'll work to make things right. You can probably assume they won't refund you if the reason for your dissatisfaction is subjective, like flavor.
Pickles get great ratings
While you won't find Kaylin and Kaylin listed on major review platforms like the Better Business Bureau or Trustpilot yet, their LA farmer's market location has built quite a buzz on Yelp. Customers rave about their pickles, with some even claiming they've ditched their beloved Claussen pickles in favor of K&K's kosher variety. Though they're still establishing their online presence, these glowing local reviews suggest you're in for a treat with their pickle of the month club.
Still pretty good
Kaylin and Kaylin ranks highly in our review for its unique flavors and concept. However, its pickle club doesn't earn our top rating due to no free shipping on smaller orders and limited online reviews of their monthly subscription service. While customers rave about their pickle flavors and quality, it's difficult to gauge how well this farmer's market business handles e-commerce without more customer feedback. They earn a solid rating, and we hope they'll strengthen their satisfaction guarantee or establish a BBB presence in the future.
More Pickle of the Month Club Reviews
The 6 Best Pickle of the Month Clubs
Which Pickle of the Month Club is the Best?
Are you tired of grocery store pickles that lack that perfect crunch and authentic flavor? Whether you're a casual snacker or a passionate pickle connoisseur, pickle of the month clubs offer an exciting way to explore artisanal varieties delivered right to your doorstep.
From traditional kosher dills to innovative flavors like gin-brined spears or honey mustard chips, these clubs provide access to unique, small-batch creations you won't find in stores. But just like the wide variety of pickles themselves, pickle of the month clubs can vary greatly in the pickles they deliver and the options they offer.
Pickle of the Month Club FAQ
Continued from above...
Some pickle of the month clubs take a "surprise and delight" approach, curating unique selections each month from gourmet producers across the country. Others put you in control, letting you handpick your favorites from their available varieties - perfect for those who know exactly what they like or have specific dietary preferences. Options can range from traditional cucumber pickles to fermented vegetables like kimchi, asparagus, or beets.
Monthly pickle subscriptions typically range from $10 to $19 per jar, with most offering free (or reasonable) shipping. Some focus on traditional fermentation methods that promote gut health, while others specialize in creative flavor combinations and variety. Subscriptions usually include 2-4 jars per delivery, with jar sizes ranging from 16 to 32 ounces.
When shopping for a pickle of the month club, several factors deserve your consideration:
- Delivery frequency and flexibility. Most clubs offer monthly deliveries, though some provide bi-monthly or quarterly options. Look for services that allow you to pause or modify your subscription.
- Storage and shelf life. Most artisanal pickles require refrigeration and can last 2-6 months when properly stored. Check whether your subscription includes temperature-controlled shipping.
- Shipping and packaging. Some pickle of the month clubs include shipping in their subscription price, while others charge separately. Look for secure packaging to prevent breakage and consider whether temperature control is provided.
- Reputation and reviews. Check customer reviews and ratings from independent sources. Look for companies with good standing on review sites and with organizations like the Better Business Bureau.
Top Consumer Reviews has evaluated the best pickle clubs available online, comparing factors like price, variety, shipping policies, and customer satisfaction. Whether you're treating yourself or searching for a unique gift, we'll help you find the perfect pickle of the month club to satisfy your craving for crispy, flavorful pickles delivered right to your door.
Compare Pickle of the Month Clubs
Select any 2 Pickle of the Month Clubs to compare them head to head
Trending Pickles News
Related Pickle of the Month Club Reviews
Since you're interested in Pickle of the Month Clubs, here are some other reviews you might find interesting.
Newest Reviews
